This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Debate Regarding The Freedman's Bureau

1049 words - 4 pages

The Debate Regarding the Freedman's Bureau


Historians and political theorists have delineated the concept of equality into two categories: the competitive individualist notion of equality of process and the egalitarian ideal of equality of results. The former is concerned with providing a level playing field for all, while the latter focuses on a just distribution resulting from the process. Richard Ellis, in his book American Political Cultures, challenges the Hartzian thesis that historically Americans favored equality of process over equality of results, making them competitive individualists. Ellis argues that “what is exceptional about America is not that it lacked a results-oriented vision of equality but that those who favored equalizing results believed that equal process was a sufficient condition for realizing equal results” (Ellis 1993: 44). In other words, the egalitarian spirit was not absent from American history, but Americans believed that justice would best be served through competition. Ellis is correct in making this fine distinction, yet it is important to note that historical evidence suggests that some factions clearly emphasized equality of results regardless of equality of process. In The Souls of Black Folk, W.E.B. Du Bois’ recounting of the political debate regarding the Freedman’s Bureau, clearly highlights this ideological difference.

Du Bois poignantly captures the necessity for a legal equalizing measure in his description of the tragedy of slavery and the ragged, conflicted nature of the black consciousness that resulted. He writes, “the facing of so vast a prejudice could not but bring the inevitable self-questioning, self-disparagement, and lowering of ideals which ever accompany repression . . . our voting is vain” (Du Bois 1997: 51). It was the realization that progress would be painstakingly slow–given the enormous obstacles the ex-slaves faced--that gave way to discussion of a legal equalizer beyond suffrage. One of the legal mechanisms used was the establishment of an agency capable of inculcating African Americans into an obviously prejudicial mainstream society.

This debate became not whether African Americans deserved equality, but rather if suffrage was sufficient, and if not, whether a more extensive organization was needed to introduce the black population to the society that had so savagely decimated its spirit. The initial response to this pressing problem, which Du Bois calls “a hasty bit of legislation, vague and uncertain in outline,” was the compromise of 1865, which created a Freedman’s Bureau “to which was given ‘the supervision and management of all abandoned lands and the control of all subjects relating to refugees and freedmen’” (Du Bois 1997: 61). The earlier unwillingness to pass a more detailed bill for such a Bureau and the haste and vagueness of the 1865 legislation suggest that the creation of an extensive Bureau did not enjoy strong support among lawmakers. Indeed, the...

Find Another Essay On The Debate Regarding the Freedman's Bureau

Emancipation and the Freedmen’s Bureau Essay

2781 words - 11 pages end of the conflict that that these men and women actually saw their freedom. Lincoln had put serious consideration into how to go about ending slavery, but had not fully developed the logistical aspect of what would happen to these men and women after the war. It was not until 1865 that the Union addressed this issue through the creation The Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands. This Freedmen’s Bureau as it came to be known was a

The Federal Bureau of Investigation Essay

2005 words - 8 pages The Federal Bureau of Investigation The agency now known as the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) was founded in 1908 when Attorney General Charles J. Bonaparte appointed an unnamed force of Special Agents to be the investigative force of the Department of Justice (DOJ). Prior to that time, DOJ borrowed Agents from the U.S. Secret Service to investigate violations of federal criminal laws within its jurisdiction. By order of Attorney

The Demystification of the Freedmen's Bureau

1252 words - 5 pages The role of the Freedmen Bureau in African-American development during the Reconstruction era has been a polarizing topic since the Bureau’s inception. While most concur that the Bureau was well intended, some scholars, believe that the Freedmen’s Bureau was detrimental to African-American development. One such scholar was W.E.B. Dubois, who in his book The Souls of Black Folk, expressed his discontent with the actions of the Bureau and

SHORT STORY : THE FREEDMEN ‘S BUREAU

931 words - 4 pages In the years following the Civil War, the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands (the Freedmen's Bureau) provided assistance to tens of thousands of former slaves and impoverished whites in the Southern States and the District of Columbia. The war had liberated nearly four million slaves and destroyed the region's cities, towns, and plantation-based economy. It left former slaves and many whites dislocated from their homes

The Bureau of Labor Statistics: Coffee Prices

1167 words - 5 pages The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), strives to provide interested parties with clear and precise information regarding the US economy through the measurement of working conditions, activities in the labor market and changes in the prices of goods and services. As such, the people it intends to serve is the vast American republic and those specifically interested in learning about emerging issues and trends of the economy. Since the agency

A History of the Freedmen's Bureau

2290 words - 10 pages war. Lincoln tried very hard to abolish slavery, but it seems that he did not fully think through what would happen to these slaves after the war ended. In 1865 the Union created the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands to help the men and women after the war. This came to be recognized as the Freedmen’s Bureau, and was used to help slaves transition to freedom. Unfortunately, not all of its goals were accomplished. Abraham

The Federal Bureau of Investigation - FBI

1086 words - 4 pages To uphold the law through the investigation of violations offederal criminal law; to protect the U.S. from foreign intelligenceand terrorist activities; to provide leadership and law enforcementassistance to federal, state, local, and international agencies; andto perform these responsibilities in a manner that is responsive tothe needs of the public and is faithful to the constitution of theU.S.: this is the mission of the Federal Bureau of

The Canadian Flag Debate

1318 words - 5 pages Canada had been an outstanding country for many years but has always lacked one important thing. Until the year 1965, Canada did not have their own official flag. The Canadian flag debate was a major controversy to Canada because many thought it was about time for Canada to have their own flag years after gaining their independence from Britain. The Canadian flag debate had a very interesting background and the Canadians involvement towards the

Marijuana: The Great Debate

2697 words - 11 pages huge start. Other states have since followed in that same direction, and in result, recent media attention and debate have been focused on the benefits of marijuana rather than its harmful effects and may have contributed to this rise in use (p.305). In his article, Golan (2010) comments specifically, “Indeed, coverage of medical marijuana has been linked to real life consequences regarding drug use” (p. 305). In support of this, Kristen Gwynne

The "Mommy Track" Debate

2248 words - 9 pages providing background information regarding the opposition, he successfully sets up the rest of his essay to explain why his organizational approach is more logical and sensible. After thoroughly analyzing both sides of the “mommy track” debate, one can acknowledge the many rhetorical strategies used for each side to convey their message. Although there may not be a right or wrong side to the debate, in a broad perspective the articles

The Sweatshop Debate

1088 words - 4 pages NIKE: THE SWEATSHOP DEBATE1Nike: The Sweatshop DebateMGT/448Date: November 25, 2014IntroductionThis paper is about a case study entitled: "Nike: The Sweatshop Debate." Legal, cultural, and ethical challenges that confront Nike's global business will be described. In addition, various roles that host governments have played in the debate will be determined and a summary of the strategic and operational challenges facing global managers for the

Similar Essays

The Great Debate Regarding Creation Essay

889 words - 4 pages The Great Debate Creation by God? The Big Bang? Books, manuscripts, scientific papers, scriptural works, documentaries, ancient artifacts, and countless web sites all deliver differing theories, most with finales of doom. One could logically suppose that a big boom did occur when this mysterious form of existence sprang into being. Attempting to argue the theories surrounding the birth of the universe, one by the hand of a Supreme Being and

The Font Bureau, Inc Essay

763 words - 4 pages The Font Bureau in a privately held company that was founded in 1989 by publication designer and media strategist Roger Black, and internationally known type designer David Berlow. David Berlow entered the type industry in 1978 as a letter designer for several respected type foundries. He is a member of the New York Type Directors Club and the Association Typographique International and remains active in typeface design. Based in Boston

The Census Bureau Essay

917 words - 4 pages The Census Bureau This paper will identify what I learned from the following two websites identified as the following: www.claritas.com and www.census.gov. The following questions are posed and will be answered in this paper. 1) What did you find that surprised you? 2) How are they different? 3) How are they the same? 4) How might these two market research sources help a company develop a marketing mix? 5) What

Farm Bureau Leading The Challenge Essay

993 words - 4 pages Imagine owning the perfect farm, perfect home, perfect pasture, and outstanding prosperous crops. What about when it floods, or there is a fire? Suddenly everything changes. You no longer have that perfect farm. You may no longer even have you home, much less a means to provide for yourself and your family. Who is supposed to protect you then and everything you had? The answer is simple: Farm Bureau. Farm Bureau is the world’s largest