The Core Function Of Police In Reference To Wilson And Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

2848 words - 11 pages

The Core Function of Police in Reference to Wilson and Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

In considering whether the core function of the Police should be to
maintain order, there are a number of issues, both historic and
current, which need to be taken into consideration. For example, the
maintenance of what constitutes “order” can be interpreted differently
by different communities i.e. urban and rural. The expectations of
police performance and in how they deploy their resources to meet
conflicting demands need to satisfy both nationally set targets and
meet locally driven priorities. These demands also impacts on the
police as they are expected to adopt a more managerialistic approach
to policing and subsequently what this means to ensure meaningful
accountability to the local communities it serves. There are different
styles of policing which can contribute to maintaining order, zero
tolerance style policing which can have an adverse effect on good
community relations or neighbourhood policing which Wilson and Kelling
assess in their thesis “broken windows”. Furthermore, there has
always been difficulties in achieving a balance between the different
functions of policing , i.e crime fighting, detection of crime and
ultimately how this reduces crime.

If you explore these issues historically, when Sir Robert Peel the
Home Secretary first established the Metropolitan Police in London
1829, he stated that the maintenance of order and prevention of crime
was considered to be a core function of routine police work. This was
explained in the new police instructions published in the Times
newspaper in September 1829, (in Muncie and McLaughlin 2002 Ch 1 p.28)
which stated, “it should be understood from the outset that the object
to be obtained is the prevention of crime”. [and] ..“the preservation
of public tranquillity” This type of policing was considered
essential to protect law-abiding citizens from the disorderly
underclass such the poor, beggars, drunks and the homeless
predominantly in urban areas. It was also felt that it would also
provide the opportunity to detect crime if certain areas were
targeted. As the police service was rolled out across other
metropolitan areas, similar styles of policing were introduced
although not with out some contention. The prioritisation of crime
prevention and maintenance of order, was contested, particularly after
a moral panic in 1862 when MP Hugh Pilkington was robbed (Muncie and
McLaughlin 2002, the problem of crime p.145) this raised many concerns
about the police in that their main style of policing was not deemed
to be effective. Hence by the late nineteenth century the detection of
crime was considered more important that crime prevention.

What this demonstrated was that there was disagreement about the
police’s primary...

Find Another Essay On The Core Function of Police in Reference to Wilson and Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

The broken windows theory and community policing and how they relate to each other

3038 words - 12 pages Community Policing and the Broken Windows TheoryThe idea of community based policing and the broken windows theory gohand in hand in this new era of policing. Robert C. Trojanowicz, an early visionary who helped define the community policing movement, described community policing as "... a philosophy of full-service, personalized policing where the same officer patrols and works in the same area on a permanent basis, from a decentralized place,...

The Broken Windows Theory Set The Standards of Law Enforcement

1480 words - 6 pages Introduction: Many experts look at experts’ looks at data and research. Great experts find out and test their research. Traditional old concepts of police work caused many to venture and test anything. George Kelling and James Q. Wilson analyzed and tested their hypothesis. I will break down their “Broken Windows Theory” and how this has changed law enforcement today. Topic I. The Broken Windows set the standards for law enforcement. A....

This essay shows the resistance and accomadation of Native Americans on Europeans. Shows the devastating affects of each style of conquest. Reference to James Wilson- "The earth shall Weep"

2060 words - 8 pages Cultural AttackThe Native Americans were living a peaceful and fulfilling life living off the land until the Europeans arrived. Most of the conquest was through war but they were also able to conquer culturally. Many tribes resisted and responded to the Europeans in different ways. Accommodation was always first, but when accommodation fails, resistance is always the last resource. Each impact had its devastating affects. The Europeans migrated...

Truman's Character, in Reference to the Paradoxes of the Presidency

2500 words - 10 pages Truman’s Place in the Political Cycle and in Political TimeThe actual time Harry Truman decided to run for “re-election” is still unknown. However, his motivations have been clearly documented despite his reluctance. Despite many historians’ opinions, Truman was not initially relieved that Eisenhower would not be running for the presidential ticket. On a few occasions, in 1946, Truman pleaded with Eisenhower to run even if it...

Migration of Windows NT to Windows 2000

598 words - 2 pages Operating SystemsIn today's technological world, the realm of the computer operating system has come along way. Just ten years ago, a business had to use a UNIX, Macintosh or Microsoft 3.X with MS-Dos operating system and the support of other software programs to make the computer work resourcefully. Today, businesses have several different choices when putting together their computer operating system.At my work, they utilize nothing but...

Rotten to the Core: Good vs. Evil in relation to Golding's "Lord of the Flies"

692 words - 3 pages Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, creator of the fictional detective known as Sherlock Holmes, once said, "What can we know? What are we all? Poor silly half-brained things peering out at the infinite, with the aspirations of angels and the instincts of beasts." Although human beings eventually possess both qualities of good and evil, instinct is something that people are born with. As children grow, they learn the difference between right and wrong. Most...

The Life and Presidency of Woodrow Wilson

1430 words - 6 pages Thomas Woodrow Wilson was born December 28th, 2014. Wilson was born in Staunton, Virginia to Joseph Ruggles Wilson, and Jessie Janet Woodrow Wilson. Wilson was born into a deeply religious family, his father was a Presbyterian minister. Wilson’s family didn’t stay in one place, because of Pastor Wilson’s duties, their family moved often. When Wilson was only 2 their family moved to Augusta, Georgia. Later on they moved to Columbia, South...

Why Laws are broken and deterents to the breaking of them

840 words - 3 pages This topic asks us why so many laws are broken everyday and what can be done to prevent people in society from breaking the law.The temptation to break a law is sometimes too strong. It is overwhelming and some find it difficult to resist. To prevent people from feeling this way, they should be shown how their acts affect the areas and people around them.Some people break the law for sheer pleasure and enjoyment, like graffiti and stealing. But...

The Function of Ethics and Morality in American Democracy

574 words - 2 pages There are a few questions surrounding the topic of ethics and morality. What are ethics and morality? Are they really necessary in order to have a decent functioning society? Would we be able to live with one another without them? Most people realize ethics and morality have something to do with the concepts of good and bad. Individuals need to have ethics and morality to a certain degree so we can maintain some sense of order.So, what are ethics...

English Feature article on Shakespears Macbeth with reference to both play and Polanski's adaptation. Title: Windows changed through time

1192 words - 5 pages Windows changed through time.A way to see the world through different eyes...In late 1606 or early 1607, The last of Shakespeare's four great tragedies waswritten. Macbeth has been said by manyto be Shakespeare's darkest work, AReflection through Shakespeare's mindgiving us a window into Elizabethan waysof politics, Human violence and Humannature.Quiet relevantly Shakespeare would never have guessed that over 400 years later the basic morals and...

The role and function of religion in society

1914 words - 8 pages Many feminists would say that religion (like the family and the welfare state...) is another site of patriarchy. It is a place where women are oppressed by men, and it serves to reproduce this oppression and spread it throughout the wider society. The Catholic Church is a favourite target. It is against women's rights such as contraception, abortion, and divorce. It is headed and run exclusively by men. God is seen in male terms; Jesus is a man;...

Similar Essays

'the Core Function Of The Police Should Be To Maintain Order.' Discuss With Particular Reference To Wilson And Kelling's 'broken Windows' Thesis

2371 words - 9 pages It may be surprising for some of us to learn that the duties of the police do not just involve fighting crime, apprehending criminals, chasing thieves and other 'crime busting' duties, but include traffic control, dealing with community and social nuisance problems, attending sports/social events, crime prevention advice and many other less pressing tasks, in other words, 'order maintenance'. The police force as we know it today has changed...

Critiquing Chicago Police General Order (Rules) To The Eleven Standards Found In "Broken Windows And Police Discretion"

850 words - 3 pages The Chicago Police Department has many policy statements that police officers and their supervisors need to know. These policy statements are called General Orders (G. O.). These orders are numbered by the year they are established, and by how many were established in that year. So, for example, G. O. 86-08 means it was established in 1986 and that it was the 8th order established that year. G. O. 86-08 (a) initiates a "Protection of Life" policy...

Essay Name: Community Perception's Of Crime Articles: "Broken Windows" By James Q. Wilson And George L. Kelling And "From Institutional Jobless Ghettos

1031 words - 4 pages Community Perception's of CrimeA community perception of crime is more important than the actual presence off crime. More officers patrolling a neighborhood on foot than in car gives the presence of safety in that neighborhood. These officers spend time with the community and get to know them. These officers learn to distinguish strangers from "regulars", kicking out strangers as a result. Other cases where neighborhoods that leave a broken...

Analysis Of Broken Windows Policing In Milwaukee

1382 words - 6 pages December 3, 2003Do Not Buy Broken Windows Policing if it Does Not FitIn 1996 Milwaukee first adopted a "broken windows" policing policy--a zero tolerance approach toward minor public nuisance offenses. The policy was expected to reduce more violent crime rates, but there is no research and it is probably too early to speculate on any correlation between violent crime rates and the increased citations for public nuisance offenses. The zero...