This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Cloning Debate Essay

1030 words - 4 pages

The Cloning Debate

Not so far in the future, a young boy of the age of six, dying a heart-wrenching death, will only be able survive with a bone marrow transplant.  His parents will have searched near and far for a match, but none will come to their aid.  The only possible way that they can produce a perfect match for their son's bone marrow is to clone their son.  Unfortunately, at this time this topic is still being discussed and debated upon with the government.  Their only child that has been their treasure for six years might die.  A clone of their son becomes their apple of aspiration to keep the treasure from being buried.

With a scenario as presented above, cloning might seem like the answer to hundreds of lives taken at the expense of uncontrollable forces.  But is there another side to the story?  Isn't there always?  Professor Kevin Williams of Georgetown University is still depicting the ambiguity of this topic when he states, "Like Adam and Eve, we want to be God, to be in control.  The question is, what are the limits?" (U.S. News World Report).  Making an identical copy of another human being is a rather drastic move, a move that in most people's eyes can only be carried through by God.  Some deem that cloning would put us in the shoes of God.  They believe that instead of God creating life, we would.  Some professors beg to differ, like David Fletcher of Wheaton College in Wheaton, IL who argues, "It is still only God who creates life."

Perhaps cloning is not the answer and our society should leave reproduction up to the natural ways.  But then one must ask themselves the question of 'why not'.  Is there some horrible outcome that will back fire due to the aberrant ways of creating a child?  Is bringing another soul into this world a sin?  If it is not natural, yes, some do believe that it is a crime against humanity (Address and Vitae) Rabbi Richard Address makes his view apparent when claiming, "[Cloning] is an area where we cannot go.  It violates the mystery of what it means to be human."  Along with Jewish leaders, Protestant theologians think cloning of humans would 'cross the line' (Herbert).  Others agree with him when they think that cloning violates, "the dignity both of human procreation and the conjugal union." (Vitae).  Is the idea of cloning homo sapiens too surreal and abstract or should it become an everyday activity?  Are we stepping in God's shoes when we should not be or are we not stepping up to our calling?  Would cloning make us God?

Another major issue concerning cloning is the fact that clones would definitely face a different lifestyle than the rest of us.  Some philosophers believe that the difficulties that clones would face would be different than the ones we do but not to a higher degree.  Everyone is born with some future hardships in their life so it wouldn't be any different for a clone (Wachbroit).  However, he also believes that there could be distinct differences between a...

Find Another Essay On The Cloning Debate

The Debate of Human Cloning Essay

2104 words - 8 pages The journey that human cloning has taken has been one of dramatic highs and lows, heated arguments and confusion about the path ahead. When researchers witnessed the birth of the first cloned mammal, they were ecstatic, but this high ended with the tragic early death of this sheep, Dolly, due to abnormalities (Jaenisch 2004: 2787). The initial success and progress in this field fueled scientists to want to do further research into this

"Cloning - A Gift From God ... Or an Injustice Towards Humanity?" A moral and religious debate between the pro's and con's of cloning

1722 words - 7 pages Cloning - a Gift From God, or an Injustice Towards Humanity?In a world that is as fast paced as the one we live in today, it is hard to stop and remember the moral values and religious beliefs we were taught as children. We live in a world where science is put on a pedestal, and religion is a far off thought saved for holidays that we hardly remember the meanings of. Why is it that when we hear about scientific advancements we get excited, and

Therapeutic vs. Reproductive Cloning

1813 words - 8 pages scientific debate over the years. With the help of advancements in technology in the future, cloning can provide medical breakthroughs. The process of cloning has existed for decades. Plants have been cloned for years now, although, cloning was never recognized until February 22, 1997 when the first mammal (Dolly the Sheep) was cloned from an adult cell (“Cloning Dolly The Sheep”). Dolly was named after Dolly Parton, the mammary cell that was

Benefits of Cloning to Humanity

1275 words - 5 pages be ruined. Cloning is more beneficial to animals than to humans, due to fact that humans will face more life threatening situations than cloning the animals. All these causes and effects to both animals and humans has started not only ethical debates but as well as political decisions on rather it should be legal or not. Although the United States are facing the debate amongst each other, the government still respects our constitutional rights

The Ethics of Cloning

1717 words - 7 pages and through experimentation on the seemingly endless supply of the strain it was found that this protein was able to stimulate the body to produce more red blood cells. It is because of success stories such as this that the debate against DNA cloning is almost non-existent. To expand on the medical uses of cloning, one of the newest forms of potentially using cloning is the use of the stem cells harvested from therapeutic cloning as a way to grow

Cloning: The Face of a Better Tomorrow

3082 words - 12 pages ”(Sampsell). As mentioned in Kate Sampsell’s article, "The Cloning Debate: The Future is Burdened by its Past “, The National Academy of Sciences made a strong proposition to completely outlaw reproductive human cloning but will still support the use of cloning in the therapeutic field. This shows that some of the oppositions of cloning are indifferent and do not completely wish to abandon all hope for cloning. The arguments against cloning can stem

The Effects of Human Cloning on Medicine

2312 words - 9 pages create the embryo of a baby from a cell in any part of her body (Aldridge). Some couples may prefer this method of having children rather than accepting the egg and sperm of a stranger (Hyde and Setaro 82). A woman may also be able to have a baby, store her additional embryos in a freezer and then years later have an identical baby (“Cloning of Human Embryos Sparks Debate”). There are also some more drastic measures that human cloning could be

Is Cloning Moral?

1243 words - 5 pages which it is very difficult to get captive animals to reproduce even under the best conditions, "by using cloning we could circumvent this problem and build a large enough population to reintroduce groups into the wild in special parks" (Cloning Debate). Secondly, one of the most exciting and beneficial effects of cloning would be the cloning of genetically engineered animals. "Scientists foresee the cloning of pigs that will produce


1210 words - 5 pages Introduction The first successful cloning of a mammal, the sheep named Dolly, was arguably one of the most celebrated scientific achievements of the past decade. The cloning of Dolly brought to the forefront a longstanding debate about cloning human beings. The possibility of cloning a human being will have great significance especially in the healthcare industry since previously unachievable operations could now be feasible especially with

Cloning: What is the right thing to do?

1363 words - 5 pages cloning they are generally referring to reproductive cloning. There is also recombinant DNA Technology, and therapeutic cloning (McGee, Human Cloning Debate).      Reproductive cloning is a technology used to generate an animal that has the same nuclear DNA as another. Scientist transfer genetic materials from the nucleus of a donor adult cell to an egg whose nucleus has been removed. This reconstructed egg containing the

The Need For an Educational Background on Cloning

1227 words - 5 pages (2), 71-77. Doi:10.1111/j.1467-8519.2008.00692.x Choi, C. Q. (2010). cloning of a human. Scientific American, 302(6), 36-38. Shannon, T. A. (1998). Cloning myths. Commonweal, 125(7), 10. Healy, B. (2005). To create, or not to create?. U.S. News & World Report, 138(10), 59. Murdoch, A. (2007), Cloning. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist, 9: 177– 180. doi:10.1576/toag. Clift, E. (2002,September), Womens Health and the Cloning Debate

Similar Essays

The Cloning Debate Essay

1022 words - 4 pages The topic of cloning has been in much debate. It is a very controversial issue, with many different and assorted viewpoints. While some find the procedures and actions concerning cloning acceptable; others object it on a basis of saying it is depraved and immoral. Many of those who raise objections are those who find it inappropriate for religious reasons. In both cases, a significant concern is the possibility of abuse of this inexperienced

The Debate Of Human Cloning Essay

4520 words - 18 pages Missing Appendix The Debate of Human Cloning Human cloning has become a hot topic for debate. As we progressed one step closer to successfully cloning and developing a human being, legislators and the general public have become more concerned about the ethical and moral implications of this procedure. The federal government has been unsuccessful in reaching an agreement as to what policy to pass and enact. Thus, any current legislation on

The Ethical Debate Concerning Cloning Essay

9513 words - 38 pages The Ethical Debate Concerning Cloning In the year that has elapsed since the announcement of Dolly's birth, there has been much discussion of the ethical implications of cloning humans. Although the simple use of the word "clone" may have negative connotations, many people have resigned themselves to the idea of cloning cows that produce more milk or using a cloned mouse

The Cloning Debate Essay

945 words - 4 pages We are born into this world an original, why would we choose to go out a copy?” Besides, we’ve had cloning in the South for years. It's called cousins.”(Robin Williams) Step by step, rung by rung we have advanced forward on this ladder. Ideas led to frogs, who have in turn led to the name “clone.” But it twas not enough. The genetic code furthered research in the stem cell research industry and voila’ the door to turning back no longer held