This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Debate Over Women In The Catholic Church

1419 words - 6 pages

The Debate Over Women in the Catholic Church

The question of the ordination of women to the priesthood has moved to the forefront of theological controversy in recent years, prompting a swamping of books, and religious opinions. This controversial issue stems not only from the renewed interest of the Catholic Church in the nature of its priesthood, but also, and perhaps predominantly, from the efforts of women to achieve a new and deeper understanding of their religion. The question, should women be ordained as ministers in the church immediately implies many questions. What difference could female priests make to the church? Did Jesus allow for women to be priests? What has been the result of many centuries of male priesthood?
However the first question you always have to ask when one has a controversial issue like this is what was Jesus' view on the topic? Jesus, nowhere in the bible stated anything about women being subservient or lesser people to men. As a matter of fact from the beginning women were part of his disciples and according to the bible Luke stated that a lot of women supported his ministry. When religious based questions are asked the greatest source of information is the Bible. The Bible itself states on many occasions that women held religion as one of the highest priorities in their lives. To add to this, women participated in some of the most important roles in the church community such as Eucharistic ministers etc.
The Catholic Church in the past centuries has been very male dominated. Male priests, male archbishops, male deacons, male popes. In fact in the Catholic Church most women have never held a higher perspective than a Eucharistic minister. This seems very odd, since these days women have exactly the same rights as any man. Why then, if a woman can get any job that a man can get, can manage a large company and can fight in a war, are they not allowed to become ordained in the priesthood? There is ample evidence in Scripture for women's leadership in the early church. Such leadership became increasingly prohibited as the church became a public institution, as it was not considered proper for women to hold leadership positions in public places. As the world has come to see the equality of women holding leadership positions in the civil public world; so it would be right for them to be church leaders today. This would signal the church's real belief in the equality of women and men.
The Old Testament states on many occasions that women are not allowed to be priests. These statements are based on the fact that men were born first therefore they are automatically capable of doing a better job. The Old Testament tends to hold a very biased opinion in that they did not even state that women participated in church life.
The New Testament does, however, give a precedent for the ordination of deaconesses (I Tim. 3:8-11, Rom. 16:1). The Bible states that Aquila and Priscilla, who served under Paul's...

Find Another Essay On The Debate Over Women in the Catholic Church

Women in the Church Essay

1839 words - 7 pages Since the death of Jesus, to the modern era, the Christianity has gone through many changes in doctrine, practices, splits, and beliefs. As the church grew from charismatic communities to a global church organization, certain groups lost power while others gained a comparative advantage. No more has the shift in power affected a group more than the role of women in the church. The role of the woman in Christian Churches transformed from their

The Lutheran Church and The Catholic Church

1052 words - 5 pages officially formed on January 1, 1988 and was a combination of three branches of the Lutheran religion: the American Lutheran church, the Association of Evangelical Lutheran churches, and the Lutheran Church in America. In 2012 the ELCA had 3,950,924 baptized members. Today, it is the seventh largest religious body and largest Lutheran denomination in the U.S. Luther, born in 1483, was a German monk and priest of the Catholic Church. While

The Catholic Church and Reformation

1305 words - 6 pages and their impacts on the world as we know it. Martin Luther was born in 1483. He was born a Catholic as that was the religion of the time. Marin Luther’s life was predetermined to become a lawyer, but instead he chose the path of becoming a monk. He toiled over questions and his relationship with God. It was thought that a person had to build up enough “good deeds” in order to be saved and to enter heaven. The church had a practice of

Background of the Catholic Church

4458 words - 18 pages Background In the Western world, the schism within the Catholic Church has made its most significant impact due to rapid changes in social standards. Of greatest importance is the evolution of modern society and their response to the reverberated traditions of the Catholic Church as well as the evolving Protestant sects. In consequence of increases in technology and science, modern society has redefined its acceptable and moral

AIDS - and the Catholic Church

1231 words - 5 pages risk of contracting AIDS, to the risk of death and to the risk of passing the virus on." For this reason the Church is being asked to regard the condom not as a life stopper but a life saver. In a recent interview with Channel Ten's Derryn Hinch, a representative from the Catholic Church, Farther Harman, talks about the AIDS debate. When given the hypothetical that, "If I am an AIDS antibody-positive husband, gotten from whatever manner, blood

History Of the Catholic Church

1788 words - 7 pages over Europe. More and better agricultural product in turn imporved the quality of life just enough so that the population grew slightly.The Growth of Trade and Crafts4. People migrated to population centers, looking for a livelihood. Because towns were markets for goods and centers of administration for btoh Church and state, they provided jobs for the people who were not needed in agriculture.5. Most towns grew around castles or the cathedrals

The Role of the Catholic Church in the Holocaust

1684 words - 7 pages From the recent conflicts over Pope Pius XII, whether portrayed as a pitiless anti-Semite or a saver of many Jewish lives during World War II, to the confusion over how to take the 1998 Vatican document on the Holocaust, the Catholic Church is in great dispute over it's history of relations with the Jews. "Who killed Christ?" has always been the justification of the Church over the issue of the persecution of the Jews. As well as every other

Chaucer and the Catholic Church

1023 words - 5 pages By the late 14th century, the Catholic Church was the main influential power in Europe. As the clergy’s influence increased, the continent’s wealth began to decline. Amidst a century of poverty, plague, and unemployment, criticism of the church arose. The people deemed the clergy hypocritical for preaching against greed, but yet keeping all of the wealth to themselves. Cathedrals were built as shrines, embellished in gold and rich jewels

The Reform of the Roman Catholic Church in Europe

905 words - 4 pages Protestantism and the Protestant form of Christianity were established, and continued to gain momentum in the 1500’s mainly due to the overall discontent many Europeans had with the socio-economic and religious dealings of the Roman Catholic Church. This discontent eventually lead to the reform of the Roman Catholic Church in Europe, and religious beliefs and attitudes became divided between northern and southern Europe. This is a summary of

Jesus and the Role of Sin in the Catholic Church

753 words - 3 pages According to the Catholic Church, every Catholic, through the sacrament of Baptism, "is freed from sin and reborn." Through the first sacrament of baptism and immersion, all individual members of the Catholic Church engage in the act of becoming members of Christ. Baptism enables an adherent of the faith to incorporate into the Church and made sharers in the mission of the Church. ("The Seven Sacraments of the Church ("The Seven Sacraments of

The Modern Era's Central Tensions in the Roman Catholic Church

1375 words - 6 pages The Modern Era's Central Tensions in the Roman Catholic Church In his narrative of the time from the French Revolution to the present in Church History: Twenty Centuries of Catholic Christianity of the Roman Catholic Church, John C. Dwyer makes it apparent that he has several goals in mind for where the church ought to end up, and his account gives us a sense that it is all leading up to these goals. They are largely accomplished by the time

Similar Essays

Stem Cell Research Moral Debate. An Ethical Debate About Stem Cell Research. Inlcudes Both Pros And Cons Of The Issue, Along With The View Of The Catholic Church As Well As A Personal Opinion

1077 words - 4 pages Stem Cell Research Moral DebateToday stem cell research is a very controversial issue. Within the past few years people have been subject to the debates over stem cell research in the news, in books, and in magazines. But what exactly is stem cell research and how can it benefit the human race? What are the reasons that people are so against stem cell research? It seems that many people have taken a side on this issue. But, no matter what side

The Catholic Church Essay

3564 words - 14 pages image is very symbolic of the attempt to overthrow the teaching authority of the Pope taking place in the Catholic Church following the historic release of Humanae Vitae, an important papal encyclical following the religious revolution known as Vatican II. Unremarkable for its content, which simply reaffirmed the current Church views on contraceptive use, the response to Humanae Vitae has been shocking. The controversy over Humanae Vitae

Origins Of The Catholic Church In Australia

1744 words - 7 pages over 1 million Catholics in a short period of time. This period brought dramatic change to the Australian Catholic Church. The Church was not the centre of life as it was in Asia or in Europe. The separation of Church and State was clear, and the Church had nearly no influence in Politics. Australian Catholics focused on saints of Irish and English origin, while these saints held nearly no influence in other nations. Catholic Practices Prior to

Women In The Church Essay

1312 words - 6 pages The 21st century, is led by a women’s movement that is allowing women to hold powerful positions in corporations that were once only considered for men. However, the Roman Catholic Church is one of the last few standing organizations that is still male dominated. Women are not allowed to be ordained ministers but rather take vows to become nuns. Therefore, women do not have influence on policies that are being imposed onto everyday Catholics