This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Church Of Scientology: Copyright Vs. Free Speech

1092 words - 4 pages

The Church of Scientology: Copyright vs. Free Speech

Abstract: In 1995, the Church of Scientology sued a number of parties, including the Washington Post, in an attempt to prevent the circulation of secret documents about the “religion.” This paper examines both sides of this issue, explores the implications to copyright law and the First Amendment, and describes the actual results of the case.

The Church of Scientology is a global organization with over 270 churches or missions worldwide. For decades, it has possessed followers with an almost fanatical devotion to their leader, L. Ron Hubbard. Since the advent of the Internet, the Church has begun to resort to various legal actions to maintain the secrecy of their “scriptures.”

On August 4, 1995, Arnaldo Lerma received a fax from a lawyer representing the Church of Scientology. This letter demanded that he remove from his webpage certain “Advanced Technology materials” from the Church. In the letter, the Church claimed both copyright and trade secret protection for the materials [1]. The next day, Lerma received an unannounced visit from two members of the Church who wanted to express their “concern” over the materials he posted. In response to this, Lerma sent a reply to the Scientologists’ lawyer and claimed that the materials he posted were affidavits taken from the public record, and so were not subject to copyright or trade secret protection. He also informed the law firm that he had sent a copy of the disputed materials along with a tape recording of the Scientologists’ visit to a reporter from the Washington Post [2].

On the morning of August 12, 1995, Arnie Lerma’s house was raided by lawyers of the Church of Scientology two armed Federal Marshals. According to posts on the newsgroup alt.religion.scientology from that morning, the lawyers were seeking “material legally obtained from the Federal Courthouse in Los Angeles … in which the upper level material, the secret, sacrid [sic] scriptures of the Cult, are revealed” [3]. The raid garnered media attention the next day; a Washington Post article quoted Lerma as saying that the cult seized “400 computer disks, four computer hard drives, a computer and
a scanner” [4].

On August 22, the Church of Scientology issued a press release announcing that they had sued the Washington Post for the return of the documents sent to them by Arnie Lerma. In the release, spokeswoman Leisa Goodman claimed that the Post “violated fundamental journalistic integrity by conspiring with lawless elements on the Internet to harm the religion of Scientology” [5]. The next day, an attorney for the paper responded by saying that “the documents at issue, which have been widely distributed over the Internet, were properly obtained by The Post from a public court file, a common and appropriate form of news-gathering. And the limited quotations included in The Post's story are well within the bounds of 'fair use' doctrine under copyright...

Find Another Essay On The Church of Scientology: Copyright vs. Free Speech

The Purpose of Copyright Essay

1412 words - 6 pages nor exaggerated, although this excessive attention constantly being drawn to it is certainly worth noting. The fact that copyrights are creating such an upheaval should not be attributed to over exaggeration. Instead, we must see this as a sign that copyrights as they are currently being maintained are in need of inspection and perhaps revision. Our excessive emphasis on claiming something as our property has caused copyright to act counter to

Copyright vs. the Right to Copy

2192 words - 9 pages Copyright vs. the Right to Copy Today's digital technology and the computer have changed how the average consumer can acquire information and entertainment. No longer do we have to wait for the CD to hear a new song, or the release date to watch a movie. The technology is available on our home computers. But is this an infringement on copyright? What about the rights of artists, authors, producers, or actors? Has our technology progressed so

The Scope of Free Speech: Categoricalism versus The Balancing Approach

942 words - 4 pages “Fag burns.” “DIE.” These slurs were scrawled outside the GLBT office at N.C. State last October. Should the instigator be indicted for hate speech in addition to vandalism? Was this expression an act of hate speech? Or was it free speech? Is the message he conveyed protected under the First Amendment? Two and a half centuries ago, the nation’s forefathers drafted the Constitution of the United States. The aim of the Constitution is to protect

The Challenge of Free Indirect Speech in Mrs. Dalloway

1350 words - 5 pages authoritative narrator that was previously used. Before free indirect direct was developed point of view was limited to direct or indirect speech. Direct speech is where a character’s speech is written exact. An example of this would be: “I’m going to take her to the movies with me tomorrow night,” he said. Indirect speech is when what the character’s speech is paraphrased by the narrator. An example of this is: He said he is going to take her to

The Restriction of Free Speech in McCullen v. Coakley

948 words - 4 pages A controversial modern U.S. Supreme Court decision is the McCullen v. Coakley case. An initial ruling for this case in Massachusetts, “…has made it a crime for speakers to ‘enter or remain on a public way or sidewalk’ within 35 feet of an entrance, exit, or driveway of ‘a reproductive health care facility.’ The law applies only at abortion clinics…In effect, the law restricts the speech of only those who wish to use public areas near abortion

Free Speech in the Military

904 words - 4 pages officials, as well as government issues that affect their lives, seems to be controversial because it limits one of the freedoms these sailors and soldiers have vowed to protect. To oppose the right of free speech of any member of the military takes away from the importance of the job they do. It has been argued that a member of the military should be mindful of whom they work for and the chain of command that orders come from, and that any display

The Freedom of Speech vs. Racism

1047 words - 4 pages on victims. In 1992, the court decided in R.A.V. vs. St. Paul that a cross burned in the front yard of an African American family by white teenagers was a form of protected symbolic speech. This decision effectively trumped the family's right to live in their home free from racial terrorism. Using the artificial distinction between speech and action, the Court decided that the act of burning a cross to intimidate a black family was equivalent to

Faith Based Organizations vs. the Separation of Church and State

2444 words - 10 pages First Amendment to the Constitution that formulates a mandate for the separation of church and state was designed to alleviate problems. Based on citations from a website article the Christian Banner exchange, in the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America states that, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or

Scientology and The Teachings of L. Ron Hubbard

1566 words - 6 pages is not based on conventional church ideals that are more familiar in older more widely known religions such as Christianity or Catholicism. Scientology is the modern religion based on the science fiction novelist L. Ron Hubbard. The goals of the Scientology is not to worship a specified deity but to discover the great question of “What are we put on this planet for?” Scientologists are given several creeds that are the instructions on how a

The Failure of Software Copyright Law

8556 words - 34 pages makers of computers handed out free accompanying software particular to their machines.5 Their thought was that this would encourage the purchase of their hardware. Soon, however, software producers began to copyright their products and the result was that each computer-maker had incompatible software.6 A company with sufficient lead-time over its competitors would

How Free Is Freedom of Speech?

987 words - 4 pages hateful things toward them on the internet, does freedom of speech sustain that? Freedom of speech is the right to express any opinions without censorship or restraint1. If someone says or posts something verbally harsh about someone else, are they not voicing their opinion on that particular individual? On that note, we must ask ourselves this: how free is freedom of speech allowed to be? Free enough to voice an opinion but restraining enough

Similar Essays

Behind The Stop Online Piracy Act Bill (Sopa): Copyright, Censorhip, And Free Speech

1700 words - 7 pages Behind SOPA: Copyright, Censorship and Free speech At the beginning of 2012, a series of coordinated protests occurred online and offline against Stop Online Piracy Act Bill (SOPA) that expands U.S. law enforcement’s ability to combat online copyright infringement. As this protest involved many influential websites like Google and Wikipedia, it certainly draws national attention on SOPA. Whether censorship should be used online against online

The Church Of Scientology Essay

3503 words - 14 pages “I'd like to start a religion. That's where the money is.” L Ron Hubbard The Church of Scientology began in the year 1953 and is one of the world's newest religions. In this essay I will address three questions: Who was L Ron Hubbard? What is the doctrine of Scientology? How does Scientology qualify as a religion? Lafayette Ronald Hubbard was born on March 13, 1911 in the town of Tilden, Nebraska and died on January 24, 1986

The Religion Of Scientology Essay

1728 words - 7 pages incorporates a vast body of knowledge developed from certain fundamental truths, such as: Man is a spiritual being with abilities beyond those of which he is usually aware; man is able to achieve new states of awareness he may never have dreamed possible. The intention of Scientology is a world without insanity, without criminals, without war, where man is free to achieve great feats. In the words of Mr. Ron Norton, Professor of Scientology

The Cult Of Scientology Essay

2843 words - 11 pages that Scientology is a cult in every sense of the word. Scientology's founder and High Priest was L. Ron Hubbard, the rather eccentric science fiction author. Most notable of his public literary achievements is the Dianetics series of books. Amazingly this rather delusional, but charismatic little man gave birth to one of the most controversial of the modern cults. In 1984 a judge who presided in a case involving Hubbard and his church said:"The