This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Controversy Around Corporal Punishment Essay

1443 words - 6 pages

To spank or not to spank? The topic of corporal punishment is a controversial and sensitive matter in our society. No matter what day in age we live in it will continue to be a social problem. Corporal punishment, also referred to as spanking is deliberately inflicting pain on a person due to an inappropriate behavior or act they have done. This involves hitting, pinching, using switch cords, smacking, and etcetera. Those who are in favor of corporal punishment and believes that it should not be illegal, uses scriptures from the bible as justification. Supporters of corporal punishment feels as if spanking is an effective way to manage behavior. Those who are against spanking points out the ...view middle of the document...

Dr. Alvy’s argument is effective to some degree because he gives brief details and examples, and to be completely fair he provides details about the opposing side also. The mode of persuasion that is being used the most in this article is logos. By simplify reading this article you will realize logic and rationale being thrown left and right. Being one of the nation’s most respected and knowledgeable parenting figures one should not turn a blind eye to his words. Dr. Alvy makes exceptionally great points when he discuss the alternatives to spanking and when he states that “Those who are advocating for the proposed ban also remind us that there are parents of all cultural and religious groups who never use any type of corporal punishment and whose children grow up to be fine citizens.” Beating a child is unnecessary and is not an essential way to discipline them, no matter how harsh or light the hand is.
The list of harmful effects due to corporal punishment is endless. In the main article written by Alvy, “Spanking Should Be Illegal” he presents a list of damaging and negative outcomes associated with spanking from research. He addresses that
Many negative behaviors and outcomes have been regularly associated with the parental use of corporal punishment. These include greater depression, aggression and suicidal thoughts for children who are more frequent recipients of corporal punishment and of harsh corporal punishment, as well as poorer school performance and more anti-social behavior on the part of these frequently and harshly punished young people. Also, such youngsters have a higher likelihood of being victims of legally determined child abuse, probably because of the escalation effect mentioned above. These young people are also more likely to abuse their children and spouses when they grow up.
In much lucid and simpler terms, spanking a child does more harm than good. The benefits acquired from doing so is questionable.
The American Psychoanalytic Association (APSAA) is in agreement with Dr. Kerby T. Alvy’s position on shunning spanking. This committee believes that corporal punishment will not enhance a child’s capacity to develop healthy emotional lives. The organization stress how spanking traumatize a child in more ways than one. APSAA claims that
Spanking is a euphemism for hitting. One is not permitted to hit one's spouse or a stranger; such actions are defined as the crime of assault. Nor should one be permitted to hit a small and more vulnerable child. Hitting a child elicits precisely the feelings one does not want to generate in a child: distress, anger, fear, shame, and disgust. Studies show that children who are hit identify with the aggressor and are more likely to become hitters themselves, that is, bullies and future abusers of their own children and partners. They tend to learn to use violent behavior as a way to deal with stress and interpersonal disputes.
The American Psychoanalytic Association (APSAA) does not only...

Find Another Essay On The Controversy Around Corporal Punishment

Corporal punishment with respect to the private and public sphere

1520 words - 7 pages 1 Introduction Corporal punishment is the unlawful intentional act of causing harm by physically inflicting punishment on the body of an offender or severely criticising the offender. There is a distinction in common-law between corporal punishment in the public sphere and in the private sphere. Corporal punishment on children in the private sphere is administered by parents. It is legally accepted in South Africa, provided that the requirements

How the Use of Corporal Punishment can Affect a Child

1748 words - 7 pages Corporal punishment is a method used to discipline someone by using physical force to inflict pain. Many parents are guilty of using physical force to discipline their children at least once in a child’s lifetime. Sometimes parents can get so caught up in being angry with the child that all they can think about is hitting the child to get the child to listen to them. This, however, may not be the best way to discipline a child. This

Critically Analyse the evidence about the effectiveness and limits of corporal punishment

768 words - 4 pages Corporal punishment to modify a child's undesired behaviour is an emotive issue within the general population and for Psychologists it is an extremely complex and challenging research topic. Within my body of work I will endevour to critically analyse and summarise the effective use of corporal punishment; it's effects and limitations; whilst presenting a summary of the phychological evidence both short and long term on childrens behaviour

The Effectiveness of Corporal Punishment on Correcting Behavior of Middle School Children

897 words - 4 pages Corporal Punishment and its Effectiveness on Correcting a Child’s Behavior in the Middle School Setting: Sixth Grade through Eighth Grade A Research Project Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of Requirements for the EDU 501 Research Method Freed-Hardeman University March 24, 2014 Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction to the Study…………………………………………………3 Statement of the Problem……………………………………………………..3 Description of Corporal

The Controversy Around Banning Books

864 words - 3 pages The subject of censorship is a very controversial one, especially the banning of books. Many people believe they must protect themselves and others from the "evils" of many classic books and works of art because they can be deemed "indecent" in one way or another. Many believe that this is absurd and censorship in its current form is a violation of our First Amendment right to free speech. Personally, I align myself with the

“Corporal Punishment Can Hurt: The Evidence"

1064 words - 4 pages This paper will be focusing on the various motives,circumstances,and effects that violent video games have on children to adolescents.In addition to the reasoning and various aspects of studies, this paper will go into an in depth analysis of several studies and provide critical and incisive thoughts on violent video games. As well as to illuminate positive effects of violent video games. While providing possible ways to combat negative

Capital Punishment Around the World

660 words - 3 pages The essay pans the whole world and presents the death penalty practices. In the last paragraph the paper focuses on the USA exclusively.Over half the countries in the world have now abolished the death penalty in law or practice:* 75 countries and territories have abolished the death penalty for all crimes* 14 countries have abolished the death penalty for all but exceptional crimes such as wartime crimes* 20 countries can be considered

Corporal punishment

2922 words - 12 pages that.Thirdly, corporal punishment may hurt children psychologically. Some children are naughty, but they are not really bad children. They are eager to learn well, too. If parents or teachers are so rude and violent to them, they will be hurt deep inside and may become hostile to people and things around them. It is bad for the child's overall development.Some people claimed that some students are just too naughty to be taught. It is necessary to treat

Children Discipline and Physical Punishment

1046 words - 4 pages compliance by the child and physical abuse of the child by the parent. Gershoff believes that these two strongest associations model the complexity of the debate around corporal punishment (Gershoff, 2002).The Center for Effective Discipline (CED) is a non-profit organization which provides educational information to the public on the effects of corporal punishment of children and alternatives to its use. In their website (stophitting.com) they present

Corporal Punishment

1875 words - 8 pages educator abuse (punishment by teachers and other educators), daycare or childcare abuse (abuse happening by child or daycare center workers), and then there is the most prevalent form of corporal punishment which is the punishment administered by parents. Throughout this paper we will discuss two out of the three or these different forms of corporal punishment and the controversy surrounding them.In Christian theology, the use of corporal

Corporal Punishment

1875 words - 8 pages educator abuse (punishment by teachers and other educators), daycare or childcare abuse (abuse happening by child or daycare center workers), and then there is the most prevalent form of corporal punishment which is the punishment administered by parents. Throughout this paper we will discuss two out of the three or these different forms of corporal punishment and the controversy surrounding them.In Christian theology, the use of corporal

Similar Essays

Corporal Punishment : The Last Remaining Acceptable Violence

2808 words - 11 pages forms, there is educator abuse (punishment by teachers and other educators), daycare or childcare abuse (abuse happening by child or daycare center workers), and then there is the most prevalent form of corporal punishment which is the punishment administered by parents. Throughout this paper we will discuss two out of the three or these different forms of corporal punishment and the controversy surrounding them. In Christian theology, the

The Use Of Corporal Punishment In Schools

1708 words - 7 pages Abstract Recently, as the value of education is increasing, corporal punishment became hot issue on the world because there is no any appropriate answer about” Should corporal punishment be for discipline?” According to a history of corporal punishment of Wikipedia, the practice was recorded as early as c 10th Century BC in Míshlê Shlomoh. Even though corporal punishment is not correct way for discipline like people usually think, how the

The Controversy Over Capital Punishment Essay

1715 words - 7 pages The Controversy Over Capital Punishment *Missing Works Cited* There have been many controversies in the history of the United States. Ranging from abortion to gun control, but capital punishment had been one of the most widely contested issues in recent decades. The questions of fact concerning capital punishment fall into three general areas: does capital punishment save money. Does capital punishment strikes fear into offenders

The Children May Suffer: The Negative Impacts Of Corporal Punishment

2061 words - 8 pages The Children May Suffer: The Negative Impacts of Corporal Punishment A young boy slowly makes his way to his mom, her scream urging him forward. He is almost to her side when he sees the shadow of her belt, he slowly backs away, he does not go far, as she quickly grabs him by his shirt. She then start to beat his hands with the belt, and then turns him around and starts spanking him on the behind. Throughout the whole time, the young boy’s