This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Construction Of Risk: 9/11 Terrorist Attack And The Response To It

2206 words - 9 pages

The Construction of Risk: 9/11 Terrorist Attack and the Response to It

On the 11th of September 2001 terrorists carried out suicide attacks on American soil. They killed over 3,000 people and shocked the world as people never really thought of the magnitude of the attacks and in particular the location of the attack, America where risk is calculated and anticipated. These events shed a light of a debate whether risk is an objective phenomenon whose probability can always be calculated, or it is subjective/dynamic phenomenon which is constantly constructed and negotiated.

To date there has been a contestation around risk approach. One approach is so called realism. The exponents of realism propose that risk is the outcome of probability and consequences of an unfavourable event (Bradbury, 1989). They see risk as an objective phenomenon that can be measured separately from cultural and social processes (Renn, 1992a). Because they view risk as an objective phenomenon, they argue that the perceptions of risk among individuals should be similar. Employing a standpoint of cognitive science, this approach has been widely used in dealing with risk in the areas of engineering, statistics, psychology, epidemiology and economics. It presents the conception of hazard with calculation of probability (Lupton, 1999).

The other approach, namely constructivism, provides a critique for realism by highlighting realism tendency to reduce the meanings and behaviours linked to risk perception and assessment to the individualistic level. In general, cognitive science ignores the symbolic meanings that humans give to objects and events. Lupton makes this clear by saying that perception in realism is restricted only to the way people see and comprehend the world through their senses and brain-functioning (Lupton, 1999). The realists have a tendency to place people outside the cultural and political frameworks, relationships, and institutions within which their beliefs and behaviours are constructed. This tendency is not correct because individuals are not free from emotions and self interests which affect the way they respond to risk.

Constructivism offers a dissenting approach by arguing that risk knowledge is not free at all from the socio-cultural contexts in which this knowledge is created (Lupton, 1999). This approach stresses that such knowledge is not free from values as it is the product of perceiving things in certain socio-cultural contexts. Therefore, the perception of risk among individuals is allowed to differ. Consequently, expert judgements of risk are regarded as equally constructed by implicit and cultural processes as are lay people’s judgements. Risks are not seen as realities lying outside of society and culture, but as integration of meanings, logics and beliefs. We can only know and experience risks through our specific location in a particular socio-cultural context. Lupton describes this well when she states that “a risk is not a static,...

Find Another Essay On The Construction of Risk: 9/11 Terrorist Attack and the Response to It

9/11 attacks and the Western response

2029 words - 9 pages Osama Bin Laden wanted nothing less than to destroy the United States and everyone in it. This idea caused Osama to attack the United States on September 11th, 2001. What were the attack plans, why did the attacks of 911 happen, and what was the reactions of the East, will all be answered in this essay. Most Americans have heard about the attacks of September 11th. Most know that there were two planes, American Airlines Flight 11, and United

Terrorism during the 9/11 Attack and Afterwards

1760 words - 8 pages Homeland Security witnessed these thoughts come to fruition. The September eleventh terrorist attack on the world trade center was a horrible surprise to United States citizens which led to the signing of the Homeland Security Act, which in turn led to the development of the Department of Homeland Security, created in an effort to dissuade and prevent any future attacks of this kind. “The ability of terrorists to put into action the attacks of 9/11

9/11 Terrorist Attacks

2024 words - 8 pages attack on the White House which ultimately became known as the Pennsylvania attack. The Pentagon and Pennsylvania attacks were not as catastrophic as the World Trade Center attacks. The terrorists killed many more people at the World Trade Center than at the Pentagon and Pennsylvania combined. At the time of the attacks, it was suggested that this may be a terroristic event so a transport plane was sent to follow Flight 77 which crashed into the

The National Response Framework and the London Terrorist Attack - Ashford - Assignment

824 words - 4 pages ). Four years later the NRP was replaced by the National Response Framework to provide an all hazards response. The NRF integrated past experiences into a long term strategic response to thwart and interrupt terrorist activity, safeguard citizens and critical infrastructures and all other disasters. On July 7th, 2005 London experienced the worst terrorist attack on British soil. At precisely 8:50 am, four suicide bombers created the first suicide

Racism after the terrorist attacks on 9/11

491 words - 2 pages school crying and others talking about being "drafted", I began to realize the truth about the terrorist attacks. That was when I started going through some changes about what I believe in.Up until 9/11 I was not racist toward anyone, but since then I have different feelings about Arabs. I used to feel that all people were equal regardless of race. Now when I see them it's weird to be around them, because I can't help but wonder how they could do

How Leaders Controlled Events in the 1906 San Francisco Earthquake and the 9/11 Terrorist Attacks in New York City

1350 words - 6 pages During times of crisis, it is understood that leaders are expected to control the situation to the best of their ability. This could not be more evident than in the cases of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and the 9/11 terrorist attacks in New York City. General Frederick Funston controlled the post-earthquake San Francisco with an iron fist while implementing measures intended to control the fire engulfing the city. Almost 100 years later

Terrorist Attacks on 9/11 Part 2

1458 words - 6 pages domestic soil. (White, 2014) Conclusion There were several events leading up to the attacks of 9/11. In these events it can now be seen that there were red flags of terrorist activity in the United States. It can also be seen that it is not an easy task to prevent each and every attack. Since the attacks of 9/11, we have still been victims of smaller attacks both domestic and foreign. The attacks of 9/11 changed the way that we perceive and

Terrorist Attacks on 9/11 Part 1

1595 words - 7 pages that have fought in the war on terrorism are taken into account. The attacks were focused on the North and South World Trade Towers, the Pentagon, and an unknown target. The unknown target is thought to be Washington, D.C. but it never occurred due to the passengers of the hijacked airliner causing it to crash in a field in Pennsylvania and never reaching the true destination. Pre-9/11 Attack The 19 Islamic terrorists that carried out the

Comparing Crucible With 9/11 Attack

603 words - 2 pages accused of being a witch was arrested and it was not until too late that the people of the trials were cleared of the charges and reparations were made. Following John Proctor's example in The Crucible, people today should not jump to conclusions about the Muslims and see what is happening.Past situations showed that mass hysteria and a mob mentality have placed an unjust and biased burden upon groups of people that have resulted in some very

US Response to Terrorism After 9/11 - US History - Essay

846 words - 4 pages in a state of confusion. The Christian Science Monitor states, “Yet the White House appears to be encouraging this false impression, as it seeks to maintain American support for a possible was against Iraq” (Document 5). This quote shows that, the White House is trying to link Iraq to the 9/11 attacks. The government knows that especially in a time of sadness and anger, that the citizens are looking for anyone to blame for attacks, and the United

Islamic Terrorism and the Attack of September 11

3194 words - 13 pages York Times News Service 9/18)   In conclusion, what happened on September 11 was a huge eruption of Dionysian energy which exploded into the world's consciousness and as in all cases of post-traumatic stress syndrome, the trauma remains under the surface taking apart reality as we know it. So the questions of insider versus outsider understanding will continue to haunt us as we deconstruct our understanding of the good life. In response

Similar Essays

The Topic Of 9/11 Is Very Controversial. Some People Believe That 9/11 Was A Terrorist Attack While Others Say It Was A Government Setup. In This Essay I Show Example Both Ways.

935 words - 4 pages 9/11 a Government Cover-upThe topic of the attack on the twin towers in New York City on September 11, 2011 is controversial. Many believe that 9/11 was a terrorist attack on the United States, from a terrorist group known as Al Qaeda. Then there are other known as conspiracist's who believe that the attack was a government set up simply to have a strong reason to go to war against Iraq. To believe that the United States government killed

The Roots Of The Terrorist Attacks Of 9/11

1507 words - 6 pages demonstrates a shallow but expansive view of the history behind the attacks of September 11, 2001. They were a result of many years of Muslim extremist hate of America’s foreign policies in the Middle East and its support of Israel. The events leading to the 9/11 terrorist attacks were set in motion many years ago. These attacks were not hasty or without much forethought and planning. This attack and other attacks against America were a response to

The Horrors Of The Terrorist Attacks On 9/11

877 words - 4 pages plane Flight 11 was crashed into the South tower. That same day another plane Flight 77 crashed into the West side of the Pentagon in Washington, DC. Earlier that day Flight 93 was hijacked and headed for the White House, but the passengers on board the plane took over and crashed the plane near a town called Shanksville, Pennsylvania. The terrorist plots on September 11, 2001 became the most significant attack on American soil to date. September

Law Enforcement Innovations In Reaction To The 9/11 Terrorist Attacks And The Virginia Tech Massacre

1112 words - 4 pages and Cordner, 2005). The latter is known as the “all crimes” approach, which believes that all types of crimes could be linked to terrorist activities. In fact, some of the 9/11 terrorists had fraudulent driver’s licenses and were actually stopped for traffic violations prior to the attack. Kelling and Moore (1988) describe the latest policing functions as providing order maintenance, problem solving, conflict resolution and giving services, but