The Bybee Torture Memo Essay

3067 words - 12 pages

The Bybee Torture Memo
On August 1, 2002, Justice Jay Bybee submitted the “Bybee Memo” or the ‘Torture Memo”, which describes the behavior that U.S. officials must exercise when interrogating outside of the continental U.S. as governed by the UN Convention Against Torture. Although this memo was rendered inoperable by the Bush Administration in 2004; for years, it gave license to American troops to inflict cruel amounts of pain, effectively “torture” upon their prisoners under the label of “coercive interrogation”. Michael Hatfield, a Professor at Texas Tech School of Law published his rebuttal to the Bybee Memo indicating that from a natural law perspective that torture, even disguised as “coercive interrogation” was fundamentally a moral wrong and should be illegal. Was his argument fair however?
In the opinion of this author, his argument is fair and includes the following strengths: that although torture is prohibited by a number of world declarations, it is so fundamental to international order that it does not need to be embodied in written credos; that simply masking “torture” as other words, does not render it legally justifiable and that by claiming necessity of the lesser of two evils, that torture does not necessarily lead to a betterment in the world; rather a deterioration. Possible pitfalls of his argument include a ignorance of the realist point of view by understanding the political and social needs of the nation at the time the memo was drafted as well as the contention that all Americans submitted to the memo; thereby becoming not citizens of a “good” world order, but villains of such. These weaknesses, however, are minimal compared to the strengths of his argument.
Hatfield contends that torture is so fundamentally wrong that it requires no written prohibition. At the core of morality, it is simply not acceptable. However, there are many international doctrines of peace-keeping which outright prohibit torture such as the Universal Declaration of Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the Geneva Convention and so on (pg. 132). He feels that as a lawyer, he is demoralized when other lawyers seek to revisit the legality of torture. However, the United States has submitted a document, the Bybee Memo, which enacted a law contrary to these accepted credos of behavior and these proponents of human dignity. “...what is clearly torture by any moral standard is not torture under American legal standards” (pg. 132). So how is it that one of the world’s largest democracies, can proclaim that “coercive...

Find Another Essay On The Bybee Torture Memo

The Human Right Violations at Abu Ghraib

1981 words - 8 pages to our conflict with al Qaeda in Afghanistan or elsewhere through the world because; among other reasons al Qaeda is not a High Contracting Party to Geneva. (Bush 2002)” In 2002, the Office of Legal Counsel responded to the President’s request of exploring the question whether American officials have the right to use torture against suspected terrorists. Assistant Attorney General Jay S. Bybee of the Office of Legal Counsel not only legalized

Torture Essay

856 words - 4 pages interrogation tactics, one of which is torture. The CIA’s approach to torture after 9/11 using techniques such as water boarding has proven to save lives and prevent future tragedies in spite of common controversy. In times of crisis, water boarding acquires the essential lifesaving information in time sensitive situations. The CIA, commonly thought of as the United States international secret police, has many notorious people in doubt of whether


972 words - 4 pages to justify torture. John Yoo, a former OLC attorney and now a University of California at Berkeley professor authored a "torture memo" that formed the legal basis for the so-called "enhanced" interrogation technique. Yoo's legal opinion stated that unless the amount of pain administered result to injury such as "death, organ failure or serious impairment to body functions, then "the interrogation technique cannot be defined as torture." For

Under the Black Hood

2442 words - 10 pages decided to not follow these guidelines, which they agreed to and made them obligatory, the people who ordered the procedures could be convicted. There where documents that disallowed the usage of the Geneva Conventions, which where created by John Yoo, deputy assistant attorney general, and Jay S. Bybee, head of the Office legal Counsel. The memos, known as torture memos, were redacted on 2002, and allowed the U.S to use torture in interrogations

Torture in Guantanamo

2013 words - 8 pages information, yet the questioners believe they hold “precious memo” (Carter 3). To access the valuable information, the interrogators feel the need to test new techniques of torture (Carter 4). Because there was nothing to stop the neglect, it became a daily routine to treat the prisoners in such a disturbing manner. Most of the abuses were secret and hidden from the rest of the world. When the American citizens found out, they were dumbfounded and

Regarding the Rwandan Genocide

937 words - 4 pages reported to have been raped and assaulted. It’s as if rape became a common method for the Hutus to humiliate and torture the Tutsis. The children are losing their parents and their siblings; becoming a homeless, lost orphan with no one to take care of them. They are driven out of their house, on to the roads where the predators can easily get to them. Relief workers should rescue these children and many other survivors and help them as best as

Terrorists Should Be Treated as Prisoners of War

2961 words - 12 pages Should Not Be Incarcerated in U.S. Jails." War Crimes. Ed. Margaret Haerens. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2011. Opposing Viewpoints. Rpt. from "Congressional GOP Memo on Moving Gitmo Detainees to Illinois."Weekly Standard (15 Dec. 2009). Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web. 15 Oct. 2013. McCoy, Alfred W. "Torture Does Not Make America Safer." Presidential Powers. Noah Berlatsky. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2010. Opposing Viewpoints. Rpt. from "The Myth

Lgbt And Russia

3034 words - 13 pages Freedoms (ECHR); and the European Convention for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT). There are also several articles in Russia’s own constitution which are incompatible with current human rights abuses against the LGBT community, as well as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), and the Yogyakarta Principles. This memo takes a detailed look at this legislation in light of LGBT human rights

Is Big Brother Watching You? George Orwell's 1984

1341 words - 6 pages in 1984. In USA Today, China's coming into view into a more powerful, controlling government country is talked about in detail. As noted in the article, in 2013, "China jailed a professional writer for sending a text of a Communist Party memo to a foreign website." Even more upsetting, the American company, Yahoo, has cooperated with Chinese authorities in order to conduct business there. From my perspective this is highly unusual and entirely

Russian Homophobia: It Needs To Stop

1208 words - 5 pages was no mention of female homosexuals. In 1936, Justice Commissar Nikolai Krylenko declared at the anti-gay law was aimed at "the remnants of enemies ... who do not wish to admit that they are doomed by history to finally concede their place to us." In 1958, the Interior Ministry sent a secret memo to the law enforcement, saying that they should enforce the anti-gay law more strictly. In 1991, a poll that was taken of Chelyabinsk reveled Russian

History lesson: GOP must stop Bush

1128 words - 5 pages Conventions regarding humane treatment of prisoners was enunciated in a memo to Bush, dated Jan. 25, 2002, from the White House counsel."As you have said, the war against terrorism is a new kind of war," Alberto Gonzales wrote Bush. "In my judgment, this new paradigm renders obsolete Geneva's strict limitations on questioning of enemy prisoners and renders quaint some of its provisions." Quaint.Since January, Bush and Rumsfeld have been aware of

Similar Essays

Abu Ghraib Essay

1149 words - 5 pages In reference to its origin, on August 1st, 2002 a memorandum was sent from Assistant Attorney General Jay S. Bybee, with the Office of Legal Counsel in the US Justice Department to Alberto R. Gonzales, counsel to the president. The memo was written in response to a CIA request for legal guidance with the purpose to provide President Bush with a rationale and justification on the use of torture on potential Al Qaeda terrorists in order to extract

Torture Essay

2191 words - 9 pages adopted different legal strategies to justifiably use ‘forceful interrogation’ i.e. torture. The first is the argument that the use of torture cannot be violating international law because its being used as an act of self-defense, the second strategy is to define the interpretation of torture narrowly. According to Jay Bybee , in order for an act to be considered torture, “it must inflict more than just moderate or fleeting pain.” There is no real

Human Torture Should Not Be Allowed

1555 words - 6 pages cases, he cancelled the trip (“George Bush”). America’s leaders know what they have done is wrong and will not face the consequences. Even though these acts are against global law, United States forces have committed the act of torture in Iraq and other places. Former Attorney General, Alberto Gonzales wrote in a memo to the President, "Your determination [that the Conventions didn't apply] would create a reasonable basis in law that Section 2441

Torture In The Us Essay

1668 words - 7 pages actions constitute torture. The meaning of torture changed in some aspects after 911. For example, a memo was issued that stated coercive interrogations can actually torture only if suffering equal, in intensity, to pain from serious injuries or even death and is caused intentionally by the Justice Departments Office of Legal Counsel in 2002. Who Supports Torture The majority of America, 58%, supports the use of torture to stop and fight