The Dualist Dilemma. This Essay Is A Critique Of Substance Dualism, An Ontology Embodied By The Likes Of Rene Descartes. Specifically, The Essay Attacks Several Of Descartes Own Dualist Principles.

1407 words - 6 pages

P.K.Philosophy 420Essay: 1The Dualist DilemmaEmbodied most emphatically by the writings of Rene Descartes, substance dualism outlines a specific ontological framework for the understanding of mind. Dualism specifically represents a philosophic uneasiness in the idea that mind is merely a projection of the physical, containing no innate or self-defining properties. More specifically, as evidenced in the writings of Descartes, and also Alvin Plantinga, the dualist seeks to ascribe a sort of substance quality to the mind, although quite distinct from that of the physical, in it's own realm so to speak. Further analysis shows that central to any dualist argument is a necessary individuality of mind and body respectively. In fact, Descartes meticulously severs (only to subsequently reconnect for distinctive purposes) the mind from the body, not to say that mind does not include some physical properties as well, only that it also exists above and beyond these distinctions in a separate realm of being. Relevant examination of the criterion pervading substance dualism reveals the necessary logic of its structure, which will be discussed in due turn, but more importantly several potential problems as well, insofar as common sense and logic requires, are seen to plague the viability of such an ontology in explaining the annals of mind.Necessary in a critique of a logical structure is diligent examination of its founding principles. Analysis of Meditations II and IV from Descartes Meditations on First Philosophy, and Alvin Plantinga's subsequent contemporary extension of these ideas in "Could Socrates Have Been an Alligator?" from The Nature of Necessity, provide adequate foundations of principal from which to launch an exploration of the viability of substance dualism. Descartes achieves his form of dualism by ascribing substance, in and of it self, to mind. This is to be taken above and beyond the obvious notion of "brain matter," which is itself a physical substance. Descartes extends that above and beyond physical brain matter, separate minds also exist which may only be categorized as "mental properties." "But notice that while I speak and approach the fire what remained of the taste is exhaled, the smell evaporates, the color alters, the figure is destroyed, the size increases, it becomes liquid, it heats, scarcely one can handle it, and when one strikes it, no sound is emitted. Does the same wax remain after this change (Descartes, 24)?" Proceeding from this famous "wax" example, Descartes points out the distinction between mind and body exists, because the changing form of the wax as it is heated goes beyond the realm of physical imagination, vision, or touch, and may only be ascribed to intuition of mind, a description of something with mental property. This displacement of body and mind is very convenient for Descartes, as it allows him to proceed from the idea of distinctness of body and mind, to the existence of corporeal objects, but most...

Find Another Essay On THE DUALIST DILEMMA. This essay is a critique of substance dualism, an ontology embodied by the likes of Rene Descartes. Specifically, the essay attacks several of Descartes own dualist principles.

Thomas Hobbes and Rene Descartes: The Science of Man

1390 words - 6 pages moves it. All of this suggests that for Descartes’ theory to be correct there must be some kind of connection between a material substance (the body) and an immaterial substance (the mind). However, we will find it impossible to understand the idea of a science of man if we cannot understand how the two substances interact. Therefore, again, we have no proof that it is possible to build a political philosophy on the basis of

Rene Descartes In Proving the Existence of God.

1332 words - 5 pages Descartes reflected on howall-powerful and omniscient God is, the more convinced he was that the idea did not originate from within himself or theoutside world. The ideas, then, must be innate; which means they were put there by God. So, according to Descartes, Godexists!The problem with this argument is that it doesn't really "prove" anything. I could think of a really huge apple as big asMassachusetts. In my imagination, this apple would be very

Heidegger's Reading of Descartes' Dualism

4301 words - 17 pages Heidegger's Reading of Descartes' Dualism ABSTRACT: The problem of traditional epistemology is the relation of subject to external world. The distinction between subject and object makes possible the distinction between the knower and what is known. Starting with Descartes, the subject is a thinking thing that is not extended, and the object is an extended thing which does not think. Heidegger rejects this distinction between subject and

Rene Descartes

1091 words - 4 pages and Paris in 1649. This work (like the Principles) is composed of a large number of short articles. Princess Elisabeth had raised the question of how the soul could interact with the body in 1643. In response to Elisabeth's questions, Descartes wrote a short work which developed into the Passions of the Soul. The work is a combination of psychology, physiology and ethics, and contains Descartes' theory of two way causal interaction via the pineal

Rene Descartes

1259 words - 5 pages psychology, in which an external object brings about an involuntary response,? (Schultz 28). This is a key idea to the reflexive theory that Descartes developed, the idea that humans have an involuntary response. During his work he did several illustration and experiments to test the idea that humans cannot control all of their actions. In one such case Descartes described shows how a human eye cannot be controlled. ?Descartes also uses as an

Existence of God. A look at Rene Descartes' theory

1307 words - 5 pages with all the modern technologies and the development of sciences, we still do not have a definitive answer to the question 'does God exist?'Among many philosophers and scholars who have tried to answer this question, we shall look upon Rene Descartes' theory on the existence of God. In terms of believers and non-believers, Descartes would be one of the believers. Before we go any further, we must ponder upon several questions. What is God? Does God

Analyzing Individuation and Identity In Descartes´ Philosophical View of the Mind-Body Dualism

1292 words - 5 pages ’ principle of mind-body dualism. I give a critical analysis of these two problems, I will first explain the basis of Descartes’ philosophical views. Surprisingly dualism has become synonymous with Rene Descartes that often times it is many just referred to by many as Cartesian dualism, as if this was the decisive line of attack to the issue. The theory behind dualism is that the mind and the body, that mind and matter, are two distinct

Descartes: Ontology or Cosmology?

1539 words - 6 pages , which are “...beliefs, propositions, or arguments the truths of which can be established only through observation” (Palmer 408). This fact is only one of a multitude of ways that the cosmological argument of Aquinas differs from the ontological argument ofAnselm.In conclusion, it can be said without a shadow of a doubt, that the arguments for the existence of God presented by the philosopher Rene Descartes are clearly more ontological in

Rene Descartes' Examination of the Nature of Mateial Things and What is Possible to Know of them Based on Passages from Meditations on First Philosophy. (the Wax example)

605 words - 2 pages "How do we know what we know?" This is a question asked by Rene Descartes as well as a host of other philosophers. A particular passage written in Meditations on First Philosophy by Descartes dubbed the "Wax Passage" examined the nature of material things, and what we really know about them. Descartes' thought process shall be followed, and his conclusion that if all attributes are stripped away, what is left is the "essence" of the wax, will be

Descartes' arguments for immateriality of mind/soul based on the notion of dualism: body is extended object and mind/soul is non-extended.

1858 words - 7 pages body. This would imply the possibility for an after-life, thus the immateriality of mind/soul.So Descartes starts his argument to prove immateriality of soul by asserting that self exists as mind/soul. After doubting everything in his Second Meditation, that is rejecting the possibility of the existence of extension, movement, senses and bodies, even his own; thus concluding that the only thing is certain that there is no certainty. But if he

Descartes and Dualism

624 words - 2 pages Descartes and Dualism   "I think therefore I am," the well known quote of Rene Descartes, is the basis of his theory known as dualism.  The intermingling of mind and body or res extensa (extended substance) and res cogitans (thinking substance) displays Descartes' ideas of a "genuine human being" (Cottingham 7).  Known as the father of modern philosophy, Descartes realized that one could not analyze a problem simply on the

Similar Essays

The Meditations Of Rene Descartes Essay

700 words - 3 pages his basis on life claiming that everything is to be doubted. Rene Descartes first begins to come to some kind of belief by the Third Meditation. Rene states . . . "I am certain that I am a thinking being; but do I not therefore likewise know what is required to make me certain of something?" (p113 Methods & Meditations). He goes on to say that God could not possibly be deceitful, it would not be his divine nature. This is when things start to

A Summary Of "Discourse On The Method" By Rene Descartes.

758 words - 3 pages comes to the conclusion that all people have a "natural light" that can be obscured by education and that it is as important to study oneself as it is to study the world. In part 2, Descartes describes his revelation in the "stove-heated room." Contemplating various subjects, he hits on the idea that the works of individuals are superior to those conceived by committee because an individual's work follows one plan, with all elements working toward

How Have Dualist Tried To Explain The Apparent Two Way Causal Interaction Between Mind And Body? Which Version Of Dualism Is The Most Plausible Theory Of Mind?

1144 words - 5 pages the mind and body, as well as justification of Cartesian dualism from that viewpoint. From this I will conclude that Cartesian dualism is the most plausible dualist theory of mind.Founder of Cartesian dualism, René Descartes, believed that interaction between the mind and body took place in the pineal gland, which is located in the middle of the brain. However, modern neuroscience has since disproved that theory, with brain scans showing

Title: Mind And Body: An Interpretation On The Works Of Rene Descartes And Benedictus De Spinoza Talks About "Dualism" And "Double Aspect Theory"

1152 words - 5 pages view in perspective. Two philosophers who argue over this topic are Rene Descartes and Benedictus de Spinoza. Descartes was one of the few early thinkers to dissect and assess the mind/body problem with his argument for dualism. In contrast to Descartes was Benedictus de Spinoza who provides a counter-example to Descartes' "dualism," namely what is known as the "double aspect theory." By analyzing the views of both philosophers we can see which