The Devine Command Theory Essay

1035 words - 5 pages

In this essay, I will examine and assess the Divine Command Theory. The theory will first be summarized. Then I will state the theory’s strengths and what makes it worth examining. Lastly, I will cover the flaws and weaknesses of the theory.
The Divine Command Theory is the idea that what makes an action wrong or right is the command of God. Therefore, an action is morally obligatory if God commands it is right. An action is morally wrong if God commands it is wrong. Lastly, an action is only optional if God doesn’t command it or forbid it. Morality is commanded by God independently of what we think is right or wrong. For instance, if God commands that murder is wrong, than it is wrong only because God commands it is wrong. If he commands that donating to charity is right, it is only right because of his will.
The Divine Command Theory has more arguments against it than for it. However, it is strongly favored by the religious, while also being opposed by many religious people. The argument from divine supremacy is the main argument that is used to promote this theory. It states that everything is dependent on the will of God. Therefore, morality in turn is dependent on God’s will.
The argument from objectivity of morality also advocates the Divine Command Theory. It states that moral standards are objective, separate from all culture’s judgment. It also states that they’re universal. Thus, morality can only be objective and universal if it depends on the commands of God. In response, morality is solely dependent on God’s commands.
While both these theories have something of value, they both hold flaws. The theory from divine supremacy, while being agreed upon within many religions, makes several significant assumptions. For instance, even if the assumption that God actually exists is true, it is a giant step to say that everything has to depend on God’s will. If this is the case, the only things that would need to depend on God’s will could depend on God’s will. This means that if something wasn’t dependent on his will, there is no reason it should. With all that said, there is also the fact that God’s own existence could not possibly depend on his will and neither could the existence of his will.
The argument from objectivity of morality has similar flaws. Firstly, God’s will does not necessarily secure the objectivity of morality. Despite universality, morality still could depend on someone else’s will. Secondly, there are also several other theories that state that morality is universal and objective. Utilitarianism and Kant’s moral theory display this trait as well.
The arguments of the Divine Command Theory might not hold up very well, but that does not mean they are false. That being said, the objections for the theory are quite significant. The most obvious objection is that the theory is based solely on the existence of God. That is a rather large assumption to make. If God does in fact exist, it is just as possible...

Find Another Essay On The Devine Command Theory

Prejudice in the School Systems and How to Fix It

1584 words - 7 pages that as long as a stereotype exist, prejudice will follow” (Devine, 1989, pg6). Stereotypes and personal beliefs are completely independent cognitive structures, therefore influencing different behaviors toward individuals of other ethnicities or race (Devine, 1989). Exposure to stereotyping and prejudice, while transitioning through childhood and into later stages, is what causes the atomization of these attitudes (Devine, 1989). Gordon

An essay on john Locke

1413 words - 6 pages perceiving higher than ourselves might be a thing of question rather than fact), it was the shift from conventional to individual morals that allows for Locke’s approach to seem so ideal. The purpose of this essay will be to analyze Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding and determine how individualism is portrayed in this work (Locke). The conclusion is that Locke’s prose indicates that he endorses the idea of individualism through his theory of

Exposition and Critique of Divine Command Theory

853 words - 4 pages This essay will explain and critique divine command theory. First, divine command theory will be defined. Second, two key arguments for divine command theory will be described. Third, criticisms will be raised against cultural relativism. Last, a final assessment of divine command theory will be given. To fully understand the overview of divine command theory six key categories outline the basic principles of this ethical theory. The six

Spring Assignment

1017 words - 5 pages present (Smith & Mackie 2007; Hewstone et al 2009). Studies carried out to test this idea use a process called priming, which is where “activating one stimulus facilitates the subsequent processing of another related stimulus (Hewstone et al 2009), Devine (1989) uses this, argued that individuals cannot avoid the automatic stereotype, and this idea is supported by Bargh (1999). However, Blair (2002) argues that automatic stereotypes and prejudice

Command Terms

698 words - 3 pages answer without explanation or calculation. Command terms associated with assessment objective 2: Application and analysis Analyse Break down in order to bring out the essential elements or structure. Apply Use an idea, equation, principle, theory or law in relation to a given problem or issue. Distinguish Make clear the differences between two or more concepts or items. Explain Give a detailed account including reasons or causes

Existence of God, Morality and Religion - Religious Studies - Assignment

1396 words - 6 pages , justice and truth; thus these were the moral principals that every Egyptian had to follow by her command.. Many religions today follow a similar system. Followers are taught Devine rules bequeathed by their God which teaches them right from wrong or a moral guidance system. When we examine these types of divine commandants be it Judaism, Christianity, Islam, we often find parallelisms between the two. It is also worth noting that we can also find

Divine Command Theory

674 words - 3 pages In order to understand divine command theory we must first understand the nature of God and Morality. So we will start by taking a look at what makes an action moral. Once we understand what makes an action moral, we can then try to understand the author's’ viewpoint on the divine command theory of ethics. Understanding the viewpoint will allow us to dissect the author’s viewpoints and come up with counter-arguments that the author must then

Social Phenomenon and attitudes - University 1st year - Assignment

1647 words - 7 pages society around them. One type of theory that supports the statement above are consistency theories. These types of theories look at how the individual will feel the need for consistency in life. An individual would want to be consistent with their attitudes with themselves as well as with the people around them otherwise they will feel uncomfortable. ("Theories of Attitude Change", 2017) For instance, the Balance Theory proposed by Fritz Heider

The Abortion Debate

1818 words - 7 pages is cut within the womb for the baby to be killed before birth. Partial birth abortion is when the doctor causes a breech birth so the baby’s head is the last thing left in the birth canal and the back of the skull of the fetus is punctured with fully open scissors. ("Surgical Abortions.") Natural Law Theory and the Catholic Church share views on the topic of abortion. According to this theory, abortion is morally wrong because one should

GOd and Morality

1664 words - 7 pages to God is just a pure assumption that is easily demolished, in a traditional discussion for the "Devine command theory" Joseph Ellin in his book, "Morality and the Meaning of Life" discusses this Theory, he debates using a concept first used by G.W Leibniz "discourse on Metaphysics" that states; If the Divine Command Theory were true, then the Ten Commandments could have gone something like this: "Thou shall kill everyone you dislike. Thou shall

The Development of the Cold War in Europe after 1945

2131 words - 9 pages up the military strength of the Soviet Union', with the first nuclear test carried out in 1949.[10] This reinforced the theory of the West that Stalin was proving to be an aggressive leader that appeared to be a direct threat to Western democracies. Churchill suggested that nuclear capabilities should be withheld, even within the United Nations, remaining in the capable hands of the Western alliance; Britain, the United

Similar Essays

How Should Theists Interpret The Abraham And Isaac Story? Is This Story An Endorsement Of Divine Command Theory? Or Does It Undermine Divine Command Theory? Or Does It Neither Endorse Nor Undermine...

2122 words - 8 pages Jake Radowski How should Theists interpret the Abraham and Isaac story? Is this story an endorsement of divine command Theory? OR does it undermine Divine Command theory? OR does it neither endorse nor undermine Divine Command TheoryThe biblical story of Abraham and Isaac presents an interesting analogy for those of the belief in Divine Command Theory (which I will refer to in shorthand of [DCT]) while also providing a jump off for which

The Euthyphro Dilemma Vs. The Divine Command Theory Two Theories Explaining Moral Behavior Explored

1104 words - 4 pages The divine command theory is the idea that moral actions are those that conform to God's will. For example, murder is wrong because God condemns it. Using this theory, there is a test for determining whether any action is right or wrong: if it conforms to God's will, it is morally permissible, but if it does not, then it is impermissible. This seems very simple. However, the theory breaks down when the will of God is examined. This is the reason

Magistrates Of Morality: How The Euthyphro Dilemma Cripples Divine Command Theory

2020 words - 8 pages Throughout human history, the topic of theology has been a central aspect of everyday life. A common denominator of all modern-day religions is that they provide a set of rules which one is to follow in order to live as a good, moral being. When a deity (or a group of deities) commands followers to abide by specific moral standards though a vehicle such as prophets, religious texts or otherwise, this is called Divine Command Theory (DCT). Those

Capital Punishment Should Be Abolished: Views Shared Between Utilitarians, Egalitarians, Altruists And Supporters Of The Divine Command Theory

852 words - 3 pages the victim's family." All of these reasons prove to either be wrong or not fully supported. Morally, it is a continuation of the cycle of violence and degrades all who are involved in its enforcement, as well as its victim.Someone who supports the Divine Command Theory, or someone who believes solely in God's will, would say that capital punishment is wrong for a couple of reasons. The first reason is that executing someone is a lot like "playing