The Debate On Suicide Essay

1127 words - 5 pages

The concept of suicide has always been the controversial debate topic among the philosophers. Since the birth of Christianity in Western world, committing a suicide is generally accepted as the act of immorality and the transgression of our duty toward God. By mid-16th century, David Hume, a Scottish philosopher, questions this traditional duty-based ethic of suicide. As he
puts it: “…though death alone can put a full period to his misery, he dare not…a vain fear left he offend his Maker” (On Suicide, p.55). On his famous paper “On Suicide”, he defends the act of suicide and concludes that suicide is at least sometimes permissible. This paper will examine the essay itself in depth and counter argues about his view since the commitment of suicide deprives us from the future possibilities.
The ultimate goal of Hume’s essay is to “restore men to their native liberty, by examining all the common arguments against Suicide, and showing that that action may be free from imputation of guilt or blame” (On Suicide, p.55). He argues that people’s confusion about the morality of suicide is based on the “superstition being found on false opinion” (On Suicide, p.55) and can only be gone “when true philosophy has inspired juster sentiments of superior powers” (On Suicide, p.55). He states that “if suicide be criminal, it must be a transgression of our duty either to God, our neighbor, or ourselves” (On Suicide, p.55).
In most theological argument about the suicide, it argues that altering the length of one’s natural life is impious to God. As Socrates puts it:” the gods are our keepers, and we men are one of their possessions... we must not put an end to ourselves until God sends some compulsion like the one we are now facing” (Phaedo, 62a). In Christian church, the act of suicide is against the natural laws of God and one who commits it is permanently labelled as criminal. Hume questions on this ‘natural’ course of things. He starts by pointing that basic nature in reality is “…two distinct principles of the material and animal world, continually encroach upon each other, and mutually retard or forward each other’s operation”(On Suicide, p.55). According to Hume, God is the creator of system of inanimate and animal creature that “governs everything by those general and immutable laws” (On Suicide, p.56). Human life is not an exception. Under these natural laws of God, all human beings use their entrusted power to seek “their ease, happiness, or preservation” (On Suicide, p.56). He argues that if suicide is required for one’s happiness or preservation, it is permissible since it is a natural process of human under the laws of God.
Hume states that “a man who retires from life does no harm to society: He only ceases to do good” (On Suicide, p.58). After committing a suicide, an individual will not be able to fulfill the duties towards to the greater good of society. However, it also means that if the expense of continuing a miserable life is greater than the...

Find Another Essay On The Debate on Suicide

The Debate on Food Irradiation Essay

3111 words - 12 pages . Many consumers are uneducated or unaware of this process. Anytime the word radiation is mentioned, people are alarmed. Ther are weary about the effects this process has on the foods they eat, and ultimately the effects these foods will have on their bodies. Food irradiation is a controversial topic, with both supporters and opponents on both sides of the debate. Food irradiation uses ionizing radiation to eliminate microorganisms and

The Christian Debate on Homosexuality Essay

2780 words - 12 pages The American debate on homosexuality reveals an unquestionable, though awfully uninvited, fusion between religion and politics, revealing a dangerous lack of separation between the church and state. The concern is not about the presence of spirituality in American politics, but the implications institutionalized religion has on the lives and rights of human beings. Nothing hinders the political and social progress of lesbian women and gay men

The Debate on the Banning of Boxing

1634 words - 7 pages The Debate on the Banning of Boxing Boxing is an ancient sport with a long history dating back centuries. It developed from bare knuckle fighting in the 18th and 19th century. The sport has already experienced a ban in 1865 and despite this remains a popular today despite this. The sport has rules established by Marquees of Queensbury that form the basis of modern boxing: three minute rounds and boxers must wear

The Debate on the Legalization of Prostitution

2818 words - 12 pages The Debate on the Legalization of Prostitution: “Prostitute” vs. “Sex Worker” CCJS 330: Contemporary Issues in Criminology Dr. B. Dooley Gabriela Lissette Alonzo May 21, 2014   What is sex, or rather what should sex be? Is it a physical and emotional intimacy and private expression of love between two people? Should it only be allowed in marriage? Is it something casual that happens in every romantic relationship? Should it be private or

The Media's Influence on Teenage Suicide

1722 words - 7 pages The Media's Influence on Teenage Suicide      Fiction: Only “bad” kids who have the wrong friends and bad lives commit suicide. Fact: Kids who have the right friends and a bright future in front of them commit suicide. Fiction: Music, movies, and other forms of media do not influence teenagers in any way, shape, or form. Fact: Music, movies, and other forms of media are influencing teenagers to commit suicide.      Teenage suicide is on

Suicide Bombings Are on the Rise

1329 words - 6 pages helplessness in their population to cause fear and chaos which leads them to gain power in their state or region. The effects of suicide terrorism affects our country on a daily basis and puts many innocent american citizens in a possible danger of one day being a victim to these violents acts of crime. As you can tell from past events in our nation's history such as the bombing of the twin towers and world trade center in new york city on September

The Proconcatholic View on Physician-Assisted Suicide

630 words - 3 pages The Proconcatholic View on Physician-Assisted Suicide Some have suggested that we legalize physician-assisted suicide in California. They argue that we should find death before it finds us, and that the right to die is the right-to-choose. They are supporting such an initiative because they fear that they will have to endure horrible pain and live out a life encompassed by absolute suffering. By being able to end the torment, preferably

Discussion on the Importance of Presidential Debate

3134 words - 13 pages Introduction Since the first televised debate between Vice President Richard Nixon (R-Calif.) and Senator John Kennedy (D-Mass.), the election process has never been the same. Despite the seemingly important democratic aspect of presidential debates, the actual impact of debates on voters’ perceptions of potential candidates is highly doubted by many scholars. Potential candidates, journalists, and a few scholars have expressed, however, the

The Debate on Abortion Laws in the United States

1562 words - 7 pages can be neutral or on the other party’s side for certain topics. Abortion is a very controversial topic as it always has been all around the country but more specifically in the United States. There are two sides to the debate those who believe abortion should be legal and their organization is known as prochoice. On the other side there are the group of people who believe that abortion should not be legal and reverse the laws from what they are

The Religious Debate on Muslim Women Wearing the Hijab

1200 words - 5 pages Should Muslim women be required to wear the traditional hijab is a religious debate I was never aware existed, I just always believed it was mandatory to wear the veil and that was that. There are many that say the hijab is a symbol of their religion but they are being challenged by the view that it is a personal choice. The Islam religion has five fundamental requirements: Ramadan fasting, believing that the only God is Allah and that

Commentary on "Suicide in the Trenches" by Siegfried Sassoon

1274 words - 5 pages Siegfried Sassoon, the poet of "Suicide in the Trenches" fought in the 1st World War, and won the Military Cross for 'gallantry in action'. However in July 1917 he was sent to Craiglockhart War Hospital near Edinburgh where he met Wilfred Owen, another famous war poet. He had become destroyed by the trauma of the 1st World War, and disheartened by the generals leading it. His anti-war stance was confirmed on July 30, when his statement demanding

Similar Essays

The Debate On Whether Assisted Suicide Is Ethical Or Immoral

1785 words - 7 pages The Debate on Whether Assisted Suicide is Ethical or Immoral Assisted Suicide, also known as mercy killing, occurs when a physician provides the means (drugs or other agents) by which a person can take his or her own life. This assistance is one of the most debated issues today in society followed by abortion. Physicians are frequently faced with the question of whether or not assisted suicide is ethical or immoral. Although assisted

The Debate Surrounding Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1650 words - 7 pages Physician-assisted suicide is the practice in which a doctor prescribes a terminally ill patient with a lethal medication as a form of active, voluntary euthanasia. These patients, rather than suffer slowly and painfully, often request this procedure as a means of experiencing a more “dignified” death. The debate surrounding this issue is a heated one, especially among the general public whose attitudes are deeply influenced by the level of

The Debate On Guns Essay

1926 words - 8 pages only reserved to the Third Reich; since the dawning of organized government, the right of the people to keep and bear arms had been greatly debated. Today in the United States it seems the debate has reached its climax. Home to virtually millions of civilian owned guns, the United States is aflame with talk of gun control on both sides of the issue. Recent tragedies like the Sandy Hook Shooting and Aurora Theater Massacre provide fuel to the fire

The Debate On Euthanasia (Oral) Essay

1023 words - 4 pages Today, I will be discussing the intentional killing by act or omission of a dependent human being for his or her alleged benefit. The process otherwise referred to as Euthanasia. There are many forms that Euthanasia can take. Euthanasia can be voluntary, non-voluntary, involuntary, assisted suicide, by action or by omission. What all these types of Euthanasia have in common is that they are all relevant to today's modern society. Shortly I will