The Critique Of Piaget's Theories Essay

2279 words - 9 pages

The Critique of Piaget's Theories

Jean Piaget (1896 – 1980) was a constructivist theorist. He saw
children as constructing their own world, playing an active part in
their own development. Piaget’s insight opened up a new window into
the inner working of the mind and as a result he carried out some
remarkable studies on children that had a powerful influence on
theories of child thought. This essay is going to explain the main
features and principles of the Piagetian theory and then provide
criticism against this theory.

Cognitive development refers to way in which a person’s style of
thinking changes with age. Piaget argued that cognitive development is
based on the development of schemas. This refers to a psychological
structure representing all of a person’s knowledge of actions or
objects. To perform a new skill which the person has no schema, they
have to work from previous skills that they have. This is called
assimilation, where they have pulled previous schemas together then
adapted and changed them to fit their task through accommodation.
Piaget theorised that children’s thinking goes through changes at each
of four stages (sensory, motor, concrete operations and formal
operations) of development until they can think and reason as an
adult. The stages represent qualitatively different ways of thinking,
are universal, and children go through each stage in the same order.
According to Piaget each stage must be completed before they can move
into the next one and involving increasing levels of organisation and
increasingly logical underlying structures. Piaget stated that the
‘lower stages never disappear; they become integrated into the new
stage (hierarchic integration) (Inhelder and Piaget, 1958). Children
themselves, through their actions on the environment, interacting with
there biologically – determined level of maturation, bring about the
cognitive changes, which result in adult thinking.

The stages theory is open to criticism as they are too rigid and
neglects individual differences such as memory span, motivation etc.
Piaget also underestimated the age at which children could do things.
This maybe due to his failure to distinguish between competence and
performance. Piaget's studies tested performance and then he assumed
that a child who failed simply lacked the underlying cognitive
structures that he believed were needed to succeed on that task.
Subsequent research suggests that a child may have these competencies
earlier than Piaget suggested. However, simply to focus on age limits
is to miss the central point of Piaget’s theory that universal,
qualitative, biologically regulated cognitive changes occur during
development. This is supported by cross-cultural research that has
replicated Piaget’s findings (Smith et al, 1998).

Another criticism relates...

Find Another Essay On The Critique of Piaget's Theories

Critique Of The Miser Essay

742 words - 3 pages Critique - The Miser In the play, The Miser, I was very intrigued by the plot and found the story line to be intriguing. As the play began, I was a little confused with the very opening scene with the two couples dancing blindfolded. I did not understand what exactly was going on and thought that the part where XXXXXX was telling OOOOO that he loved her might have been a better opener. That part really sparked my interest and took me

Piaget's Theory of Cgnitive Development:Discuss the 5 stages of cognitive development

682 words - 3 pages Swiss biologist, Jean Piaget is renowned for constructing a highly influential model of child development and learning. His theory is based on the idea that the developing child builds cognitive structures for understanding and responding to physical experiences within his environment. Piaget's theory identifies four developmental stages: sensorimotor stage, preoperational stage, concrete operations, and formal operations.During the first stage

Theories of the Enlightenment

1210 words - 5 pages they held to be sacred and at the center of life and, by the sixteenth century, books were printed in mass quantities throughout Eurasia. Leading scientists and theologians, such as Galileo Galilei, began to argue that both Scripture and science can be right with the latter helping to better interpret the former. (AR 2) Born out of the revolutionary ideas of Galileo, and many others, were the hopeful theories of the Enlightenment. However, when

Theories of the End

796 words - 4 pages predicted the ending did not just make these dates up. Every prediction they made had a theoretical reasoning behind it. Does this make these people wrong because the event did not occur? Is one theory more accurate than the other? The apocalypse has various theories. Three known for predicting the date of the apocalypse are biblical theory, the Mayan theory, and the scientific theory. Christians believe that the Apocalypse will occur based

Theories of the Atonement

1626 words - 7 pages Erickson (1998) says there are a few theories on the atonement depending on how your read certain scripture, the theories are as follows: The Socinian Theory (1998:801); This theory speaks of Christ on the Cross as a perfect example of what kind of dedication followers of God must do, there is no connection to a sacrificial death whatsoever. The moral influence theory (1998:802); This theory believes the cross was an example of God’s love and

The Theories of Education

2763 words - 11 pages The Theories of Education This essay is going to look at the Functionalist, Marxist and Interactionist theories of education and outline the key points; it will also provide some criticism in relation to each of the theories. Although the theories are mainly very different, they all have the similarity of suggesting that a person’s social class will contribute greatly to how well they will do at school and also on how

The Theories of Truth

1224 words - 5 pages , since if there isn’t then they are not true. In the end, the most basic set of statements should correspond with something, which essentially makes the coherence theory the same as the correspondence one (in which case it would be subject to the same flaws). All of these theories seem to contradict themselves. They provide insufficient explanations of truth and, as such, are neither is stronger than the other. Perhaps the answer lies

Piaget's Belief that Children Construst Their Understanding of the World Differently than Adults

953 words - 4 pages Piaget's Belief that Children Construst Their Understanding of the World Differently than Adults Piaget believed that children actively construct their understanding of the world in radically different ways from adults. He further believed that children's minds develop through a series of stages in which they form increasingly complex schemas that organize their past experiences and provide a framework for understanding future experiences

Analytical Critique of The Godfather

923 words - 4 pages Analytical Critique of The Godfather      I believe the reason that, 'The Godfather', is such a great film is because it lets audiences decide whether they like the characters or not. Too many movies made about organized crime begin with some seemingly random act of violence. 'The Godfather', however, lets it be known from the start to judge the characters in the film based on what type of person they are instead of the criminal activities

Critique of Movie The Insider

1006 words - 4 pages Critique of Movie The Insider A dramatization of 1995 events in which the tobacco industry allegedly covered up proof that nicotine is addictive and harmful. When Brown and Williamson executive Jeffrey Wigand (Crowe) tries to expose the industry's cover-up, he is threatened into silence. He eventually gets his story to 60 Minutes producer Lowell Bergman (AL Pacino), but CBS decides against airing it due to political and economic pressures

Critique of The Play Foxfire

1045 words - 4 pages Critique of The Play Foxfire *Works Cited Not Included The play I saw was called Foxfire. This play was about an old woman named Annie Nations who lived in Raybun County, Georgia. Her husband Hector had died five years earlier leaving her alone in their home in the mountains. However, she did not feel alone because she still saw Hector and spoke to him. Their son Dillard had long been trying to persuade her to come live with him in Florida

Similar Essays

Perspectives Of Learning And Teaching In Piaget's And Vygotsky's Theories

1769 words - 7 pages The Venn diagram is comparing the similarities and differences of two theories Piaget’s and Vygotsky Theories on Cognitive development. Piaget’s difference to Vygotsky is children collaborating with peers of the classroom, having stages of development that impact child development over birth to adulthood and how inherited characteristics of being a confident or quiet child. Vygotsky Theory is about Zone of Proximal development, scaffolding of

The Influence Of Piaget's Four Stage Theory

1095 words - 4 pages The Influence of Piaget’s Four Stage Theory Jean Piaget was an influential psychologist who created the Four Stages of Cognitive Development. He believed when humans are in their infancy, childhood, and adolescence they try to understand the world through experiments. During cognitive development children are little scientists that create theories, experiment, and conclusions on how to adapt to the world. By the time children become

The Main Features Of Piaget's Theory Of Cognitive Development

3066 words - 12 pages The Main Features of Piaget's Theory of Cognitive Development Jean Piaget (1896-1980), a Swiss biologist turned Psychologist, has had perhaps the most influential development on the understanding and progression of Cognitive Development. Cognitive development being all of the processes relating to thinking and knowing, involving perceiving, interpreting, reasoning, remembering and using language. His theory starts

Discuss Piaget's Account Of Cognitive Development In The Preoperational Stage

1333 words - 5 pages theories suggested. One psychologist to contest Piaget's theory was Jerome Bruner. Bruner (1966) suggested that children's development passed through three stages, instead of four, and these stages were not age-dependent, unlike Piaget's. Several other psychologists also contested aspects of Piaget's theory. For example, psychologists McGarrigle and Donaldson (1974) found that 62% of preoperational children could conserve number when the task was