This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Comparative Advantage Of Sexual Divisions Of Labor

5610 words - 22 pages

Historical Perspectives on the Comparative Advantage of Sexual Divisions of Labor

In modern microeconomic models of the household, one commonly sees a division of labor between the husband and wife predicated on a comparative advantage in the market or the household respectively. The idea is that women are somehow less fit for work in the marketplace while they are innately superior at the domestic tasks of cooking, cleaning, and childrearing. There are two prevailing perspectives on the mechanics of this comparative advantage. The first argues that women are somehow biologically fitted to domestic tasks. This was true for Adam Smith who saw the social structures of society arising out of a biological necessity. Malthus, on the other hand, saw the same biological necessity as operating in opposition to the social structures that arose to keep the pressures of population in check. The second perspective argues that a comparative advantage is a socially constructed idea and not rooted in the biological history of the race. Martineau in her story “Cousin Marshall” delineated the life of what she saw as a virtuous and noble woman. Virginia Woolf, however, decried what she saw as the deplorable poverty of women in A Room of One’s Own. Her solution, however, only served to further separate the spheres of men and women. Finally, Charlotte Perkins Gilman similarly objected to the state of women in Women and Economics and ultimately proposed a society that abolished any division of labor along sexual lines.

None of these authors seem to contest the presence of a comparative advantage in the division of labor as their societies stand. However this does not imply that all the authors agreed on the exact features of this advantage. If this advantage is a social construct as argued by Martineau, Woolf, and Gilman, the necessary implication becomes that the comparative advantage is a matter of choice. For the advantage to working in the household to operate, it must be that women choose (or men choose for them) to live in a society of gendered work roles. This perspective is strongly held by both Woolf and Gilman though with slightly different consequences. Gilman’s proposed society is predicated on the elimination of gendered work roles. More specifically, she argued that the inefficiency inherent in gendered work roles demands their abolition. However, implicit in her model is the demands made by society as existed for her that women remain in the household and men work in the market. Woolf and Gilman both choose to deny the inevitability of gendered divisions in labor, however none of the authors deny that without significant change to social structures, women are more able to work in the household than men. Or phrased more to Woolf’s and Gilman’s tastes, that women are unable to work in the market due to restrictions placed on them by the patriarchy.

Adam Smith: Marriage, Social Rite and Biological Imperitive


Find Another Essay On The Comparative Advantage of Sexual Divisions of Labor

The Impact of Sociology of the Social Divisions

1067 words - 4 pages The Impact of Sociology of the Social Divisions Examine critically some of the ways in which the sociology of the social divisions have impacted on your own personal and family history, and assess

"The divisions of society's povety classes" in the US

1746 words - 7 pages If I had the power to abolish poverty in the United States I would do it in a second. Abolishing poverty would be almost impossible because there are just to many poor people for one person to help to abolish poverty we must all work to help those who are poor get out of this condition.There are two types of poor, there are people who are relatively poor and there are people who are absolutely poor. People who are relatively poor are poor

The Advantage of Video Games

1569 words - 7 pages wrap. Before Nintendo had let the controversy hurt them, they had released the first portable gaming experience in 1998. They had called it the Nintendo Game Boy and gamers fell in love with it immediately. “In the mid-1990’s, the giant electronics manufacturer Sony Corporation entered the console business with the introduction of the PlayStation. The new console took advantage of the large storage capacity of CD-ROM's, offering games with more

The Advantage of School Uniforms

733 words - 3 pages Did you know that as many as twenty-five percent of the nation?s pubic elementary, middle, and junior high schools have successfully implemented a school uniform policy? (Isaacson, 1998) School uniforms greatly benefit both the students and faculty by creating an atmosphere in which the students are able to get the most out of their education. I believe that all students should wear school uniforms regardless of whether or not the school is

The History of Organized Labor

1026 words - 4 pages win the fight and achieve a standard of living unknown to American workers at any other time in history. As the industrial revolution forged ahead the factory system grew many American workers began to form organized labor unions to protect their interests. In 1792 the shoemakers union was the first union to collect dues and hold regular meeting. Shortly after the shoemakers, carpenters and leather workers in Boston and printers in New York

The Immorality of Child Labor

1305 words - 5 pages The Immorality of Child Labor Child labor is a serious moral issue. There have been many controversial debates over whether it should be legal or not. Two different viewpoints on the subject exist. Many argue that child labor is morally wrong and that the children should not work, no matter how poverty stricken their family might be. Advocates and major corporations that support child labor argue that it is good because it gives

Highlights of the Labor Movement

930 words - 4 pages This essay details the history of the labor movement from the late 1800s to the present.During a meeting of national unions (1886) the American Federation of Labor was created. The cause, differences in opinions regarding the mixing of skilled and unskilled workers. The federation was formed by about 150000 workers. Unions maintained control over their workers while sending complaints and disputes to the AFL to be resolved. The AFL maintained a

The Flaws of Prison Labor

953 words - 4 pages The Flaws of Prison Labor The debate over prison labor has existed as long as the concept it’s self. Opponents claim that it exploits prisoners, takes away jobs from the general population, and puts people in danger by allowing convicts access to their personal information. While supporters of prison labor argue that it helps the economy as well as benefits prisoners. On this issue I stand on the side of the supporters. By having

The Advantage of a college education

948 words - 4 pages The most important decision any individual must decide upon after high school is whether to pursue a college degree, or not. There are many things that would influence this decision; therefore it is common for a person to wonder if a college education is actually significant or not. While the facts and details suggest that attending a college will provide a tremendous advantage, and the opportunity to achieve a higher level of success; many high

History of Social Divisions in Society and the Role of the Social Worker

1613 words - 6 pages divisions, class and their positions within society. Marx was interested in the theories of economic development, he believed that economy was dominated by agriculture and power was held by the aristocratic landowner, in the period when manufacture was the dominant mode of production which he called the ‘bourgeoisie age’. According to Marx the history of human society past and present, has been that of class struggles. There has always been

Unmanageable Divisions: The Result of Bismarckian Politics in Turn of the Century Germany

1970 words - 8 pages importantly however, the Kulturkampf cannot and should not be seen solely as a struggle between German Protestants and German Catholics, but internal battles of religious, ethnic, and political flavors provided for an even more divisive environment. Internal divisions during the Kulturkampf only escalated and grew to involve even more interested groups with time. An obvious difference of opinion that arose early during this period was on the issue of

Similar Essays

The Theory Of Comparative Advantage Essay

749 words - 3 pages improve our nation. It seems like an absolute certainty that we should only buy things from other Americans. But is it really? Economics tells a very different story. While it is imperative that we create more jobs for Americans, this is only a temporary bandage over the much larger wound in the system. According to the Theory of Comparative Advantage, self-sufficiency is never the most efficient way to survive. The United States must expand its

Sexual Division Of Labor Essay

1388 words - 6 pages The establishment of duties within a social group, based on gender, is known as the sexual division of labor. The early 20th century produced many surprising changes for the United States, providing similarities as well as differences in comparison to the mid-20th century regarding women in the workplace. The early 20th century ranges from the year 1901 to about 1933 and is known as a time of urban and industrial modernization, which brought

The Advantage Of Sarcasm Essay

850 words - 3 pages The Advantage of Sarcasm “Sarcasm is a form of humor that uses sharp, cutting remarks or language intended to mock, wound, or subject contempt or ridicule, generally saying the opposite of what the statement really is” (Oxford). Brian Dickerson, a free press columnist, does just that to bring the readers over to his side. He utilizes a very convincing combination of sarcasm and emotional appeal in his column called “Promises to Keep? Not in the

A Comparative Advantage Of Us Food Products In Japan

745 words - 3 pages Japanese consumer to purchase Japanese items.The reason for the large volume of exporting to Japan is due to United State's comparative advantages. Food products are very expensive to produce in Japan. Japan's current labor shortage, combined with import restrictions and domestic price stabilization programs, have driven up domestic production costs.The Japanese food consumption pattern consist of an openness to foreign products and a strong