This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Caribbean Identity Essay

1484 words - 6 pages

The Caribbean Identity

The way in which Benítez-Rojo and Mintz tackle the question of Caribbean identity in their articles, is a removed, objective ideal, in contrast to Michelle Cliff’s portrayal of Jamaican identity. Cliff’s portrayal touches the heart and soul of Caribbean identity. While Mintz and Benítez-Rojo are investigating trends in the Caribbean as a whole, from an outside perspective, Cliff offers the personal, tactile imagery of what it is to live in the Caribbean, utilizing the objective account of history as a background. Furthermore, Cliff deals with Jamaica, one island in the Caribbean, while Mintz and Benítez-Rojo are dealing with the Caribbean on a grand scaled overview. The fact is neither article can be taken as complete truth. In fact, although Cliff uses history in her novel, I believe the account of history from someone who has completely accessed the interior of a place, is always going to be biased. Likewise, Mintz and Benítez-Rojo in making their hypotheses, are lacking an insider’s view. It is the difference between a Caribbean person and Caribbeanist, respectively. Therefore, while on a logical level, an analytical level, Benítez-Rojo and Mintz’s, conclusions as to Caribbean identity could rightly be accepted, these two authors do not possess the experience and intensity to make me as a reader, convinced of their conclusions.

Benítez-Rojo and Mintz do utilize imagery in their texts. For example, Benítez-Rojo quotes E. Dovergier as a manner of displaying with images what he has attempted to explain regarding rhythm as being the unifying factor of Caribbean culture. Part of this description reads, "the buyers buzz around like a swarm of flies; they haggle, they gesticulate, they laugh, they babble in the harmonious colonial patois." (Benítez-Rojo, 1992, p. 79) Now, this imagery is excellent- reading it, I can envision what Benítez-Rojo is explaining. However, the author is using the quote to prove his point that except for rhythm, there is no common theme in the islands of Caribbean as far as culture goes. The incentive/ motivation for utilizing imagery is at the other end of the spectrum of Cliff’s motivation. Cliff’s motivation is to communicate to the reader how it is to live in the Caribbean. She is not writing to analyze or make sense of how it is, though her use of historical background offers some clues as to the development of the Caribbean society. For example, the following is a description of a funeral procession Cliff, as character Clare, witnesses it:

The procession moved forward underneath a steady hum, which at first seemed of the same key and pitch, but soon differentiated into harmony, led by the high falsetto of a man, whose voice circled the hum and turned it into a mourning chant. The words of the chant were strange, unrecognizable. (Cliff, 1995, p. 50)

It is important to note that Cliff does question elements of Jamaica’s society. Works such as The Diary of Anne Frank provoke questions...

Find Another Essay On The Caribbean Identity

Analysis of the Sea is History by Derek Walcott

1601 words - 6 pages Derek Walcott, acclaimed Caribbean author, writes to make sense of the legacy of deep colonial damage. Born in 1930 in the island of St. Lucia, Walcott has a melancholic relationship with Caribbean history which shapes the way he carefully composes within “The Sea is History.” Walcott’s application of Biblical allusions seeks to revise and restore Caribbean identity. Born on the island a former British colony in the West Indies, established

The Caribbean According to Three Writings

1497 words - 6 pages )." According to Mintz, it was the plantation that began the separations in Caribbean cultures, while Benitez-Rojo seems to think that the "Africanizing" of the creole culture was already in place. In calling the creole culture "Africanized" before the explosion in the slave-trade, Benitez-Rojo touches on an idea that neither Cliff nor Mintz mention. History/Identity Both of Cliff’s works focus on identity. In "If I Could Write This in Fire

Music in the Caribbean

1801 words - 8 pages Lyrics." March 21, 2011. http://islandlyrics.com/lyrics-david_rudder-rally_round_the_west_indies.htm (accessed November 02, 2013). Oecs Culture. "Caribbean Culture." 2013. http://www.oecsculture.com/caribbean-culture/ (accessed November 01, 2013). Ray Allen, Lois Wilcken. "Island Sounds in the Global City: Caribbean Popular Music and Identity in New York." 1-6. Illinois: University of Illinois Press, 1988. RexRuff. "The Bob Marley Influence and

The Subversion of Beauty in Rhys’s Wide Sargasso Sea

1836 words - 8 pages literature. My argument in this paper is two-fold: I believe that Jean Rhys writes about this beauty attributed to the Caribbean as a rejection of European influence on the Caribbean and a declaration of the Caribbean’s independence over colonialism, and that his characterization of Christophine is his definition of true Caribbean beauty and identity. I will attempt to explain how this is significant to our understanding of these works, and the Caribbean

Rebecca

1270 words - 6 pages identity. Similarly in The Origin of Waves Tim and John who are also Barbadian immigrants reflect on their past life in Barbados and make comparisons with the hardship they have endured in Canada. The two childhood friends accidentally meet in a snowstorm in Canada, however, the first chapter of the novel provides a flashback to the Caribbean and already Clarke reveals the dislocation that results from being in an unfamiliar space as the sun

The Social Impact of Slavery on the Caribbean Society

1332 words - 5 pages Caribbean. When reading the book one sentence rings true, this sentence strikes at the heart, it is a feeling that is ever so present in those coming from the colonized Caribbean. " She was a colonized child, and she lived within certain parameters-which clouded her judgement." We from the Caribbean always seem to question ourselves, to question our identity, our duality and for most of us our ‘tri-ality’. In reading Cliffe’s ideas about

'Crick Crack Monkey' by Merle. CaribbeanExcepts highly influenced by the British ideals: Merle Hodge's 'My Aunt Gold Teeth' by V. S. Naipaul, and 'If I could Write This in Fire, I Would Write This in

1463 words - 6 pages story, a totally different picture would unfold. For if Gold Teeth received an education equivalent to a white person, she would be able to discern that her change in religion would not affect her husbands health. Caribbean writers clearly express the inadequacies in the education system, and the problems can be traced to the British occupancy.A final affect the British had on the people of the Caribbean was the loss of their identity, and the lack

Life in Trinidad and Tobago

2312 words - 9 pages Be a Man: Culture, Socialization and Gender Identity in Five Caribbean Communities by Barry Chevannes Review by: Pedro A. Noguera Social and Economic Studies, Vol. 52, No. 2 (June 2003), pp. 167-170 Published by: Sir Arthur Lewis Institute of Social and Economic Studies, University of the West Indies Article Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/27865332 Sharpe, Jenny, and Samantha Pinto. "The Sweetest Taboo: Studies Of Caribbean

"The Autobiography of My Mother" by Jamaica Kincaid as an anticolonial text

1528 words - 6 pages forced to accept the culture of those in power which eventually leads to self-effacement. However Kincaid subverts the relationship of the colonised and the coloniser in this novel. Unlike many colonised people, Xuela succeeds in constructing her own identity and asserting her rights against those in power. Through her character, Kincaid shows the Caribbean daughters' dynamics of resistance. Xuela's refusal to adhere to the stereotypical roles

Caribbean Integration

2361 words - 9 pages job opportunities for Caribbean people      the creation of a Caribbean identity According to McAfree, “Strengthened regional cooperation could enhance the Caribbean’s self reliance and productive capacity. Exchanges of skills and technology, and a division of labour among Caribbean states in the production of various commodities and specialised services, could increase economic efficiency and the quality

Exploring the Reasons for Differences in Educational Achievement Between Different Ethnic Groups

1103 words - 4 pages Exploring the Reasons for Differences in Educational Achievement Between Different Ethnic Groups I believe that this is an important issue to consider as research has shown that whilst Afro-Caribbean males are at the very bottom in terms of achievement, West Indian females tend to do even better than white females at GCSE. Sociologists such as Cecil Wright link educational achievement with teacher racism and labelling

Similar Essays

The Identity And History Of The Caribbean

2174 words - 9 pages The Identity and History of the Caribbean The Caribbean is a vastly diverse area representing the effects of colonialism, slavery, and the combination of many cultures. Since the arrival of Europeans the Caribbean islands have been going through constant change. The loss of native peoples and the introduction of the plantation system had immediate and permanent reprocussions on the islands. The Plantation system set up a society which

The Caribbean Islands Essay

1205 words - 5 pages , Antonio Benitez-Rojo, and Michelle Cliff, all and address the problem of the Caribbean’s identity. They each discuss how the Caribbean’s diverse culture was created and molded by each individual island’s history, how its society was molded by the development of plantations, how the Caribbean dealt with the issue of slavery, and how miscegenation and the integration of cultures, as a result of slavery, contributed to the region’s individualism in

Lost In Translation Literature And Language Of The Caribbean

638 words - 3 pages others try to convey the personal triumphs and hardships of the individuals that inhabit the Caribbean space. In Her True-True Name: An Anthology of Women’s Writing from the Caribbean, the reader experiences both differences in the way the language conveys identity and the themes from the different authors. Literature has to be translated surely in order for the words to be read by people across the world. Reading the stories from Cuba

The Caribbean Essay

1119 words - 4 pages The Caribbean The inhabited islands clustered in the Caribbean Sea are an interesting study in cultural and social identity. Colonized by european powers from the Fifteenth Century, the Caribbean islands have become mixtures of cultures from Europe, Africa, and India, as well as from the original inhabitants of the islands. As a result, describing and defining the Caribbean is a much more difficult task than it appears on the surface. The