This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Case Of Conjoined Twins An Ethical Dilemma

3253 words - 13 pages

Jodie and Mary are twins joined at their lower abdomens. Jodie is an alert baby, with functioning heart and lungs. Mary has no effective heart or lung function and lives purely because of her attachment to Jodie. According to commonly accepted medical evidence, Jodie’s life would be virtually as long as, and would have the quality of, that of any ordinary child if separated from Mary. It is clear that if the twins were separated then Mary would die. Equally, it is clear that if the twins were not separated then eventually Jodie’s heart and lungs will fail and both twins will die. The parents are resolutely opposed to any surgery for the twins as they feel it would be morally wrong to intentionally cause the death of one of their twins.The doctors have two choices. They can apply to the courts to undergo the operation against the parents’ wishes, or they can respect the parents’ wishes and not operate.A scenario like this raises a number of issues, whether it be the individuals involved, the laws or the challenges involved in making the ‘right’ decision. In addition many ethical questions usually arise in trying to understand or explain the situation. For example, will the outcome of the surgery be successful? Is sacrificing one twin to save the other justified?In this rare case of conjoined twins, the decision on separation presents a conflict of interest between the parents’ values and the medical professionals’ expertise or duty. The outcome also presents a ray of possibilities. Firstly if surgery is carried out, there are a number of potential results e.g. a successful separation, the death of the weaker twin, the separation resulting in the death of both twins or a risk of long-term complications during and after surgery. However if the surgery is not carried out, this could result in both twins dying due to the heart mass or lungs not being able to support two growing babies or Jodie having a slimmer chance of a longer life.Furthermore, since this case is dealing with babies, the complexity of making a decision extends. Thus, in order to weigh out the best possible solution, both sides of the conflict need to be taken into consideration.Both Jodie and Mary’s parents, as well as the doctors are both dealing with the case on the basis of ‘best interest’ in regards to the twins. However their opinion as to what the ‘best interests’ for the twins are, is very much different.As health professionals, the doctors’ responsibility is always the care of the patient and in making the best possible decision in the interest of the patient. If we accept that as patients we tend to embrace the ‘doctor knows best’ theory, we can see why they may present a stronger argument. In this case the doctors being those in support of the separation can be seen as overriding the autonomous wishes of the parents, with the goal of benefiting one of the twins or acting in their ‘best...

Find Another Essay On The Case of Conjoined Twins- an Ethical Dilemma

An Ethical Dilemma within the Army

1619 words - 6 pages that your children are good enough to go to combat but not good enough to remain in our ranks in garrison. How would you feel if this were your child? As operations begin to draw down in Iraq, you could make the case that this is an ethical dilemma of the past. We will not need as many troops in the future. This may be true, but consider for a moment the following. MSNBC.com posted an Associated Press article in 2005 that highlights some

Banking: An Ethical Dilemma? Essay

2628 words - 11 pages Topic: Banking; an ethical dilemma? Name: Kan Shen ID number: u1368086 Module: Introduction to financial services Module code: BFE0012 Tutor: Shabbir Dastgir and David Pearson Date: 11 March, 2014 Word count: 2300 Introduction With the massive development of modern society, people’s income statement has become better and better. The bank has played the important role in many different kinds of areas such as loan contracts

An Ethical Dilemma

1526 words - 7 pages guilty. Bowen’s ethical dilemma was this: Was it ethical to leave the Sadhu after doing his part to assist him, or should he have done more? This particular case also sheds light on Individual Ethics contrasted with Group Ethics. Bowen comes to the realization that he “walked by an ethical dilemma without appropriate action”. How can one identify an ethical dilemma upon encountering a situation such as this? An Ethical Dilemma is a complicated

Abortion: An ethical dilemma

1960 words - 8 pages Abortion, the intentional termination of a pregnancy through surgical or medical devices, was legalized in 1973. This issue of abortion has caused a great segregation in our country. Often the debate is thought to be conservative versus liberal, republican versus democrat, but more accurately it is pro-life versus pro choice. A pro-life stance opposes the belief that a woman should have the freedom to choose an abortion in the case that for any

The Ethical Dilemma of E-Cigarette Regulation

2401 words - 10 pages Introduction Ethical dilemmas occur on many different scales. These dilemmas, and the complexity attached to them, range from personal to corporate conflict. Depending on the nature and structure of a particular situation and the values in conflict, personal definitions of what an ethical dilemma is may vary. Harold Gortner defines an ethical dilemma as “ a situation where two or more competing values are important and in conflict. If you serve

The Dilemma Of An Accountant

1344 words - 5 pages The ethical dilemma in this case is one that Daniel Potter is faced with. Daniel is a staff accountant at a Big Eight accounting firm, Baker Greenleaf. He was given the duty of performing an audit on a wholly-owned real estate subsidiary (Sub) of a long-standing and important client of his firm. Oliver Freeman is Daniel’s project manager. Oliver is the one that gave Daniel the task of performing the audit, and he is expecting a clean

Find the main issues that arise from 1)<Tab/>Re A Conjoined Twins [2001] Fam. 147:21

1721 words - 7 pages was argued by Lord Ward. We must to admit that was a real challenge to override the binding precedent that was arising from the previous case of Queen v Dunley and Stephens. It took us a lot of effort to understand his arguments and how these were applying in the occasion of the conjoined twins.One of the main issues of the case is the parent's views. The parents of the Siamese twins disagree with the separation. They said 'we cannot begin to

Hypothetical Treatment of Ethical Dilemma

1969 words - 8 pages This paper is an analysis of a hypothetical vignette in which a counselor-in-training named Callie, a fairly experienced and nearly-licensed counselor supervisee, approaches her counselor supervisor for advice and direction regarding an ethical dilemma. The purpose of this paper is to identify the ethical and legal implications of the dilemma along with an optimal solution to ethically resolve the issue. Using the Forrester-Miller and Davis

Mandatory vaccination in Children – an ethical dilemma

2280 words - 10 pages researches by financial rewards. In modern medicine, ethical principle of autonomy weigh more than beneficence, non-maleficence and justice implying the physician has to respect the decision of an individual even if he knows that the patient is wrong1. In the case of a child, the parents are their decision makers. Parents always decide for the best interest of their child, for which they need the correct and accurate information regarding safety of

Physician Assisted Suicide: An Ethical Dilemma

1939 words - 8 pages they began using the Mercitron, because as a doctor he didn’t want them to experience pain. (Jackson). The use of this machine brought about an ethical dilemma. Is it ethical for terminally ill patients to end their own lives with the assistance of their doctor? Many patients when faced with this decision do not wish to go through the suffering or loss of abilities for doing every day activities. They want to die before they become incapacitated

An Analysis of Racism Conjoined with Affirmative Action

1219 words - 5 pages brought to the Supreme Court Justices. This case arose from Michigan’s Proposal 2, which prohibits the special treatment of students based on race and other things, which was on a ballot that voters voted in support of the proposal. It was sent to the Supreme Court to see if the proposal was considered to be unconstitutional. The decision was “Reversed, 6-2, in an opinion by Justice Kennedy on April 22, 2014.” (Kennedy, 2014). There were many

Similar Essays

The Unusual Physical And Emotion Bond Of Conjoined Twins

637 words - 3 pages often have a difficult time bending their backs forward and backwards and sitting up straight. In the case of conjoined twins, it is doubly difficult, not just because there are two babies involved, but also because the children who survive face tremendous obstacles, and the parents must make with tremendous decisions. Conjoined twins are rare, and few public resources exist specifically for conjoined twins or their families. But there are a number

The Conjoined Twins Jodie And Mary

1093 words - 4 pages The Conjoined Twins Jodie and Mary The moral and legal case of the conjoined twins Mary and Jodie has set the nation off in a frenzy of debating on whether or not the twins should be separated. In doing so, it has been revealed that only Jodie has a chance of surviving the operation, meaning the operation is virtually an act of murder in order to save Jodie's life. It has also been made known that if both twins are left

Euthanasia, An Analysis Of An Ethical Dilemma

1083 words - 4 pages Voluntary euthanasia is defined as the act of killing someone painlessly, especially to relieve suffering from an incurable illness, with their consent (Collins English Dictionary, 2013). The morality and legal aspect of voluntary euthanasia has been a debate for many years. Voluntary euthanasia is a significant ethical dilemma that impacts nursing practice and other professionals in the healthcare field. With the utilization of ethical

The Ethical Dilemma Of Euthanasia Essay

822 words - 3 pages The Ethical Dilemma of Euthanasia An incredibly controversial issue clouds the minds of millions of people everyday as death confronts them. The problem revolves around the ethics of euthanasia. Should medical assisted suicide be outlawed in all situations or under certain circumstances, could it be considered ethical? Do humans violate nature’s course with science and advanced technology by playing God? Why should doctors and