This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Characteristics Of God Essay

2646 words - 11 pages

The Characteristics of God
In Section eleven of An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding Hume argues that if a teleological argument is sufficient proof for a god, then that god must have deficiencies in morality, power, benevolence and intelligence. I will present Hume’s argument and the subsequent objections he considers. As well, I will defend Hume’s final position by giving my best objection to it and explaining how that objection fails.
Hume chooses to speak about the matter in the style of an imaginary dialogue between the ancient Greek philosopher Epicurus and the Athenian populace. I assume Hume did not do this to take a stance against the Greek pantheon but rather because the positions he presents in this argument could easily be seen as atheistic and openly being atheist was illegal in Scotland during Hume’s time.
The teleological argument that Hume allows for the purpose of building an argument for God’s imperfection is represented as follows:
-All things which appear intelligently designed have a creator.
-Nature (the universe) appears intelligently designed.
-Therefore nature has a creator (we will refer to the creator as god).
An auxiliary thought is added to this conclusion by apologists, that the aforementioned creator is a perfect god. Hume’s argument claims however, that this addition to the creator is not logically permitted and further still there are in fact other attributes which we should reason the creator to have. To justify this position, that from an effect we can infer of its cause only what is necessitated by the effect, Hume uses two examples of scales and of artists. In the example of scales Hume explains that if an object of unknown weight is placed on one side of a balance and an object known to weigh ten ounces on the other and the unknown object is seen to outweigh ten ounces, then we may only know that the unknown object weighs more than ten ounces; we may not infer from the scales that the unknown object weighs a specific amount or any threshold amount greater than ten ounces. Similarly if you happen upon a fine painting and have no knowledge of its painter, you are not justified in saying that the painter is as well a skilled stoneworker (though this remains a possibility). (EHU 11.13-14)
Hume’s argument that God is imperfect is viewed as follows:
-All things which are created reflect, in their qualities, the qualities of their creator.
-Nature was created. (from the teleological argument; we will refer to the creator as god.)
-Nature is flawed in moral order and in happiness.
-Therefore god is flawed in moral order, intelligence, or power, or benevolence (these being the causes which result in the aforementioned flaws in nature)
Hume is sympathetic to those who after accepting a teleological argument assert the stronger proposition that god must be capable of anything and that god is perfection, But he also points out that by making this assertion we are also required to give an explaination of the...

Find Another Essay On The Characteristics of God

Characteristics of the Online Learner Essay

973 words - 4 pages Characteristics of the Online Learner Learners (specifically adult) engage in learning or training for various reasons, i.e., learning new skills to, add value to their qualifications, mandated by their employers, optimize spare time etc. However, learners face the challenge of remaining motivated if they do not feel the training is relevant or practical. To develop effective training when preparing a training plan/instructional material

The Six Characteristics of Families Essay

842 words - 4 pages According to Garris L. Christian (2006) he describes the six characters of families, which are based on their own unique beliefs, cultural context, and family tradition. Three of the six characteristics that strongly resonate to me are role, rule, and hierarchy. Role family can be described as never good enough, peacemaker, everyone feels responsible within the family, a lot of activities, over worked, helpful at home, and/or outside. Each role

Characteristics of The Beowulf Poem

1050 words - 4 pages There are many characteristics of the Beowulf poem that make it a significant part of the history of literature. It is a perfect representation of how the people in eighth century England communicated, what their feelings were, and their culture. 'It gives us vital information about Old English social life and about Old English politics and about many things that scholars would like to have much more information on.'(Raffel ix) Another

The Characteristics of Intelligent Behavior

1187 words - 5 pages WOMAN’S UNIVERSITY IN AFRICA a) Describe the characteristics of intelligent behaviour (5 marks) Stair, R.M. and Reynolds, G.W (1996) defines intelligent behaviour as the ability to learn from experience and apply the acquired knowledge, handle complex situations, solve problems when important information is missing, determine what is important, react quickly and correctly to a new situation, understand visual images, process and manipulate

The Characteristics of Women Managers

797 words - 3 pages The Characteristics of Women Managers Working women managers are more competent (capable) than male managers, showing differences in management and leadership skills. Janet Irwin co-author for the 1997 survey study of Women are better bosses stated that "Women are stronger than men overall in both interpersonal skills and managerial effectiveness". Also studies showed that on average females are rated higher overall

The Characteristics of Meningococcal Disease

792 words - 4 pages This paper will cover the characteristics of meningococcal disease and the bacteria that cause it, Neisseria meningitides. Neisseria meningitides is a Gram-negative dipplococcus. It is a facultative anaerobe and is non-motile. The bacteria can live in a commensal relationship with the mucous membranes in the human nose (Peterson, n.d.). When grown in a colony (on a chocolate agar plate or a blood agar plate) it has a clearly defined edge, is

The Attributes of God

1403 words - 6 pages Characteristics of God - The Significance "What comes into our heads when we think about God is the main idea about us." So says A.W. Tozer in his timeless novel in the characteristics of God, The familiarity with the Sacred. Why would he make this kind of extreme pronouncement? In our hearts we understand the preceding is accurate. It's not sufficient to follow "God." Then we're simply creating an idol in our heads, if we all simply make up our

The existance of God

1588 words - 6 pages ." Both concluded that this great Being was perfect, was God and must exist in reality. Descartes and Anselm both use the non-believer to show the contradiction between the man who understands the concept of God but cannot connect God with existence. While Descartes moves from the implications and characteristics of a perfect God to prove He exists, Descartes maintains Anselm's established position of a perfect Being who must exist to achieve

The Existence of God

1724 words - 7 pages ). Given such characteristics draws criticism and ire considering that on any given day the world as we know it is plagued by death, pain, suffering, and an overall unsatisfactory life. It goes on to say that if God was what he is thought to be and more shouldn’t his power reflect as a utopian world? First of all, before using human suffering as an excuse to deny the existence of God it is necessary to establish the origins of suffering which fall

The Idea Of God

2394 words - 10 pages God as the supreme ruler and creator of the universe is a core tenant of many religious traditions. Judaism, Islam, and Christianity all have a God who whilst remaining completely transcendent interacts with the world of humanity. In order to create a coherent idea of God, the traditions must resolve the dialect of transcendent and immanent and the dialectic of love and justice. Judaism’s idea of God focuses on the creation of a covenantal

The Existence Of God

1209 words - 5 pages The Existence of God Works Cited Not Included For centuries, the idea of God has been a part of man's history. Past and present, there has always been a different integration consisting of the believers and the non-believers of God. The group of those who have "faith" in God tend to be related to one religion or another. On the other hand, the skeptics find the existence of God somewhat puzzling and try to seek the answers through

Similar Essays

Some Characteristics Of Adam, Eve, And God

1367 words - 5 pages Many people look to God for comfort. They live their lives based on His teachings in the Bible. People also look to their parents for comfort and live their lives based on what they teach them. In numerous ways, God is comparable to a parent. Providing comfort, setting rules, and disciplining are three traits of parents that God exhibits.One way God is similar to a parent is He provides comfort to His children. An example is when people are

God Exhibits Parental Characteristics. Uses Examples From The Old Testament Of The Bible To Prove That God Exhibits The Traits Of A Parent When Interacting With Humans

566 words - 2 pages Many people look to God for comfort. They live their lives based on His teachings in the Bible. People also look to their parents for comfort and live their lives based on what they teach them. In numerous ways, God is comparable to a parent. Providing comfort, setting rules, and disciplining are three traits of parents that God exhibits.One way God is similar to a parent is He provides comfort to His children. An example is when people are

The Characteristics Of Adolescents Essay

3113 words - 12 pages The Characteristics of Adolescents Works Cited Not Included Adolescence, the period of life between childhood and maturity, may be regarded as one of the most crucial stages through which the human individual passes in his journey from conception to death. For many, it is seen as the key stage in development. Changes in physique and the maturation of the reproductive system bring with them associated changes in

Characteristics Of The Misfit Essay

1089 words - 4 pages Characteristics Of The Misfit People can be very misunderstood, especially literary characters in dramatic stories. In Flannery O'Conners "A Good Man Is Hard To Find", the Misfit is judged by the grandmothers point of view. At the beginning of the story she reads about the Misfit and compiles her own data on his lifestyle, and says "I wouldn't take my children in any direction with a criminal like that aloose in it. That is basically