The Dredd Scott Case Essay

2677 words - 11 pages

The Dredd Scott Case

The Dredd Scott case involved a landmark decision in the history of the Supreme Court, in the history of the United States the decision in this case was one of the most damaging statements in the history of the Supreme Court, involving the citizenship of a black person in the United States, and the constitutionality of the Missouri Compromise in 1820. The history of a black man named Dredd Scott states that he was a slave originally owed by a family by the name of Blow, which ended up selling him in 1833 to an army surgeon by the name of Dr. John Emerson of St. Luis. Due to his involvement as an army surgeon, Emerson was transferred to numerous places such as Rock Island, Illinois, Fort Snelling in the Wisconsin Territory then back to St. Louis in the end of 1838. Scott had accompanied Emerson throughout this period. Emerson had taken Scott to places that forbidden slavery according to the Missouri Compromise of 1820 and Scott was even allowed to marry during this! time period on free territory, his companion being a woman who was also a slave owned by Emerson. As Emerson and Scott had returned to St. Louis, a territory where slavery was legal, Emerson died and Scott was left to his widow, who eventually gave Scott back to his original owners, the Blows. Henry Blow,
Scott’s original master, was opposed to the extension of slavery into the Western territories, and Blow lent Scott’s residence on free soil in Illinois and Wisconsin Territory had made him a free man. In 1846, Dredd Scott brought suit in the state court on the grounds that residence in a free territory released him from slavery. A lower state court had found to be in favor of Scott, but in 1852, the Supreme Court of Missouri ruled that upon his return to territory where slavery was legal, the status of
slavery was reattached to him and therefore he had no standing before the court. The case was brought before the federal circuit court, which took jurisdiction, but held against Scott. The case was taken on appeal to the Supreme Court, where it was argued at length in 1855 and 1856 and finally decided in 1857.

The decision handed down by a majority of the vote of the court was that there was no power in the in the existing form of government to make citizens slave or free, !
and at the time of the formation of the US Constitution they were not and could not be citizens of the United States in any of the states. Scott was ruled still to be a slave, and not a citizen of Missouri or any US state for that matter, from which it followed that he had no right to sue in the federal courts. Now it was not so much the court’s decision that was so damaging, but the series of opinions that Roger Taney, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court and how we look at it. The court had announced its
decision on March 6, 1857. By a 7 - 2 vote, the court ruled against Scott. Of the seven opinions written by the members of the majority, Chief Justice Taney’s is considered to...

Find Another Essay On The Dredd Scott Case

Ethics in the Workplace Case Study Action Plan: Scott Paper Company

2311 words - 9 pages suggests there are usually three primary motivations for reorganization; the first is the poor financial performance, second, is the need for a new corporate strategy, and lastly it is used to correct how the company is valued in the capital market (Jenkins, 1994). In this case the warning signs were clear at Scott Paper with the declining sales, stale product lines and some irrelevant business ventures; a lagging revenue stream and stock price, also

"The two wrongs of an alcoholic case", by F. Scott Fitzgerald

842 words - 3 pages 'The Two Wrongs of an Alcoholic Case'In his writings, F. Scott Fitzgerald sometimes blends many similar character traits among the main characters. So it goes with 'Two Wrongs,' and 'An Alcoholic Case.' Perhaps it may seem an unlikely choice for a comparison/contrast, however I believe these stories are very much correlated. From the way that Fitzgerald typecasts, 'alcoholic artists' as the main characters, to the similarities in the reactions

All Men Created Equal

999 words - 4 pages issue was dealt with in the ruling of the Dredd Scott case. Lincoln points out that the ruling of the case was based on historical fact that was wrongly assumed. Judge Taney, who presided over the case stated that "Negroes were no part of the people who made, or for whom was made, the Declaration of Independence, or the Constitution of the United States." This statement was later refuted by Judge Curtis who shows that "in five of the

All Men Created Equal - Stephen Douglas versus Abraham Lincoln

1079 words - 4 pages with in the ruling of the Dredd Scott case. Lincoln points out that the ruling of the case was based on historical fact that was wrongly assumed. Judge Taney, who presided over the case stated that 'Negroes were no part of the people who made, or for whom was made, the Declaration of Independence, or the Constitution of the United States.' This statement was later refuted by Judge Curtis who shows that 'in five of the then thirteen states...free

Women’s Reproductive Rights Are In Danger

1728 words - 7 pages The battle for women’s reproductive rights is similar to the struggle for African Americans to have “the full liberty of speech in public and private” as Dredd Scott found out in 1865 when he petitioned for his personal freedom from slavery and lost. Moreover women’s reproductive rights are akin to defending the rights of racial equality, civil rights, desegregation, same sex marriage, and universal human rights. Every individual should have the

Study notes for Indian removal for united states history class

689 words - 3 pages . Georgia (1831)(i)The Cherokee wanted an injunction against removal since they were a sovereign nation(ii)In a gross mischaracterization of the Cherokee, the court ruled that the Cherokee were destitute and reliant upon the US for their welfare. Thus the US claimed them as a ward (a domestic dependent nation).(iii)Since the Cherokee were not a foreign nation, they could not sue Georgia as they had no standing in court (it is the ‘Dredd Scott

Dred Scott v. Sandford

1089 words - 4 pages . Dred Scott lost his first case in a lower St. Louis court because he could not prove that he was owned by the Emerson family at all. A second trial took place in January 1850, Dred Scott and his family were declared "Free." Unhappy with the decision, Mrs. Emerson appealed, and in 1852 the Missouri Supreme court reversed the decision. New attorneys were needed because his first attorney had passed away. His new team consisted of attorneys

Supreme Court Cases - Dred Scott vs Sanford

574 words - 2 pages Dred Scott v. Sanford is a popular case in United States History. It set precedence for the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments, the amendments that solely relates to African Americans. Dred Scott, a slave in 1857 declared his right to be free under the Supreme Court. In 1839 Scott and his master moved to Missouri, which was a slave state. Four years later, a U.S. army surgeon named Dr. John Emerson bought Scott and moved him into the free state of

F. Scott Fitzgerald

1273 words - 5 pages Curious Case of Benjamin Button; And a notable novel is The Beautiful and the damned. But nothing could compare to the literally genius that was to come. (F. Scott Biography) F. Scott’s most critically acclaimed and possibly his best work is the genius that is The Great Gatsby. Sadly, it was not until the 50’s and 60’s, well after F. Scott’s death, that the book reached its’ full potential of being the pitch-perfect caption of the roaring

Dred Scott case

2027 words - 8 pages On June 19th 1862 the US Congress prohibits slavery in the United States territories nullifying the Dred Scott Case. This was the most important day in US history for African Americans. This is because it helped blacks gain the rights they deserve. It also gave them rights they never thought they could achieve. This Court case of Scott vs. Sanford was a catalyst to riots, other court cases such as Brown vs. Board of Education

Dred Scott Decision report

1496 words - 6 pages The Dred Scott Decision was a very remarkable and historic case in the United States. The trial involved slave Dred Scott and his wife Harriet which were both slaves, suit against their widowed owner Mrs. Emerson. The trail first took place in a St. Louis Circuit court which eventually ended up the in the U.S Supreme Court eleven years later. The U.S Supreme Court issued that the decision that Scott and his wife were still to be slave. This

Similar Essays

Dredd Scott Case: Minority Opinion Essay

1071 words - 4 pages act by taking a free man from a free territory by force into Missouri. These powers of the individual state are clearly defined by the constitution of the United States.The rights of a citizen?s private property have been protected by the constitution, but in this case the plaintiff was no longer considered private property once he and his master established residence in Rock Island, Illinois. It is contradictory in itself to assume that a man

The Dred Scott Case. Essay

2409 words - 10 pages could give him. He was the cause of a change that dictated how black people were viewed in this country. Dred Scott made every black man ask himself the question am I free or have I been deprived of my freedom. The repercussions of this were enormous. The Dred Scott decision was a climactic event amidst the debate of a divided nation. Its outcome would be one more push that headed the country into Civil War. It was a case that the Supreme Court

Dredd Scott Decision Essay

1752 words - 7 pages charged atmosphere stepped a black slave from Missouri named Dred Scott. During the 1850s in the United States, Southern support of slavery and Northern opposition to it collided more violently than ever over the case of Dred Scott, a black slave from Missouri who claimed his freedom on the basis of seven years of residence in a free state and a free territory. When the predominately pro-slavery Supreme Court of the United States heard Scott's

Dredd Scott Decision Essay

2568 words - 10 pages INTRODUCTION United States Supreme Court case Scott v. Sanford (1857), commonly known as the Dred Scott Case, is probably the most famous case of the nineteenth century (with the exception possibly of Marbury v. Madison). It is one of only four cases in U. S. history that has ever been overturned by a Constitutional amendment (overturned by the 13th and 14th Amendments). It is also, along with Marbury, one of only two cases prior to the Civil