The Contrast Between Gothic Architecture And Romanesque Architecture

1920 words - 8 pages

The Romanesque and Gothic architecture period both occurred during the Middle Ages with the Gothic period taking place during the later half. Gothic and Romanesque architecture were related in many ways, but they also contrasted in style too. Over time, masons began to test the waters and push the limits. They thought of new ways to add lighting and ways to allow more height to the building without it being to heavy and weak. Many of the reasons for the change in styles had a lot to do with society and the changes it faced. There was a greater intensity occurring in piety and literature. The Gothic style embodied this new urban society. Romanesque and Gothic shared similar characteristics, but Gothic architecture was a greater departure from its previous predecessor.
The Romanesque architecture style, which occurred during the late 11th century to the middle 12th century, literally means “roman-like” architecture. The Romans, who were inspired by the Etruscans, used barreled and groined vaulting. Romanesque architects later adapted the use of rounded arches, giving the style its name. The Romanesque style, being inspired by the Roman architecture, used the plan of the basilica style. Romanesque cathedrals were not originally designed for aesthetic purposes. Romanesque style replaced flat wood ceilings with stone vaulting. It was one of the first styles to use mainly all stone, but the walls of the Romanesque cathedrals were built very thickly. They were almost like a fortress. Romanesque cathedrals had few windows as a result of their thick walls so the churches were very dark. In a sense, this echoed the life that was outside of these sanctuaries’ walls during the Middle Ages.
Some Romanesque characteristics in architecture were stone barrel vaulting or groin vaulting, thick and heavy pillars, small windows so less natural light, round arches, multiple towers, wooden roofs, and painted decorations, like frescoes, throughout the interior.
These characteristics contrasted with the style of Gothic architecture. With the new Gothic style, the walls were thinner. Masons worked towards a more artistic look. Unlike the Romanesque style, which had few windows, Gothic architecture had many.
The Gothic style, dating between the 12th century and 16th century, began in France and eventually spread throughout the rest of Europe. An example of the first true Gothic church was St. Denis of Paris. Now, it is considered one of our finest artistic periods, but at the time, the term “gothic” did not exactly hold the same meaning it does today. The name came from the Goths and was used rather negatively when describing this style of architecture as they considered it to be similar to the works of the barbarians from which the name was derived.
Defining characteristics which began to create the line between Romanesque and Gothic architecture was the use of flying buttresses, this allowed for more light, bigger windows, and of course the use of a pointed arch...

Find Another Essay On The Contrast between Gothic Architecture and Romanesque Architecture

Gothic Architecture Essay

1576 words - 6 pages Architecture (1836). He states, “The Gothic, breaking the horizontal line, and leading the eye upwards till its pinnacles vanish in the sky, seems adapted, by an easy correspondence, to the offices of that blessed religion, which takes the heart from the contemplation of earth, and directs it to its heavenly inheritance.” This theme of the relationship between the Gothic cathedral and divine spirit finds its continuation in the research of Stephen

Gothic Architecture Essay

1271 words - 5 pages , wall ornaments and unique structures. The exterior group can be broken down into the two basic groups: exterior design and exterior ornaments. Many cathedrals have been built in the gothic style that involves the use of many interesting and intricate details.The interior, which is the inside of the cathedral, has many details that distinguish it from other styles of architecture. Most cathedrals have an interior design that consists of a short

Gothic Architecture

1392 words - 6 pages A cathedral is a work of art, no matter its "type". Most cathedrals take decades or more of planning, building, and sweating. To construct such a masterpiece can only be done with the help of God's grace. The effort is worth the result. Cathedrals are majestic edifices, and some are the perfect examples of Gothic architecture.Gothic art and architecture had their roots in France in about 1140, and spread to the rest of Europe in the following

The Romanesque Period: An in-depth analysis of the romanesque medieval period covering both architecture and sculpture

1718 words - 7 pages The style of architecture immediately preceding Gothic within Europe is known as Romanesque. The term Romanesque, like many other stylistic designations, was not a term contemporary within the art it describes but an invention of modern scholarship to categorize a period. The term Romanesque attempts to link the architecture, especially, of the 11th and 12th centuries in medieval Europe to roman architecture based on similarities of form and

Church Architecture of the Early Christian, Byzantine, Carolingian/Ottoman, and Romanesque Periods.

1592 words - 6 pages standard element of many Romanesque churches. Although the nave's proportions had changed from earlier churches, it retained the continuous and unbroken appearance of its Early Christian predecessors.The Pisa Cathedral Complex, with its freestanding baptistery and campanile, forms one of the most famous building groups in the world. Except for the upper portion of the baptistery, with its remodeled Gothic exterior, the three structures are

Gothic Architecture in Europe

1848 words - 7 pages average person from the Gothic Period-these structures produced an intense experience. Evolved from Romanesque, Gothic was a more eclectic application of architecture. The decline and eventual fall of the Roman Empire had left a void in Western Europe, and for the first 500 years after the fall, there was anarchy and chaos. This period is most often referred to as the “Dark Ages” as indeed they were. Around 1100 AD, the Catholic Church

Gothic Architecture - Amiens Cathedral

1214 words - 5 pages the columns did not need as much support. Ribbed vaulting a characteristic that was seen throughout Romanesque style. Ribbed vaults are the intersection of two or three barrel vaults. There are often thinly vaulted webs in between the separate ribs as well. Gothic style was expressed in many churches and cathedrals in France throughout the 12th to 16th century. In this paper, I am going to focus on the tallest completed gothic style cathedral in

Origins of Gothic Architecture

978 words - 4 pages The origins of Gothic Architecture are credited to Abbot Suger and the renovation of The Cathedral Basilica of Saint-Denis. The “Church” was largely defined by the Gothic Style during the Middle Ages. This style was an amalgamation of earlier styles, and prior to being recognized as “Gothic”, was not necessarily popular nor was it not part of the original program of the Cathedral Basilica of Saint-Denis. This soon changed and it became

Erwin Panofsky's Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism

1015 words - 4 pages Erwin Panofsky's Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism presents a compelling connection between the architectural styles of Gothic Cathedrals and the order and form of the Scholastic school of thought. Focusing on the "100 mile zone around Paris" during the years between 1130-40 and 1270 where and when Scholasticism was the dominate theory of education and Gothic architecture began to take a stronghold over the ageing Romanesque style. In

The History of Gothic Architecture in Italy

1692 words - 7 pages Architecture in Italy shows the gradual transition from simple Roman work to Romanesque and Byzantine and lastly to Gothic architecture. In Italy Gothic had no much impact on career perspective like it had in other part of Europe, liken France, Germany and England. Gothic Architecture in Italy led to constant knowledge of grand works of classic period which the influence was from the East. The first buildings used for worship in Italy had no

Gothic Architecture During the Middle Ages

1293 words - 5 pages architects wanted big windows on the buildings and this new style made their wish come true. Architecture during the Middle Ages became a new style with new problems to solve and a new kind of extraordinary buildings to build. The world was changing, and Europeans’ perceptions of it as reflected in art and architecture too. A style termed Romanesque from about 1000 onward had dominated; this gave way to the Gothic in about 1150 which spread

Similar Essays

Romanesque And Gothic Architecture Essay

1130 words - 5 pages Romanesque and Gothic Architecture The 11th to 15th centuries saw a great surge of the Christian Church within Europe which was emphasized by the persuasiveness of the Crusades. The growing population of the Church increased the demand for the increased presence in architectural monuments and during the Romanesque and Gothic periods, a great cathedral construction boom occurred across Europe. The Romanesque and Gothic architectural styles

The Romanesque Style In Architecture And Sculpture

650 words - 3 pages Alisha WilliamsChartres CathedralThe Romanesque Style in architecture and sculpture.10/16/2013The Five books of the Histories.This chapter is about the life and works of Rodulfus Glaber, whose works and life was greatly influenced by the kings of France and Germany, and also by the Capetian dynasty, where he lived for a while after the election of Hugh Capet. Glaber was regarded as one great man of politics, with the writings of his diaries

Classical And Gothic Architecture Essay

820 words - 3 pages between Classical and Gothic architecture, both also some noteworthy differences; however, no matter the result of comparison, both styles have left the world with beautiful architectural achievements.The Parthenon in Greece is one of the best examples of Greek Classicism. Built on the Athenian Acropolis, this temple was dedicated to the Greek goddess Athena, the goddess of wisdom, courage, inspiration, skill, and strength. The precision and symmetry

Gothic Architecture Essay

2253 words - 9 pages selves. There were number of reasons that the need for the development of the gothic architecture that developed from its proceeding Romanesque architecture. One of the main reasons being the wooden roof that kept burning down due to fire and the lack of aesthetic appeal (Gombrich, 1966). Due to the need of building moats and walls around the cities the space was limited and on the other hand they need to accommodate more people in to the church