This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Creation Of The United States Constitution: Was It Based On Compromises, Or Consensus?

1191 words - 5 pages

Although the US Constitution was created moderately with consensus, it was largely established on compromises. There was much rebelling and it was realized that a new, stronger constitution was necessary. It was indispensable to bring several hot issues to compromise, including elections, slave importation, and the bill of rights. The authors of the Constitution were building for the future as well as the present. They were keenly aware of the need for a structure of government that would work not only in their lifetime but for generations to come. Hence, they included in the Constitution a provision for amending the document when social, economic, or political conditions demanded it.Election by the people was a highly debated topic. Roger Sherman, a member of Continental Congress, stated that the people immediately should have as little to do as may be about the government, saying "they [lack] information and are constantly liable to be misled." Many agreed with Sherman, and felt that it was easy for the citizenry to get information wrong and be easily misled. However, others agreed with the opinions of men like George Mason of Virginia, who argued strongly for an election of the larger branch by the people. Mason was an important and intelligent man, but refused to sign the Constitution, which represented the ideas of some men. He felt that "by requiring only a majority [of Congress] to make all commercial and navigation laws, the five Southern states, whose produce and circumstances are totally different from that of the eight Northern and Eastern States, may be ruined. ...will enable the merchants of the Northern and Eastern states not only to demand an exorbitant freight, but to monopolize the purchase of the commodities at their own price, for many years, to the great injury of the landed interest and impoverishment of the people. And the danger is the greater as the gain on one side will be in proportion to the loss on the other." Mason believed that the Constitution will only benefit the Northern states and not the South. He does not agree with the judicial system and believes that a person should not stay in office for to long or else it will "produce a monarchy or a corrupt, tyrannical aristocracy. It will most probably vibrate some years between the two and then terminate in the one or the other." Even though the propositions for election standards varied in individual opinion, these men generally came agree on what is know as the Connecticut Compromise.The compromise proposed two houses: a lower house which was elected in proportion to population, and an upper house, where the people of each state, regardless of size, collectively would have equal representation. This resulted in the current US House of Representatives and the US Senate, respectively. At the time of the Convention, every state but Pennsylvania had a bicameral legislature. Thus, there was already a strong consensus for a two-house national legislature, with the only...

Find Another Essay On The creation of the United States Constitution: was it based on compromises, or consensus?

Describe the creation of the United States

557 words - 2 pages The creation of the United States all began when the colonies settled in Jamestown. From there, they worked hard and long to obtain their independence, and to come together to be united as one.There were many reasons why England wanted to establish colonies. Gold and silver were prominent, so economic opportunities lured them the most. English sailors hoped to finally find a water passage through North America to china + the Indies. They also

The Ratification of the United States Constitution

1044 words - 4 pages computing representation in congress that was never adopted. The Founding Fathers of the United States wanted a system foundation upon the rule of law that was applied equally to every person. They wanted to prevent anyone from taking property, denying liberty or taking life without amends. They wrote the Constitution to fairly strengthen the federal government. The main purpose of the Constitution of the United States of America is to give a sense of

The Constitution of the United States

1094 words - 5 pages Confederation expressly delegated to the United States in Congress assembled.” It is not possible for the national government to be in power if each state had their own independence, it was creating the thirteen countries of America, and was not united. Therefore the first part of the Preamble and the entire American Constitution addresses this problem and sets guidelines for a national government in order, “to form a more perfect Union.” In

The Constitution of the United States

1423 words - 6 pages The Constitution of the United States The United States Constitution is the law of the United States. It is the foundation of this country and the most important document in its history. It provides the guidelines for the government and citizens of the United States. The Constitution will unquestionably continue to carry us into the 22nd century, just as it has for over two hundred years. The principles of the Constitution remain strong

Role of the United States Constitution

740 words - 3 pages sex. Even though based on our reading this week, states may have their own constitution as long as it does not overrule what the federal law has specified currently.Companies today may have substantial consideration and freedom of choice to determine who not only can qualify for health benefits. Federal and state law as it relates to taxing of those said health benefits must follow federal and state law. Employers can decide whether or not to

Role of the United States Constitution

784 words - 3 pages branch and finally the judicial branch. With enabled power distributed to these branches, the importance of the Constitution now stands in as a protective body or means for every citizen. "It protects individual rights by limiting the government's ability to restrict those rights" (Cheeseman, pg. 49, ¶5).One of the most important amendments in the Constitution would be amendment 14: Due process."The Fourteenth Amendment was added to the U.S

Framing The United States Constitution

1602 words - 6 pages Framing the United States Constitution In 1787, at the Constitutional Convention, a group of knowledgeable and brilliant men met in order to revise the problematic, inefficient, and weak Articles of Confederation. These experienced and well read men produced a four-page document, suggesting an entirely new form of government. This achievement was absolutely remarkable considering it had no precedent in history, and this document established a

Constitution of the United States: Our Living Constitution

933 words - 4 pages The United States Constitution has been governing our way of life for over 200years. Throughout its time it has been viewed in many ways to make our lives easier. Ithas been the legal structure of our political system, establishing governmental bodies,determining how their members are selected, and prescribing the rules by which theymake their decisions.The Philadelphia Convention, which was later called the ConstitutionalConvention, began on

Free Speech on the Internet v. United States Constitution

1681 words - 7 pages or may not protect children from indecent materials but it most definitely puts a restriction on the freedom of speech that is protect by the constitution.” (Policing Cyberspace) Shortly after the injunction was issued a court in Oregon awarded 107 million dollars in damages caused by the Nuremberg Files. (Policing Cyberspace) This anti-abortion web site listed names and address of abortion providers.(Policing Cyberspace) After the two different

The Development to The United States Constitution

1546 words - 6 pages for the citizens of the United States. Under the Articles of Confederation, each state had one representative in the Congress, regardless of state population. This system, while balanced, made it difficult for delegates to truly know and represent the opinions of their constituents. The large states proposed a plan where representation was based on population, but the more diminutive states objected. The Virginia Plan, however, called for a

Analizing the preamble of the United States Constitution

1359 words - 5 pages interpret it very differently. The American people would not just include men who own land and are faithful Christians; they would include all people. Any gender of persons can hold the constitution as a part of his/her life. In the United States of America you can be any color, white, brown, black, green, or blue to be considered one of "the People".The next main phrase in the preamble is "in Order to form a more perfect Union." Our forefathers

Similar Essays

The Constitution: Analyzing The Reasons Behind The Creation Of The United States Constitution As Well As How It Was Created

678 words - 3 pages change. The scrutiny of human society where citizens argued publicly and aggressively to the question of whether or not people could govern themselves was the turning point that led to a document of rules and rights. Through compromises, conventions, developments of government systems, and ratifications of just and unmerited laws, the Constitution of the United Stated was formed.Over the years, the United States, just like any other country, has

The Creation Of The United States Constitution

2758 words - 11 pages reality that is the exact opposite of what happened. They in fact drafted up a whole new constitution. The Articles of Confederation had a profound effect on the making of the United States Constitution. There were many opposing plans and conflicting views of the delegates to the Constitutional Convention. It was these plans and views which ultimately led to the creation of the Constitution of the United States of America.The Articles of

The History Of The United States Constitution

1735 words - 7 pages Constitution based on the agreements. (Harr, 2012) The Constitution was to include six main articles, the first three describing each branch of the government. Article I of the Constitution describes the Legislative Branch. It gives the Congress the power to pass laws, but not interpret them. (Harr, 2012) Article II of the Constitution describes the Executive Branch of the government. The Executive Branch is the one of the President and his Cabinet

The Constitution Of The United States

771 words - 3 pages The Constitution of the United States was written in 1787 at the Constitutional Convention, where it was held in Philadelphia. It was written by a group of people known as “Farmers,” or the “Founding Fathers,” and few of the most famous Founding Fathers were George Washington (The first president of the USA), Thomas Jefferson (The first vice president and the third president of the USA) James Madison (The fourth president of the USA), Samuel