The Constitution. Why Did It Fail To Uphold The Union That It Created ?

744 words - 3 pages

The Constitution certainly contributed to the failure of the union it created. The document was originally formed with the intention of unifying the newly formed United States of America. Since then, the Constitution was effective in protecting the rights and ideals of the people. But by 1850, the Constitution had become a point of sectional disunity and had influenced a split both politically and ideologically between the North and the South. The writers of this document can in part be held responsible for the tension it caused. Although the Constitution was very effective in its early years, the writers had made the mistake of leaving several important issues open and unresolved, causing the eventual disunity over these issues. The Constitution ultimately contributed to the failure of the union because of the issues that were not resolved, and therefore caused controversy in the years leading up to the Civil War.One of the main unresolved issues of the Constitution was succession. The writers of this document did not consider that any state would ever wish to leave the union, and so did not address whether or not a state could secede. As a result of the Constitution's failure to address this issue, when the southern states wanted to leave the union, it was considered unconstitutional to use force to stop this uprising. James Buchanan was in support of the states' rights to leave the union if they did not feel they were properly represented. He stated in Document G, "The Southern States, standing of the basis of the Constitution, have a right to demand this act of justice from the States of the North." He also comments on the power of Congress to use force in keeping a state from succeeding, saying "... no such power has been delegated to Congress." Abraham Lincoln thought the opposite, and did not support the southern states' movement toward succession. He believes that because no state has ever been a state outside of the union, it does not have the right to destroy the union. In Document I, he clearly supports his opinion, stating "Having never been States, either in substance, or in name, outside of the Union, whence this magical...

Find Another Essay On The Constitution. Why Did it Fail to uphold the Union that it created ?

Why Did Reconstruction Fail? Essay

1266 words - 6 pages court house on April 9, 1865. The causes of the war was the secession of several southern states, they argued that it was up to them and it was in their rights to decide whether they should make slavery legal or illegal in their own boundaries. But the Union had other things in mind, the union wanted to decide whether or not the states were going to have slaves. This was just to make sure the country was equal on slavery and non-slavery on both

Why did the Revolution fail to topple the Tsar in 1905, but succeed in 1917?

1670 words - 7 pages Why did the Revolution fail to topple the Tsar in 1905, but succeed in 1917?The Russian Revolution had a decisive impact on the history of the twentieth century. Its implications and influences went on to effect a huge area and last decades. True to the large impact that it had, it was a large event. It spanned years and included many various groups and individuals. When studying the Russian Revolution it is important to note that it came during

Why did the USSR fail to keep control over Eastern Europe?

819 words - 3 pages citizens opened their eyes and realized that this wasn't want they wanted. What they wanted was reform.When it came to their economy, the Soviet Union had to crunch its numbers. The USSR spent around $40 billion a year propping up communist governments across the world in countries such as Cuba, Vietnam, Afghanistan and even countries in Eastern Europe. East Germany was almost completely dependent on the aid given by the Soviets. In addition to

Why did the US fail to save South Vietnam from Communism?

1235 words - 5 pages matter how big America is, they will never be able to control the majority, for it is the majority that will eventually rid this country of its foreign occupiers. America couldn't have possibly saved the Vietnamese from communism simply because they didn't want to be saved, and much preferred living under the communist regime of the North. Furthermore another reason why they were seen as imperialists was because a lot of Vietnamese were forced to

Why did Chinese Nationalism fail?

925 words - 4 pages . Within fifty years of the British trade convoys first arriving at the Forbidden City, the first Opium War had begun, and China was suffering. This was good for maintianing control, but meant that China did not advance at all for all this time. The main reason that Britain had for trying to control parts of China was because of trade and profit. Since the Chinese Emperors refused to allow them free trade the British began to attack China to let

Why did Communism and the Soviet Union collapse by 1991?

566 words - 2 pages his new political thinking. Over 15,000 Red Army soldiers were killed in the war, which cost $8 billion per annum lasting over 10 years. Gorbachev felt it unnecessary and shameful to their citizens and Bolsheviks after 60 years. He wanted to make the Soviet system more productive and responsive. He recognized that in order to achieve this, military spending had to be reduced. This could be done only if arms limitation talks with the USA were

What were the causes of the Berbice revolt of 1763? Why did the revolt fail?

824 words - 4 pages like and wanted to experience those conditions again. The slaves desired revenge against the whites due to the ill treatment they received from the manager and overseer. The slaves wished for permanent freedom from the Dutch and felt that a revolt was the only way to achieve this. Some slaves received little or no provisions because the planters did not grow enough on the estate and the Berbice Association cut down food imports, therefore they

Why Did The Restored Bourbon Monarchy Fail In France (1815-30)

1922 words - 8 pages Why did the restored Bourbon monarchy fail in France (1814-30)? Much of the historical interest in the restored Bourbon monarchy has concentrated on its shortcomings, often giving the impression that it was destined to failure from its very inception. Indeed, as both the First and Second Restorations ended in relatively swift revolutions, it is difficult to argue against the validity of this method. However, I don't believe that the question of

Account for Changes in British Policy Towards Ireland Between 1914 and 1922. Why Did These Changes Fail to Satisfy the People of Ireland?

2218 words - 9 pages continuously post-dated'1 The Nationalists were left without purpose as Home Rule had been won, although it had not yet been won. It also seemed that even with the war the English were still prejudice towards the southern Irish, as they were not promoted to officer and were not allowed their own corps which the Ulster unionists had. Redmond was losing support with many of it's members and this gave way to more extremist groups growing restless and

Why did the United States dump the Articles of Confederation for the Constitution of 1787?

870 words - 3 pages balance in size. Everyone wanted the question of state sovereignty answered. The Articles of Confederation attempted to answer these questions, but instead, only succeeded in creating an ineffectual, self-contradictory government that required reform. This reform came in the form of the Constitution of 1789. Commensurate representation was the first issue faced by the Confederation Congress. The Articles mandated a continuation of the structure

Why did sparta not manage to get control over a large part of the greek world that athens did?

2290 words - 9 pages Why did Sparta not manage to get control over a large part of the Greek world that Athens did?In 550BC the Spartans defeated Tegea, this was followed by Argos in 544BC. From 520-490BC under king Cleomenes Sparta was seen as the leader of the Peloponnese and the leader in Greek defence against Persia. In 490BC the Peloponnesian league was created with Sparta as the recognised leader. Despite all this, the Spartans never managed to get control

Similar Essays

Reasons The Articles Of Confederation Led To The Ratification Of The Constitution: Why Did The Articles Fail? Did The Constitution Solve The Problems?

942 words - 4 pages was not easy. Not everyone agreed with all the changes, but, that will never happen. The Articles of Confederation were weak and bound to fail; a stronger government had to be built. We still stand by the Constitution today, with only a few amendments from the original. Even now no one has found a solution to every problem we have in this country or any country, but the problems the Constitution did solve in 1787 made it possible for America to

Why Did The Equal Rights Fail?

855 words - 4 pages Amendment fail? People concerned about the E.R.A. – whether they be for or against the very thought of the idea of prohibiting gender-related prejudice – all have their own opinion and views toward the reason why the E.R.A. failed. Some believe it was because of the favoring from others toward the amendment, others believe it failed because it was more gender specific when choosing to support it, but very few think that it was the persuasive

Aos After Experiencing A Change; Why Is It That We Fail To Appreciate These Repercussions Of This Change? It Is Too Often That We See Past The Positive Effects

1144 words - 5 pages participate in what she wanted most in life; and did so. Diana came about a life change, and because of it she was able to better the world; proof that her change was good.It is quite clear that all change brings a positive outcome. So when contemplating over your next life change, try to incorporate the positive repercussions of your change before you plan on neglecting them -because all change is good.

The Oprichnina This Essay Is About The Oprichnina In Russian During Ivan The Terrible's Reign. It Goes Over What They Did And Why They Were Created

645 words - 3 pages sure no one survived. Ivan then went on to attempt to sack Pskov. There Ivan decided not to sack the city, nevertheless the Oprichnina looted the churches and monasteries. Essentially, the Oprichnina were vehicles for countless murders.There are three reasons why Ivan may have created the Oprichnina: One is that he was trying to create a central government in which Moscow was the capital and he was the all-powerful ruler. By destroying all other