The Cathedral Response Paper

1424 words - 6 pages

New criticism uses important elements that factor into its nature when closely examining the texts of different types of literary works. Formal elements like voice, irony, and speaker all have different functions when communicating what’s being read between the lines of poetry, text, and style. In this story, the author uses logical formal fundamentals we use when constructing the many different ideas, the author is trying to tell us. However, in the short story, “Cathedral” by Raymond Carvers, his theories are shown thorough examination of the narrator’s hesitation, of his wife’s blind friend Robert is coming over for a visit. Since Carvers doesn’t give the narrator a specific name, he gives his readers the tools to personalize who that could be. “Cathedral” ends with Robert and the narrator hand in hand, drawing the cathedral. The narrator has his eyes closed as he guides Robert through the process of constructing an image while not being able to see. Both men become equal, giving the reader a different outlook from the fearfulness the narrator succumbed to before the visit.
“Cathedral” starts off with the narrator describing his wife’s past job relationship with a blind man many years before their marriage. “This blind man, an old friend of my wife’s, he was on his way to spend the night. His wife had died. So, he was visiting his wife’s relatives in Connecticut” (32). However, the narrator is worried and not fond of the sleep-over because of Robert’s blindness and his wife’s past relationship. This shows that the narrator has a stigma towards blind people, while also stating that he has never been around a blind person before. His stigma is shown by his attitude and thoughts about Robert. Throughout the night, the narrator’s relations changed and became effortless and uneasy as the wife went off to bed. It became uneasy because he didn’t have to worry about the wife staring or showing signs she still has feelings for Robert. His insecurities went away. The narrator asked Robert if he knew what the cathedral was, when he replied with “no”; however, the narrator decided to describe it for him. Robert then gets a bright idea for them two, to draw it together. Robert and the narrator then proceed to draw, hand in hand. The narrator closes his eyes at the request of Robert. Meanwhile what becomes of the drawing is unknown, but the narrator seems to become spiritually aware of the “sight” Robert possess. Carver’s proposal of the blind man becoming the light-bearer of a closed-minded individual captures a classic ideal: “Never judge a book by its cover”.
The narrator’s point of view is not one of happiness and cheerfulness. For Carver to wants the reader to appreciate and be interested about the narrator’s point of view, he causes the narrator to reflect on his wife’s past marriage, “her too-close-for-comfort” relationship with Robert, and his own dysfunctional reality between himself and his wife, “My wife finally took her eyes off the blind man...

Find Another Essay On The Cathedral - Response Paper

Response paper on the short story: "Bone" written by Fae Myenne Ng. Not too long but decent for its size

629 words - 3 pages Response Paper on BoneFae Myenne Ng's Bone narrates the story of an immigrant Chinese family settled in Chinatown. The story revolves around various types of relationships among the characters, with marriage as a common thread binding them all. The author presents different types of marriages and their respective effects on the protagonist's family, such as Mah's first and second marriages, and Leila's marriage to Mason Louie.First person

The shared Patio by Miranda response - Eng 102 - Response paper

558 words - 3 pages The Shared Patio response In The Shared Patio by Miranda July she shows that Miranda is a lonely woman who demands comfort and love.Miranda shows that she needs someone in her life that could take away her loneliness. “What if she and I were close friends,What if I borrowed her,clothes and she said,That looks better on you, you should keep it” this shows that Miranda is looking for a friend that shares her feelings with her and try to express

Response Paper: Mamma Mia! The Musical

2061 words - 9 pages “A mother. A daughter. Three possible dads. And a trip down the aisle you’ll never forget!” MAMMA MIA! The Musical performed on Tuesday March 18, 2014 at the Hanover Theater by Work Light Productions written by the British playwright Catherine Johnson and directed by Phyllida Lloyd. A musical based on the 1970’s Swedish pop band ABBA top charter album ABBA GOLD: THE GREATEST HITS set on a Greek island vacation getaway unfolding the bride-to-be’s

The True Costs Documentary - Response Paper

633 words - 3 pages The True Costs is a documentary that tells about the true side of the fashion industry. It shows the audience how ignorant we have been to the stuff we take for granted. Worker’s in places like Bangladesh make our clothes for little to no pay in terrible working conditions. The workers are working in a building that is not fit for people to even be in. The buildings recently have been collapsing and killing many people inside. Women, men and

Reflective Response - "My Papa's Waltz" - Theodore Roethke. A response paper describing the situation in the poem

827 words - 3 pages Roethke, Theodore. My Papa's Waltz. Retellings: A Thematic Literature Anthology. Eds. Clarke, M.B. and A.G. Clarke. Boston: McGraw-Hill, 2004. 67-68Roethke's "My Papa's Waltz" initially bestows upon the reader a scene of a father and child passing by the evening's late hours in dance, and then finally rest. Further investigation of the poem's lines provides quite a few alternate meanings that completely differ from the initial portrait that is

Response paper: "The Implications of the Lavell Case"

835 words - 3 pages Original article fund here: identity has two polices; one is based on the person's biology/ race or blood quantum. The other subjective is self-definition and cultural affiliations (Martin - Hill, 2006).To be an Indian in Canada is not just a cultural identity but also a legal category. The Canadian State, rather than aboriginal communities themselves, has, through the Indian Act of

"Gothic Architecture in France" This paper talks about the Abbey of St. Denis, the Chartres Cathedral, Amiens Cathedral, Abbot Suger, Robert Luzarches, with quotes from Scholar H.W. Janson, etc

1321 words - 5 pages become a symbol of wealth and prosperity for many European cities.The first Gothic architectural project will begin with the rebuilding of the Royal Abbey Church of St. Denis by Abbott Suger. This cathedral is located North of Paris. The apse of the original church of Abbot Suger's caught fire in 1140, so reconstruction was necessary. This church was a shrine of the Apostle of France, as well as a memorial to the Carolingian Dynasty. Some of the

The Night in Question Collection - Short Story - Response Paper

444 words - 2 pages The Night in Question by Tobias Wolff The Night in Question is Tobias Wolff’s second collection of short stories which embraces settings of wars and is driven by conflict as it explores aspects of loyalty and betrayal. The title The Night in Question appears to suggest that the main characters in each of the stories are guilty of something and are having their behavior assessed for them or by them. In “Powder,” the narrator’s father keeps making

Reflective Response - "A Wasp's Look at Lizzie Border" - Florence King. A response paper describing the situation in the poem

541 words - 2 pages King, Florence. "A Wasp Looks at Lizzie Borden". Retellings: A Thematic Literature Anthology. Eds. Clarke, M.B. and A.G. Clarke. Boston: McGraw-Hill, 2004. 246-253Lizzie was acquitted of the murders, but King assumes she was guilty. What evidence does King offer? How convincing is it?King's "A Wasp Looks at Lizzie Border" gives the reader a portrayal of the Borden murders that Angela Carter's "The Fall River Axe Murders" does not. King shows us

This paper is a review and response to the motion picture, Gandhi

589 words - 2 pages Gandhi's MessageThe movie Gandhi is a focus on the life Mahatma Gandhi, and the message of peace and equality between people of all religions and all races and all walks of life that he presented. Gandhi believed that his message was bigger than himself and he was completely dedicated to the message and was willing to give up everything including his own life for it.We first see Gandhi's belief in equality of all people when he is still a

Summary Paper on The Perils of Obedience by Stanley Milgram Response to his writing Christina Mahoney

1122 words - 4 pages ourselves from the final "evil" outcome. He brings up Eichmann who was sickened by visits to the concentration camps in Nazi Germany. Eichmann ordered the execution of the Jews and was able to say he was simply "following orders". By alienating ourselves from the final outcome by saying we were following orders we can remove the evil from ourselves and place it on someone else's shoulders.In Response:In response to Stanley Milgram's "The Perils of

Similar Essays

Gift Of The Gorgon Response Paper

842 words - 4 pages Gift of the Gorgon Response Paper The Gift of the Gorgon is a two and a half hour play that I believe is worth seeing because it is exciting, and it kept me on the edge of my seat throughout the entire play. Although it was not just me, the rest of the audience seemed just as captivated as I did as the mesmerizing plot of Peter Shaffer's unfortunate tale unfolded. After the death of the playwright Edward Damson, his son Philip Damson travels to

October: The Story Of The Russian Revolution Response Paper History Response Paper

847 words - 4 pages October: The Story Of The Russian Revolution ​Response Paper 1 China Miéville’s book, ​October: The Story Of The Russian Revolution​, attempts to convey the significance of the two 1917 revolutions in Russia, the first of which occurring in February that successfully overthrew the imperial government and the second, taking place in October, placed the Bolsheviks as the nation's reigning power. Although the book does provide extensive detail on

The Odyssey Response Paper

2396 words - 10 pages True wisdom, according to the Odyssey, is having the ability to reflect on your experiences and tradition, and then doing what ought to be done in similar situations based on the virtues you learned and gained through these insights. The Odyssey portrays a man’s journey toward and growth in true wisdom through his better knowledge of human nature. He undergoes many different trials on his journey back to his home and family, and it is during

(Introduction Paper) The Impact Of Formative Assessment And Feedback On Student Learning Using The Student Response System

2339 words - 9 pages , V. (2007). Teaching with student response systems in elementary and secondary education. Educational Technology, Research and Development, 55(4), 315-346. Retrieved April 19, 2009, from ProQuest Education Journals database. Rochelle, J., Penuel, W.R., & Abrahamson, L. (2004). Classroom response and communication systems: Research review and theory. Paper presented at the 2004 Meeting of the American Education Research Association. San Diego