The Different Theories And Conclusions About Multiple Personality Disorder

1116 words - 4 pages

Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) is a condition in which an individual has the experience of being more than one distinct person. As with all the concepts and theories we use to explain reality, anomalies in the experience of what we define as a self challenge such definitions. Advances in understanding often arise from unexpected quarters, so to close off any such quarter would be to willfully limit our understanding

All the writers I look at accept the existence of MPD, but each has a different conception of its causes. Each draw different conclusions about the self based on their interpretation of MPD or, in Hacking’s case, rule out meaningfully connecting MPD with our beliefs about the self.

Dennett and Humphries see the formation of MPD as illustrative of his philosophy of mind. This explains the self as ‘fictitious’, (clarify Dickhead’s theory here) but real enough to be in charge of the various sub-systems that give us our experience of self.

As usual with Dennett, he has a bet each way. The experience of self is not demonstrable but seems nevertheless to be acceptably inferred by the overall expression of an organism. We each have a network of sub-systems which somehow add up to an experience of self. Although he doesn’t try to define this self as it actually exists in our heads, in our lives, we are told that it exists like the US President exists. However closely this might ‘fit’ with our lived experience, Dennett’s explanation does nothing to explain any scientific truth of MPD. As Hacking would assert, this disqualifies Dennett’s explanation of MPD as evidence for any particular notion of self. Again, we have simply a happy, reasonable coincidence between an experience – MPD, an explanation - the self splintering under pressure, and a norm - the self.

As much as he’d like it to, Dennett’s claim that the self is fictive does nothing to make his explanation of MPD any more plausible, nor his use of MPD to explain the self more philosophically viable. Dennett simply fails to cover the gaps between his theories and the terms he relies on for them to hold.

Dennett’s theory

Hacking’s crit of this plus looping

Flanagan’s theory of the multiplex

Finish with Dom and the metaphysical, the fact that science does give us our understanding of the ‘real’ physical world and gives us our only model for connecting and correlating our perceptions/knowledge ie. The problem with loping effect is that it presumes that we only exist in concepts/words and can’t ever connect our theories to any objective world. Even if it is impossible for our mind to understand and express the objective world, it seems absurd to ignore the territory we mark out between subjective fantasy and scientific fact. No matter how “constructed” such theories are, no matter how interactive is the human ‘kind’, the notion of a real physical world is an essential construct in what we call ‘reality’.

I think Hacking’s conception of the looping effect...

Find Another Essay On The Different Theories and Conclusions About Multiple Personality Disorder

Multiple Personality Disorder in the movie "Identity"

2124 words - 8 pages negative experiences all build up and separated from a child's mental life and forms separate personalities. DID and MPD (Multiple Personality Disorder) are commonly diagnosed as a form of schizophrenia because these people tend to have a loss of connection within the brain which can cause hallucinations, delusions and disorganized thinking. Multiple personalities can function completely separate of each other. In other words, one of a person's

Overview of Multiple Personality Disorder Essay

1186 words - 5 pages Multiple Personality Disorder (Dissociative Identity Disorder) Mental disorders have perplexed physicians, psychiatrists and the general public since the beginning of time. One specific disorder called Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), also known as Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD), has caused controversy between those who believe it is real and those who think it is purely part of an individual’s imagination. For those who believe

Multiple Personality Disorder in "Identity"

1165 words - 5 pages that Timmy had a homicidal personality and was the one who killed all the people at the motel. Timmy ends up assassinating Paris right where the number one motel key was at. The movie ends with Malcolm Rivers strangling his psychiatrist while he was on his way to a mental institution. Overall Malcolm Rivers has a psychological disorder called Dissociative Identity Disorder, which is also known as Multiple Personality Disorder. This disorder

Multiple Personality Disorder (Dissociative Identity Disorder)

686 words - 3 pages and they may obtain different ailments such as diabetes or asthma.                Individuals with multiple personality disorder can go on and receive successful treatment. Long-term psychoanalysis, in which the analyst will encourage the patient to confront repressed memories and expand his or her consciousness, provides the best results in recovery. Integration, or the combining of all the altars to create the true self, also provides

Poe's William Wilson And Multiple Personality Disorder: Shedding New Light

2518 words - 10 pages Heather Knous 11-2-01 Poe's "William Wilson" and Multiple Personality Disorder: Shedding New Light In Edgar Allan Poe's story "William Wilson," he attempts to explain a psychological issue before the presence of the science of psychology. By explaining a new idea, he struggles to define the sickness from which the narrator is suffering, and of which he ultimately becomes a victim. In light of the modern theory of multiple personality disorder

Multiple Personality Disorder - conflicting views regarding the controversy of the disorder.

1296 words - 5 pages Multiple Personality Disorder Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD), also known today as Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), is a psychiatric disorder where two or more personalities seem inhabit a single body. The different personalities are referred to as "alters". At different times, the personalities alternate in their control of the person's actions and general conduct. (American Psychiatric Association, 1994) Dissociation is a mental

Gender Differences in Antisocial Personality Disorder: An Explanation of Theories of Unequal

1210 words - 5 pages . More specifically, it will attempt to explain various theories formulated about the difference in prevalence in male and female populations and why men are so much more likely to receive a diagnosis. Before we can begin to discuss the reasons that the disorder is more commonly diagnosed in men, we must first understand some background information on the disorder itself. Antisocial personality disorder was first introduced as a disorder in

Borderline Personality Disorder and Dependent Personality Disorder

1547 words - 6 pages Axis Two: Illnesses “A personality disorder is an enduring pattern of inner experience and behavior that deviates markedly from the expectations of the individual’s culture, is pervasive and inflexible, has an onset in adolescence or early adulthood, is stable over time, and leads to distress or impairment” (American Psychiatric Association, 2013). There are several different mental illnesses that can branch off from mental disorders

The Personality Disorder: Narcissism

2189 words - 9 pages The personality disorder, narcissism, was named after the Greek mythological figure Narcissus. The myth goes that Narcissus was so indulged in self-love that he gazed and fell in love with his own mirror image, refusing to leave he died beside his own reflection. In “The Double” by Dostoevsky, the protagonist too suffers from narcissism, an obsession with his own self. This self-obsession manifests itself as he finds himself reflected by the

The paper is about different sociology theories on socialization and social problems.

1711 words - 7 pages Social Perspectives on Socialization and Social ProblemsIntroduction:Sociology is the study of human behavior and thought and how the social aspects of the society influence the human groups by changing their behavior. It focuses on social relationships; how these relationships influence people's behavior and how societies tend to change because of it (Schaefer, 2006, pg. 3). Sociological perspectives provide different approaches which helps to

Narcissistic Personality Disorder and Treatment

1858 words - 7 pages -righteous certainty, and adamant commitment that allowed no protest and created almost total submission (Kohut, 1979, p. 15). Mr. Z had not elaborated on specific experiences with his mother and described her precisely as the image that she portrayed to others (Kohut, 1979, p. 13). The absence of this pertinent information surely explained the analyst's lack of emphasis upon her personality disorder; however, the second analysis revealed the

Similar Essays

Ramtha And Multiple Personality Disorder Essay

787 words - 3 pages I've taken the position that JZ Knight is actually inducing an alternate personality when "Ramtha" is speaking through her. This condition would be assessed in the discipline of psychology, as Multiple Personality Disorder. I also believe that her followers do not quantify the supernatural existence of Ramtha, but rather are an example of our need to believe in the unexplainable.A person diagnosed with multiple personality disorder has two or

Multiple Personality Disorder Essay

2019 words - 8 pages Multiple Personality Disorder Mental disorders have baffled physicians, psychiatrists and the general public since the beginning of time. One particular disorder called Dissociative Identity Disorder, also known as Multiple Personality Disorder, has caused controversy between those who believe it is real and those who think it is purely part of an individual’s imagination. For those who believe strongly in its existence, it poses very real

Mpd Multiple Personality Disorder. Essay

2273 words - 9 pages The concept of Multiple Personality Disorder is an idea that is not readily accepted in the psychological world. Many psychologist and psychotherapist do not believe that there is such an illness as Multiple Personality Disorder. It is a common belief that some psychologists somehow brainwash their patients into believing that they have the illness.The reality is, that yes, psychologists do often brainwash their patients into believing that they

The Controversy Surrounding Multiple Personality Disorder

2513 words - 10 pages is an alcoholic, it could be because MPD is too much for them to handle, and they need some way to forget about it. If the patient is a drug abuser, it could be because they have an alter who is a drug addict. These may sound a bit extravagant, but this really is how some psychologists think. Another issue that must be addressed when discussing multiple personality disorder is what causes the onset of the disorder. This is yet another