This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Conflict Between Common Sense Morality And Utilitarianism

887 words - 4 pages

I examine the claim that Utilitarianism treats actions as just in cases where common sense holds that they are unjust. For this purpose, I described the guiding lines of the doctrine as John Stuart Mill defined them and presented the objection against it. I show that Utilitarians might refute the objection by proving that common sense morality itself allows the increase of evil.
Utilitarianism is a moral doctrine that sees ‘utility’ in benefit, which is described as ‘pleasure’. It is based upon “the greater happiness” principle, according to which the best action is the one that maximizes happiness. By ‘happiness’ it is meant obtaining pleasure and avoiding suffering. According to the doctrine, a person is supposed to aim in her actions at the largest possible amount of happiness, either in the magnitude of the benefit itself or in the number of people benefited. Moreover, long-term benefits outweigh short-term ones. Since “all action is for the sake of some end”, actions and their consequences are inseparable. The doctrine holds that the consequences of actions outweigh in significance the nature of the actions.
Therefore, no action is considered wrong according to Utilitarianism as long as it maximizes happiness, even if the action is morally wrong in its nature. The doctrine appears to encourage actions that contradict common sense morality, the body of moral rules accepted by society. This impression raises an objection to Utilitarianism saying it promotes unjust, evil actions. For example, imagine a case of a surgeon who has five patients who can only be saved by transplantations of certain organs, and another patient with healthy organs. According to Utilitarianism, sacrificing the healthy patient in order to save five others seems right because that will produce happiness for more people. Killing her would be morally wrong according to common sense, but as an action that appears necessary for maximizing happiness, it might be justified by Utilitarianism. Common sense morality values the life of every individual in society, as opposed to Utilitarianism that allows sacrificing a life to save others. Thus, while focusing on the benefit achieved through an action, Utilitarianism ignores the damage done in the process.
A possible reply to the objection may address the fact that while it stands against unjust actions, common sense morality at the same time allows unjust results, since actions and their results are inseparably linked . Sometimes a morally right action may lead to unjust consequences. For instance, “the Trolley Problem” illustrates a trolley approaching five people that are tied to the tracks. The only way to save them is to stop the trolley by throwing one person under it. The choice stands between an action of killing one...

Find Another Essay On The Conflict between Common Sense Morality and Utilitarianism

Common Sense, Ethics, and Dogma in The Wife of Bath

3262 words - 13 pages Common Sense, Ethics, and Dogma in The Wife of Bath In his Canterbury Tales, Geoffrey Chaucer assembles a band of pilgrims who, at the behest of their host, engage in a story-telling contest along their route. The stories told along the way serve a number of purposes, among them to entertain, to instruct, and to enlighten. In addition to the intrinsic value of the tales taken individually, the tales in their telling reveal much about the

On the Principles of Nature and Common Sense

736 words - 3 pages affected the news press and the independent lawyers. It appeared that England had, to some extent, taken a step toward a state of absolute monarchy. The Quartering Acts were also in effect, which stated that the subjects had to house British soldiers. In paragraph seven of Common Sense, Thomas Paine states, “America has flourished under her former connection with Great Britain, the same connection is necessary towards her future happiness

The Relationship Between Religion and Morality

2114 words - 8 pages necessary for morality. Throughout the age of humanity many people have come to believe that one cannot be moral without religion. Even though there is an overwhelming amount of evidence, studies, and research that denies the correlation between religion and morality; the religious community argues that without God, our society will descent into moral chaos. Theists find it difficult to understand how atheists develop moral principles and what

The Link Between Time, Money, and Morality

1008 words - 5 pages Trachtman 1998, The paper successfully demonstrates the influence of irrational financial and monetary responsibility instilled onto human ethics and the concept of time through the multiple experiments. Through the various experiments within a controlled environment, the theoretical link between time, money and morality is carefully established, however the practicality between these

The Distance Between Morality and Luck

2129 words - 9 pages The Distance Between Morality and Luck In the moral realm, I tend to align my intuitions with Kantian morality, forming a very strict interpretation of those actions which carry moral worth. As one who believes that the world is not governed by determinism, I place a great deal of emphasis on moral evaluation. This is why I find Nagel’s Moral Luck article so troubling. Nagel describes a concept which, if accurate, completely undercuts our

Exploring the Relationship Between Morality and Religion

1553 words - 6 pages The relationship between religion and morality is one which has been, and continues to be, exhaustively discussed and debated by philosophers. Are the two hopelessly intertwined, or are they able to exist independent of one another? One argument which seeks to provide a solution to this matter of contention is the Divine Command Theory. In this paper, I will argue that the reasoning provided by the Divine Command Theory is an inadequate

The relationship between morality and religiosity

1204 words - 5 pages Religiosity and morality stood out because it is a controversial topic that is compelling to learn about. Everyday life can be affected by these two factors in a positive or negative light. People do not usually think about the morals they obtain and where their morals came from. Researching this topic and understanding the relationship between these two issues will provide a better, clearer view of how people respond in different situations

Comparison between Utilitarianism and Idealism

1158 words - 5 pages seems harder to realize because everyone has to go through a long process that not every individual wants to perform or is able to perform. This theory is Idealism. On the other hand, in Utilitarianism a scale can be made out to lead people in the right way (and that scale is in fact present in our society). These theories are different in the sense that Utilirianism is easier for a society to perform well. To give rewards and punishments, society

Title: Was The Federalists Papers really propaganda in the same sense as the Declaration of Independence and Paine's Common Sense?

749 words - 3 pages Ithink that the Federalists Papers, the Declaration of Independence, and Paine's Common Sense were all forms of propaganda. Each, however, served topromote different ideas about American life and America as a nation, whether itwas about a different outlook of war, what the government's purpose is, or adefense and justification for the new federal constitution.Inthe first year of the Revolutionary War, many people were still unsure of whatthey

Using the Internet: Common Sense Must Prevail

858 words - 3 pages but may not be appropriate sending very personal information through this gateway because someone may have legal right to review these emails. In summary, E-mail writing can be the most momentous experience and surely it is sometime fun. However common sense must always prevail when writing them. Otherwise, we may end up in heap of ruins of damaged careers, reputation and marriages or perhaps end up behind bars. Works Cited Flynn

Comparison Between The Others and The Sixth Sense

1475 words - 6 pages Comparison Between The Others and The Sixth Sense The blockbuster movies 'The Sixth Sense' and 'The Others' are two of the best examples of supernatural thrillers you will ever see. Both storylines are gripping and compelling and there are many unsuspected twists and turns along the way. 'The Sixth Sense' and 'The Others' have comparable storylines because they are both based on the idea of a parallel universe in

Similar Essays

Common Sense And The World View

1025 words - 4 pages Nils Christie's book "Crime Control As Industry" discusses various aspects of common sense and how it is used for justice, behavior control, modernity, among others. People around the world have the same basic problem concerning crime control and the delivery of pain administered. However, they all go about fixing this particular problem very differently. Ideas that people believe are common sense in the United States, may be beyond imagination

The Common Sense Economic Book And The Affordable Healthcare Act

1418 words - 6 pages The Common Sense Economics Book includes a quote by Thomas Jefferson that says, “A wise and frugal government, which shall restrain men from injuring one another, which shall leave them otherwise free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvements, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned. This is the sum of good government.” The United States has been in much need of a sensible healthcare reform, but

Common Sense And The Constitutionality Of The Texas Privacy Act

1277 words - 6 pages Amendment rights. In 2012, news broke that one of the Dallas’ oldest businesses, Columbia Meat Packing, was dumping huge amounts of pig blood into the Trinity River via a nearby stream (Lee). When tests also confirmed that hazardous chemicals were also flowing into the river from the plant, there was a general sense of outrage and disgust. However, it seems that what outraged the Texas legislature the most, was the fact that this transgression

Common Sense Summary And Review

1116 words - 5 pages The immediate sensation of 1776, Common Sense, a pamphlet by Thomas Paine, had given the urge to many Americans at the time to fight for their independence. January, 10 1776, the pamphlet was published at around the begging of the American Revolution and had hit all of the colonies. It was sold and distributed widely and read aloud at taverns and meeting places. Even George Washington had read it to all his troops, which at the time had