The Contribution Of Robert Merton’s Work To Criminological Theory

2269 words - 9 pages

Merton’s work has contributed greatly to criminological theory as he took a different perspective than Durkheim’s concept of anomie and reworked to the American context. The theories and concepts of anomie and strain that Merton argued have influenced the works of Cohen as well as the New Deviancy Theory and the New Penology. Therefore, Strain theory has evolved across time to encompass different situational circumstances of crime. Furthermore, due to the individual’s inability to achieve the appropriate cultural status, the idea of reference groups have also been highly relevant to today’s understanding of crime. Where evaluating oneself against peers constantly occurs as people try to better or compete against others.

Durkheim was raised in France during the second half of the eighteenth century, a time when individuals were regulated through society’s collective conscience which was heavily reliant on religion, enlightenment, and Darwinism. It was also a time of great turmoil generated by the French revolution in 1789 and the industrialisation of society, which created the division of labour and specialisation between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie (Gold & Bernard, 1986). One of Durkheim’s key themes is centred on social solidarity, where the transition from mechanic solidarity and the collective conscience of the church became punctured leading to the rise of individualisation (organic solidarity). Durkheim theorized that if the desire for goals was boundless, anomie would ensue due to the lack of normative control, followed by the emergence of strain. The strain would manifest into a range of outcomes, one of which could be deviant behavior (Pfohl, 1994). As crime was an inevitable product of the strain produced by the alienation and dissatisfaction concurrent in the deregulation of society, anomie was therefore representative of suicide and the division of labour.

Although Merton came to the similar conclusion of Durkheim’s that deviance was a product of societal structures, he took a different position to the grand theorist (Sztompka, 1986). Anomie did not originate from the collapse of structures beyond a point, but was based on the very design of the social structures. Hence, Durkheim’s anomie was based on the lack of restriction on goals, whereas Merton’s refers to a constraint on the means (Clark, Modgil, & Modgil, 1990). Because Merton was a middle-range functionalist, he questioned and furthered Durkheim’s concept of anomie from a different perspective. He looked at the smaller problems and tied it to greater society, whereas Durkheim focused on society as a whole. Merton therefore wanted to find out what produced anomie in the first place and did this by looking at particular goals that are endemic in American society (Hunt, 1961).

Merton’s upbringing in Philadelphia and the events that occurred during his writing influenced his take on anomie (Evans, 2006-2009). The Great Depression and the influx of immigrants...

Find Another Essay On The Contribution of Robert Merton’s Work to Criminological Theory

The Jungle's Contribution to a Nation's Reform- Exploration of Upton Sinclair's work

856 words - 3 pages out in these acts. John Whiteclay Chambers II proclaims that these pieces of legislation not only spelled out regulations regarding foods and drugs, but also indicated the consequences of disregarding the rules. This resulted in a healthier, more wholesome nation.The biggest achievement of The Jungle was its contribution to today's Food and Drug Administration, which affects the lives of every individual in the United States. The Center for Food

Robert D. Furchgott’s Contribution to Physiology and the Discovery of Nitric Oxide as a Cardiovascular Signaling Molecule

1988 words - 8 pages Robert F. Furchgott’s Prior Work in Pharmacology and Physiology Robert F. Furchgott was awarded a Bachelor of Science from the University of North Carolina in 1937 and a PhD in biochemistry from Northwestern University in 19401,2. During this PhD, he initially examined the physical and chemical changes egg albumin denaturation produced, but after attending a symposium in 1938 he decided to study the effects of unbuffered isotonic

Karl Marx's Contribution to Labor Theory of Value

1263 words - 5 pages Contrary to popular belief, the origin of the Labor Theory of Value (LTV), which states that the value of a commodity is proportional to the amount of labor consumed to produce it, is not attributable to Karl Marx. While this may be true, the LTV is most familiar to economists as the cornerstone of Marx’s argument against capitalism in Capital. In studying Marxism, it is important to understand the degree to which Marx expounded upon the

X-Bar Syntax and Its Contribution to the Linguistic Theory

2229 words - 9 pages X-Bar Syntax and Its Contribution to the Linguistic Theory 'X-bar syntax, as a theory of phrase structure grammar, makes a significant contribution to both the descriptive and the explanatory adequacy of Linguistic Theory.' The aim of a theory of language is to describe a speaker's linguistic competence. (Class notes) In order for a grammar to be satisfactory it must satisfy two main conditions: descriptive adequacy and explanatory

Discussion of the contribution of Dunning's Eclectic Theory

1951 words - 8 pages theories of foreign direct investment and international production as what it has proved that it can be used in this Citibank case (Dunning, 2001); There are many others FDI cases that can not be explained by the theory. Then, the issue here is "Does Dunning's eclectic theory gives a good contribution to the study of international business in general and more specific to the existence of FDI?" Even Dunning's eclectic theory seems to be quite

Literary and Political Appropriations of Eça de Queirós’s Work: a Contribution to the Study of Portuguese Literary Canon

1066 words - 4 pages in Eça emerged in the nineteen-forties . In Portugal, the reception of Eça’s work can be traced back to his own literary generation. His first works are from 1866 and, in 1874, it is Ramalho Ortigão who introduces him to the readers of Diário Ilustrado as a writer on the margins of the literary establishment. Eça’s writing is described as an uncompromising and insightful amalgamation of sublime and grotesque elements served by a crafty and

How does IR Theory explain the United Nation’s contribution to the maintenance of international peace and security?

2039 words - 9 pages How does IR Theory explain the United Nation’s contribution to the maintenance of international peace and security? “More than ever before in human history, we share a common destiny. We can master it only if we face it together. And that is why we have the United Nations.” (Annan: 2001) It is generally considered that international organisations ought to stand accountable for the preservation of global stability and peace, be this

Contribution to the Evolution of Distance Education

1528 words - 6 pages traditional student have for so many years. Andragogy is a theory which is focused on the teaching of adults. The term Andragogy was first coined in 1833 by the German educator Alexander Kapp (Reischmann, 2000), and was adopted in the United States by Malcolm Knowles. Knowles began his career as a mentor for the youth. As a youth, his intelligence was obvious, for he created a chart to assist other scout members in earning advancement awards

Explore Durkheim's contribution to sociological theory

3102 words - 12 pages best for it's interpretation.Durkheim's other important contribution to sociological theory, was his work on social values and alienation, and his Functionalist approach to social phenomena, and the division of labour.The work of Durkheim is now conventionally described as a Functionalist approach to society whereby society is seen as a unity of integrated working parts. The functionalist believes that each part of the whole has a part to play

"Dr. Robert A. Moog and His Contribution to Electronic Music"

1442 words - 6 pages solo flight across the Atlantic during a period when woman's suffrage began to bring about serious recognition. A lesser known individual by the name of Dr. Robert Arthur Moog initiated a ground breaking change in the field of music forever. Prior to his birth on May 23, 1934, music creation as an art had reached their limit with the acceptance of inharmonic compositions such as Stravinsky's Rite of Spring. Yet, almost theatrically occurring at

The Contribution of Feminists to the Sociology of the Family

1172 words - 5 pages Traditional functionalists such as Murdock and Parsons have stressed the need for both parents for effective socialisation of the young, this view was revitalised by the work of the New Right theorist, Charles Murray who claims that the substantial rise in the number of single parent families, is indicitative of a rising underclass. However, Ellis Cashmore failed to find any negative effects on the individual or society although she acknowledges

Similar Essays

Robert Merton’s Work And Criminological Theory

799 words - 3 pages ). Criminological Theory: Robert K. Merton. Florida: Florida State University, Centre for Criminology and Public Policy Research. Retrieved from http://www.criminology.fsu.edu/crimtheory/merton.htm Gold, G. & Bernard, T. (1986). Theoretical criminology. New York: Oxford University Press. Hunt, M. (1961, January 28). How does it come to be so? Profile of Robert K. Merton. The New Yorker, pg. 39–63. Johnson, D. (1981). Sociological theory

Applying Criminological Theory To Solve The Murder Of Tigger

1297 words - 6 pages Applying criminological theory to a suspect’s anecdotal evidence can help to distinguish which suspect could be the possible offender. In this certain case, poor Tigger has been murdered and there are 3 possible suspects. Merton’s Anomie Theory will be applied to suspect number 1: Winnie The Pooh. Eysenck’s Theory will be applied to suspect number 2: Piglet and Social Bond Theory will be applied to suspect number 3: Eeyore. Merton’s Anomie

Robert D. Furchgott’s Contribution To The Discovery Of Nitric Oxide As A Cardiovascular Signaling

1506 words - 6 pages Introduction In 1998 the Nobel Prize in physiology was awarded to three scientists for their contribution to the discovery of nitric oxide (NO) as a physiological singling molecule, particularly in vascular smooth muscle: Dr. Robert F. Furchgott, Dr. Louis J. Ignarro, and Dr. Ferid Murad1,2. Although the Prize was only initially awarded to Furchgott and Murad, it was later admitted that without the work of Ignarro an important link would

The Work Of Robert Gagné Essay

1447 words - 6 pages The Work of Robert Gagné Overview The fundamental concern of instructional design is the creation of more effective learning environments for learners. In order to do this, instructional designers must consider the various learning styles and stages of development of the learners as they interact with course material and develop a mature understanding of a topic. According to Ormrod (1995), theories of learning provide