This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Cowboy: In Terms Of Masculinity

2320 words - 10 pages

In my paper, I want to examine the difference between a stereotypical western cowboy and the two main characters Jack Twist and Ennis del Mar of the short story “Brokeback Mountain” by Annie Proulx and its movie adaption by Ang Lee. This paper will analyze how the author, Annie Proulx, defies masculine cowboy norms when writing such an extravagant love story about two cowboys falling in love through an unexpected consultation. Ultimately, this paper will analyze the key differences, both physical, and emotional between the stereotypical western cowboy and the cowboys presented by Annie Proulx, Jack and Ennis. I will use the short story/film “Brokeback Mountain”, and the movie No Country for ...view middle of the document...

The image of a cowboy is pushed by societal norms to be depicted as a masculine icon that is looked highly upon for their immense physical and social traits.
Stoeltje Beverly, the author of Parades and the Hero: The North American Cowboy describes the masculine features of a cowboy as a miraculously changing figure throughout history. She says “the cowboy had been transformed into a romantic, heroic figure, performing on the national stage,” being that this new cowboy was a prominent rodeo figure that everyone went to see for entertainment purposes. Beverly also suggest that there can be various types of cowboys, such as rodeo workers, cattlemen and herders: “During this time, an individual might work as a cowboy for a cattleman who owned a large herd and be paid in kind (with a few cattle), and then develop his own herd, using the land free of charge” (Beverly). Houghton Mifflin argues that the stereotypical cowboy is described as a figure who exemplifies masculine traits:
The men who worked the cattle in the treeless expanses of the West, at least one-fourth of them blacks, became known as cowboys. The image of the courageous, spirited horseman living a dangerous life carried with it an appeal that refuses to disappear. Driving a thousand to two thousand cattle hundreds of miles to market; facing lightning and cloudbursts and drought, stampedes, rattlesnakes, and outlaws; sleeping under the stars and catching chow at the chuckwagon—the cowboys dominated the American galaxy of folk heroes (Houghton Mifflin).
Thus, the cowboy figure can be said to have masculine traits including courage, spirit, romanticism and labor work.
Furthermore, In Masculine Style: The American West And Literary Modernism, Daniel Worden describes a masculine figure as more than being a man. He exaggerates that one does not “possess” masculinity, in the sense of having a penis, a gun, or a rugged leather jacket. Instead being masculine is a lifestyle. He says in his book
One acts masculine, and this acting involves negotiation of a complex set of signs. The often-voiced commands to walk, talk, act, and take it “like a man” make clear that masculinity does not reside in a male body but instead in a series of performative gestures and public presentations. Being “like a man” has little to do with possession and everything to do with performance (Worden 1).
In his book, he also depicts the cowboy as the heroic masculine figure because of their countless performances and the courageous lifestyle they live. The concept of masculinity is also explained in Becoming the New Man in Post-Postmodernist Fiction Becoming the New Man in Post-Postmodernist Fiction when A.S Delfino. Delfino describes the cowboy as a man who paradoxically is tough and competitive at work, though caring and nurturing to his family; a man who is considered a ladies man in society, but late settles down and is faithful to only one woman; a man who is strong and emotionally closed, only opening up to...

Find Another Essay On The Cowboy: In terms of masculinity

Masculinity in the Workplace Essay

1404 words - 6 pages Masculinity in the Workplace The concept of masculinity first emerged during the early stages of the modern industrial revolution. With the rapid progress of technology, the conditions of living became better and the traditional definition of masculinity changed. Today, in the modern workplace of America, masculinity is a factor that has to be taken into account by managers and also by employees. It plays a crucial and distinctive role in

Masculinity in the Media Essay

2048 words - 8 pages Masculinity in the Media Masculinity has changed and evolved since the beginning of human creation. Males have had to adhere to the social norms of their time to survive without undue persecution. In the beginning of the 19th century, there was a shift in the way men could attain manhood. It was no longer easy for a man to enter into manhood with straightforward expectations and rituals. The state of manhood became difficult to

The representation of masculinity in Macbeth - Literature - Report

1052 words - 5 pages answer is simple: many of the themes in Macbeth are still prevalent today. One of the most important of these is what has been dubbed by the academic world as 'toxic masculinity'.   What is toxic masculinity? It is the emphasis that society places on the stereotypical aspects of a traditional man. In simpler terms, it is the attitudes that men are expected to have. The word toxic places it in a negative light, because in our modern society, these

Portrayal of Masculinity in Art

616 words - 2 pages Portrayal of Masculinity in Art According to several versions of the Webster dictionaries, the word “masculinity” refers to the characteristics of being masculine, manly, male stereotypes, having or occurring in a stressed final syllable <masculine rhyme>, having the final chord occurring on a strong beat <masculine cadence>, of or forming the formal, active, or generative principle of the cosmos. The word “masculinity” overall

Masculinity in The Wife of Bath's Prologue and Tale

2391 words - 10 pages Masculinity in The Wife of Bath's Prologue and Tale      The Wife of Bath, with the energy of her vernacular and the voraciousness of her sexual appetite, is one of the most vividly developed characters of 'The Canterbury Tales'. At 856 lines her prologue, or 'preambulacioun' as the Summoner calls it, is the longest of any of the pilgrims, and matches the General Prologue but for a few lines. Evidently Chaucer is infatuated with

Roles of Masculinity in The Ultraorthodox Jewish Community

1421 words - 6 pages same outcome, the views on what masculinity is and the way they get there is very different. The ultraorthodox are a group of about 600,000 people who make up one of the most religiously observant sectors of Judaism in contemporary Israel (Bilu, 2000). This group views education as one of the most important factors of their culture and view orthodox society, as Bilu (2000) puts it, a “society of learners” (Pg. 34). This culture values men who

Motherhood in terms of the “Black Culture”

2265 words - 10 pages what they know. The first image that appears is the “Mammy role” (Collins 42-57). Which will be later examined in its own terms. These views that the Eurocentric have will continue to play the effect role in Black woman’s lives. Now in terms of motherhood in the African perspectives these views are ones that our important and should be uplifting to our culture. The late and great Professor Barbara Christian points out the key facts of how

The great depression in terms of macroeconomics

3577 words - 14 pages The Great Depression: When Great Despair Brings Great KnowledgeThe United States was built on an idea that sober means creates sober measures. But what happens when those moderate times turn into trying times with drastic complications? The Great Depression was the worst economic slump in United States history, but by no means the only depression that our nation as endured. This depression is arguably one of the most misunderstood events in

Masculinity in the Trinidadian Diaspora

871 words - 4 pages from the reality of what he was caught up in. He longs for the simplicity of Trinidad where one can just lime and possibly not be who he was in New York. The men in the stories are not conforming to the Caribbean conceptions of gender and sexuality in the Trinidadian diaspora. They are participating in life on their terms free of any restrictive societal expectations not defined by their cultural ideas of masculinity, rather find themselves forging a new space for themselves.

The Good in Terms of Aristotle

2266 words - 9 pages kitchen I heard her scream in a loud shrill voice "Oh my god, oh my god!" The scream was so loud I literally froze in place. All of my muscles tightened up so tight that it took all my breath away. She screamed for me to come into the kitchen, and when I peaked my little head around the corner I had no idea of what I was about to see. There was a mouse running around in circles, not having an escape because my mom was blocking the entrance to the

The Masculinity in Fatherless Men

2394 words - 10 pages masculinity. Fight Club and Regeneration are a warning of what happens in a society when there is no father archetype upon men can look up to. In an interview with the author, Palahniuk, stated that he meant the story to be a cautionary tale of what can occur when an entire segment of a culture is disenfranchised. He explains why he was moved to write the book: “I wanted to acknowledge what my friends were complaining about, being failed by their fathers

Similar Essays

In Search Of The American Cowboy

2199 words - 9 pages Perhaps one of the most romanticized images in America at the turn of the century is that of the Wild West. One of the most celebrated images of the Wild West was that of the cowboy, America's defender of the frontier. The American cowboy became a figure of construction by businessmen and literature, and in recent years, a figure of reconstruction by modern historians. The businessmen and literature presented a highly glamorized view of the

Cowboy Bebop : Living In The Dream

828 words - 3 pages when they fight. Sometimes I thought I should cry for the ending of the movie, but I was just too tired to cry and I was even too tired to fall asleep. I could not stop myself thinking about the movie for the following few days."Cowboy Bebop" tells a story that happens in space; Spike Spiegel and his partners, Jet, Faye, Ed and a dog Ein, live together in a ship called "Bebop". They work to help soldiers catch criminals and so they gain the bounty

The Representation Of Masculinity In Print Advertising

2038 words - 8 pages -looked at male' in recent advertisements to the commonly eroticised female of years before. That said, he also points to the fact that in current advertising the avoidance of intimacy by the male subject, which is 'a frequently noted accoutrement of traditional masculinity, remains intact' (ibid. p97). 'Regardless of gender, advertising sells us the message that our happiness in personal terms is in some way dependent on the acquisition of the item

Concepts Of Masculinity In Faulkner’s The Unvanquished

507 words - 2 pages Concepts of Masculinity in Faulkner’s The Unvanquished In The Unvanquished, the reader assumes that the narrator is Bayard Sartoris, a boy born to John Sartoris and his now deceased wife. Bayard's gender is not immediately apparent, though remote understanding of southern customs and common boyhood activities encourages one to guess that he is male. First, Ringo is more easily identified as a black boy, and by the age of twelve, black boys