The Davis Trial Accused Of Murder By Abortion

2206 words - 9 pages

The Queen vs. Davis case concerns the murder trial of Arthur Paul Davis and Alice Davis that occurred in 1875. In it, they were tried and convicted of murder for conducting an abortion; the killing of a fetus and subsequently causing death of the victims, Catherine Laing and Jane Vaughn Gilmour. This essay will examine the historical context of the case, what the trial reveals about the nature of women’s lives in Toronto during the 1870s as subordinate women who are deemed as caretakers and how women managed to end unwanted pregnancies. During the late 19th century ending an unwanted pregnancy was an illegal offence because it was considered unethical to kill a fetus. Women were not able to access safer alternatives such as contraception, as it was an offence to sell or advertise them at that time. Women did not claim they wanted an abortion directly, but rather that they wanted to be fixed of their problem. They did not feel guilty as they thought it was acceptable to induce abortion before the 3rd month of pregnancy or quickening of it, which under the English common law, it was not wrongful to procure an abortion prior to the feeling any movement of the fetus. Doing an Abortion was a private matter but nonetheless a criminal offence. Beginning in the early 19th century, laws were passed to support the prohibition of abortions; these then continued on to the revision and creation of the 1892 criminal code for abortion.
In 1875, Dr. Arthur Paul Davis and Alice Davis of Toronto, feloniously and willfully murdered Catherine Laing and then subsequently a week following on Sunday morning murdered Jane Vaughn Gilmour. They were found guilty of the crime committed to victim Gilmour as the case with Laing did not precede them to a guilty verdict. There were approximately 25 witnesses presented during trial and K. Mackenzie was for the Crown as Mr. C. Cameron represented as counsel for prisoners. Catherine Laing was a married woman, who left her husband and two children to work for another family as a washerwoman and had two children. Laing and her husband, George, were separated; she did not have any sexual relations with him before or after she left him. After her death George Laing’s suspicions led him to believe that she did not die of Typhoid fever as the man who buried her stated. Dr. Davis had hired Jacob Amour to build a coffin the size big enough to fit a body, and told him that it was case of Typhoid and presented him with the death certificate. She was put in a coffin and taken out of Toronto to Hamilton. Dr. Davis received the certificate of death from Dr. Isaac Ryall by stating that it was the case of typhoid. No one knew at the time that Catherine was pregnant or that she was had a family of her own. Suspicions grew about the cause of death as the body did not seem like a case of typhoid when examined; instead seemed like an induced abortion by means of violence. It was clearly noted during the investigation and...

Find Another Essay On The Davis Trial-Accused of Murder by Abortion

Analysis of The Hanged Man's Bride, The Trial for Murder and Confession Found in a Prison

3638 words - 15 pages , handsome, accomplished and generally loved by others. This later turns to fear of justice catching him and possible regret, when he is finally caught. In The Trial For Murder the main ideas and issues are those of the influence of the supernatural upon people and those of psychic experiences and the fact that the narrator believes that more people have such experiences than admit to having them. The other main ideas

The Trial by Existence Essay

927 words - 4 pages A state of being is just existing but bravery is the true meaning of living a life. Robert Frost is notorious for speaking on the different stages of life. In the poem “The Trial by Existence”, Robert Frost speaks of bravery, life, and the after-life. A life lesson taught throughout the entirety of the poem is doing what you desire and overcoming the fears that are implanted in the cycle of life. Frost gives everyone hope in every poem he

The OJ Simpson Murder Trial and the Criminal Justice System

2106 words - 8 pages The OJ Simpson Murder Trial and the Criminal Justice System A crime being committed is the first event to initiate our criminal justice system. On June 12th 1994 a double murder was reported at the residence of Nicole Brown Simpson the ex-wife of the then beloved Orenthal James (OJ) Simpson. It was discovered that Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman had been brutally murdered and the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) began their

The Success of Davis Wiki

1724 words - 7 pages We believe the success of Davis Wiki is a result of the vision we had as well as the tremendous effort we put in to bring that vision to life. We also believe this type of success is replicable, but it is by no means easy or necessarily obvious. We see similarities in the mainstream adoption of blogging as a new medium. Although the concept has existed since 1994, and many users kept online journals, there were few examples of successful

The Trial of God

1119 words - 4 pages world and his life experience involve events such as violent actions against the Jewish community. The events of Elie Wiesel’s life heavily influenced the creation of his play the Trial of God. To many in the United States and Europe, World War II is an icon that represents unimaginable turmoil and tragedy. The hardships brought about by World War II raises the theodicy question of how a righteous God could allow the Nazi’s to reign. Elie Wiesel

The Trial of Socrates

1100 words - 4 pages The Trial of Socrates The trial of Socrates is an excellent source of events during the period in which Socrates lived and died. Athens was a democratic city with much pride in their freedom. Especially their freedom of speech. Socrates was a political philosopher who did not agree with these freedoms provided by the Athenic democracy. However, it is his trial in which both the democracy of Athens and Socrates himself show their

The Trial Of Socrates

1918 words - 8 pages citizens had the virtue needed to nurture a good society; instead he equated virtue with knowledge unattainable by ordinary people and criticized the right of every citizen to speak in the assembly.The status of Socrates among his fellow citizens suffered for what I.F. Stone called the "Three Earthquakes." These three political events happened just about ten years before the trial and shook the city's sense of security and made its citizens

The Trial of Socrates

983 words - 4 pages Socrates was accused of being a sophist because he was "engaging in inquiries into things beneath the earth and in the heavens, of making the weaker argument appear the stronger," and "teaching others these same things." (Apology, Plato, Philosophic Classics page 21) Socrates is also accused of denying the existence of the gods, and corrupting the youth. Socrates goes about trying to prove his innocence. The jury that Socrates was tried by

Falsely Accused: A Defense of the Death Penalty

3056 words - 12 pages question: If the chances of executing an innocent person are so high, should we have capital punishment?" ( We no longer live in a Nuremberg Trial-era where a man can be hanged in the town square by an angry mob when suspected of ogling the Sherriff's daughter. Suspects are innocent until proven guilty, and the law requires the prosecution to bear the intricate burden of proof beyond all reasonable doubt for conviction - which does not

Morality of Murder in Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie

1146 words - 5 pages arrested. However, the Armstrongs are successful and they will not receive punishment for their crime. Poirot knows how For the Armstrong family, the sentence of death that Ratchett escaped needs to carry out to prevent him from attacking other children like Daisy Armstrong. Most people believe that the lie can destroy the relationship. However, in Murder on the Orient Express, the lie seems permitted. By using the lie, the passengers on the

No Sugar by Jack Davis: Exposes the Mistreatment of Australian Aborigines During the 1930's

1335 words - 5 pages written by Jack Davis in 1985, is one of these stage dramas. Jack Davis brings issues and even expresses his own ideas about issues such as the injustices of Aboriginal treatment during the 1930's, to life in No Sugar very well because No Sugar is a revisionist text, and therefore offers a new perspective of an Aboriginal point of view, on events which occurred during the time of the issue at hand. No Sugar, the revisionist stage drama written by

Similar Essays

The Murder And Trial Of Emmett Till

1964 words - 8 pages , and rarely is there a general consensus. Nearly every detail of every event had several different versions due to the fact that truth was frequently absent and filled with hypocrisy and myth. (Huie) The murder trial of Milam And Bryant only lasted 68 minutes. In 68 minutes an all white jury let two men who later confessed of being guilty, once the case was appealed of course, walk free. One of the defense attorneys said later, "After the jury was

Abortion: The Murder Of Inconvenient Lives

839 words - 4 pages Mother Teresa once said, “The greatest destroyer of peace today is 'Abortion', because it is a war against the child... A direct killing of the innocent child, 'Murder' by the mother herself... And if we can accept that a mother can kill even her own child, how can we tell other people not to kill one another” (“Quotes”). I vehemently oppose abortion because I believe it is the practice of killing the weakest and most defenseless among us to

The West Memphis Three Murder Trial

1215 words - 5 pages Damien Echols was known for his dabbling in different religions and Wicka,(Summary of Damien’s Mental Health History).When word got out that the murder of the three boys was an act of Satan worshipers, it was determined before a trial even took place that the boys were guilty.This belief stuck all the way through the trial ,leading to the jury having their decisions made before hearing any evidence or witnesses. People and celebrities from

Is Abortion Murder? Both Sides Of The Argument

877 words - 4 pages for and against one's choice of abortion. There are many arguments by pro-choice activists who support one's choice in abortion. First off, nearly all abortions allegedly take place in the first trimester of pregnancy, when a fetus cannot live independently. Its health is dependent on the mother's health and cannot be regarded as a separate entity as it cannot exist outside her womb. In an attempt to suppress the idea that abortion is unnecessary