This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Demystification Of The Freedmen's Bureau

1252 words - 5 pages

The role of the Freedmen Bureau in African-American development during the Reconstruction era has been a polarizing topic since the Bureau’s inception. While most concur that the Bureau was well intended, some scholars, believe that the Freedmen’s Bureau was detrimental to African-American development. One such scholar was W.E.B. Dubois, who in his book The Souls of Black Folk, expressed his discontent with the actions of the Bureau and suggested that the Bureau did more harm than good. Upon further probing, research refutes the position that the Freedmen’s Bureau was chiefly detrimental to Black development. While far from flawless in its pursuits to assist the newly freed Negroes, the actions of the Freedmen’s Bureau did not impede African-American progress; instead, these actions facilitated African-American development.
The Bureau for Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands, more commonly known as the Freedmen’s Bureau, was created with the passage of the Freedmen’s Bureau Act on March 3, 1865 (United States). The bill, which was supported by Abraham Lincoln as well as Radical Republicans in Congress, faced a great deal of opposition from Southern states and passed with only a two vote majority (Dubois). The bill is intentionally vague in order to allow leniency in its implementation. The flexibility provided by refraining from outlining specific programs was intended to benefit the freedmen by allowing the program to mold and fit his needs (Colby).
Though flexibility in the Freedmen’s Bureau allowed the Bureau to attempt to solve many different problems, Dubois found fault with all sections of the Freedmen’s save the education sector. Dubois labeled the Bureau, “ one of the most singular and interesting of the attempts of a great nation to grapple with the vast problems of race and social condition” (Dubois). While Dubois did take issue with the Bureau, his concerns appear rooted in personal rather than substantive causes.
Analyzing the other opinions voiced in The Souls of Black Folk provides more insight into why Dubois was not fond of the Bureau. Dubois’s views on classical education and the progress of African-American race correlate with his views on the Freedmen’s Bureau. Thoughts expressed in The Souls of Black Folk promote distinctly anti-agrarian ideas. Dubois opposed the redistribution of land to freedmen because he felt that it would create a “Black peasant proprietor” (Dubois). This belief contrasted with the beliefs of the majority of freedmen, who dreamed of the forty acres acres and a mule. Because of their slave heritage, freedmen tended to support the agrarian lifestyle. For the large majority of freedmen, being able to own and work their own land was the ultimate goal (Abbot 150-151); however, Dubois believed that classical education and not farm work was the key to progress for African-American race (Dubois). Dislike for a reversion to a life of agriculture also fueled Dubois’s disdain for contracted labor as well....

Find Another Essay On The Demystification of the Freedmen's Bureau

The Font Bureau, Inc Essay

763 words - 4 pages The Font Bureau in a privately held company that was founded in 1989 by publication designer and media strategist Roger Black, and internationally known type designer David Berlow. David Berlow entered the type industry in 1978 as a letter designer for several respected type foundries. He is a member of the New York Type Directors Club and the Association Typographique International and remains active in typeface design. Based in Boston

The Census Bureau Essay

917 words - 4 pages opposed to white collar; and that women are the majority in manager roles with their profession. This would explain some of the spending habits of these individuals as being simplistic and not maintained on material items. The material from the Census Bureau is outdated. Therefore, the data is not useful. However, if it were maintained, I think it would be useful for many observations; but the information is overwhelming and confusing. The material

Emancipation and the Freedmen’s Bureau

2781 words - 11 pages congress passed the Freedmen's Bureau Bill. This bill initiated by President Lincoln, and passed in March 1865 was the cornerstone of the Freedmen's Bureau. The new bureau was overseen by the War Department, and its first commissioner was Union General Oliver O. Howard. Howard was tasked with the challenge of; helping freedmen locate work, making sure they received a basic education, settling disputes, ensuring they received adequate compensation

Farm Bureau Leading the Challenge

993 words - 4 pages general farm organization, and the voice of agriculture. Most people would think however that Farm Bureau can’t be that big, but Farm Bureau actually has over six million member families across the country and in Puerto Rico. Statistics show that three out of every four people involved in a farm organization actually belong to Farm Bureau. One of the main reasons so many people want to be a part of Farm Bureau is because Farm Bureau is a

The Debate Regarding the Freedman's Bureau

1049 words - 4 pages The Debate Regarding the Freedman's Bureau Historians and political theorists have delineated the concept of equality into two categories: the competitive individualist notion of equality of process and the egalitarian ideal of equality of results. The former is concerned with providing a level playing field for all, while the latter focuses on a just distribution resulting from the process. Richard Ellis, in his book American Political

SHORT STORY : THE FREEDMEN ‘S BUREAU

931 words - 4 pages In the years following the Civil War, the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands (the Freedmen's Bureau) provided assistance to tens of thousands of former slaves and impoverished whites in the Southern States and the District of Columbia. The war had liberated nearly four million slaves and destroyed the region's cities, towns, and plantation-based economy. It left former slaves and many whites dislocated from their homes

The History of and Employment with the Federal Bureau of Investigations

1519 words - 7 pages so did the rate of crime. Thus, the Federal Bureau of Investigations was formed. “In July 1935, the FBI was given its official name. Ever since, they’ve had their hands full with tough cases. At any given moment the FBI is on the lookout for 12,000 fugitives!” (Ramaprian 11). The nation needed an investigative team that could solve very extensive crimes. This group was also given the ability to solve crimes that crossed the state lines. Since

The American Reputation for Fair Play, by Victor Rauly Haya de la Torre and the Federal Bureau of Narcotics

1089 words - 4 pages Response Paper Reaction to “The American Reputation for Fair play:” Victor Raul Haya de la Torre and the Federal Bureau of Narcotics Victor de la Haya was once a celebrated Peruvian politician. He is remembered primarily as an advocate for democracy and workers' rights in Peru. Haya was often viewed as a great political reformer, who tried very hard to change the way the country was governed. In 1923, Haya is most known for establishing the

WATER RESOURCE CONSERVATION IN HEADWATER AREA FUNDED BY A CITY: THE A CENTURY- LONG CASE STUDY OF YOKOHAMA WATERWORKS BUREAU FOREST AND DOSHI VILL

1275 words - 6 pages After implementing the FMP, planting and cutting were greatly dropped. Figure 5 shows cutting volume. Harvesting fuelwood in the coppice forest already stopped in 1960’s. Coppice forest is mainly composed of some kinds of oaks, and is regenerated with fresh shoots from the stumps of trees after harvesting fuelwood is done. And both coniferous and broad leafed timber declined around 1990. Planting area followed almost the same trends. After 1995

The Tale of the Heike

1055 words - 4 pages this. Shigehira declared “I was not acting of my own free will when I committed my grave sins; I was merely trying to do my duty. Who that lives can spurn an imperial command?” Regardless of what was commanded the warrior was obligated to obey. Director of the Military Stores Bureau Yorimasa confirms this decree when he is ordered to restrain an invisible monster. Yorimasa reported “from the old, the mission of warriors posted to the court

The History of the FBI

1300 words - 5 pages and 30's was a time of great criminal activity with prohibition in full force.Gangsters were having great success's because there crimes were federal in nature, but under local jurisdiction. There was limited success in going after people like Al Capone and the KKK. In 1924 Hoover was appointed to head the Bureau, by this time there were about 650 employees with 441 of them being special agents that worked out of field offices in nine different

Similar Essays

A History Of The Freedmen's Bureau

2290 words - 10 pages : Oxford University Press, 1999. Cox, LaWanda. 1958. "The Promise of Land for the Freedmen.” Mississippi Valley Historical Review 45, no. 3: 413-440. America: History and Life with Full Text, EBSCOhost (accessed April 17, 2014). Freedmen's Bureau Records: W. Storer How to Orlando Brown, January 8,1866. The Valley of the Shadow. http://valley.lib.virginia.edu/papers/B1159 (accessed on April 17, 2014). Freedmen's Bureau Records: W. Storer How to Orlando

The Federal Bureau Of Investigation Essay

2005 words - 8 pages The Federal Bureau of Investigation The agency now known as the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) was founded in 1908 when Attorney General Charles J. Bonaparte appointed an unnamed force of Special Agents to be the investigative force of the Department of Justice (DOJ). Prior to that time, DOJ borrowed Agents from the U.S. Secret Service to investigate violations of federal criminal laws within its jurisdiction. By order of Attorney

The Federal Bureau Of Investigation Fbi

1086 words - 4 pages To uphold the law through the investigation of violations offederal criminal law; to protect the U.S. from foreign intelligenceand terrorist activities; to provide leadership and law enforcementassistance to federal, state, local, and international agencies; andto perform these responsibilities in a manner that is responsive tothe needs of the public and is faithful to the constitution of theU.S.: this is the mission of the Federal Bureau of

The Bureau Of Labor Statistics: Coffee Prices

1167 words - 5 pages The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), strives to provide interested parties with clear and precise information regarding the US economy through the measurement of working conditions, activities in the labor market and changes in the prices of goods and services. As such, the people it intends to serve is the vast American republic and those specifically interested in learning about emerging issues and trends of the economy. Since the agency