This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Demotion Of Pluto From Planetary Status

1607 words - 7 pages

Elyse Aucoin
Professor David Smillie
HIST 1250
21 March 2014
The Demotion of Pluto from Planetary Status
“Pluto has been voted off the island” (Inman). In August of 2006 the celestial body was officially retitled a dwarf planet. The media’s portrayal of the demotion of Pluto began in 2006 and covered a broad variety of topics including the official ruling in Prague, the public’s reception of the decision, a book written by a scientist claiming sole responsibility for the demotion, and finally NASA’s most recent statement in 2012 regarding the dwarf planet. Media interest in Pluto’s demotion spiked twice, first in 2006 when Pluto was demoted to dwarf planet status with both supporters and detractors displayed in the media; in the following years interest waned significantly until the second spike arose in 2010 when Mike Brown published his book. In the 2010 the media presented to the public was strictly supporters. “Throw away the placemats. Grab a magic marker for the classroom charts. Take a pair of scissors to the solar system mobile…Pluto got its walking papers” (Overbye).
The ninth planet Pluto lost its planetary status when it did not “make the cut” after The International Astronomical Union collaborated in Prague to finalize the definition of the word planet. The International Astronomical Union decided that there are eight planetary bodies in Earth’s solar system and that Pluto should be categorized as a dwarf planet. Online newspaper articles from 2006, the year The International Astronomical Union met in Prague, up until 2012 emphasize how the demotion of Pluto was presented to the general public. The articles covered within this six year span emphasize the more scientific aspect of the media’s portrayal of Pluto’s demotion. This timeline begins with the official demotion of Pluto to dwarf planet status, followed by an article detailing the public’s immediate reaction, and continues until 2012 when NASA reaffirmed the original ruling.
In 2006 a group of astronomers met in the Czech city of Prague for what would become one of the most controversial recent decisions regarding astronomical science. A year prior to this meeting Mike Brown, a planetary scientist discovered a celestial object larger than Pluto which he unofficially named Xena. The controversy surrounding whether or not Xena would be officially deemed a planet sparked motivation to define a planetary body. A New York Times article published in 2006 states “Two years ago, the International Astronomical Union appointed a working group of astronomers to come up with a definition that would resolve this tension…This year a new group with broader roots led by Owen Gingerich of Harvard, took up this problem” (Overbye). The vote can in the Czech Republic can be summed up by William J. Kole who wrote for The Washington Post “Leading astronomers declared Thursday that Pluto is no longer a planet under historic new guidelines…After a tumultuous week of clashing over the essence of...

Find Another Essay On The Demotion of Pluto from Planetary Status

The Love Story of the Underworld God: Pluto

764 words - 4 pages of the maiden, he fell in love with her. Even though the girl was scared, she quickly understood what had happened and thanked the handsome god, who had saved her life and invited him to her home. From that day on, Pluto visited the girl, whose name was Ariana, every day, helping her around the house, walking with her from merchant to merchant, dancing with her on the festivals. As the weeks passed, his two brothers and his father saw the change


877 words - 4 pages Do women have equal rights as men? Can they balance their housework, take care of kids and work outside homes? Do men in our society always overshadow their existence? These questions came to my mind when I first thought about the changes in the status of women from ancient times to the women of today. Throughout history, most societies have held women in an inferior status compared to men. This situation was often justified as being the natural

The Role and Status of the Actor from Classical Greek to Medieval European Society

1487 words - 6 pages The Role and Status of the Actor from Classical Greek to Medieval European SocietyBy Alexander GriffinActors throughout the ages have had a raw deal, sometimes held in high esteem at other times driven underground by their native states who wish to silence them. However in ancient Greece actors were often looked upon as the most fundamental part of society and often formed their own guilds. They were tools of the state, Used to inform the

What are the Causes and Effects of Interactions Between the Solar Wind and Planetary Bodies?

3028 words - 12 pages creates a much greater aurora, the area of which is much larger than normal and is therefore visible from points much further from the poles.Physical Variations of Planetary MagnetosphereVariations in SizeOne reason for the difference in size is that as a planet gets further from the sun the solar plasma particle density that it encounters decreases by the inverse square of its distance. This means that further out, a weaker field can create a bigger

The Fleeting of Social Status

847 words - 3 pages Historically it has been viewed that one's place in society is fixed. This concept included the notion that not only was it impossible for one to move up in society, but also that it was difficult for one to move down the social ladder. The American dream, of course, promotes the idea that one can move up in the social ladder. However, many fail to realize that one can plummet from highest social class to the bottom, without even realizing how

The Roles of Socioeconomic Status

1350 words - 6 pages Julius Wilson was a sociologist that believes in Structural racism. The people in the structural underclass suffer from” joblessness reinforced by a social isolation and an improvised neighborhood.” They not only suffer from lower socioeconomic status, but minimal education, lack of opportunities and they further victimize a lack of community and safe guard about resources. The “underclass” defining a characteristic is the absence of a job of

current status of the philippines

898 words - 4 pages troubled with the lack of culture from the nation. They believed that the culture of foreigners was more important than the existing Filipino culture. This caused Filipinos to be discomfited to be Filipino. The traditional nation state reenables itself and initially creates new forms of modern social consciousness after being barged in on my the American Colonization. In the Filipino society, family connections are essential. In the philippines

The Changing Status of Women

1502 words - 6 pages The Changing Status of Women Women have played a huge role in society. Many people respect women for the simple fact that they bring life to every human that is put on earth and, without them, none of us would be here today. Although many people respect women, women believe that they have been treated unfairly in the past. I believe that women have been treated unfairly, but I also believe that women today have much better opportunities

The Status of Single Mothers

1715 words - 7 pages in changing a single mother’s status in society. Works Cited Chen, Martha; Vanek, Joann; Lund, Francie; Heintz, James; Jhabvala, Renana; Bonner, Christine (2005). Progress of the World’s Women 2005: Women, Work and Poverty. United Nations Development Fund for Women. pp. 36–57. Citron, Rodger D. "Charles Reich’s Journey From the Yale Law Journal to the New York Times BestSeller Lis." 2007/08. Web. 24 Feb. 2012.

The Status of Medical Marijuana

2321 words - 9 pages Medical Marijuana is a growing legalization movement throughout the United States consisting of 16 states and the Washington D.C area. This movement has grown immensely as a hot topic issue since 1996, when it began in California. The main issue behind Medical Marijuana results mainly from an ethical standpoint, yet this essay will refrain from discussing any morality and will strictly be structured through factual information. Arizona recently

Ultra-Orthodox Deviation from the Status Quo Agreement & Subsequent Discrimination

1719 words - 7 pages these sentiments. Ironically, whereas Ben-Gurion wrote the Status-Quo Agreement as a reluctant concession to the Ultra-Orthodox, many contemporary issues stem from the negligence of the Haredim in compromising with secular Jews and their desire to avoid the imposition of a more radical, Ultra-Orthodox culture. This document, which meant to unite secular and Ultra-Orthodox Jews in the establishment of Israel, provides the background of the modern

Similar Essays

Demotion Of Pluto Essay

1373 words - 6 pages The controversy of Pluto can be observed from two different perspectives, the scientific way and from the eyes of the public audience. Towards scientists despite that the solar system is exactly the same as it was in 2006, the demotion of Pluto resulted into a less vague definition of the word "Planet" and lead to a step forward in the life of science and technology. Although Pluto has many characteristics that make up a planet, it did not meet

Pluto, God Of The Underworld Essay

856 words - 4 pages wife, Proserpina, was the daughter of Jupiter and Ceres. Not only was she the queen of the Underworld, she was the goddess of spring. She unwillingly became his wife after he abducted her from a field and she ate the food of marriage while in the Underworld, the pomegranate seed (Wickersham 122). Proserpina didn’t like the Underworld, even though Pluto was generous enough to dedicate a section of it to her. The Underworld was divided into three

Pluto´S Ideals From The Republic Essay

1635 words - 7 pages the philosopher king no longer is needed for the “ideal” city to it run. The “Theory of forms” is taught in Plato’s “allegory of the cave”, a thought experiment which makes his point from a real world scenario. He wants us to imagine humans in the conditions of enslavement to the extent that we cannot move and what we can only see are images of everyday objects: pencils, books, tables, letters, etc. What the people, in this condition, are

Informative Speech: The History Of Pluto

1363 words - 6 pages , Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune, Pluto. Apparently now teachers teach it as, “My Very Educated Mother Just Served Us Nachos”. Come on what happened to pies, personally I prefer pies over nachos. Thesis Statement: With the advances in technology, scientist have opened the door to the discovery of Pluto, however from its discovery to current day Pluto has gone from being a planetary object in the sky to the loss of its planetary status, resulting in