The Debate On How Urban Middle Class Identities Have Changed

3922 words - 16 pages

The Debate on How Urban Middle-Class Identities Have Changed

“Materialism is the new karma”. (Pavan K Varma, 2005)

Whilst numerical estimates of the Indian middle classes vary drastically, media images contribute to their portrayal as affluent consumers- participants in the IT boom in urban centres such as Hyderabad and those revelling in India’s status as a call centre “superpower”, particularly thought to symbolise a new urban middle-class. Varma’s quote encapsulates the astonishing effect mass culture is thought to have had upon Indian identity, especially those who occupy this middle ground of consumption. This spectrum ranges from the lower middle-class youth, such as the aforementioned call-centre workers whose parents often experience a very different lifestyle, to the upper middle classes whose educational heritage has enabled them to maintain their class status over a longer period. Hence it is clear that the notion of an “urban middle class” within the Indian context is uniquely problematic, being internally differentiated- encompassing great variety in factors such as culture, language and religious belief, while of course attempting to reconcile the existence of the caste system as a further, but importantly distinctive form of hierarchy to class.
As Fernandes notes, the very question of defining what Beteille termed the “most polymorphous middle class in the world”, itself represents a site of political debate in both academic and public discourses. Additionally there is a marked transition between what is considered the “old middle-classes” and the “new middle-class.” Whereas the former has its origins in the “colonial encounter”, the latter, since liberalisation policies initiated by Rajiv Gandhi in the 1980s came to fruition, has become increasingly defined by its consumption patterns, most apparent in an era of a global economy. Fernandes writes that this overwhelming focus on consumption has somewhat neglected the impact of structural socioeconomic changes in the middle classes.(Fernandes, 2000). At various points these intersect with shifting economic conditions, such as kinship changes affecting the upwardly mobile, however they are not always resultant of the status jockeying of these newly prosperous classes. (Vatuk, 1972). Thus while the transformative effects of liberalisation may appear to have directly visible effects upon the restructured labour market, in the context of family life- locale specificities and historical factors, as well as the advent of urbanity must all be considered. For instance a shift in the values of the Malayali middle-classes can be partially attributed to the implementation of colonial legislation instigating the abolition of polygamous practices such as the Marumakkathayam system of inheritance amongst Nayar communities, whilst increasing nationalist sentiment contributed to the diminishing importance of unique matrilineal forms in Kerala in favour of the patrilineal inheritance that...

Find Another Essay On The Debate on How Urban Middle-Class Identities Have Changed

How Television and The Internet Have Changed The World

1881 words - 8 pages layout, where one may search the internet while engaging with television. Through the connectedness of these online communities, the response to events that interrupt the daily routine is much greater. The ever changing narrative can be viewed and discussed in almost any physical environment. We may for example, be engaged in light conversation at the dinner table, and at the same time be involved in a political debate on the war in the Middle East

The shrinking middle class Essay

1239 words - 5 pages . According to Issues for Debate in Sociology, more than half of all middle class incomes enjoy cable or similar services, have two or more cars, and have high speed internet (pg105). All of which are things that the previous middle class did not have available to them. Wages Are Not Moving At the Same Rate Because the cost of living is rising exponentially faster than the rate that the middle class is being paid, the middle class is feeling the

How Have Computers Changed Education?

764 words - 4 pages Imagine school without computers. Without them, school and learning would be remarkably different. Over the years, computers have really changed school systems. More and more schools are using computers today and it’s changing the way students are being taught. Computers improve learning and teaching by making it more beneficial, more efficient and more motivating for not only the students but also the teachers. Computers make a big impact on

How Pyrotechnics and Explosives Have Changed the World

2367 words - 10 pages written and passed on, Europe has many of their own specialized formulas, making the pre-modern weapons our current guns are based on. From the first experiences with fire, to Greek Fire, Chinese gunpowder, European weaponry innovation, and today’s amazing compound chemical weapons, to play with fire and control it completely has led us to stride to learn all we can about what makes up what and how it reacts. Pyrotechnics and explosives have changed

The Middle Class

10798 words - 43 pages western world will be 0 %, while the rest of the world will still have 57 %. That increase is the residual effect of the improvement in health service in colonial times. Between the years 1750 and 1950, at the height of the demographic explosion of the western world, the Middle Class has replaced the old elite. There is no doubt that there

The Effect of Outsourcing on Middle-Class American's

2143 words - 9 pages The Effect of Outsourcing on Middle-Class American'sThe American middle class is in danger of becoming defunct by the outsourcing of jobs to foreign countries. Jobs that Americans once considered stable long-term employment are now being outsourced at a rising rate. If this trend continues, America could be the next third world country. How has this happened? What can the average American do about it?Outsourcing is not a new concept. As early as

Images of nursing- how the images of nursing have changed over time. How these images impact on the position of nurses within society. Includes interviews with 5 participants

1418 words - 6 pages readings on the subject, seem to indicate that gender norms; particularly in relation to the nurse as a female entity, have had a significant impact on common images. Perpetuated by the media, these images both reflect and reinforce the social status of nursing through out history.I interviewed two female and three male students, all of whom were nineteen years of age. To maintain the private identity of the respondents the interviews were conducted

How World War One Changed the Middle East and East Asia

1030 words - 5 pages forever changed at the end of world war one.Many of the countries formed in the Middle East after world war one would have territorial disputes over their lands and beliefs. These disputes are still largely active today and still cause conflict in the region. With the Japanese gaining control of German territory in East Asia, this would cause disputes between the two countries. After the war the world would never be the same as people would look

Obama Destroying the middle class

1130 words - 5 pages . The single largest tax hike in ObamaCare is the one that boosts the Medicare payroll tax rate to 3.8% on family incomes over $250,000, and extends that tax to their investment earnings (Merline).” This quote shows how the middle class will be hit with the health laws three major taxes. Obamacare is targeting the low-income families to sign up for this affordable care act. Little do Americans know that the upper to middle class will be the ones

How Have Cell Phones Changed People Socially?

1041 words - 5 pages .” (Dempster) Good communication is important because when teens become adults and apply for interviews, they might not know how to have proper communication. Teens and kids are so focused on social networking on cellphones that we spend less time on school work which causes failing grades. In the future when applying for college, they will not accept people because they have failing grades and that is due to cell phone use. (Strahan) Studies

How Ethics and Values Have Changed

881 words - 4 pages It is amazing how as time goes on, people’s ethics and values seem to change and no longer be what they use to be. It is safe to say that ethics and values are worse now than they used to be because people are not willing to help others, society no longer values family and community, and things that once were a private matter are socially acceptable. It is truly amazing to see all the changes that have been made in just a short amount of

Similar Essays

"Prepare A Report Which Explains How 3 Urban Dynamics Operating In The City Of Sydney Have Changed The Nature And Spatial Patterns Of The City

1746 words - 7 pages Geography ReportThe nature and the spatial pattern of Sydney have been changed by various operating urban dynamics. The Urban Morphology refers to the functional form and character of the urban environment. The factors that contribute to the city?s morphology include its land use and street patterns; its architectural styles, building types and materials; streetscapes and density of development; the nature of the biophysical environment, such as

How The Standards Of Beauty Have Changed

1689 words - 7 pages effects of this are imminent. Eating disorders have the highest mortality rates of all psychiatric disorders. Girls affected are twelve times more likely to die than those who are not and disordered eating is the third most chronic illness in adolescence (How the Media Keeps Us Hung Up on Body Image). While this method is not necessarily advertised, adults and teens use the social media as a medium to condone eating disorders. Online forums and

Obamacare's Heavy Toll On The Middle Class

816 words - 4 pages annually, $200,000 today is the same as $152,000 in income in 2020 and just over $100,000 in 2030. So these provisions of the law are really massive back-door tax increases on the middle class. And they will destroy jobs for the middle class too because the tax will lower the incomes of thousands of small business owners who pay their business taxes on the individual schedule. These entrepreneurs will have little choice but to downsize and employ

The Middle Class: A Discussion On The Origins And Usage Of The Term 'the Middle Class'

1185 words - 5 pages their definitions.So, the dictionaries do not provide an adequate definition of the word. However, the dictionary is not alone in its failure. Both the government and the legal system use the term middle class, but nether recognize it officially and provide a concrete definition. The United States Census Bureau, when asked what their definition of middle class is, respond on their website with, "The United States Census Bureau does not have an