This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Condemnation Of Galileo Essay

1036 words - 4 pages

The Condemnation of Galileo
The condemnation of Galileo by the Catholic Church is a prime example of the vast dispute between religion and science. It is widely believed that his support of Copernicanism, the theory that the earth rotates on its own axis, led to his condemnation by the Catholic Church. However, modern historians disagree with this belief and as a matter of fact they do not believe that indeed there is warfare between religion and science. Under the content of condemnation of Galileo are subjects such as Copernicanism, Eucharist, Popes Paul 5 and atomism.
Galileo’s idea of atomism conflicts with the church‘s definition of the Eucharist. According to the church, bread and wine represent flesh and blood of Jesus Christ. Aristotle’s theory, stating that the material of bread and wine changes but the quality does not, was used to affirm the Eucharist. In 1612, Galileo openly criticized Aristotle, saying his ideas were wrong and ridiculed Christopher Scheiner, a Jesuit scientist, over the idea of sunspots. These actions led to his widespread condemnation by the Roman Catholic Church. It was also observed that although Galileo had revealed that Aristotle’s ideas were inconsistent, he did not prove Copernican ideas that he readily supported. As a result, Pope Paul V warned and ordered Galileo to immediately stop supporting Copernican ideas.
Moreover, Pope Urban had affirmed that God had limited man’s understanding of the universe but Galileo had different thoughts. According to him, God gave man the explicit mandate to reason and discover the world. This statement was contrary to the belief that the Pope was not supposed to be disputed but Galileo had just done that. He was thus arrested and after trial, he was found guilty of fervent mistrust of heresy. Galileo’s condemnation was basically about him being against Aristotelian science, which the church ardently believed in.
2. The Radical Reformation (The Anabaptist Portion of the Reformation)
Reformation in sixteenth century is mostly associated with the Lutheran Protestants, Roman Catholics and the radicals who are identified to be historians. The radical group is further divided into three subgroups, which are the Socinians, the spiritualist and Anabaptists. The basic focus of this paper is the radical Anabaptists’ portion of the Reformation.
The phrase “Anabaptists” means to be baptized again and members of this group are referred to as radicals because of their intrinsic desire for thorough church reconstruction in line with their own theological convictions.
It is ostensible that Thomas Muntzer engineered the inception of the Anabaptists. His main objective was to introduce this new faith to mankind all over the world and ultimately form a democratic theocracy. However, before he could fully execute his plan, some people began questioning the authenticity of his pastorate. They felt that his pastorate was not official in the sense that he was not lawfully ordained...

Find Another Essay On The Condemnation of Galileo

The Success and Intentions of Galileo

910 words - 4 pages and Bellarmine died, he immediately drafted a debate between the old sciences, which were Geocentrism and other beliefs that the Church had, and the new sciences, which were Heliocentrism and other things that Galileo discovered. He was a Catholic, and believed in searching for the truth of the world, thus he was not researching for his own sake, but for the world’s. In such circumstances, he was an opportunist, but not cynical. Galileo have had

Galileo and the History of the Catholic Church

2626 words - 11 pages Galileo and the History of the Catholic Church In the history of the Catholic Church, no episode is so contested by so many viewpoints as the condemnation of Galileo. The Galileo case, for many, proves the Church abhors science, refuses to abandon outdated teachings, and is clearly not infallible. For staunch Catholics the episode is often a source of embarrassment and frustration. Either way it is undeniable that Galileo’s life sparked a

The Life and Work of John Calvin and Galileo Galilei

1167 words - 5 pages requested to come back to Geneva by the Council of Geneva. So, in 1541, Calvin returned to Geneva. He remained in Geneva until his death on May 27th, 1564. Those last several years were plentiful with lecturing, preaching, and the writing of commentaries, treatises, and various editions of the Institutes of the Christian Religion. Galileo Galilei was born February 15th, 1564 in Pisa, Italy. His parents were Vincenzo Galilei and Guilia Ammannati

Quest for Identity in The Life of Galileo by Brecht

1600 words - 6 pages Quest for Identity in The Life of Galileo by Brecht Throughout the course of history, from era to era, mankind has been on a continuous attempt to perpetuate what they perceive as the truth; and in doing so, embark on a quest to find their true identity and place in life. One must realize that the common theme in all literature is the search for identity and belonging. Bertolt Brecht, author of "The Life of Galileo," effectively uses

Bertolt Brech and Galileo. This essay addresses bertolt's play Galileo. This essay tells how bertolt brecht uses the story of Galileo to speak to the urgent questions of his own time

1142 words - 5 pages The story of Galileo by Bertolt Brecht was for the most part a historically accurate telling of the life of Galileo. Brecht's story of Galileo's life is filled with him succumbing to the authorities no matter what his beliefs may be. This is similar to the lifestyle in Germany about the time Brecht had written this play.Born in Augsburg, Germany in 1898 Brecht began writing at an early age. Writing was not his only interest, Brecht enrolled in

Sir Isaac Newton: Standing on the Shoulders of Galileo and Aristotle

1412 words - 6 pages improved on Aristotle’s), but it explained a number of anomalies, including resolving the issue of retrograde motion (Ede, A. & Cormack, L., 2004). The problem was that Aristotle’s physics of ‘natural motion’ fell apart without the earth in the center of everything. Eventually Galileo Galilei (1564 – 1642) came to popularity, rejecting the Aristotelian notions of motion (O'Connor, J.J., & Robertson, E. F., 2002). He showed that speed does not

How does Galileo view the issue of religion and science? How does he resolve the tension between religion and science?

1127 words - 5 pages The New Science Versus the Old FaithDuring the 18th century, the age of Enlightenment, traditional thought patterns about the world were beginning to be challenged by scientific discoveries. Both Galileo and Descartes believed that one could believe in the teaching of the Bible and simultaneously accept the findings and conclusions of modern science. Galileo is credited for saying, "I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who endowed


1538 words - 6 pages cast their shadow of hate on brilliant Galileo. Galileo was getting respect across Europe as he came to the hypothesis of: "Bodies in motion would continue unless some form of resistance was introduced." All of the brilliant work that Galileo had produced had been separated when he was sentenced to Condemnation in 1633. The Catholic Church brought down one of the greatest men in scientific history. With the overuse of power the Church

Galileo Galilei

1005 words - 4 pages Galileo Galilei Galileo was born in Pisa along the Via del Cuore in 1564 to Vincenzo Galileo, a man known for his study of music, and Giuli Ammananti. When Galileo was ten he moved to Florance.1 At eleven young Galileo was sent to Vallombrosa for school. At fifteen Galileo decided to be a monk, but because of his father gave up his ambition. In the late summer of 1581 Galileo entered the University of Pisa and embarked on a course of

Galileo vs. Church

1990 words - 8 pages “Letters on the Solar Spots” was made public in 1613. Copernicus’s theory was openly discussed in this letter (Galilei and Drake, 145). Copernicus proposed than an axis-revolving Earth circumnavigated around the heart of the universe, the Sun (Andrade, 120). Father Lorini, a Dominican friar and professor of ecclesiastical history in Florence, was among the first to criticize Galileo for his Copernican views (Linder). The Copernican theory


1011 words - 4 pages Galileo was an Italian physicist and astronomer who initiated the scientificrevolution that flowered in the work of the English physicist Sir Isaac Newton. BornGalileo Galilei, his main contributions were, in astronomy, the use of the telescope inobservation and the discovery of sunspots, lunar mountains and valleys, the four largestsatellites of Jupiter, and the phases of Venus. In physics, he discovered the laws of fallingbodies and the

Similar Essays

The Condemnation Of Marcus Brutus Essay

2203 words - 9 pages Five: Scene One we see the condemnation and trial of Brutus, the three-headed dog and co-conspirator of Pa Ubu, and through this can draw a direct parallel to the real-life difficulties that were encountered by South Africa when trying the political players involved in Apartheid. Taylor uses this scene as a prime representation of the inability of the TRC to justly discern between the roles of the whole versus the individual in regards to the

The Discoveries Of Galileo Galilei Essay

988 words - 4 pages The telescope was invented based off of a “spyglass” that was created by a Flemish lens grinder. Galileo was a man of many trades; philosophy, astronomy, and mathematics were among his favorites. Before he started studying the skies, Galileo taught math at Pisa and then Padua. After creating his telescope he became known as a hero to many people across Italy and most of Europe. Galileo Galilei was born in Pisa, Italy in February of 1564. As

The Invention Of The Telescope: Galileo Galilei

671 words - 3 pages "Nature is relentless and unchangeable, and it is indifferent as to whether its hidden reasons and actions are understandable to man or not." This quote was once said by one of the most famous scientist in history; his name was Galileo Galilei. Born on February 15, 1564 in Pisa, Italy. He was an Italian physicist, mathematician, astronomer, and philosopher. He had three children; two girls and one boy, but was never married. In 1564 was also

The Life And Work Of Galileo

1374 words - 5 pages The Life and Work of Galileo Galileo Galilei is considered to be one of the greatest mathematicians of all time. He made life changing discoveries and mystified many with his knowledge. However, not all of his work was accepted well. Galileo challenged the church creating a controversy that will never be forgotten. Galileo Galilei was born in Pisa, Italy February 18, 1564. He was the son of Vincenzo Galilei, a member of a Nobel family, a