This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Deception Behind Canada's Commercial Sealing

1233 words - 5 pages

For as long as humans lived in Atlantic and Northern Canada, seals were hunted for food, clothing, tools, and cultural customs. Seal hunts still take place off the Newfoundland coast, near the Magdalene Islands, the Northern Gulf of St. Lawrence, and Inuit regions every spring for rural communities and commercially to provide part-time employment for fishermen. Commercial hunts occurring only for money differ from traditional hunts and lack the respect for seals. Many individuals take offense to the gruesome sight of sealing, and in 2010 the European Union banned all seal product imports, excluding products from Aboriginal hunts, causing low demand in the seal market. Amidst the controversy, ...view middle of the document...

In an industry where the principal market is for fur, much of the other parts are rendered useless; the Memorial University of Newfoundland (2006) found that 80% of seal blubber is discarded, which is traditionally essential for Inuit meals. In addition, the competitive nature of the sealing industry makes the capture sloppier. By shooting in open water or clubbing on the edge of ice, wounded seals can slip into the ocean and become a complete waste—an average of 26 000 seals each year are struck and lost (Department of Fisheries and Oceans Canada [DFO] 2006). By claiming that the seal population is healthy, supporters of the commercial seal hunt exclude that it is an inefficient use of seal, a deep contrast to traditional sealing. Arguing that commercial sealing is just as environmental as traditional ways blurs the distinction between the two, but an analysis reveals their social differences as well.

Sealing in many Atlantic and Northern communities dates back to thousands of years, therefore it is crucial to keep the heritage alive. However, the Canadian Government argues that commercial sealing is essential to maintain “cultures [and] traditions” (as cited in CBC News 2013), which could not be further from the truth. Commercial duties involve killing the seal, sometimes skinning it, and then the animal is sent to a processing company and the sealer receives a paycheck. This is nothing like the traditional hunt that honours everything, not just the act of killing. Therefore a ban on the commercial hunt would not affect any traditions, but give peace to those concerned over its humaneness, an ongoing issue. As a response to criticism, in 2009 the Marine Mammal Regulations enacted a three-step process to kill seals that includes using a club, Hikapik, or rifle to stun, palpating the skull to ensure it is crushed, and draining the seal of blood so it is dead before cutting it open. However, the root cause of the EU ban is concern for the welfare of seals—video and picture evidence from a variety of organizations record sealers completely ignoring the three-step process. The DFO claims that the hunt is “tightly regulated”, but sealer Mark Small states “the DFO turns a blind eye to the activities taking place . . . there is no way [to] keep [work] up, do the job [they] want, and make sure that everything is carried out humanely” (as cited in Canada’s Commercial Seal Slaughter, 2009, p. 14-15). The slaughter of seals taking place not only generates controversy, but also creates a bad image—by claiming that commercial sealing is essential to keep heritage alive the Canadian Government improperly depicts traditional sealing as a slaughter. Banning the commercial hunt all together will satisfy the majority of Canadian’s that oppose...

Find Another Essay On The Deception Behind Canada's Commercial Sealing

Deception in Advertising Essay

1000 words - 4 pages gain profit in the end. Society considers deception as a relational transgression, which normally leads to betrayal and mistrust among individuals. Deception can take many forms that may include propaganda, dissimulation, distraction, concealment, camouflage and even self-deception (Carson, 2010). Advertising and Deception The most common form of deception is the use of misleading or false statements in commercial transactions. This is referred to

Canada's Multiculturalism and Its Benefits Essay

1364 words - 5 pages the most important ideas behind the Multicultural Policy is that all people are equal, and can participate as a member of society, regardless of racial, cultural, ethnic, or religious background. Multiculturalism strives to preserve people's cultural identity, while at the same time ensuring that common Canadian values are upheld (Reitz, 1980). Also Canada's policy on immigration has changed accordingly over the years, reflecting social values and

Seal Hunting in Atlantic Canada

1791 words - 7 pages . Complex socio-cultural relationships and behaviour with respect to the sharing of seal meat have been well documented in aboriginal populations of Eastern Canada (Wenzel 4). Contemporary dishes like seal flipper pie have also contributed to the cultural identity of Newfoundland society. As a result of these strong cultural ties, commercial and subsistence sealing continues to exist through legal policy by demand from both government and society

Who Killed King Duncan in William Shakespeare's Macbeth

933 words - 4 pages reaches the castle of Macduff. Macbeth and his soldiers butcher Macduff's wife and children. So sealing Macbeth's fate. Because of the time the play was written, maybe Macbeth represents a small part in King James Ist, James's wariness his distrusting manner, for it is common knowledge that after (and before) The Gunpowder Plot James always wore full armor under his clothes. The play is symbolically riddled with the

The Baby Boomers Boom Through the 21st Century

2231 words - 9 pages involving senior's lives, to senior clothing stores and products meant to ease the lives of the seniors as their biological, psychological, social and economic needs, and expectations shift (6). Without a doubt, Boomers continue to change the way society is revolutionising and changing, whether directly or indirectly.Other than the commercial changes that the baby-boomers have brought, their numbers have also had a toll on Canada's general trends

The Sale of Indian Textiles in Canada

6091 words - 24 pages denomination except Roman Catholic, have no religious affiliation at all. Diversity is the keynote of Canada's geography, which includes fertile plains suitable for agriculture, vast mountain ranges, lakes and rivers. Wilderness forests give way to Arctic tundra in the Far North. Canada has six time zones. The easternmost, in Newfoundland, is three hours and 30 minutes behind Greenwich Mean Time (GMT). The other time zones are the Atlantic, the Eastern

Panama Deception

1152 words - 5 pages The “Panama Deception,” directed by Barbara Trent of the Empowerment Project and narrated by actress Elizabeth Montgomery, observes a distinct failure to implement 20th-century democracy in Latin America in the late '80s and early '90s. More specifically, the film documents the U.S. invasion of Panama under "Operation Just Cause” during this period, showing how the cause was anything but just. Rather, the film shows how the Operation intended to

Ecommerce and Developing Nations

3832 words - 15 pages and recreate new ones; redefine new markets and transform relationships between business partners, competitors and customers.Within this report, I discuss Canada's current position in regards to information technology and their adoption of electronic commerce. Canadian industries are explored (manufacturing, resource-based and online pharmaceuticals), providing tangible evidence of the impact the Internet and e-commerce has on globalization

Business Law Assignment

1108 words - 4 pages potential or its hidden assets and liabilities. But in contemporary world the deception is very common and in everyday life every second human becomes a victim of some deceptive purchase or mislead purchase. Ideal rules of corporate law should be consistent. A rule barring deception might be expected to increase the ex ante value because customers would pay to eliminate the risk of conflict transactions at desired prices. Conversely, one could

A Peacekeeping Canada

615 words - 2 pages Traditionally, Canada's military has supported its powerful allies, defended the principle of democracy, and protected its trading partners. Since 1956, it has participated in United Nations peacekeeping and security operations.1990: Oka CrisisIn 1990, Mohawks living on the Kanesatake reserve in Quebec believed that some important ancestral lands of theirs would be taken over by a golf course. They erected a barricade, blocking access to the

Acts Of Deception In Twelfth Night

827 words - 4 pages another act of deception which shows the relationship between Malvolio and the residents of Olivia’s court. After a bad encounter with Malvolio ruining their fun; Sir Andrew, Sir Toby, Maria, and Feste plan a trick behind his back to shame him. Maria says, ‘‘The devil a Puritan he is\ For Monsieur Malvolio, let me alone with him. If I do not gull him into nayword, and make him a common recreation, do not think I have wit enough to lie straight in

Similar Essays

East Coast Canadian Fisheries Essay

2448 words - 10 pages Coast was started by the Canadian Aboriginals in Atlantic Canada who solely depended on the fish for their survival. Aboriginal fisherman in Canada fished for at least 11 000 years before the Europeans took over the industry. The aboriginals fished in many different locations and regions on Canada's east coast. This happened in part because Canada's Atlantic coastal geography ranges from place to place. It is rugged in Newfoundland and Labrador

Deception In Homer's The Odyssey Essay

1384 words - 6 pages Hiding behind a false identity or a false story is sometimes the easiest way to face difficult decisions. Some believe that, if they make others think something other than the truth, they will have an advantage and, in turn, be superior. Stephen Porter and John C. Yuille acknowledge that “deception is the deliberate misrepresentation of facts through words or actions” (450). Deception is a form of disguise used by humans to hide who they are

Online Essay

654 words - 3 pages Virtual Relationship Fraud 2.0 Introduction Deception is one of the most highly discussed terms within the modern day society; the awareness between deception and communication technology has raised many questions regarding deception and technology, also known as ‘digital deception’. Research Questions The questions this paper will research are societal issues concerned with deception and self-presentation. 1) How can the Internet facilitate

Financing The War In Afghanistan Essay

2475 words - 10 pages and consumption of goods and services and their management” {}. This concept is the fundamental principle behind economics and demonstrates how Canada is financing the Afghanistan mission. This report will demonstrate the economical significance of various financing ventures embarked by the Canadian administration’s financing of the war efforts and infrastructural projects. Through examining Canada’s military