The Desire To Die: Suicide And Euthanasia In The Elderly

1894 words - 8 pages

Mrs. Jones, 78 years old, arrived in the emergency department (ED) via ambulance. She was alert and oriented, but was having episodes of lost consciousness. She was put on the cardiac monitor and her vital signs were obtained. Her cardiac rhythm was normal. Her vital signs were as follows: Temperature 97.3°F, Pulse 43, respirations 26, blood pressure 100/58 and O2 saturation of 94% on room air. Additionally, Mrs. Jones was vomiting and had 2 loose, incontinent stools. She was pale, cool to touch and diaphoretic. Auscultation of her lungs revealed expiratory wheezes.

Her brother reported finding her in her living room on the couch. He reported that she was difficult to rouse, and becoming concerned, he called 911. Prior to the ambulance arriving, Mrs. Jones vomited several times and her brother noted a significant amount of partly dissolved pills in the emesis. Upon checking her medicine cabinet, he found several prescription bottles empty and some over the counter medications open in the cabinet. He brought these medication bottles to the ED. Poison control was contacted and they recommended giving her activated charcoal to absorb the medications. The charcoal was offered and Mrs. Jones refused, stating that she wanted no treatment and had attempted to kill herself for a reason.

Upon speaking to her brother, it was learned that her husband had died about one year earlier and that she had several new diagnoses in the last few months; including: Diabetes mellitus, anorexia (with marked weight loss), sleep disturbances, and mild dementia. She had been having difficulty with the management of these new illnesses and was still grieving for her husband.

Because it was an attempted suicide, a crisis management team was called to assist with the case. The doctor went in and spoke to the patient and she still refused all treatment. A discussion of what to do then followed. Legally the ED staff could force treatment on her because emergency, life sustaining care does not require consent. This is true after a suicide even if the patient refuses care. But, the question was: Should they try to force care on this woman? If nothing was done she would most likely die, but there wasn't a lot that could be easily forced upon her without causing harm. How could you force her to drink the charcoal? When the crisis team arrived they went directly into the patient's room. They tried to persuade her to accept treatment, but could not.

The team decided to allow the brother to speak to her to see if he could persuade her. While the brother was speaking with Mrs. Jones, she lost consciousness. Poison control was again consulted and they recommended a stomach lavage and suctioning for the unconscious patient. This was performed. Blood was also drawn to check the levels of the various meds she had taken. The results of these tests showed dangerously high levels of Physostigmine, a cholinergic, and atropine was given to treat this toxicity.


Find Another Essay On The Desire to Die: Suicide and Euthanasia in the Elderly

Assisted Suicide and the right to die

1418 words - 6 pages really knowing what they requested for. Although in the article Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: attitudes and experiences of oncology patients, oncologists, and the public Ezekiel stated that “patients with depression and psychological distress were significantly more likely to have seriously discussed hoarded drugs” (Emanuel). In making this comment Ezekiel is arguing that the patients know what they are requesting regardless of the drugs

Euthanasia, the right to die Essay

909 words - 4 pages by Steinbeck, there are examples of euthanasia. Candy and his dog were together since the dog was a pup. One of the farm hands pointed out that the dog was no good to himself. The dog was old and would surely die a slow death. Knowing this, Candy agreed to let the man shoot the dog in the back of the head so the dog would die without feeling a thing.' 'I don't see no reason for it,' said Carlson. He went to his bunk, pulled his bag from

Suicide The Right to Die

1512 words - 6 pages criticism and attacks on personal safety similar to those involved in the acts of abortion. Arguments against Assisted Suicide Legalization begins a process that will inevitably lead to involuntary, active euthanasia of patients who may or may not be terminally ill. Legalization will subject the elderly, disabled or others who are disenfranchised in our society to bow to social pressures to die in order to relieve social, economical, and emotional

Euthanasia: We Have the Right to Die

1056 words - 4 pages ventilator is needed. They patient has the option of accepting or refusing the treatment. The patient could say to take off the ventilator and will eventually die, but it would take longer and would be more painful. It would have been better to have active euthanasia, where the death would have been quicker and painless. The patient wouldn’t have to suffer in agony for so long. The doctor is still taking an action that will cause the patient to die

Euthanasia and Doctor-Assisted Suicide - The Will to Live

605 words - 2 pages Euthanasia and the Will to Live   The denial of food and fluids to Terri Schindler-Schiavo, the 36 year old Florida woman in a vegetative state since a heart attack, has caused Americans to ponder the fact that any one of them could be in this woman's place for a variety of reasons, like an auto accident, fall, mishap, etc. And most Americans don't want to be treated by their family as Terri is being treated by her husband - being denied

Euthanasia: The Right for the Right to Die

1681 words - 7 pages sophisticated as it is now, much like the western frontier of the United States in the late 19th century. In 400 B.C. medicinal practices would seem like torture today, the people that underwent euthanasia back then no doubt suffered a great amount. Many people were given poison to ingest, which would essentially eat and dissolve their organs.During the 1300's England considered suicide and any assistance of another's suicide a crime and was punishable. The

Euthanasia Essay: The AMA and Assisted Suicide

926 words - 4 pages The AMA and Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide      The American Medical Association (AMA) has long been known for its strong views. As the issue of euthanasia, particularly doctor-assisted suicide, has come to the forefront, the AMA has taken a strong position on this controversial subject also. This time the AMA has taken a firm stand for preserving, not terminating, the life of the elderly/handicapped/depressed/mentally ill, etc. patient. This

Euthanasia: We All Have the Right to Die

1482 words - 6 pages Physician-Assisted Suicide, or Euthanasia, is a serious issue, and it affects people throughout all walks of life. From teenagers with angst, to older adults feeling hopeless in their life, to the elderly suffering from terminal illnesses, suicide pervades throughout their thought processes as an alternative to their emotionally and physically pervasive situations. Euthanasia, or physician-assisted suicide, has a history dating back to the

Assisted Suicide: Do You Have The Right to Die?

814 words - 4 pages child's death to prevent them from living with pain. There are people however that may argue that giving parents power to determine if their child should die leaves room for some exploitation and for some parents to “rid themselves of burdensome offspring.” It is doubtful as cases like these have not appeared when dealing with the elderly or disabled in the jurisdictions that allow these methods. In 1992, there was the “Baby K” case. An infant was

This essay deals with the idea of euthanasia and suicide

479 words - 2 pages Euthanasia and assisted suicide are two controversial issues. People are against both of the subjects, euthanasia in particular. There are many reasons that doctors should stop performing Euthanasia. One major reason is that it is morally wrong. Another reason is that the patient could get better. The last of the three major reasons is that the doctor performing might not get taken seriously.The first reason to talk about is that it is morally

Euthanasia Essay - Assisted Suicide and the Supreme Court

1568 words - 6 pages doors. Instead it recognized that the debate belongs at the state level where the realities can be fully and honestly addressed. Now, with their resounding defeat from the Supreme Court, assisted suicide advocates are forced to take their case before the court of public opinion where they are losing support.   During the last year, national support for euthanasia has fallen 18 percentage points. In l996, 75 percent of Americans said they

Similar Essays

Euthanasia: A Controversial Issue Paper Dealing With Whether Or Not People Have The Right To Choose To Die. This Paper Is In Support Of Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide

1257 words - 5 pages Euthanasia has come to represent either an active or passive termination ofa person's life, in modern-day usage. (Outerbridge, 95) "It is estimatedthat more than five thousand people die each year in the Netherlandsthrough active euthanasia." (Outerbridge, 96) "The guidelines under which aphysician can perform euthanasia are narrowly drawn. First, the patientmust be competent. Second, the patient must request euthanasia persistentlyover time

To Die Or Not To Die, Euthanasia In The U.S

1666 words - 7 pages individual (National Right to Life Committee, 1997). Euthanasia is described as intentionally killing someone who declares a desire for death. We most commonly witness the desire to die in terminally ill cancer patients. A majority of these patients have suffered and undergone countless attempts to lengthen their lives, but the sad truth is that a majority of cancer patients don't survive for a long desired amount. The cost of treatment is

Euthanasia And Aging: The Right To Die

1961 words - 8 pages Euthanasia: Is it a Right?It is time to take your head out of the sand and look at the subject of euthanasia. Many people are for it when it comes to people of elderly years. Many are against it for anyone. There are still more who look the other way and hope someone will decide the issue for them. It is against the law in most of America. It is legal in the Netherlands, Switzerland, and Oregon, USA. Should we head toward a universal law on this

The Right To Die In Assisted Suicide

2878 words - 12 pages fearless to help his patients even though he was misunderstood by many. As far as I am concerned, it is very sad when patients who suffer from unbearable pains cannot make the final decision in their lives – to die at the appointed time. My grandmother had Parkinson’s disease and one of her symptoms was tremor – shaking; she could feel the nerves twitching all the time, from head to toe. She requested to physicians with assisted suicide