The Constituion Is A Bundle Of Compromises

980 words - 4 pages

It has been said that the constitution is bundle of compromises. It is my belief that this statements validity is very high. By human nature we do not agree with every idea that is presented to us. When a group of people gets together to make important decisions, there are bound to be constant arguments. Through the use of chronological historical evidence it will become evident in this discussion that during the secretive meeting of the Constitutional Convention; our Constitution was formed based on a collection of compromises.The Great Compromise as it later became known started of with an agreement formed about the Virginia plan. Proposed by the governor of Virginia, Edmund Randolph; this plan called for representation in congress based on a states population. The details of the Virginia plan included the set up of two houses, membership determined proportionally, lower house elected by the people, upper house elected by the lower house, an executive was in power but would only exist to ensure the legislature will was carried out, forms of judiciary, an executive and judiciary would have the power to veto legislation and also a national veto of any state legislation.This plan however created a problem because it did not settle well with the smaller states. Their main objection towards the plan was that in this new plan everything was according to population size of a state. The smaller states feared that larger states would take away their equal suffrage. Therefore William Paterson of New Jersey presented the New Jersey plan to the delegates on June 15, 1787.At this time, the convention was split in half, between the supporters of the Virginia plan and the New Jersey plan. To resolve this quarrel the Great Compromise came about. This compromise was enacted so that a solution could be worked out between the squabbling states. The major issue on everybody's mind was the representation. On June 9, 1787 the Virginia plan came to debate. The delegates bickered non-stop, with threats of dissolving the union. But it was one man, Roger Sherman who saved the convention by proposing compromise. Compromising last until July 23 when the delegated finally decided to have two house: the house of representative would house represent of the population, and the Senate would have equal representation; regardless of state or size there would be two senators. . It was on July 23 that the Senate as we know it was formed.At the same time, smaller issues arise and had to be worked out. These issues included fugitive slaves, export taxes, and import taxes. The topic of slavery, although shameful, was another heated topic under debate. The colonies were split once more, but this time it was over the enslavement of blacks in America. Southern delegates argued for slavery because it increased their economy. The northern delegates did not have any affection towards the blacks but they fought to free them, to protect themselves. They believed if the...

Find Another Essay On The Constituion is a bundle of compromises

The creation of the United States Constitution: was it based on compromises, or consensus?

1191 words - 5 pages no power is given by which restrictions may be imposed? I will not contend that such a provision would confer a regulating power; but it is evident that it would furnish, to men disposed to usurp, a plausible pretence for claiming that power."During the writing and ratification of the constitution, there were numerous ideological possibilities. Through many compromises, the US Constitution stands as a great and noble document.

Discussion on the creation of South Africa & how racial compromises affected this

1144 words - 5 pages The creation of the Union of South Africa was the result of numerous events throughout South Africa, spanning from the late 19th Century through to the Early 20th Century. Racial discrimination was a burden that had been and is still somewhat today, unfortunately, a large part of South African life. Furthermore, there were compromises through these issues that played a key role in the creation of the union.Numerous items of legislation stamped

"Religious Wars of India" looks at the wars in Kashmir and Ayodhya between India, Pakistan, and Afghanistan. It is written in an argumentative style with an emphasis on new compromises

2336 words - 9 pages Religious Wars of IndiaThe beginning of the new millennium has been a heart wrecking one for the peace loving people of the world. The year 2001 saw dispute, destruction, and death, all in the name of religion.As we usher in a new year with high hopes of peace, India and Pakistan are again on the brink of a war! Why are these two siblings always at loggerheads with each other? Is it because Pakistan is an Islamic nation and India predominantly a

'His bundle of names links all our little band of men together': How one man relates to another in the novel of "Dracula"

1900 words - 8 pages In the last note of "Dracula", Jonathan Harker describes his son as the union of the men who defeated the horrible vampire. Is this union an amicable one, merely taking in consideration the adventures they had together; or did Stoker refer to some other meaning of bond when writing this sentence, and many other utterances as well? In order to give a satisfactory answer to this question; the importance of having some knowledge about Stoker's life

What is the definition of a friend?

606 words - 2 pages Russell: What is friendship?Marcus: A friend is one who can help you in times of need.Russell: But what if the person is after something that you have?Marcus: Then I think he is not a friend.Russell: Then how would you define a friend?Marcus: A friend is one who can help you in times of need, but not for any gain.Russell: Then maybe he hates you, and helps only because he owes you a favor?Marcus: I correct myself that is not a friend.Russell

Is The Statue of Liberty a Lie?

1781 words - 7 pages Is The Statue of Liberty a Lie? The issue of immigration has shaped the history of the United States throughout the years of its existence. People from numerous different countries have immigrated to America in search of a better life and new opportunities. While Americans often ponder whether immigration is a benefit to society, legislators have recently enacted many anti-immigration laws which have been enforced to keep control over

Herb is the Healing of a Nation

1562 words - 6 pages Herb is the Healing of a Nation Life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness are the sovereign rights of a man. This means every human should be able to live a fulfilling life as they see fit following dreams and aspirations until happiness and inner peace is achieved. From the dawn of human time expanding one’s conscious was the known path to enlightenment, self actualization, and ultimate happiness. People take all different routes whether it

Turn of the Screw: A Cigar is Just a Cigar

855 words - 3 pages Ambiguity by definition is an attribute of any concept, idea, and statement or claims whose meaning, intention or interpretation cannot be definitively resolved according to the rules of or process consisting of a finite number of steps. And ambiguity in plays can make the reader think in ways never thought possible, the many different meanings and outcomes. Similar to Sigmund Freud and his dream theory of not everything in a dream has relevance

What is the Role of a stakeholder in a Company?

986 words - 4 pages A stakeholder is “a person, group or organization that has interest or concern in an organization.” http://www.businessdictionary.com. Stakeholders are affected by the operations of the business and if the business is successful or unsuccessful. Internal Stakeholders Internal stakeholders are stakeholders who “benefit directly from their contributions to the growth of the company.” http://www.investorwords.com The internal stakeholders in

Who is a Child? The Definition of a Child

2399 words - 10 pages This research paper looks at the definition of a child as expressed in four fields: international law, international child convention, Sharia and Islamic law, and Arab countries. A child is considered any person below the age of 18 years of age. However, each of the four fields has its own modifications of the definition. For instance, the international law and international child conventional loosely consider the age of 18 years as the upper

The State of Nature is a State of War

1484 words - 6 pages To understand Hobbes’s argument for why the State of Nature is a State of War it is important to understand Hobbes’s meanings of the terms State of Nature and State of War. The State of Nature is the condition where mankind is forced in contact with one another in a society where there is no authority to enforce power or laws. In this state, the lack of authority encompasses the lack of political institutions and the connotations associated

Similar Essays

A Constitution Of Compromises Essay

876 words - 4 pages When the 55 delegates of the Confederation came together in 1787 to record their ideas in the United States Constitution via consensus, the subject touching upon slavery in the States turned out to be the most debated point. States were openly divided in their economical, political, social and moral ideologies. Yet the impulse for a well-ordered, prosperous union gave way to making many compromises despite those ideals. With the intention to

A Finnish Bundle Of Joy Essay

2549 words - 11 pages -income mothers, the box has progressed to be a trademark of the country’s public policy: every child gets an equal start no matter the social circumstances (Picard). Though motherhood itself is a rite of passage, the mothers of Finland take pride in receiving their maternity packages and find it as a way to connect themselves to the struggling, yet strong mothers of the country’s past (Lee). Because of certain restrictions put on the grant

The Triumph Of Bundle Theory: A Lack Of Evidence For An Enduring Self

1270 words - 5 pages I. Introduction When thinking about the self, one is inclined to accept the idea of a personal identity that survives throughout time. This tendency is reflected in substance theory, the belief that the self is not just a collection of properties such as experiences and perceptions, but the vehicle for possessing these properties. The bundle theory makes the opposite argument. The theory claims that the inclinations for a personal identity are

How Effective Was The Articles Of Confederation And Did The Constituion Solve These Problems

678 words - 3 pages The Articles of Confederation were written in 1776 and finally ratified in 1777, after independence from Great Britain had been declared and while the American Revolution was still in progress. The colonists set out to create a new nation free of the rule of a strong central government. Many identified themselves as citizens of their state or colony, and not as colonies or nations as a whole. State rights became an important factor in the new