This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Count Of Monte Cristo.. A Critique Between The Movie And The Novel.

1356 words - 5 pages

Claire Gilman

Claire Gilman

English 12 CP

March 2, 2010

A Monte Cristo Critique: Novel vs. Motion Picture

����������� "Fool that I am that I did not tear out my heart the day I resolved to revenge myself!" (Dumas 408).� These words spoken by Edmond Dantes in Alexander Dumas's The Count of Monte Cristo are full of emotion brought upon Edmond by many people in the story.� A motion picture was made in 2002 to honor the novel due to its incredible popularity.� The actors portray the story of Edmond Dantes very well, which keeps the audience interested.� Although the story itself is incredibly interesting, the plot had to be tailored slightly to keep the audience writhing in anticipation.� Ending that anticipation is a stunning conclusion to the story, although the motion picture's end is quite different from the novel.

����������� "He was a tall, lithe young man of about twenty years of age, with fine dark eyes and hair as black as ebony" (Dumas 1).� Though originally a description of Edmond Dantes, the quote also perfectly describes James Caviezel, the actor who took the role of Edmond.� Caviezel's remarkable resemblance to the image that readers envision Edmond would look like, makes him stand out.� Another actor that looks like the character he is playing is James Frain.� Frain is an excellent actor, who shows the resentment Villeforte has for his father extraordinarily well. Richard Harris is also an exceptional actor.� He is able to show the audience all that Abbe Faria has to offer Dantes, which is fairly difficult to do.� Harris's magnificent acting grips the audience and shows them what life is like in a dungeon.� While Richard Harris's appearance is exactly as one would imagine Abbe Faria, "[who] was short, with hair blanched with suffering rather than age", the appearance of the actor portraying Danglars could not be farther from the reader's imagination (Dumas 67).� Albie Woodington appears as Danglars in the motion picture.� Woodington displays Danglars greediness very well, but his yellowing teeth along with the rest of his ghastly appearance throws everything off, as the novel describes Danglars as a younger man who fits into the crowd rather than standing out.

����������� For a motion picture to succeed, it must capture the audience's attention right from the start.� Kevin Reynolds, the director for the motion picture version of The Count of Monte Cristo, did just that by changing the story to appeal to the masses.� He first changed the opening scene, taking the audience to the Isle of Elba before anything else.� This scene was changed from the original simply to grab the audience's attention.� Also, the opening scene is used to introduce the main characters and the story behind them.� Reynolds also made Edmond Dantes and Fernand Mondego friends.� Edmond and Fernand are everything but friends in the novel.� In the novel, Edmond realizes that Fernand is...

Find Another Essay On The Count of Monte Cristo.. A critique between the movie and the novel.

The Count of Monte Cristo book report

1352 words - 5 pages The Count of Monte Cristoby: Alexandre DumasTheme: RevengeJoshua BanMrs. Haynes01/10/14The novel "The Count of Monte Cristo" is a classic work of literature that was written by Alexandre Dumas in 1844, about a young man, wrongly thrown in jail by his jealous "friends," and breaks out and uses a hidden treasure map to take his revenge. This essay is going to discuss the relevant aspects in the story concerning the authors life and the events of

The Count of Monte Cristo: Revenge and Justice

1194 words - 5 pages say to exact precise justice and revenge. After entrapping him, he starved Danglars, and punished Danglars for his greatest sin, being his greed. The Count of Monte Cristo/ Edmond Dantes put Danglars in the same/ if not better conditions than he was in during the original sin. This is again, a compromise between the Bible’s teachings, and the laws of old. After such, he starves Danglars, as he himself was, but gave Danglars the opportunity to

A Summary and Analysis of the Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas

2240 words - 9 pages everybody but Mercedes, de Villefort, and a few others. Characterization: Provide a list of at least three characters, major or minor, and a description of their personalities and roles in the story, using identifying terms like protagonist, antagonist, supporting character, static/dynamic, simple/complex, and direct/indirect characterization, in 50 words or more each. (30 points) The Count of Monte Cristo is the protagonist in the novel. He is a

Eyes of Revenge: The Count of Monte Cristo

1763 words - 8 pages give him the right price like how the Count gave him sixteen thousand francs for his best horses. The overall conflict of The Count of Monte Cristo Edmond Dantes being sent to jail for false prosecution of men who conspired to get him out of the way to achieve their own selfish goals. Edmond decides to become the Count of Monte Cristo to exact his revenge on those men; leading to an external conflict between him and them. This causes a man vs

Shakespeare’s Influence on "The Count of Monte Cristo"

637 words - 3 pages Alexandre Dumas had many influences. One of Dumas’ most notable books, The Count of Monte Cristo , for instance had many influences. One of Dumas greatest influences in his writing is Shakespeare. Dumas had been a fan of Shakespearean writing, and it shows in his style and ideas. Being influential, Dumas used some of Shakespeare’s ideas in his own stories. The most obvious influential idea Dumas used, was the use of a sleeping potion. The

Eyes of Revenge: The Count of Monte Cristo

1249 words - 5 pages Alexandre Dumas is the author of the adventurous love story The Count of Monte Cristo, used both internal and external conflicts along with imagery. These literary elements enhanced the theme that revenge can drive a man to do the unthinkable. Dumas used these elements to tell the story of France’s history. His bestselling novels are not deep but have spectacular adventure, action, and larger-than-life-characters. Alexandre Dumas was a French

"Count of Monte Cristo" Movie Review

530 words - 2 pages that no matter how much you get back at those who stabbed you it will never fully replace what they did. The only way to fill the void is to forget, forgive and move on with those who truly mean something to you.The movie truly reflects on of life's biggest lesson. Family and friends are all you need to be happy. It shows the true battle Edmonds faces and how he grows as a character. The movie illustrates the purpose of book without sacrificing detail that Hollywood loves to do. With excellent acting and riveting plot, "The Count of Monte Cristo" has captured a spot on my Top 5 list in both movie and book form.

The Count of Monte Cristo Summer Reading Essays

2000 words - 8 pages life and has learned that he himself is the only who can be trusted and no one else. But, the Count of Monte Cristo had not always been this way. He had once been a man free of all sin and didn't even see the turn of events that was about to be bestowed on him. The three main events that caused him to develop an alternate personality was the encounter with Faria in the prison, the acts of manipulation and revenge, and him being able to love and

Narcissism in "The Count of Monte Cristo" by Alexandre Dumas

1497 words - 6 pages In Alexandre Dumas' novel, "The Count of Monte Cristo", Edmond Dantes exhibits many different personality traits throughout the course of the story. He starts the novel as Edmond Dantes, a young man known for his loyalty and innocence. After spending 14 years in the Chateau d'If he emerges a new man. The identity he uses for the majority of the rest of his life is The Count of Monte Cristo. Edmond Dantes is extremely narcissistic, believing

The Count of Monte Cristo Modern Translation - Chandler / Dretzka - Assignment

1597 words - 7 pages BR 3 Script Title: The Count of Monte Cristo, by Alexandre Dumas; translated by Lowell Blair. Page 1. In the distance, Monsieur Morrel saw his ship, the Pharoan, coming to port. He was nervous, because his ship was going quite slow when it was usually very fast. Page 2. Monsieur Morrel decided to row out to it and have a word with the captain. When he got there, he found out the captain had died, and as first mate, Edmond Dantés had taken

"The Count of Monte Cristo" by Alexandre Dumas

1095 words - 4 pages . However, before Dantes is able to kill himself, he meets an interesting scholar who rescues Dantes, teaches him many lessons, and unknowingly prepares The Count of Monte Cristo to avenge his false imprisonment. In Alexander Dumas' The Count of Monte Cristo, Edmund Dantes rightly assumes the role as the god of vengeance as he punishes those who wronged him by taking away his livelihood, his love, and his freedom.Edmund Dantes was a young man of the

Similar Essays

The Count Of Monte Cristo Essay

1451 words - 6 pages We are always told to never judge a book by its cover because we never know what is truthfully inside those pages and what excitement is held within. Whether the rising action be slow or quick, the climax must always be the same; exciting, heartwrenching, or suspenseful. There were many climaxes in Alexandre Dumas’s book The Count of Monte Cristo that could cause the reader to feel intimately with the characters and feed our hunger of

Summary Of The Movie : The Count Of Monte Cristo

544 words - 2 pages The Count of Monte Cristo SummaryIn France during the eighteenth century, Edmond Dantes along with his close friend Fernand Mondego stop in a strange land in search of rescue help for their captain, who has just attained brain fever. They meet Napoleon and ask for medical attention for their captain. Napoleon allows them to stay in his quarters. On the first night of their stay, Napoleon asks Edmond a favor. He requests he deliver a "harmless

The Count Of Monte Cristo: Classically Entertaining

1714 words - 7 pages child. Everyone in between will likely be moved by some aspect of the film. While the plot is exciting enough on its own, the awe-inspiring scenery, flavorful language, and superb acting are what turn this classic story into a truly enthralling and passionate film. The most recent adaptation of Alexander Dumas’s classic novel, The Count of Monte Cristo, was directed by Kevin Reynolds and released in 2002. The story takes place in the 1820’s when

Vengeance In The Count Of Monte Cristo

698 words - 3 pages longer say 'God is for and with me.'" Set in France during the turmoil of the Napoleonic Era, The Count of Monte Cristo is an intricate tale of obsession and revenge. Alexander Dumas uses brilliant language and spell binding characters in order to weave the plot together to form a masterpiece. Falsely accused of treason, Edmond Dantes, a young sailor with a promising future,is arrested on his wedding day and imprisoned on the island fortress of