The Core Function Of Police In Reference To Wilson And Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

2848 words - 11 pages

The Core Function of Police in Reference to Wilson and Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

In considering whether the core function of the Police should be to
maintain order, there are a number of issues, both historic and
current, which need to be taken into consideration. For example, the
maintenance of what constitutes “order” can be interpreted differently
by different communities i.e. urban and rural. The expectations of
police performance and in how they deploy their resources to meet
conflicting demands need to satisfy both nationally set targets and
meet locally driven priorities. These demands also impacts on the
police as they are expected to adopt a more managerialistic approach
to policing and subsequently what this means to ensure meaningful
accountability to the local communities it serves. There are different
styles of policing which can contribute to maintaining order, zero
tolerance style policing which can have an adverse effect on good
community relations or neighbourhood policing which Wilson and Kelling
assess in their thesis “broken windows”. Furthermore, there has
always been difficulties in achieving a balance between the different
functions of policing , i.e crime fighting, detection of crime and
ultimately how this reduces crime.

If you explore these issues historically, when Sir Robert Peel the
Home Secretary first established the Metropolitan Police in London
1829, he stated that the maintenance of order and prevention of crime
was considered to be a core function of routine police work. This was
explained in the new police instructions published in the Times
newspaper in September 1829, (in Muncie and McLaughlin 2002 Ch 1 p.28)
which stated, “it should be understood from the outset that the object
to be obtained is the prevention of crime”. [and] ..“the preservation
of public tranquillity” This type of policing was considered
essential to protect law-abiding citizens from the disorderly
underclass such the poor, beggars, drunks and the homeless
predominantly in urban areas. It was also felt that it would also
provide the opportunity to detect crime if certain areas were
targeted. As the police service was rolled out across other
metropolitan areas, similar styles of policing were introduced
although not with out some contention. The prioritisation of crime
prevention and maintenance of order, was contested, particularly after
a moral panic in 1862 when MP Hugh Pilkington was robbed (Muncie and
McLaughlin 2002, the problem of crime p.145) this raised many concerns
about the police in that their main style of policing was not deemed
to be effective. Hence by the late nineteenth century the detection of
crime was considered more important that crime prevention.

What this demonstrated was that there was disagreement about the
police’s primary...

Find Another Essay On The Core Function of Police in Reference to Wilson and Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

The broken windows theory and community policing and how they relate to each other

3038 words - 12 pages , working in a proactive partnership with citizens to identify and solve problems" (Trojanowicz and Bucqueroux, 1994, 1). This helps promote mutual trust and cooperation between the community and the police officers, at the same time it helps empower neighborhoods in danger of being overwhelmed by crime, drugs, and the general fear of crime. The broken windows theory, a hypothesis created by James Q. Wilson and George L. Kelling in 1982, determined

The Broken Windows Theory Set The Standards of Law Enforcement

1480 words - 6 pages Introduction: Many experts look at experts’ looks at data and research. Great experts find out and test their research. Traditional old concepts of police work caused many to venture and test anything. George Kelling and James Q. Wilson analyzed and tested their hypothesis. I will break down their “Broken Windows Theory” and how this has changed law enforcement today. Topic I. The Broken Windows set the standards for law enforcement. A

This essay shows the resistance and accomadation of Native Americans on Europeans. Shows the devastating affects of each style of conquest. Reference to James Wilson- "The earth shall Weep"

2060 words - 8 pages square mile strip along the Minnesota River. Tribes and families were broken apart because the Europeans became selfish in their conquest. It created war and the death of many tribes. Lastly, it also helped in the death of their religion. Tribes were not able to perform religious ceremonies on sacred land. The European Americans did not respect the land and didn't care it was sacred. Most of the time the Native Americans responded by just doing what

Analysis of the provision in your setting with reference to theory and guidance

1093 words - 5 pages This assignment will analyse the provision in a setting with reference to theory and guidance, using the National standards, the EYFS guidelines and OFSTED. I currently work in Tameside College Nursery as a Nursery Nurse. My job requires me to work with children between the ages of six months old and five years old as well as being responsible for a small group of children known as my key children. We have three rooms, Ladybird room, Caterpillar

Truman's Character, in Reference to the Paradoxes of the Presidency

2500 words - 10 pages enough to take on the Republicans. This election was much more to him than merely hoping his team won, rather he wanted FDR’s ideals to remain intact in the American executive. His place in the political time cycle clearly illustrates the president of articulation which will be covered soon.After being relatively silent during mid-term elections of 1946, Truman sat back and watched his party get humiliated. Truman relished in the idea of

Wilson and the Treaty of Versailles

664 words - 3 pages the treaty. In the beginning Wilson opposed demanding compensation from the Central Powers, then the Allied leaders convinced Wilson to put reparations on Germany. The reparations set upon Germany was $56 billion, however in the end they only paid $9 billion which was more than Germany could afford. John Maynard Keynes said that the treaty should not deprive Germany of all its belongings, Germany is still made up of human beings and they should

The Life and Presidency of Woodrow Wilson

1430 words - 6 pages Carolina. Wilson was born just shy of 5 years before the outbreak of the American Civil War. Their family was fortunate that no family member had to serve in the war, but they did open their house and church up for the Confederate soldiers. Although Wilson’s family was never in the war, he viewed the war through the men and woman who came into their home and ended up viewing the war as a dividing line, where the original constitutional structure of the

Migration of Windows NT to Windows 2000

598 words - 2 pages 2000 on a client PC and when it needs additional files, IntelliMirror will upload these in the background.§ MMC - The industry joke is that to manage an NT network you simply have to remember which button to press. Well, if that's the case then 2000 makes it even easier because you can have all the buttons in the same application if you want. Instead of having a separate application (like DHCP Manager, User Manager, etc) for each thing you want

Rotten to the Core: Good vs. Evil in relation to Golding's "Lord of the Flies"

692 words - 3 pages importantly, though, they learn that instinct is not rewarded. Instinct, in a child, is an impulse... it is kicking and screaming and misbehaving. It is not tolerated. Instinct is not good; it is evil. But, what causes a child to act on his or her evil tendencies? The answer lies in the book of Psalm, the intellect of Freud, and the under-developed brains of children.In the Holy Bible, the story begins in the Garden of Eden. Inside this garden

With reference to the concepts of Post modernity discuss "24" in terms of its contradiction in narrative, genre and representation

3347 words - 13 pages With reference to the concepts of Post modernity discuss 24 in terms of its contradiction in narrative, genre and representation.This essay will discuss the broad concepts of representation, narrative and genre in relation to the theory of Post modernity.The text I have chosen to illustrate the points raised in this essay is a series that is currently running it's third season on TV called 24, broadcast by Fox Television and created by Robert

The Function of Ethics and Morality in American Democracy

574 words - 2 pages function in society?The laws in our country are based on such rules or principles. The founding fathers of the United States, although most of them were deists, used the Bible as a guide to making most of the constitutional laws. If we did not have those sets of rules, then America would have a very chaotic society. Friedrich Nietzsche thought that it is not human nature to be moral, and that "religions seek to enforce a moral code of conduct by

Similar Essays

'the Core Function Of The Police Should Be To Maintain Order.' Discuss With Particular Reference To Wilson And Kelling's 'broken Windows' Thesis

2371 words - 9 pages radically from the first policemen that patrolled the streets in the 19th century and criminologists have recently played a large part in influencing police strategies. Recently, a return back to the early days of maintaining order has seemed to have emerged with the appearance of the 'broken windows' theory, an approach to policing that emphasizes creating and maintaining orderly public spaces. suggesting that continuing urban decay of a community

Critiquing Chicago Police General Order (Rules) To The Eleven Standards Found In "Broken Windows And Police Discretion"

850 words - 3 pages " policy relative to the use of deadly force by police officers, (b) sets forth Department policy regarding a police officer's use of deadly force, and (c) establishes guidelines controlling the use of deadly force by police officers.When critiquing this general order to the eleven standards found in "Broken Windows and Police Discretion" you find that this policy does not meet all eleven standards. The first standard, which states that a policy should

Essay Name: Community Perception's Of Crime Articles: "Broken Windows" By James Q. Wilson And George L. Kelling And "From Institutional Jobless Ghettos

1031 words - 4 pages . As more acts of vandalism accrue the worse they become. These neighborhoods usually experience vandalism followed by more severe acts such as mugging.The community level, disorder and crime are usually inextricable linked, in a kind of developmental sequence. Social psychologist and police officers tend to agree that if a window in a building is broken and is left unprepared, all the rest of the windows will soon be broken (269,Kelling)According

Analysis Of Broken Windows Policing In Milwaukee

1382 words - 6 pages nuisances and embrace the policy.Milwaukee's "broken windows" policy, called "quality of life" policing was initiated in late 1996 by the then Police Chief Arthur Jones and Mayor John Norquist. It was a big change from the strategy of problem solving and community cooperation emphasized by Chief Philip Arreola, Jones' predecessor. Police were now expected to enforce a zero tolerance approach toward minor offenses. Milwaukee's expectation was that