This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Dichotomy Between Sanity And Insanity In Durrenmatt's The Visit And Dorfman's Death And The Maiden

1086 words - 4 pages

A sane state of mind is generally associated with serenity and an individuals’ ability to decipher between iniquities and make sound judgment. However, in Frrederich Durrenmatt’s The Visit and Ariel Dorfman’s Death and the Maiden, a paradoxical dichotomy of sanity derived from a perceived insane state is revealed. Although these two plays differ in plot, they both present a common theme of vengeance sought by a seemingly fanatical female protagonist. Death and the Maiden exposes Paulina Salas as a tortured and raped blindfolded woman that years later believes she recognizes her capturer. In The Visit, similar Claire Zachanaishann wishes to render justice years later for the grievance delivered to her by her lover; Ill. The two plays demonstrate the conflicting dichotomy between insanity and sanity and the related irony of the gain of consciousness through the loss of sanity. Durrenmatt reveals this through an alcohol motif representing intoxication while Dorfamn uses the theme of memory in Paulina’s experience to reveal the ambiguous nature of sanity.The alcohol motif in The Visit is present in all relation dealing with morality. The blind pair Koby and Loby reveals that they had been bribed by Ill with a pit of brandy to lie in court and testify that they had impregnated Claire instead of Ill. As a later consequence Claire seeks revenge and “blinds and castrates” them (Durrenmatt 38). It is in this condition that they are brought back into the town of Guellen to re iterate the truth. Ironically is as the “blind” pair that they confess the truth (Durrenmatt 25). Blindness connotes the loss of ones ability of sight and an associated impaired judgment; however ironically Durrenmatt displays that as one is drawn closer to a senseless state he ironically is more susceptible to gain consciousness and reveal the truth. However, the more active participation of the alcohol motif and its consequential affect on the consciousness of man is through the school master’s confession on the injustice of the town. Following Claire’s offer of a million dollar in return for Ill’s death and as a retribution for her suffering, the leaders unanimously disagreed. Conversely, they suddenly start indulging in expensive “cognac” (Durrenmatt 44). Consequently, they are drunk and such intoxication is associated with impaired moral and physical sense, or an approach toward insanity. Durrenmatt however reveals the paradoxical nature of the dichotomy of sanity and insanity through the school master’s confession of admitting to the cruel intentions of the town. As an inebriated man he admits of the misdeeds and gluttony of the townsmen as well acknowledges that “ one day an old lady will come for [them] too and what happened to [ill] will happen to [them]” ( Durrenmatt 77). This wisdom is ironically only exposed when he is the most deranged mental state as he admits that “soon perhaps in a few...

Find Another Essay On The Dichotomy Between Sanity and Insanity in Durrenmatt's The Visit and Dorfman's Death and the Maiden

Significance of memory for Paulina in Death and the Maiden

1045 words - 5 pages of retrieval, this stored memory is then recalled by the brain and this is when an individual remembers something. In Ariel Dorfman’s 1990 play Death and the Maiden, memory serves to be the central theme based on which the rest of the play develops. The play is set right after the fall of General Augusto José Ramón Pinochet Ugarte’s regime in Chile in March 11, 1990. During Pinochet’s regime, Chile experienced the worst of horrors at the hands

Questioning Sanity And Insanity Essay

2518 words - 10 pages Questioning sanity and insanity Medea: A 5th Century Play written by Euripides Is Medea sane? What is the difference between insanity and sanity? The pressing question is what can one consider sanity at all. Truly is anyone sane or insane or is it just how everyone views someone else to judge them accordingly, well lets suppose one could find out by taking a perspective look at Medea, the person herself and how she develops the role of what

Death and the Maiden: The Effects of Chilian Dictatorship

1474 words - 6 pages (continue) the advice(council) of his(her,your) husband: " it(he,she) allows that the past should turn into past; we will assume and follow(continue) it forward ". Maybe this it is the first fruit of the pardon: to get rid of this asphyxiating rope that ties us to the past and that does not leave us to live through the present. In the pardon there is a construction indeed between(among) two persons, because of it, the pardon has to be an individual

Immortality And Resurrection: The Dichotomy Between Thought and Physicality

1820 words - 7 pages and life after death. The perspective of a dichotomy between the body and the spirit seems to be further proven by the parapsychological work Hick relies on to prove the possibility of life after death. Whether or not they are actually true evaluations of life after death is irrelevant, rather that they do not show just cause for an immortality of a psychophysical person. In the cases referenced, the psychic or telepath did not actually project a

The Connection Between Creativity and Insanity

1291 words - 6 pages ). This quote shows her development in to madness by the creative description the narrator gave about the yellow wallpaper. The relationship between creativity and madness are closely tie together because the narrator only thinks about the yellow wallpaper, with what it signifies, which drives her to complete madness. Back in the 19th century prisons were used to isolate murderers and writers with mental disorders. Zott said “Writer of the early 19th

The Sanity in Violence in Thelma and Louise

3098 words - 12 pages between men and women in terms of what both genders are able/expected to do, in terms of personal characteristics, actions, and lifestyles. “Feminism allows women to step outside their culturally created gender roles and take on a lifestyle that is not traditionally "female", and thus allows for the freedom of choice,” ( Lanouette). This is feminism at its core: the power of choice and individuality free from gender norms and cultural expectations

Insanity: A Separation between the Ordinary and the Extraordinary

1423 words - 6 pages until the one night that she completely snaps. Being inferior, she cannot handle her consumption. Becoming frantic she shouts of how Rodya is coming, that he has to becoming, and for that reason but of course he must. In her raving, like a mechanical device malfunctioning her being unsettled becomes illness, she dies a pathetic death do to insanity as an ordinary person. It is easy to compared Katerina Ivanova with Pulcheria

Dichotomy Between Theory and Practice in Education

1118 words - 4 pages The interaction between “theory” and “practice” in education is a dichotomy that people have been trying to understand for over 2,000 years. The relationship between theorists and practitioners is very complicated because there are issues that surround the pace of change in theory and practice. The debates that have occurred continue to occur through today in an array of perspectives about the purpose of education and about how to encourage

Doll House and The Visit

787 words - 4 pages In the “The Doll House” by Henrik Ibsen and “The Visit” by Friedrich Durrenmatt the protagonist, Nora and Claire use their marriage with or without love for materialism to benefit themselves. Ibsen observes the consequences of stereotypical role of couples in marriage and presents how the Nora regains her strength and self-respect. Nora used money to save her husbands life but she also did it to because she felt dependent on similarly as how the

The Dichotomy and the Development of the Early Childhood Education and Care Services in Australia

1905 words - 8 pages children progress to evaluate the outcome of the many different type of early childhood program. The reasons of National Quality framework is the agreement between all Australian government to work together to get the better education and development outcome for children in early childhood education and care service. (Australian Children's Education and Care Quality Authority (ACECQA), 2011-2014). National Quality Framework include a national

The Hinckley Trial and the Insanity Defense

1237 words - 5 pages Trial of Murder or claims of Insanity What does the term "insanity" mean? A mental illnesses which are so severe and debilitating that prevents a person from functioning in a lawful socially acceptable manner. (google.com) A little history about psychiatric hospitals and how things were handled in the past. “The nation's first two psychiatric hospitals opened in the late-1700s. Eastern State Hospital in Williamsburg, Va. opened Oct. 12, 1773

Similar Essays

The Visit And Death And The Maiden 12th Essay

1447 words - 6 pages lights go down further and Paulina's voice continues in the darkness, only the cassette recorder lit by the light of the moon." After a while, "in the darkness, we hear Roberto's voice overlapping with Paulina's and the second movement of Death and the Maiden." Then, "the lights go up as if the moon were coming out" while at the same time "the Schubert fades," where Roberto is put into light, and when he says "too late" the first time, "the lights

Death And The Maiden Essay

646 words - 3 pages “There is only one thing in the world worse than being talked about, and that is not being talked about.” –Oscar Wilde Death and the Maiden discusses Princess Diana, her media, and her public from the point-of-view of Maureen Dowd. Was Diana the “spendthrift of her own celebrity”? Is the media a market of vultures feeding off of Diana? Does the public actually have any remorse for the Princess? There is no right or wrong answers for these

Friedrich Durrenmatt's The Visit Essay

1362 words - 5 pages , foreshadowing Ill's death and initiating suspense in the audience. Ill even states that, “They’re hunting [him] like a wild beast” (Durrenmatt 57). Ill is later hunted down like this panther. Once the panther is killed an ominous tone is created because Ill’s death is going to be a reality. The panther also shows a theme of ignorance in The Visit; even the color imagery of black portrays this theme. Ignorance is directed from the way the townspeople

Death And The Maiden Film Vs

1120 words - 4 pages The Polanski film Death and the Maiden is a wonderful and intelligent interpretation of Ariel Dorfman’s human rights problem play. Polanski has produced, in this film, an exceptional piece of direction, in which his own personal, emotional input is evident. The main theme of the play is an extremely personal one for both playwright (and scriptwriter) and director. Both Dorfman and Polanski have had to face and flee the horrors of