The Debate Is Whether One Society Can Truly Have One Structure Of Power That Lasts Over Time And This Essay Will Agree With The Pluralists, That Power

2343 words - 10 pages

The debate is whether one society can truly have one structure of power that lasts over time and this essay will agree with the pluralists, that power is ever-changing and elite domination can at best only be fleeting and temporary. However, this essay will also argue that this is not just down to the issue of power, but elite domination is also a flawed theory, in that history shows it fails in practice. It should be made clear that there is no universal understanding of pluralism and therefore it is difficult to generalise all pluralists as having one understanding of the definition of pluralism. The same can be said for power; Walter Gallie (1956) describes power as an “essentially contested concept.” Gallie means that different thinkers cannot agree on one particular definition of power. However, for the purpose of this essay I will be using the definition that government can only have true, legitimate power when it has the support of its people. First this essay will evaluate the meaning of power and pluralism, how the use of interest groups makes power easily adaptable. Then I will evaluate elitism and how it fails to last as a structure of power by itself making it at best only fleeting and temporary.

Pluralists believe that no structure of power is stable over time as there is no single, correct way to govern; different frameworks will work at different periods of time and for different nation states. There is no “single unified and universal body of knowledge” in pluralism (Hay, 2006; 21). Pareto believed that elitism is essential to a society as only competent elites can govern the people who are controlled by their own irrational emotions (Pareto, 1916). However, while many argue that there is evidence of elite domination as a successful form of power in modern societies today, there is little to demonstrate this. It is hard to clearly define when a society is truly dominated by an elite regime. Pluralists argue that large inequalities in society do not prove the existence of elitism. The elitists would also justify something such as the redistribution of resources to the poorer members of society, an action that many would deem democratic and liberal, as a way of stabilizing society in the interests of the elite (Dryzek & Dunleavy, 2009; 77). Power is always changing and many citizens want an equal political voice, which is clearly demonstrated through interest groups. Elite domination is unable to be anything but fleeting and temporary, especially in modern societies today where the power is widely dispersed with many sources of governance.

No government can have true power unless it has the consent of its people; a society governed by elites may have some form of control but it can never have true power without the support of its people and that would be unlikely as elitism and democracy are incompatible. This is because democracy literally means rule by the people and elitism means rule by the minority, they are total...

Find Another Essay On The debate is whether one society can truly have one structure of power that lasts over time and this essay will agree with the pluralists, that power

The Power of One Essay

783 words - 3 pages I believe the human spirit is the qualities a being can show throughout life such as the quality of courage, bravery, fearlessness, friendship and determination. These aspects are all explored in the movie, "The Power of One".I chose this text because it relates to the concept of the human spirit by exploring almost all the aspects of it and the intention of John Avildson, the director, was to convey the message that one person can make a

The Power of One Essay

1648 words - 7 pages Elie. In a terrible faith of irony, Elie’s relationship with his father is better then any other time in his life during their improsenment. We will discuss Elie’s relationship to his father and how it changes throughout this memoir. We will also talk about their relationship connection to the authorities at the camp, and finally we will discuss Elie’s questioning of his almighty God. Elie’s describes his father as, “a cultured, rather

“Each character in King Lear has control over their fate. The fate of each character is determined by the events that occur in act one of the play” - To what extent do you agree with this?

1006 words - 4 pages the play. I do agree with this statement, although I also agree to an extent that the fate of some characters was inevitable. The characters in the play view their lives as caught in a pattern they have no power to change, just as the stars in their courses are fixed in the skies.Like in Romeo and Juliet the fate of some main characters can be seen as being dependent on their choice of actions. Just as Romeo and Juliet's decision to elope and fake

Discussion of the Concept of a Cashless Society and the Assertion that We Will Become One

1501 words - 6 pages Discussion of the Concept of a Cashless Society and the Assertion that We Will Become One A cashless society is one of those things that is vastly becoming more popular and is beginning to replace having to go into a shop for example and pay with money that you have stuffed into your wallet. With the creation of bankcards paying is now much easier and a lot safer as you now just swipe your care on special machines assigned

"There is not one single Psychological theory that can adequately account for human aggression and violence." To what extent do you agree with this claim?

1548 words - 6 pages people suffer symptoms like poor attention span hyperactivity and poor impulse control. It is strongly linked to aggression in childhood from this can be predicted that aggression will stay with the sufferer through the rest of their lives.Differences in levels of hormones have also been seen to cause aggression high levels of testosterone make people violent. So male are by nature more aggressive than women as they have more testosterone, but

One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest: Power

820 words - 3 pages One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest: Power      Peoples' ability to use power to control and manipulate situations and people is a skill not many people have. Unfortunately this skill can lead to conflict as it did in Ken Kesely's novel One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest when McMurphy and Nurse Ratched meet each other.      McMurphy has been after Nurse Ratched's power right from the beginning. After

The Power of One: Peekay's Triumphs Over Adversity

520 words - 2 pages Triumph Over AdversityBy definition resiliency is the ability to recover from depression or adversity and throughout the Novel The Power of One by Bryce Courtenay, the Protagonist, Peekay, endures many hard times in which he shows resiliency.One of these extremely hard times is the death of his chicken and best friend, Grandpa Chook. The Judge's brutal murder of Grandpa Chook left Peekay scared, upset, and vulnerable. Grandpa Chook was not only

With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility- "The Crucible", "Silence of the Lambs" and "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest"

1256 words - 5 pages “With great power comes great responsibility”To what extent is this true of the texts you have studied in this unit?With great power comes great responsibility; however the texts studied in this unit show that this obligation is not necessarily fulfilled. The core text The Crucible ironically portrays the powerful institutions of the court and church to be acting irresponsibly in contrast to the integrity of the individual. The concept

The Power of One God

1258 words - 6 pages desired to defend the Roman state and its people. As a result, the Roman army drastically diminished and could no longer defend its borders. Finally, with the establishment of Christian churches and the roles of the Bishops and the presbyters, the authority of the pontiffs and the Pontifus Maximus greatly decreased. For the first time in Roman history, there was a struggle for power in Roman religious practices. Thus, the rise of Christianity is

The Power of One and Pocahontas

1020 words - 4 pages Post-Colonialism Reflective Essay The historical attempts of Europeans to claim lands that are not their own and forcibly take them from previous owners have created a repeated scenario of fierce conflict between the colonizers and the colonized. This scenario is seen so often in history that it has become a sort of universal theme, a fact not missed by writers and filmmakers. In both The Power of One and Pocahontas, the colonization of an

Essay Question: 'Pluralists and ruling elite theory provide fundamentally different accounts of the distribution of political power.' Discuss.

1267 words - 5 pages . There are no groups in society which have more power or control more than anyone else, hence no one can be dominant or have a dominant influence on some one else. The accountability associated with free and fair elections and free speech leave almost no vacuum for dominance. The inclusion of national suffrage means that everyone in the country get a chance and is able to vote in their interests. In many countries this is not the case and that's why

Similar Essays

Bias Essay: This Essay Is Adressing The Question Of Whether One Can Tell A Story With Or Without A Bias.

984 words - 4 pages Israelis is a perfect example of how two sides are not represented equally. The newspapers, television, and radio are, in this case, the authors of the book. Unfortunately, however, none of them are representing each party to the fullest. The problem is that they are not stating the reasons for the actions taken, which can make one side or another look a lot worse than they really are. The "authors" are always, as one can plainly see, the first to

This Essay Is About A Magical Eraser. Great For A Philisophical Essay, Or If You Have One Of "Thoes Teachers" That Are Contemplating The Universe All The Time.

692 words - 3 pages , Right, Mech) or my civilization, Left. Nature. The C is where you are, N is where the Chinese Culture (fading away slowly) is. And O, where I am. A level of achievement like no other. See, with the mere wave of my hand, I can simply destroy plant life. Now, the power of the eraser is truly amazing. Mixing our technology with yours. See, that would turn the line into a circle. One X would be no tech, and the other infinite, but both the same at the same time. This eraser, when combined with opposite UV rays, is a weapon like no other. Capable of wiping out infinitely, until I choose to stop it. Now if you would be so kind as to hand it over.

The Power Of One Essay

1122 words - 5 pages The power of one is and has always been the most sought after and forgotten concept in human history. To determine who the power lies in has often been left to the historians to debate and perhaps immortalize. However, many career and new educators have often sifted through the troubled students in their charge and chosen one they thought could be reached or at least shown a different path that could be chosen. What makes a student that others

"The Power Of One" Essay

1138 words - 5 pages halfway down the alley and shouted in Afrikaans, 'I'll get you back for this, you rooinek (redneck, a derogatory term for the English) bastard.'" Time and time again in the book you can feel the tension and hatred between each of the groups in South Africa. Another area of his culture that is present in the book The Power Of One is that of sports. There all sports all over this book and in his writings. In the African culture sports are very big