The Canadian Governing System Is Not Fair Or Democratic

1391 words - 6 pages

There are Canadian citizens who thought that the Canadian government we have is perfect, citizens who believed that every aspect of the government was truly democratic, and citizens who believe that government could do no wrong. Truly this group of believers has been living a lie. In our Canadian system of government, large aspects within are far from democratic and need to be changed. Liberal-minded people will cry out for a change in order for government to serve the people better, and on the other hand the more conservative thinkers will argue that no change is needed because our government is efficient and considerate. However, our voting system, our Senate, and the power vested to the Prime Minister are far from democratic, do not meet the actual needs of the people and definitely need to be addressed.

Canada itself claims to be democratic, yet the Canadian Senate is appointed to office by the current Prime Minister rather than elected by the citizens. The original purpose of the Senate was to give fair representation between provinces and to the citizens. Having failed its purpose, clearly there are issues within the Senate that need to be addressed. Because of the Prime Minister appointing the Senators, they will now serve the Prime Ministers needs rather than the people who they should have been listening to. As if this were not enough of a show of power for the Prime Minister, the Senators cannot be lawfully kicked out of office until the age of seventy-five. An example of Senate idiosyncrasy in Canadian government is Ross Fitzpatrick, who was appointed to office by former Prime Minister Jean Chretien of the Liberals in June 1990. His official opponent, Preston Manning, rightfully questioned the circumstances regarding this appointment. Fitzpatrick was a former business associate and close friend of Chretien’s, having helped Chretien gain more than $40,000 in the stock market. It was obvious that he would make votes in favour of Chretien’s aims. However, even with his appointed position he only very rarely showed up for work, ignoring his basic obligations as Senator. Even when the whole of the government was in outrage at this incompetence, they could not legally kick him out of office. There will inevitably be more incidents like these unless the Senate is reformed. Thankfully, there are several possible ways to reform the Senate as to make it a more democratic institute.

The Senate, undemocratic as it is, obviously needs some tweaks and changes in the system to make it more so. The Canadian Senate should reform entirely into a triple-E Senate (Elected, Efficient, Equal). In the Triple E Senate, Senators should be elected by the voters instead of appointed, the efficient distribution of power towards the Senate to balance out the power. This would create a more democratic and fairer Senate that would better serve the needs of the citizens it represents. While the Triple-E Senate may not get things done nearly as quickly as the...

Find Another Essay On The Canadian Governing System is not Fair or Democratic

What is wrong with the Canadian Health Care system?

1173 words - 5 pages controversial solution proposed, but it is to go semi-private. Meaning, that there would still be the public healthcare system in place, but if one has money, they can pay to 'jump the line' and have surgery faster, but at a price (Canada and the World). This could give hospitals money. It would not affect those already waiting if only certain hospitals or time slots were given to those who pay. Many disagree and say that this is not fair to those who

Is Our Justice System Fair to All?

1688 words - 7 pages Is our justice system fair to all? Although the answer to this question is an opinion, there are pieces of evidence and commentary to defend this argument. The process of the legal system itself is all an opinion because in the end, the only person whose judgments matter is the judge himself. Over time, the wrong people have been arrested for the wrong things. Living in the United States, a country where crimes are committed constantly

Reforming the Canadian Electoral System

1479 words - 6 pages unfairly reward the larger parties while, on the other hand, making it difficult for the small parties to receive any seats. For example, during the 2004 Canadian federal elections, the Green party did not acquire any seats and yet it garnered 4.3% of all the popular votes casted. In this regard, it is not uncommon under the current Canadian electoral system for parties or candidates to win the majority seats and yet fail to have the majority of

The Canadian health care system.

727 words - 3 pages benefits from their employers to cover the additional expense.The importance of universal health care is that all Canadian citizens are unimpeded by financial or other barriers, ensuring a valuable piece of mind by not having to worry about financial diminishments due to sickness or injury. To statistically prove how successful the universal health care system is, the life expectancy for Canadians born in 1999 is 79.0 (81.7 years for women, and

The Canadian Juvenile Justice System

1131 words - 5 pages , intensive support and supervision orders, deferred custody and supervision orders, and orders to attend a non-residential program. Since their introduction, the new sentences have not been commonly used. In 2006/2007, deferred custody and supervision orders were handed down the most frequently in only about 3% of guilty youth court cases, or 1,080" (May, 2008). In conclusion, the development of the juvenile justice system resulted from social

Rights toward Equality: Fair for Homosexuals or Not?

1894 words - 8 pages Throughout the United States there are many rights that should be practiced by everyday citizens, but there are many people that would not agree to that statement. Homosexuality has gone the distance in the past two decades and is finally being accepted by most people. Although it is being accepted, most rights that have been passed have not been equal to that of non-homosexuals. Discrimination towards homosexuals is the most problematic topic

The Canadian Justice System vs. Aboriginal People

569 words - 2 pages are more likely to be denied bail, spend less time with their lawyers, and if convicted, are more likely to be incarcerated.It is not merely that the justice system has failed aboriginal people; justice has also been denied to them. For more than a century the rights of aboriginal people have been ignored and eroded. The result of this denial has been injustice of the most profound kind. Poverty and powerlessness have been the Canadian legacy to a

Is Austalia More Or Less Democratic Then Canada?

637 words - 3 pages serve a sentence of five years or less. Less people get to vote in Canada because immates don't get to vote if they serve a sentence of five years. They only get to vote if they serve a sentence of two years or less. The voting age in Australia is twenty-one years of age and the voting age for Canada is eighteen years of age. Comparing the age limit of Australia and Canada would make Canada more democratic. Elections in Australia are every three

System Failure: Abandoning New Orleans - essay about whether or not it is worth it to rebuild New Orleans after the hurricane katrina.

1117 words - 4 pages Orleans should not be rebuilt due to its ongoing health concerns, cost to the economy and its geological location. The first problem that needs to be looked at before anyone can even go back into New Orleans, is the contamination found in the flooded waters.New Orleans was a disaster waiting to happen. Hurricane and flood preparation in the city of New Orleans has always been an issue, even before Katrina struck. Its location is a huge threat, having

The Treaty of Versailles - Fair or Unfair?

632 words - 3 pages well as others. The Treaty of Versailles was unfair.Punishing Germany harshly is what the French dreamed of. From their perspective, the treaty was not fair enough and that it should have been harsher. France wanted full revenge on Germany for the destruction they caused to France during the war. Clemenceau's ideal outcome would have been to see Germany destroyed by the treaty. The French felt unsafe being so close to the Germans as they did not

Is Frances "The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of Citizens," more democratic, or liberal? In the classical sense.

528 words - 2 pages Democratic point of view is not represented as strongly because of the absence of representation of the people at large.Liberalism is the ideology that an individual is born with civil rights/freedoms, security of their own person, beliefs and private property. Eight of the articles in the declaration reflect a liberal standpoint, particularly the very first article that states, “Men are born, and always continue, free, and equal in respect of

Similar Essays

The Democratic System Of Government Is Appropriate For Pakistan

904 words - 4 pages Certain countries in the world have been ruled by the military dictators as well as the democratic leaders. Pakistan is one of the finest examples of such a system. In Pakistan, military and democratic government exchange hands time and again and this chain goes on. This is evident from the past experiences. This is also evident from current economic crisis of the country after a long period of dictatorship. It seems that the democratic system

The Canadian Human Rights Act: Controversial Or Not?

1747 words - 7 pages Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, who tried Lemire’s case, proceeded to dismiss the charge as he too shared the public’s view. The CHRC appealed the decision made by the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal in Warman v. Lemire to the Federal Court of Canada, a ruling from which may or may not establish a precedent that will effectively negate Section 13. However, the assertion, made by members of the public and Judge Hadjis, which states that Section 13 is

Is The American Justice System Fair To Blacks

1087 words - 4 pages A study by the National Center on Institutions and Alternatives found that 85% of all Washington, D.C., black males have been arrested at least once in their lifetimes. Obviously this shows that most black people are just a bunch of criminals and felons, right? Not in my opinion. One viewpoint, which is continuously argued throughout the country, is whether or not the criminal justice system is fair to blacks. Did you know that, in Dallas, if

So What If The Canadian System Is Broke?

629 words - 3 pages alarming, however, for I intend to talk about our political system.Claims that there is something wrong with our political system are not new, of course. In fact, they have become rather trite. Most of the comments about what's wrong with the system, however, tend to focus on the institutions of democratic society. And most of the "solutions" or corrections therefore have to do with creating new institutions or patching up the old ones.I am not come