This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Debate Over Abortion Essay

2024 words - 8 pages

With the ongoing debate and the advancement of technology in determining the viability of a fetus, abortion, the ending of a pregnancy by removing a fertilized egg, has become increasingly controversial. The morality of abortion has caused many to separate into opposite sides of the spectrum, pro-life and pro-choice. The arguments over abortion has stirred a continuous debate between a pro-choice stance such as that presented by the analogical reasoning of Thomson or Glover’s examination of social context and a pro-life position argued by a moral view of personhood by Noonan. The ethical arguments presented by the conflicting views in the abortion debate has caused others to taken into consideration a sociological account visible in Luker’s examinations of world views in order to discover underlying motivations.

The debate has caused many to argue either in support of or against abortion. In the article “A Defense of Abortion,” Judith Jarvis Thomson uses analogical reasoning (such as the case of the sick violinist) to support and convince a right to abortion. Thomson presents the argument that all people are entitled a right to life and that a person’s right to life outweighs any person’s right to decide what happens to their body (1, Thomson, CC p.188).Thomson proposes a hypothetical situation in which the reader is kidnapped and their circulatory system is linked with that of a sick violinist in order to prevent his kidneys from failing. If the person agrees to offer his or her kidneys, they would have to remain plugged for nine months or even more. However if the person refuses, the violinist would die. By using the sick violinist example, Thomson seeks to undermine the argument that an abortion cannot be performed because the fetus’s right to life outweighs the mother’s right to decide.

Thomson constructs the analogy of the sick violinist to explain that abortion is not a violation of the fetus’ right to life, and thus not necessarily an act of unjustified killing. Thomson concludes that it does not matter whether or not a fetus is a person because even if a fetus is granted a right to life, it is not accurate to assume that abortion is murder (2, Thomson, CC p.192). Murder is an intentional act that is unjustified while abortion is not direct killing but results in the death of the fetus. For instance, in cases involving rape or other conditions of unintended pregnancies, a woman undergoing abortion is not necessarily committing murder since she was not responsible for an unwanted pregnancy. Therefore, in no case should the personhood of the fetus determine the morality of abortion. Thomson suggests that having a right to life does not grant the right to use another person’s body (3, Thomson, CC p.191). In other words, the fetus’s right to life does not apply to any moral obligation of the mother’s body. Abortion is justifiable because there is no obligation on part of the women for an unwanted pregnancy. In the case of the sick...

Find Another Essay On The Debate Over Abortion

The Abortion Debate Essay

1930 words - 8 pages The Abortion Debate Abortion is a form of murder and demeans the value of human life. Other birth control is readily available; thus, abortion shouldn't be a form of birth control. The societal contributions of a potentially valuable human being are wiped out. Women who have abortions often suffer major psychological damage from the experience along with, in some cases, the father of the child. The advances of genetic testing may

The Abortion Debate Essay

1103 words - 4 pages The Abortion Debate There are all kinds of people in the world, and we all have different opinions. In this report I am discussing abortion. You will read about the pros and cons of this subject. Some people think that abortion is wrong; they think that abortion is the killing of innocent children. Other people believe that the unborn child is not actually a human until it takes its first breath of air. Many

Abortion: The Public's Debate

1156 words - 5 pages these points that she made really helped her in developing a strong debate. On the other side, Terry didn't has a strong argument because he needed to give more points in his issue against abortion and tried not to connect things that don't look match together. However, he did pointed out two good points in his article, he said, abortion is murder and the Freedom to Access to Clinic Entrance is like opening a floodgate to violence. But overall, I

The Abortion Debate

1371 words - 5 pages The Abortion Debate There are few issues that can cause as many heated and sometimes, irrational, debates than that of abortion. The issue strikes at the very heart of an individual's religious and philosophical beliefs. Does a woman have the right to terminate a pregnancy? Is it moral to do so in any circumstance? Is a fetus a living human being? The debate has raged for nearly thirty years and there does not seem to be any end to the

The Abortion Debate - 1948 words

1948 words - 8 pages and hinged on were currently hated and undermined. In spite of the fact that premature births still happened with normality, they were kept noiseless and seen as a matter of disgrace. "Over the next hundred years, public sentiment for the fetus continued to rise until the inevitable happened in America during the early 40's; Abortion was made illegal." (Cohen 17). There was such a large number of back applauding and congrats around the against

The Abortion Debate - 1818 words

1818 words - 7 pages Catholic Church, abortion is always morally wrong, but many individuals and societal morals may argue otherwise. This debate may never be resolved, but each person is entitled to have their own views on the topic. But before you judge others choices, just think “what if I were in this sitaution?” Works Cited "Catechism of the Catholic Church - The Fifth Commandment." Catechism of the Catholic Church - The Fifth Commandment. Vatican.va

The Abortion Debate - 1162 words

1162 words - 5 pages Abortion has been defined as the termination of a pregnancy and is a very controversial topic (Abortion). The heated discussion about legalizing and restricting abortion has arisen over many years. During the Women's Rights Movement 1848-1920, not only were women fighting for their right to be treated like everyone else, they were fighting for the right of birth control and reproductive rights (ushistory.org). Introducing the birth control pill

The Abortion Debate - 1603 words

1603 words - 6 pages The Abortion Debate According to Dean Stretton, “The most plausible pro-life argument claims that abortion is seriously wrong because it deprives the foetus of something valuable. This

The Debate Over Euthanasia

1282 words - 5 pages The Debate Over Euthanasia The controversy over euthanasia has recently become highly publicized. However, this issue is not a new debate. Society has voiced its opinions on the subject for hundreds of years. Euthanasia, which is Greek for "good death", refers to the act of ending another person’s life in order to end their suffering and pain.1 Two forms, passive and active euthanasia, categorize the actions taken to end the person’s life

The Debate Over Vaccination

732 words - 3 pages “Immunization Is a Question of Science, Not Faith: How I Evaluated the Immunization ‘Debate’ “, by Chanda Cooper-Warren. Her article appears on the website www.quackwatch.org, and is written with the authority of a concerned mother without any medical credentials listed. Warren believed that, “A medical issue should be judged by science”, and any claim on the subject had to be based on valid scientific data from a reputable source (Cooper-Warren

The Debate over Homeschooling

2331 words - 10 pages     There has always been a debate on whether children should be forced to go to public school or have the choice to attend homeschool. This debate has been around because many educators find that homeschooling is a lazy way out of learning, while other people argue that homeschooling is a great way to learn specifically for those who are sick with diseases like cancer and sickle cell or who learn better in a private environment rather than

Similar Essays

Shoulld You Live Or Die? The Debate Over Abortion

989 words - 4 pages What if I told you that right now someone was deciding, without even knowing you, whether you would live or die? What if I told you that this choice wouldn’t be based on what you could or couldn’t do, it wouldn’t be based on what you have done in the past or what you will do in the future? And what if I told you that there was nothing that you could do to change their mind? That choice is abortion, and that someone is a child’s mother

The Abortion Debate Essay 1610 Words

1610 words - 6 pages No matter where you stand on the issue, abortion is a highly debated topic in today’s society. In this essay I will examine both sides of the abortion issue. I will begin with a brief overview of the abortion debate, to include the morality of the situation. Next I will discuss the Pro-Life argument. Lastly I will look at the Pro-Choice view. In the final analysis I will show how utilitarianism, altruism, and situational ethical views apply to

The Abortion Debate Essay 2133 Words

2133 words - 9 pages fighting fire with fire in any case like that. There are two sides in the debate of keeping abortion legal or making it illegal. There are pro-choice people, who feel as though every female should have a choice in whether they want to carry their child or not. On the other hand there are pro-life people who feel as though just because the public cannot see the baby, the baby is still there no matter who wants to ignore them. Simply put, pro-life

The Abortion Debate Essay 1566 Words

1566 words - 6 pages . Only 41% of those in the survey identified themselves as pro-choice (Pickert 2). It can be claimed that a large majority of Americans support the right of a woman to obtain an abortion in cases of rape, incest, or if the mother's life may be at risk. Most of these supporters also back the state imposed regulations placed on abortion for safety reasons and other fine details. Since the case of Roe vs. Wade over 50 million legal abortions have taken