"The Catholics Were Never A Serious Threat To Elizabethan Church And State." How Far Do You Agree With This Statement?

1773 words - 7 pages

Haigh argues that the 'strategic and logical errors' of the Seminary Priests not only prevented Catholicism from posing a serious threat during the reign of Elizabeth but were responsible for its decline. However, other historians - and historical evidence - suggest that when Elizabeth came to the throne, the Catholics were a serious threat. The involvement of the Catholics at the beginning of Elizabeth's reign - in formulating the Religious Settlement and in passing the Acts of Supremacy and Uniformity - shows that Elizabeth considered them a power to be reckoned with. However the Policy of Continuity undid much of the Catholic input to the Religious Settlement, by introducing the people to Protestant ritual via their regular service, and the Seminary Priests, on top of Haigh's purported 'strategic and logical errors', found them an unwilling audience. Increasingly strict government legislation meant that the Recusants, although they held strong beliefs, could not air them and the Church Papist majority never heard what the inflammatory Jesuit and Seminary Priests had to say.The fact that within 5 years of the Religious Settlement, Louvainist attacks on the Elizabethan Church were reaching England is testament to the excellent organisation of the Catholics at the beginning of Elizabeth's reign. The Protestants, exiled, divided and weakened during Mary's reign, could not have hoped to pose such a formidable challenge to Elizabeth in the 1560s. By 1566, Elizabeth was suggesting ships be searched for smuggled Catholic books. However, it swiftly transpired that the Catholics had nothing to put their organisation towards. The fact that the Pope offered no decisive guidance on the event of Elizabeth's ascension was hugely detrimental to the size of the Catholic threat: they were amply prepared to take action at the beginning of the reign, but did not know what action to take. The penalties the Government imposed upon Catholics had grown increasingly harsh, from the 1560s when the Queen 'only took vigorous action against individuals who openly defied the law' (Doran) to the 1590s when even Catholics who promised not to rebel were not tolerated. In an increasingly hostile political and religious climate, it became increasingly difficult for Catholics to operate - just as the Protestants had had their power bases broken down during the previous reign. If action had been taken while the Government's policy was still tolerant, and the Catholics still had their Marian-era power, they might have been a far more serious threat than they eventually became. The Papal Bull of 1570 came too late - Doran suggests that William Allen actually advised Catholics to ignore it. It could be that by this point in the reign, its effective incitements of civil war were unpalatable to the weakened religious minority, with the 1569 Northern Rebellion fresh in their minds as an example of how disorganised and scattered they had become. The execution of Mary Queen of Scots in...

Find Another Essay On "The Catholics were never a serious threat to Elizabethan Church and State." How far do you agree with this statement?

"The most important reason why there was little opposition in Germany towards the Nazi regime was its use of Propaganda" How far do you agree with this statement?

1207 words - 5 pages strengthening the faith of those who support them that they did pick the right party, the Nazis did this fairly successfully.As soon as word of Nazi genocide spread to Allied nations, the Nazis used propaganda for a very different reason: to cover up atrocities. The Nazis started forcing concentration camp prisoners to send postcards home, stating that they were treated well and living in good conditions.On June 23, 1944, the Nazis permitted an

"The Soviet Union should be responsible for the Cold War, instead of the USA." How far do you agree to this statement?

1287 words - 5 pages economy so that it could resist communism. In theory, East European nations could join the plan but Americans made it clear that communist states were not welcomed. The Truman Doctrine and Marshall Plan were aimed to minimize influence of communism from spreading into Eastern Europe. More importantly, this indirectly condemned communist ideals of Russia, posing a direct threat to Russia's spread of communism. This inevitably created tension and

"Monopoly is against the interest of the consumer." To what extent do you agree with this statement and why?

1388 words - 6 pages Monopolies can be national (royal mail), regional (water companies) or local (petrol station). Unlike a perfect competition situation were firms are 'price takers' and only respond to consumer demand, a monopoly finds itself in an imperfect competition market. In this type of market the firm is more of a 'price maker' and can therefore influence the market price. When comparing monopoly and perfect competition under the same conditions, we can

"Dreams and aspirations feature significantly in "The Caretaker." To what extent do you agree with this statement?

1339 words - 5 pages characters are hoping to live their "dream" life and the methods in which they display it in their speech. For example, Mick's use of shifting occupations as a way of domination over Davies plays out in this instance. He changes from being a lawyer in which he states "I can turn you to the police station in 5 minutes, have you in for trespassing, loitering with intent, daylight robbery, filching, thieving and stinking the place out." This shows how he

C.W.E. Bigsby suggests the Glass Menagerie asserts that people 'desire to live with comforting fictions, rather than confront brutal truths.' How far do you agree with this?

1663 words - 7 pages C.W.E. Bigsby suggests that the play asserts that people 'desire to live with comforting fictions, rather than confront brutal truths, a doomed and ultimately deadly strategy. It is a bleak vision of life.'How far do you agree with this evaluation of 'The Glass Menagerie'?In The Glass Menagerie none of the characters are capable of living completely in their present circumstances. They all retreat into their own little worlds to escape the

"Ideological differences played little part in the origin of the Cold War." How far do you agree with this judgment?

645 words - 3 pages opposite to communist ideology, which was about a one-party state where all was state-owned. A communist Russia would be a threat to the interests of the West. Although ideology was an important factor here, to say that this sole event was the origin of the Cold War would be ignoring significant events that occurred in following years.In 1933, Roosevelt became president of the US and recognized the USSR. If ideology were so important, would the

The League Of Nations - A Success In The 20’s, A Failure In The 30’s. How Far Do You Agree With This Satement?

534 words - 2 pages The League Of Nations was set up after World War One. The idea was discussed by American, British and French Politicians with the aims of; 1. Preventing future war, 2. Keeping the peace, 3. Deciding on matters via. the council. It wanted to do this through punishment methods, it did this through a system called "˜collective security' which meant that country's acted together to punish and stop any country that attacked another.During the

"The Wingfields and their gentleman caller are all dreamers." How far do you agree with this assessment of the characters in "The Glass Menagerie"?

1263 words - 5 pages At the very beginning of the play, Tom (as the narrator) describes to the audience that it is a "memory play", hence it has:"...dimly lighted, it is sentimental, it is not realistic."These features prove to the audience and reader that dreams often have to do with illusions and the lack of reality, which is a central theme in "The Glass Menagerie".TOM: "I give you truth in the pleasant disguise of illusion."Also, what is very evident while

'A short story tells us only one thing and that intensely' How far do you agree with his assertion.

912 words - 4 pages The Short StoryV.S Pritchett said: '...the short story tells us only one thing, and that, intensely.' I do not agree with this assertion and believe that whilst this might be true to some short stories, this cannot be applied to them all. To show this I will look at two short stories. 'A Very Short Story' (Ernest Hemingway) which I believe does conform to Pritchett's claim, and 'The Selfish Giant' (Oscar Wilde) which does not.There are many

"Revolutionaries were successful in putting their ideas into practice." Do you agree with this statement? Argue your case.

1416 words - 6 pages increased production in Russia to the stage where it was almost at pre-revolutionary levels after only 3 years of being introduced. The problem with Lenin doing this was that he now showed the Russian people the splendors received from a capitalistic economy. He became ill in late 1921 and died soon after so never saw Communism the way he had envisioned.France's revolutionaries were highly political; however the lack of doctrine meant they could be

'The most important reason why there was little opposition in Germany towards the Nazi regime was its use of propaganda' Explain how far you agree with this statement?

3809 words - 15 pages 'The most important reason why there was little opposition in Germany towards the Nazi regime was its use of propaganda' Explain how far you agree with this statement?Hitler's use of propaganda was very effective. It was in important factor to why there was little or no position in Nazi Germany from 1933-45; however it wasn't the only reason. Propaganda was a very powerful tool; Hitler used it to indoctrinate the German people with his Nazi

Similar Essays

"The Benefits Of Globalization Outweigh Its Cost." How Far Do You Agree With This Statement?

1478 words - 6 pages Fund . "Benefits" is defined as "advantage or profit" and "cost" is defined as the "effort or loss necessary to achieve something" by the Oxford dictionary of Current English.We agree to a large extent to the statement, "The benefits of globalization outweigh its cost." Even though there are some disadvantages in the process of globalization, but the benefits that the world receive far outweighs the costs of it. We have to look at the bigger

'the Roman Games Were Cruel And Degrading And Cannot Be Justified,' How Far Do You Agree With This Opinion?

921 words - 4 pages to why mythology may have played a part in the arena as well as elsewhere in Ancient Roman life.While I am of the opinion that the Roman games were indeed both 'cruel and degrading,' I do not think we can say that they are entirely unjustified, the Romans as we do, neededa method of both instilling law and order and ensuring the safety of Rome, the arena provided this.

'germany Was Economically United A Decade Before She Came Politically United.' How Far Do You Agree With This Statement?

925 words - 4 pages the Prussian Army ascended to the potion the Parliament would virtually become a Prussian Empire, with their King as Emperor he could call on the Army to do whatever he wanted and this foretold how Germany would be unified. By 1848 the economic union (Zollverien) was in full swing 38 out of the 39 states of the confederation where in it the only state not included was Austria, Metternich had refused to join it and his country would suffer for his

How Far Do You Agree With The Statement That Amir Only Saw Hassan As A Servant Not A Friend.

939 words - 4 pages How far do you agree with the statement that Amir only saw Hassan as a servant not a friend.The Kite Runner is a novel that challenges the social status of the Afghan society and the test and sacrifices of true friendship, Amir and Hassan's relationship tests both of these concepts. This is because the only factor standing between their friendship is the fact that Hassan is an different type of muslin to Amir.Amir has always seen Hassan as more