The Question Of Language Acquisition (Lenneberg Vs. Chomsky)

867 words - 3 pages

Lenneberg formed the Critical Period Hypothesis theory which contends that language is innate but has to be attained before the age of puberty or else the ability to learn language ebbs (as a result of the lateralization of the brain). 1 At present, the Critical Period Hypothesis theory is widely accepted by numerous linguists. Evidence has been presented that there is a limited time when the brain is malleable (in terms of language). Studies such as, linguistically isolated children (a.k.a. feral children) support Lenneberg's theory of the critical period because they are unable to fully acquire language. 2 Moreover, there is a non-uniform success rate in adults who try to attain a second language yet children can obtain a new language a lot more quickly and sufficiently than adults. 3 It is thought by many that a critical period for acquisition of a language does exist.The most common contrasting viewpoint against the Critical Period Hypothesis is the theory presented by Noam Chomsky. Chomsky hypothesized that people are born with a set of rules known as 'Universal Grammar'; thus people can acquire language at any point within their lifetime as long as they are placed in an adequate learning environment.4 Although many linguists concur with Chomsky's views about Universal Grammar; the movie, "Nell" can be interpreted in such a way that Chomsky's theory is erroneous. In the movie, the character Nell learned a language within her critical period made up of the distorted English from her mother (who had a speech defect as the result of a series of strokes) and words remembered from a private language spoken with her twin.5 However, when she was being taught English in her late 20's, Nell showed little progress in using the English language and continued to speak in her own language.6 In the film, the audience never witnesses Nell communicate in correct English sentences; most probably because she doesn't learned English syntax. Hence, there is a critical period in which the brain is malleable and if language is not learned within that time span, language acquisition becomes difficult and sometimes unattainable.There have been several studies that strongly support Lenneberg's hypothesis. Among the most prominent are feral children. Feral children are persons that have been linguistically isolated. When they were found, most were unable to pick up on language abilities.7 These cases propose that there may be a 'critical age' in which any child who has somehow missed out on learning a language will never fully master one. The most famous of these cases is Genie. Genie was a 13 year-old girl who was denied human interaction.8 When she was discovered, she only knew two words.9 Although upon discovery, a team of scientists tried to teach her language.10 They wanted to prove the falsehood of Lenneberg's hypothesis. However, this did not happen. Genie never...

Find Another Essay On The Question of Language Acquisition (Lenneberg vs. Chomsky)

The Process of Language Acquisition in Childhood

2953 words - 12 pages the ability to learn the fictional language. Phonological Development In the first years of life children transcend from infancy, in which they cannot speak nor comprehend language, to age four in which they begin to be able to express themselves in their own language (Hoff, 2006). Overall, the language acquisition process has the same endpoint for all capable children. The only difference in the language acquisition process between children is

Theories of Language Acquisition Essay

966 words - 4 pages Theories of Language Acquisition The theories of language acquisition are essentially centred around the nature nurture argument. The theory that children have an innate capacity for language was created by Noam Chomsky (1928- ) an American linguistic. This nativist approach states that learning language is part of the genetic makeup of human species and is nearly independent of any particular experience which

Innateness of Children’s Language Acquisition

1497 words - 6 pages The subtlety of language acquisition has been the most fundamental question in the study of linguistics and human development. From Bow-wow Theory to Yo-He-Ho Theory, major theories on the origins and learnability of language have emerged in mid-20th century and heavily debated ever since. Among them, the idea of universal grammar in which is usually credited to linguist Noam Chomsky, remains the most notable and controversial theory over time

The Impact of Culture on Second Language Acquisition

959 words - 4 pages concerning the language learning difficulties from different perspectives. One of the theories to explain second language acquisition issues from the sociocultural/sociolinguistic point of view is Brown’s (1980) Optimal distance Model, which is in parallel with Schumann’s (1986) Acculturation Model. Brown (1980) and Schumann (1986) state that both second language learning difficulties and the level of mastery in that language can be determined

An Examination of the Dogme Method of Language acquisition in English Language Teaching

1292 words - 5 pages Dogme ELT has collective key concepts of making a language learning process more successful. But a question is being arisen what is the reason behind adopting Dogme technique for English Language Teaching? According to an Oxford online forum report (2005) course books are designed regardless of where they would be used or with whom and it is expected to cause learners leaving the language points focusing on the topic itself. For instance, students

An Inquiry Into The Question Of How Technology Has Expanded Or Limited The Acquisition Of Knowledge

1251 words - 5 pages dependence on calculators to do their simple math. Technology also expands the acquisition of knowledge through language. A personal example is when my mother purchased a SAT review program for the computer that drilled math and English to help me bring up my score on the test. This program allowed me to practice sample math problems and use vocabulary "flash cards" in order to increase my knowledge and improve my score. The utilization of technology

Three Main Theories of Child Language Acquisition

1160 words - 5 pages already understands the language. A final theory that is connected to the writings of Noam Chomsky tries to pinpoint the first language acquisition to a Language Acquisition Device or LAD. This LAD is supposedly already hardwired in a child’s brain and somehow is connected to structural properties found universally in all languages (Linguistics 201). Although, no evidence of this theory has been found, all languages do seem to contain nouns

Krashen’s Hypotheses of Second Language Acquisition

1678 words - 7 pages Krashen’s Hypotheses of Second Language Acquisition For decades, foreign language teachers wandered in a scientific abyss. Until 1983, there had been little real research dealing with the ways in which someone acquires a second language. Teachers mostly used the audiolingual classroom model that had been in place for the past twenty years (or, even worse, the literally ancient grammatical translation model that had been used by

Discussion of the Importance of the Social and Cultural Context Where Child Language Acquisition is Concerned

3568 words - 14 pages Discussion of the Importance of the Social and Cultural Context Where Child Language Acquisition is Concerned Beginning with Elene Lieven’s review of the importance of the environment for language learning, discuss the importance of the social and cultural context where child language acquisition is concerned. Environment According to Elena Lieven, the roles played by brothers and sisters, and other children and

Chomsky V. Friedman: A persuasive essay on the differing opinions of Noam Chomsky and Thomas Friedman when it comes to foreign affairs. In favor of Chomsky.

790 words - 3 pages Chomsky V. FriedmanThe events of September 11th, 2001 evoked many different reactions and sparked diverse conversations within the United States. One of the major topics to emerge from the rubble was "What did we do to deserve this?" Although, many people asked it earnestly wanting to know, and others asked rhetorically, implying that we did not do anything to deserve this. Even though both Thomas Friedman and Noam Chomsky ask the question

does evidence support the theory of an innate language acquisition mechanism?

1733 words - 7 pages conclusion that can be drawn from this finding is that if adults and children have different ways or mechanisms of operating with language and if adults aren't the ones who teach children about that, this means that they must possess an innate mechanism which facilitates language acquisition. Consequently, if it were just a matter of teaching and socialization, biologically similar beings like apes (their left hemisphere has approximately the same

Similar Essays

The Influence Of Noam Chomsky In Child Language Acquisition

2599 words - 10 pages The influence of Noam Chomsky in child language acquisitionNoam Chomsky dominated the world of linguistics like a colossus for decades after the late fifties. My main aim of this essay is to discuss his influence in the area of child language acquisition and inspect to see if his influence is waxing or waning. After that I will examine the reasons behind the increase or decrease of his influence. I will be relating back every so often to

Critically Assess The View Put Forward By Linguist Noam Chomsky That Children Are "Predisposed", To Learn Language With Ease Because Their Brains Contain "Language Acquisition Devices".

1433 words - 6 pages go onto the using of words, utterance, speech act and so on. What rule or theory is governing this development?The linguist, Noam Chomsky (1957) believed that all language are grammatically and linguistic universals though they are spoken and written differently. He suggested a hypothetical model: the Language Acquisition Device (LAD), which attempts to explain language development by inferring what must be going on in the child’s brain, but

The Importance Of Language Acquisition Essay

2042 words - 8 pages The Importance of Language Acquisition *Missing Works Cited* It is known, even to a person to whom the entire study of language isn't familiar, that the language is the greatest factor on which most of the human activities depend. Without any form of language, any cooperation and communication would be almost, if not totally impossible (World Book Encyclopedia 62). This significance of language is what draws scientists to study origin

Language Learning Vs Language Acquisition Essay

799 words - 3 pages Association has 32 Schools enrolled as active members throughout San Pedro Sula, La Ceiba and Tegucigalpa. As if the environment were not alone a mayor revelation of second language acquisition, Gardner moves us in a more intimate description of the learners influencing factors. These factors include multiple intelligences variables, aptitude tests which measure cognitive abilities and motivational and situational anxiety, which bring us to