The Debate Surrounding Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1650 words - 7 pages

Physician-assisted suicide is the practice in which a doctor prescribes a terminally ill patient with a lethal medication as a form of active, voluntary euthanasia. These patients, rather than suffer slowly and painfully, often request this procedure as a means of experiencing a more “dignified” death. The debate surrounding this issue is a heated one, especially among the general public whose attitudes are deeply influenced by the level of patient pain and discomfort (Frileux et al. 334). At the heart of the issue is the conflict between a patient’s right to choose between life and death and, as expressed by one social scientist, “society’s obligation to protect its most vulnerable members from hastened and not completely voluntary death” (Ardelt 424). The healthcare field acknowledges the role of medical technology, which has extended the lifetime of many patients through life support therapies like feeding tubes and dialysis, in creating a lower quality of life characterized by an agonizingly prolonged and costly dying (Martin 54). This phenomenon has made physician-assisted suicide a highly relevant and compelling issue today. But, while some defend physician-assisted suicide as a form of medical autonomy for the terminally ill, others contend that such voluntary euthanasia is too extreme a solution for most situations and improvement in patient and palliative care is a more acceptable option and would help maintain the patient-doctor relationship. The purpose of this literature review is to present these scholarly perspectives in an attempt to provide a relatively expansive overview of the attitudes relating to physician-assisted suicide in the medical community, with an eye to how they compare with public opinion.
In “Euthanasia- a physician’s viewpoint,” Dr. Robert Twycross argues against physician-assisted suicide by discussing the importance of palliative care, which is centered around treating and reducing patient pain and suffering. Assisted suicide is criticized as a drastic answer to “a situation that demands a far more comprehensive and compassionate approach” (86). Focusing on patients with advanced cancer, Twycross notes that it is crucial to humanize the experience of the dying so that their emotional, physical, and spiritual needs are met. For example, more than sixty percent of patients with Stage IV cancer experience severe, overlooked pain (89). The establishment of several hospices and care units as a response to the gaps left by medical technology has significantly improved the standard of care received by terminally ill patients. These care facilities work on symptom control by carefully evaluating the cause of pain and adopting a multidisciplinary approach that incorporates both regular analgesic use and non-drug measures like creating a positive, comfortable environment (89). Twycross concludes that it is not a change in the legal status of euthanasia that is needed, but rather a change in medical education to teach...

Find Another Essay On The Debate Surrounding Physician-Assisted Suicide

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1982 words - 8 pages human dignity. Also, if this Bill were to be passed we will no longer be bound by law, only by our personal ethics. This would place a much larger emphasis on the ethics that have already being discussed previously. The possibility of legalized murder in Canada makes it crucial to fully understand the ethics of Physician Assisted Suicide.There is a great deal of moral and ethical issues surrounding Physician Assisted Suicide. As practicing

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

2568 words - 10 pages communities there are many definitions of assisted suicide, along with the contentious debate of suicide that is assisted by a physician rather a family member or friend. PAS has some benefits with it but it also has some disadvantages. The benefits of assisted suicide for the terminally ill individual are significant, even though the debates still raise questions about the responsibilities of the medical community. Being able to take a well

Physician Assisted Suicide

641 words - 3 pages ‘incurable’. Pulling into the hospital parting lot, you began to slide out of your car and notice he had been waiting in the lobby to take you into the family conference room, where you knew that every serious situation was discussed. Your mother’s doctor told you about your mothers questioning in physician-assisted suicide. If this was your situation, would you encourage your mother to go through with the physician-assisted suicide, otherwise know as

Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide

1424 words - 6 pages In current society, legalizing physician assisted suicide is a prevalent argument. In 1997, the Supreme Court recognized no federal constitutional right to physician assisted suicide (Harned 1) , which defines suicide as one receiving help from a physician by means of a lethal dosage (Pearson 1), leaving it up to state legislatures to legalize such practice if desired. Only Oregon and Washington have since legalized physician assisted

Physician Assisted Suicide

814 words - 3 pages physician-assisted suicide, a topic that has become an increasingly popular debate in America's changing healthcare policies. It is only legal in 5 out of 50 states. However, assisted suicide, or euthanasia, should be legalized in all 50 states because of its positive moral and economic effects.In a PEOPLE interview, Brittany Maynard explains, "My [cancer] is going to kill me, and it's a terrible, terrible way to die. So to be able to die with my

Physician Assisted Suicide

2555 words - 10 pages , regardless of the reason for hastening death, be denied assistance if sought after? The concept of physician-assisted suicide has been a topic of debate since the birth of medicine. Controversy even surrounds its name as the term “suicide” is associated with a form of mental illness and irrational behavior, both of which are to be prevented it if at all possible according to medical obligation (Quill and Greenlaw). Physician assisted death

physician assisted suicide

1655 words - 7 pages unconscious robbing the family and friends of a final goodbye. Physician assisted suicide would give them that chance, and die with dignity. Vital organs could be saved allowing you to save someone else’s life. There is long waiting list for all kinds of organs that could save the lives of others. If diseases run their full course those organs could be useless to help someone else. Do we have the right to put the needs of the living ahead of those

Physician Assisted Suicide - 800 words

800 words - 3 pages Should physicians be able to assist patients who are terminally ill end their lives? Physician assisted suicide is a very controversial subject. In today’s society, people who commit suicide are known as “insane,” a person who takes prescription pills is known as a “drug addict” or “criminal.” However, when a doctor honors a patient’s request for a lethal dose of medicine, (which the patient will inject themselves) to end their life in peace

Physician Assisted Suicide

986 words - 4 pages Is Physician-Assisted Suicide A Solution ?       Physician assisted suicide (PAS) is a very important issue. It is also important tounderstand the terms and distinction between the varying degrees to which a person can be involved in hastening the death of a terminally ill individual. Euthanasia, a word that is often associated with physician assisted suicide, means the act or practice of killing for reasons of mercy

Physician-Assisted Suicide

2223 words - 9 pages physician-assisted suicide should be their choice, we feel it should be legalized because: they don't want to go through the suffering caused by the illness they have. They fear the loss of their independence because they feel they become a burden to their family or friends. On the other hand those opposed to the issue of assisted suicide feel it goes against religious beliefs and common medical ethics. They also believe that there is always

Physician-Assisted Suicide

1007 words - 4 pages Is the role of a medical professional to ensure the well-being of their patients, or to assist them in ending their lives? Many people may believe that physicians would never perform the latter, but in actuality one practice does so. Physician assisted suicide is the intentional ending of one’s life brought on by lethal substances prescribed by a doctor. In the majority of cases, the patient is terminally ill and simply does not desire to live

Similar Essays

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay 1295 Words

1295 words - 5 pages William Rehquist stated this issue best when he said we are “engaged in an earnest and profound debate about the morality, legality and practicality of physician assisted suicide as it should in a democratic society”(Karim Paragraph 10). Cut to 2014 and over ten years later this issue has gained more momentum than ever, specifically in California after the California Compassionate Choices Act following the passing and implementation of The Dignity

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay 1108 Words

1108 words - 4 pages The practice of assisted suicide is not a modern phenomenon. In ancient Greece, the government gave hemlock to those who wanted it. William Shakespeare memorialized the Roman practice in Julius Caesar by depicting Brutus running into the sword held by Strato (Egendorf). While physician assisted suicide is not a new concept the moral debate surrounding euthanasia in America has certainly been brought to the forefront in the last thirty years with

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay 1559 Words

1559 words - 6 pages ”( ETHICAL DEBATE: On the horns of a dilemma.). People usually are unable to distinguish the physician-assisted suicide from the euthanasia. In fact, “assisted suicide differs from euthanasia, which is when someone other than the patient ends the patient's life as painlessly as possible out of mercy. Euthanasia may be active, such as when a doctor gives a lethal injection to a patient. It can also be passive, in cases where a physician doesn't

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay 624 Words

624 words - 2 pages commit physician-assisted suicide?" 1 April 2006. 9 Feb. 2007 .Newman, Ed. "Part Five - Making The Final Choice: Should Physician-Assisted Suicide Be Legalized?" 9 Feb 2007 ."Physician Assisted Suicide...The Continuing Debate." 9 Feb. 2007vtethicsnetwork.org/PAS.htm>.Pretzer, Michael. "Assisted suicide: Should it be legal?" 25 Jan. 2000. 9 Feb. 2007 .Willke, J.C., M.D. "Euthanasia". 9 Feb. 2007 .