The Crimean War, Why Do Some Historians Refer To It As " The First Modern War"

994 words - 4 pages

The Crimean War of 1853-56 was one of the long series of Russo-Turkish wars, but it differed from the others in that Britain and France were involved. In fact, the military conflict was between Russia and a coalition of Great Britain, France, the Kingdom of Sardinia, and the Ottoman Empire (now Turkey). Some historians consider the Crimean War as "the first modern war", in that it utilised many new factors that weren¹t used in previous wars.The Congress of Vienna introduced new rules into the balance-of-power game. Great Britain, France, Russia, Prussia, and Austria were now dedicated to a European territorial settlement maintained by a new mechanism called the Concert of Europe. Any changes would have to be made by prior consultation among the five major powers. The Eastern Question revolved around the fear that one of the European powers would upset the balance of power by taking advantage of any internal changes made in the domains of the Ottoman Empire.By the early 1850s, however, Czar Nicholas I of Russia believed he saw another opportunity to further Russian influence by intervention in Turkish affairs. He felt confident of grateful support from Austria in return for the aid Russia had given the Habsburg dynasty during the revolutions of 1848 to 1850. He also believed, mistakenly, that the British government of George Hamilton-Gordon, 4th earl of Aberdeen, would collaborate in a partition of the Balkan territories controlled by the Turks.The immediate pretext for Russian intervention was a dispute between Roman Catholics and Orthodox Christians over control of the holy places in Palestine, which was part of the Ottoman Empire. In December 1852 the Ottoman sultan, responding to French pressure, decided in favor of the Roman Catholics. Nicholas, the protector of Orthodoxy, quickly dispatched a mission to Constantinople (now Istanbul, Turkey), aiming at a new settlement in favor of the Orthodox and a treaty guaranteeing the rights of the Orthodox population of the Ottoman Empire. At the same time, in discussions with the British ambassador to Russia, Nicholas raised the possibility of a partition of the Balkans and a 'temporary' Russian occupation of Constantinople and the straits.The British ambassador to Constantinople, Viscount Stratford de Redcliffe, helped arrange an amicable settlement of the holy places question, but persuaded the Turks to reject the other Russian demands as a threat to their sovereignty. Russia responded on July 1, 1853, by occupying the Turkish principalities of Moldavia and Walachia. The European powers attempted to arrange a compromise, but this proved futile. On October 4, confident of British and French support, Turkey declared war.The Crimean War began at Sevastopol, on the tip of the Crimean peninsula in 1853. Neither side distinguished itself during the war. Far more soldiers died of disease than of battlefield wounds. Utilization of the newly developed telegraph system exerted an influence on government...

Find Another Essay On The Crimean War, why do some historians refer to it as " the first modern war"

Causes of the Boudiccan Revolt (references to modern and ancient historians as well as archaeological evidence).

963 words - 4 pages they're more importantly the catalyst. Queen Boudicca's outrage would of been the final injustice to the Iceni tribe. Tacitus describes that the Celtic Icenians were willing to take some oppression but "not yet to slavery". Dio Cassius agrees that this was a factor; the mistreatment of Boudicca and her daughters was an insult to all Icenians.According to modern expert Allason-Jones it [the rapes] were also injustices by Roman Law. She states the

Although Germany gained a fully democratic state in 1919, explain why some historians believe it was doomed from the start.

1466 words - 6 pages Despite the Weimar Republic lasting fourteen years some historians viewed it as merely an interlude between imperial and Nazi Germany, and believe that it was doomed from the outset. It had been described as a 'republic without republicans', which to have been introduced immediately after the war was 'a gamble standing virtually no chance of success'. There are many factors that have drawn them to this conclusion, primarily the long-term

How Do Military Historians Explain War?

2604 words - 10 pages the conclusion of the Cold War brought about a new theory. Was this the end of history? Of course, the literal answer to this question is no, but Ferguson explained the reasoning as to why historians might pose this question following the end of the Cold War. The two superpowers, the United States and the Soviet Union, squared off in a not so cold war in which the overwhelming economic power of the United States’ free market lead to the downfall

The Causes of the Civil War. It is based on the book called The Coming of the Civil war by Michael Perman. It discusses the arguments in the book as to why the war took place.

2123 words - 8 pages only one issue, but by many. Exactly what the main cause was is what is being debated. No one is exactly sure what caused the American Civil War, but most historians agree that it had something to do with the absolute difference between the two areas.Michael F. Holt believes that the war was caused by human intervention. He claims that as the rivalry between the Whigs and the Democrats started to calm down and the Whig party started to split, the

"The First World War was the first modern war" discuss and evaluate this statement

1304 words - 5 pages as "a 20th century war fought with 19th century tactics". It was the first "world" war in the true sense of the word, involving the whole of Europe and even, towards its end, the United States of America."Modern" it became indeed when one considers the new, deadlier weapons that were developed just before and during this war: Tanks, airplanes, machine guns, chemical weapons are the most widely known by the general public.However, "old fashioned

Why were the French unable to defeat the Viet Minh in the first Indo China War?

1857 words - 7 pages The French lost the First Indochina for a variety of reasons, such as the inability to match the Vietnamese War machine, lack of vision regarding the end of colonialism and independence for Vietnam, and finally the disaster which was Dien Bien Phu and the reaction at home.The French had controlled the country from the 1850's up until 1940 when during WWII Japan moved into Indochina, taking control of the country, but leaving it under the rule of

Who do you blame for the First World War?

788 words - 3 pages Like Henry A. Kissinger once said about war, "No country can act wisely simultaneously in every part of the globe at every moment of time." In 1914 it was Germany who didn't act wisely. I make Germany responsible for the First World War, because they started the ally system by signing the Triple Alliance in 1882. They caused the Agadir crisis. Shortly explained, the crisis was a disagreement between Germany and France which ended with Britain

Why The Ottomans Entered The First World War

1530 words - 6 pages economy and other European powers were still equally, if not more, involved in the Empire. Thus the reasons why the Ottomans would have freely chosen to enter the war can begin to be examined as it is unlikely that they were forced to enter into an agreement with Germany. It has been argued that the Ottomans entered the First World War because they believed an alliance with one of the major powers would end their

Why Did A.J.P Taylor’s Analysis of the Origins of the Second World War Cause Such Controversy Among Historians?

1043 words - 5 pages Why did A.J.P Taylor’s analysis of the origins of the Second World War cause such controversy among historians? It was broadly considered that the Second World War began in 1939 because of Hitler’s plan for world domination; many historians validated this view at the time until A.J.P. Taylor published his book ‘Origins of the Second World War’ in 1961. A. J. P Taylor was the first historian to examine the war with a completely open mind

The First World War

7479 words - 30 pages , scientists, engineers, and mechanics would be as important as soldiers.These changes did much to make the First World War the first 'modern war'. But it did not begin as one. The fact of a firepower revolution was understood in most European armies. The consequences of it were not. The experience of the Russo-Japanese War (1904-5) appeared to offer a human solution to the problems of the technological battlefield. Victory would go to the side with

The First Opium War

2278 words - 10 pages The First Opium War or the Anglo-Chinese War fought in 1839 to 1842 between Britain and China was the product of a century long imbalance between the two country’s trades and had long lasting impacts on China. Britain was a nation addicted to tea, a delicacy that could only be grown in China and the silver they spent on it began to drain the treasury. The counterattack for Britain was opium. The ill effects of the drug soon became apparent, as

Similar Essays

The Crimean War Essay

715 words - 3 pages Ottomans, and therefore the British took a firm stand against the Russians. As part of their victory, the Turks forced the Russians back to their pre - war borders. The French supported the British in the war; as a result an Anglo - French - Turk alliance was formed.The allies focused on the Crimean Peninsula, in the hopes of capturing Sevastopol. This would be detrimental to the Russians, as it was home to the Russian Black Sea Fleet. The French

Notable Aspects Of The Crimean War

2116 words - 8 pages the port of Sevastopol. Ownership of this port would give them year round access to the open oceans. Some notable aspects of the Crimean war include it was the first industrial powered war, it helped to spawn great change in battlefield medicine, and it paved the way for the world’s first war correspondents. Industrial Revolution The Crimean war started in 1853 after the Turks declared war on Russian. Realizing the Russian force was much greater

When People Say "Emotion Just Gets In The Way", What Do You Think They Mean? Why Does Or Doesn't It Make Sense To Refer To Emotion As An Obstacle?

1317 words - 5 pages . Doctors, specifically surgeons, will not agree to perform operations on their family members because they are not prepared to undergo such a daunting task with a load burdened as a result of the family ties. Even if a surgeon is the most skilled in his hospital, and will be able to do the best job, he will not perform an operation on a family member.However, there is some good that comes out of this scenario. If the surgeon were to ignore his emotions

Why Germany Lost The First World War

698 words - 3 pages The First World War was one of the most horrifying the world has ever seen. Lasting between 1914 and 1918 the impact is such that many of the repercussions can still be seen as late on as today. The allied nations defeated Germany after 4 years of war and thousands of deaths, this essay will help to explain some of the reasons why this was the case.There were numerous reasons behind why Germany eventually lost the war. Probably the most