This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Commander In The Handmaids Tale English 4 U Essay

1826 words - 8 pages

[Type text] [Type text] [Type text]
1 MURRAY
Sagal Mohamoud
906129
ENG4U0
November 3rd 2017
Is the Commander a sympathetic character, a monster, or both?
Is the Commander someone to be pitied, or hated? It could be disputed that to rank highly in a regimented, oppressive state such as Gilead as the Commander does suggests by nature that he must be a monster. Yet, Atwood’s portrayal of the Commander through the narration of Offred paints him in a more sympathetic light- his illicit meetings with Offred and apparent need for an emotional connection portraying him as a pitiful individual. Atwood’s humanization of the Commander is similar to that of the mistress of the Nazi guard Offred reminisces of in chapter 24- could Offred be a victim of similar conditioning? It could be debated he is a monster by deed, and any sympathy felt by the reader is merely a result of Offred’s biased narration.
It could be argued that the Commander is a character to be sympathized due to his impersonal relationship with his own wife, and his corresponding loneliness. He opens up to Offred in Chapter 25 about the cold Serena: ‘She wouldn't understand. Anyway, she won't talk to me much anymore. We don't seem to have much in common, these days.’ For such vulnerability to be exposed by someone as high ranking as the Commander conveys to the reader how truly lonely he is- ‘these days’ showing how the rise of Gilead has stripped the Commander from being able to maintain any intimate relationships, not even with his wife. However, this could be countered with the possibility that the Commander played on Offred’s natural dislike of Serena Joy, and manipulated the situation as to make her a common enemy to gain her trust. Yet, throughout ‘A Handmaids Tale’, Atwood portrays a humane side to the Commander, demonstrating the destructive power of an oppressive regime to all those within it, even those who may have aided its rise to power. Furthermore, the Commander is to be sympathized as this lonely side is accompanied with a compassionate one; he treats Offred fairly well despite having total dominance over her life, and holding the power to coerce her into anything. Offred notices this, narrating that he ‘"want[s] [her] life to be bearable"-one could argue it is this courtesy that allows for the reader to feel sympathy for the Commander- remorse for his part to play in the rise of Gilead being a possible motive for this kindness as well as his loneliness. Before finding out the Commanders intention to play scrabble with her Offred is aware denying him could have dire consequences- ‘But to refuse to see him could be worse. There’s no doubt about who holds the real power.’ The emphasis of his power to be ‘real’ exposes the serious problem Offred was facing- whilst Serena could have her sent to the colonies for their meetings, the Commander had the ability to wreak much more havoc on her life. Atwood’s use of blunt sentence structure reinforces this, and so for being cordial for...

Find Another Essay On The Commander in the Handmaids Tale - English 4U - Essay

The Handmaids Tale Essay

1111 words - 4 pages ENGLISH ITERATURE ESSAY Chloe Reynolds "˜The Handmaid's Tale' written by Margaret Atwood is an extreme dystopic vision of the oppression of women, their rights and feminist values. Atwood describes a theocracy in which women are "˜walking wombs' intended for reproduction only. In Gilead, the arbitrary in which the tale is set, women are denied their identities and their own personal freedom. To overcome this dehumanisation, the

The Handmaids Tale Essay

1548 words - 6 pages Handmaid's Tale. Women have no rights. They are assigned their ranking (social class) and told what to do. They may not read or write, and if they are not able to reproduce they are punished. Offred, the main character, and narrator of the novel, is a Handmaid. This means she must do the shopping for her "household". She must also have intercourse with the Commander, who 'owns' her, in order to increase the population of Gilead. All of the people in

The Handmaids Tale - Feminist?

1518 words - 6 pages Do you agree that although The Handmaid's Tale is written from a feminist point of view, the portraits given of men are surprisingly sympathetic while those of women are often critical? Yes, I agree with this statement. Although the theocratic totalitarian regime operating in Gilead was instigated and is controlled by men, the male protagonists in the novel are seen as caring and sympathetic. Although one or two women have become quite close

THe Handmaids tale

683 words - 3 pages The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood follows the life of a Handmaid, Offred, in the days after the United States. An oppressive regime has taken over the United States, which is now called Gilead. Gilead is run by religious radicals who use fear to rule its people. Women, now stripped of many of their rights must live in a world where they are assigned to their roles by the government. Offred is a Handmaid whose main purpose of living is to

The Handmaids Tale

1257 words - 5 pages author's present milieu is magnified and made more horrific in the near or distant future.The way in which Margaret Atwood establishes dystopia in "The Handmaid's Tale" is that it seems to feel like you are reading a science fiction novel, but as the story goes on it becomes more about how everything in the world has gone from good to bad in a social point of view.We can see from the first sentence "We slept in what had once been the gymnasium

The Handmaids Tale In Novel And Film

3039 words - 12 pages The Handmaid's Tale in Film and Novel The Ceremony: the impregnation of the Handmaid, a compulsory monthly ritual at the beginning of the 21st century in the Republic of Gilead, the country formerly known as the United States of America. The dystopian novel The Handmaid's Tale, by Margaret Atwood presents a clear and understandable view of the Gilead society and the role of Handmaids therein, which the film adaptation by director Volker

Gender and Power in the Handmaids Tale

1877 words - 8 pages the Chariot, much better than the chunky, practical Behemoth". Gilead even removes the Handmaids names, in this society the are know as Of[Male name here] in reference to the Commander in which they are placed with. Throughout the novel, Offred resists these rules. She creates her own vision of the world through the use of English. Poetic devices are utilized and repeated; from the use of a simile in her description of a young guardian "His skin is

The Handmaids Tale by Margaret Atwood

989 words - 4 pages . People in Gilead are viewed based on their social classes. This includes the Handmaids, Wives, Commanders, Aunts, Angles, Eyes, Martha’s, and the Econowives. It’s either they have power in their hands, or they don’t have power at all. In The Handmaids Tale, Gilead the dystopian state is the reason for all of misery and misuse of power. In the book, the narrator Offred explains how Gilead came to be. Gilead was created because of low birth

The Handmaids Tale, by Margaret Atwood

880 words - 4 pages In Margaret Atwoods ‘The Handmaids Tale’, we hear of one women’s posting ‘Offred’ in the Republic of Gilead. A society based around Biblical philosophies as a way to validate inhumane state practises. In a society of declining birth rates, fertile women are chosen to become Handmaids, walking incubators, whose role in life is to reproduce for barren wives of commanders. Older women, gay men, and barren Handmaids are sent to the colonies to clean

The Presentation of the Commander in The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood

793 words - 3 pages The Presentation of the Commander in The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood The commander can be seen as a man torn between two worlds, he was one of the founders of Gilead yet still enjoys and yearns for the pleasures of the old society he managed to break. It can be seen as ' he has made his bed and now he must sleep in it'. The commander is cool and collected on the surface but underneath he is bitter and corrupted

The Importance of the Japanese Tourists in Chapter Five of The Handmaids Tale

1008 words - 4 pages The Importance of the Japanese Tourists in Chapter Five of The Handmaids Tale The Japanese tourists presented in chapter five may only cover a page and a half in the novel, however, this passage should not be underestimated as the tourists importantly act as a subtle representation of everything that the Handmaids have been stripped of, most importantly their freedom. The way in which the author introduces the reader to

Similar Essays

Handmaids Tale, How Atwood Presents Serena Joy English Essay

1037 words - 5 pages immediate and effective. Also, the use of the direct speech asserts power and hierarchy, which represents Serena Joy as the leader of the interaction between herself and Offred. In The Handmaids Tale, in the eyes of the Gileadean Law, it is illegal to smoke. Atwood uses a description of the physical action smoking; “She inhaled, blew out the smoke.” The use of this description is an example of vivid imagery which heightens the effect of the language

The Handmaids Tale Connections Essay

621 words - 3 pages work, read, dress and express herself (as well as many other freedoms), but now that those have been taken away from her, she does not see the world the same way and does not believe in the same things that she used to. Connection 2 – School or community: There wasn’t many connections because women in this novel are not allowed to read, but I think that the way that the Handmaids and Marthas gossip is similar to the way that people gossip at

Essay On Appearance Versus Reality In The Handmaids Tale

738 words - 3 pages Appearance versus Reality in The Handmaids Tale   Imagery is an effective element used by writers. It allows readers to be one with the story and to better comprehend the actions and thoughts conveyed by the author. In Margaret Atwood's The Handmaids Tale, actions and images of Offred and other individuals parallel with the theme of appearance versus reality. These images such as food and nature are reoccurring to further stress the

Themes In The Novel 'the Handmaids Tale'

2351 words - 9 pages manners that the government of Gilead uses ignorance to control the handmaids and successfully forces them to "not want things they can't have"(151).On the surface, The Handmaid's Tale appears to be feminist in nature. The point-of-view character and narrator is a woman and thus we see the world through a woman's eyes. There's much more to the story than that, though. Atwood doesn't show us our world. She shows us a newly created world in which