The Death Penalty: Can It Ever Be Justified?

1500 words - 6 pages

“The Death Penalty: Can It Ever Be Justified?”

Edward I. Koch uses his essay “The Death Penalty: Can It Ever Be Justified?” to defend capital punishment. He believes that justice for murderous crimes is essential for the success of the nation. The possibility of error is of no concern to Koch and if would-be murderers can be deterred from committing these heinous crimes, he feels the value of human life will be boosted and murder rates will consequently plummet (475-479). Koch makes a valiant effort to express these views, yet research contradicts his claims and a real look at his idea of justice must be considered in order to create a fair nation for all.

One point that Koch tries to address is the value of human life. Koch is noted as believing that “life is indeed precious.” He feels that the death penalty helps to establish this fact by demonstrating that if a person commits a heinous crime such as murder, they will suffer the worst of consequences (476). How, though, does the taking of another life demonstrate that life is indeed so precious? All other facts aside, is it not simply the end to another life? Most citizens would be in agreement that such inhumane crimes deserve severe ramifications, but ending a life to make up for an unlawful death would contradict these principles of the value of life. Bud Welch supports this theory. His daughter, Julie, had her life viciously taken from her in the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing. Welch, although enduring the greatest pain of all, concluded that Timothy McVeigh’s execution “is simply vengeance; and it was vengeance that killed Julie.” Welch understood the true value of all human life and was able to put his natural emotions away and theorize that vengeance has “no place in our justice system” (“In Opposition to the Death Penalty: Retribution”).

Deterrence, in Koch’s eyes, also represents how valuable life is. He believes that capital punishment can prevent future murders by eliminating the murderer and making potential murderers think twice about committing a crime (478). Nonetheless, killing the murderer through capital punishment is not the only means to eliminate the possibility of the killer striking again. For example, a life sentence in a secure jail would ensure that the killer would not be able to take another life. Moreover, it would mean one less death in the end. Also, studies have shown that capital punishment may not be the miracle deterrent that Koch and other capital punishment supporters allege it to be. From the Death Penalty Information Center website, William Bowers, a Northwestern University criminologist, states that “society is brutalized by the use of the death penalty, and this increases the likelihood of more murder.” Along with Bowers, 84% of experts in the academic criminological society say that their research has concluded no proof that the death penalty is a successful deterrent (“In Opposition to the Death Penalty: Deterrence”). ...

Find Another Essay On The Death Penalty: Can It Ever Be Justified?

'The death penalty is justified because it - and it alone - pays proper respect to the importance of human life.' What is your view on this?

1305 words - 5 pages . However it is my own personal belief that the death penalty is justified not only in its punishment of criminals, but also as the most respectable way to uphold the sanctity of human life. It must be understood that the death penalty is only meted out in cases which involve murder. When a criminal goes so far as to commit the crime of murder, he is obviously exhibiting his disregard for the victim's right to life. Human rights are a contract deal

can abortion be justified Essay

823 words - 3 pages Can abortion ever be justified?Entrenched as an ubiquitous phenomenon throughout the world, abortion- the premature expulsion of a fetus in the womb is now mounting in our present era. In fact, with modernization, abortion is becoming a culture the new generation is bringing as this therapy is therapeutic to myriad of women. Yet, this medical advancement has generated controversy surrounding the moral and legal status of abortion. Is there any

Can terrorism be justified?

685 words - 3 pages Can terrorism be justified?The devastation and destruction that terrorism causes has impacted greatly on the USA and the world. The 1983 Beirut barracks bombings have shown how terrorism is not justified, and how it has caused a worldwide issue, involving not only America but France, England and Italy. The bombings were not justified by the group/individuals responsible, and their reasons for the attacks were not supported, and not accepted by

Can capital punishment be justified?

773 words - 3 pages Can Capital Punishment be justified?In this day and age it is quite common for young men to carry knives and other weapons. In spite of police campaigns to educate people against carrying weapons there has been a significant increase in the deaths of young British males. Often an argument may become heated, weapons are pulled put with tragic consequences.As well as carrying knives it has become increasingly common, particularly in the English

Can Crime Control be Justified?

1341 words - 5 pages out of every eight people are minorities.Overall, in my opinion, the emphasis on street level crime can be justified. Everything relates to something else. This world goes in giant cycles. Overtime, we have seen that minorities, the poor, and those with a lower socioeconomic status commit more crime. They have a need to succeed. There is also a problem with police presence proportionality. Police patrol poorer areas, because it is said that poorer

Why the Death Penalty Should Be Terminated

3128 words - 13 pages the United States of America. A socially mature and morally established country should refrain from taking the lives of any of its citizens.      The death penalty is indefensible on three distinct and specific grounds: pragmatic, legal, and moral. The penalty of death is not economically efficient, and is indeed a drain upon the financial resources of our country. Also, it can be proven that the death penalty does not act as a deterrent to

Can Euthanasia Be Justified Morally?

1152 words - 5 pages – therefore one will follow the truth in one's mind (categorical imperative) (Macintyre 1996: 193). Is there such a universal order to justify the actions of both doctors? The doctors will argue that their actions were morally right insofar as a universal law can be applicable. Their rationale is to treat others just as others will treat them; hence their actions are justified because they will expect similar treatment if the roles of the patients and

The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished

1608 words - 7 pages , harshness is considered as the only way of hampering humanity from killing each other, arbeit, according to Statistic Brain, by a 85% of deaths, it clearly is not. In spite of capital punishment, life parole is a cordial way of incarcerating people, and there is a possibility of discharging. To make out more apparent, discharge can be exceptional as people have the grasp to profit from life parole. Hence, due to the fact that death penalty and

The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished

1632 words - 7 pages gone forever. But the question you can ask yourself is if there are situations where it's fine or ok for someone to kill another human being? You don't have to go far to find a country that still implements the death penalty. The United States. But the question is if this should be allowed. Is it ok to break the human rights in order to keep a country safe? And does it make the country safer? Do the pros out weigh the cons, or do human rights have

The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished

2233 words - 9 pages The death penalty is no doubt a just punishment to any person that purposely takes another man’s life. The Bible confirms that “whosoever shades man’s blood by man shall his blood be shed: for in the image of God made He man.” (Genesis chapter 9 verse 6). But the first murderer in the bible; Cain, was not executed but was banished for life. It became clear that there is an error in the idea of killing someone that killed another person. Such

Witches And Heretics In The Medieval World: Why It Can Never Be Proven If The Ever Existed

814 words - 3 pages endured some type of torture, whether it be whipping, stretching, burning, or being thrown in icy water. Then, "at the prayer at some of those present," they were asked once again to confess. They were led to believe that if they confessed they would not be put to death. That decision lay solely on the judge. Some agreed to let the accussed live under imprisonment, or possibly exile. However, most judges were so religious that they would not grant

Similar Essays

Capital Punishment And Human Rights Does The Death Penalty Breach Human Rights? Can It Ever Be Justified?

1180 words - 5 pages did not increase when it stopped using it.The death penalty has been abolished by 123 countries; this is a majority over the 73 that still have it. Fifty countries have eliminated capital punishment from their legal system since 1985 and none of those countries have reinstated it.6 This shows that many countries now understand the significance of everyone's human rights.In conclusion, there is no way that capital punishment can be justified in

Research Essay: Can Terrorism Ever Be Justified?

1588 words - 6 pages Research Essay: Can Terrorism Ever Be Justified? “One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter.“ This is a popular quote regarding the state of terrorism, and how certain people may consider terrorism justifiable. Justifying terrorism is, however, not different from justifying innocent slaughter. Justifying innocent slaughter suggests that terrorists believe that political or religious conflicts are more prominent than a segment of

Spring Assignment: The Ticking Time Bomb: Can Torture Ever Be Justified?

1673 words - 7 pages . If they are not coded SPSS will see them as ‘missing data’ which is not necessarily the case (Crow and Semmens 2008). The advantages of quantitative analysis are that is provides tables and charts (an effective way of data presentation), analysis can be fairly quick, it allows the researcher to develop confidence about their data, and the data are scientific (Denscombe 2003). Qualitative analysis involves “identification of themes and

Can Terrorism Ever Be Justified? If So How? If Not, Why Not?

3205 words - 13 pages shall take precedence with the highly contested issue of whether terrorism can ever be justified. In what follows I shall endeavour to explore a number of issues that confront academics when discussing the judgement of terrorism. Primarily, a comprehensive analysis of just war theory shall be undertaken to see if acts of terrorism can accommodate its citation. A particular focus into the discriminate principle shall be discussed, as it is widely