This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Duty Of Assistance Or Humanitarian Intervention

1116 words - 5 pages

John Rawls, proponent of the Liberal Nationalist tradition in international ethics, suggests that liberal societies have a duty of assistance toward burdened societies. As a principle, the duty of assistance is not adequate in terms of distributive justice as described by Michael Blake in his “Distributive Justice, Coercion, and Autonomy.”
The duty of assistance stems from Rawls’ Law of Peoples as a means of creating a more just society. The basic premise is that those who have access to more materials and economic resources should provide resource assistance to burdened societies. A burdened society is a failed community, lacking the ability to foster growth, sustain successful institutions, or produce capital of any kind. The duty to assist pertains to other communities who have success in these areas and are capable of providing material and economic resources to these burdened societies. The reasons why this principle may seem adequate as a means of distributive justices are because of the conditions Rawls attaches to this assistance.
The first condition is that once these burdened societies have had assistance to the point where they can create and sustain their own liberal political institutions or decent hierarchies (where leaders must consult with the people they rule over even if the leaders do no always adhere to the people’s preferences), liberal states no longer have a duty to assist. In this way, liberal societies are not labeled as perpetual givers or are taken advantage of by the numbers of burdened societies. This condition seems fair in that liberal societies are able to provide assistance up to a point and that previously burdened societies are not forever suckling from other societies.
Liberal societies can also reduce the amount they assist burdened societies if the burdened societies are ineffectively using the resources or have corrupt individuals receiving the assistance and not reforming their political infrastructure. The ability to withdraw assistance allows liberal societies to guide development and progress in a way they see fit.
Blake’s argument for distributive justice is that the duty of assistance not be applied at the international level, but rather a humanitarian intervention be taken on by the liberal state. Coercion is present at the domestic level because citizens are forced to live together and thus participate in their society together. But this level of coercion does not exist between states since states are not forced to participate with one another; they only exist in the world together. Existing together and participating together are separate actions. Existing in the same world as another does not mean there is a necessity to interact with another. As this is the case, Blake argues that state sovereignty should be respected within the international system and that no state should be coerced into participating with others and implicitly forcing others to change in order to receive...

Find Another Essay On The Duty of Assistance or Humanitarian Intervention

Title: South African support on Humanitarian Intervention in the 1653

1149 words - 5 pages security. As a result of Assadistan being weak state that is not fulfilling its role of being the “fundamental purveyor of security” for its citizens (Baylis and Ownes.2014, 452). Rather it is the source of the threat to its citizens. Therefore South Africa’s support of the resolution will support the UN charter (1945) in its commitment to protect fundamental human rights and respect the right of humanitarian intervention in customary international

Did the war against Iraq fulfil the criteria for a legitimate use of force under the 'humanitarian intervention' doctrine

1073 words - 4 pages I believe that the coalitions invasion of Iraq, was not justified on the basis that it did not fulfil the circumstances which justify the doctrine of humanitarian intervention.The use of force against one state by another under article 2(4) of the UN Charter is expressly prohibited, however, it is argued that humanitarian intervention is a justifiable exception to this article (p190, r4.10). The argument that humanitarian intervention

The Duty of Women

1584 words - 6 pages The duty of women to have children creates a bias against them. Many laws for women and writings about women relate to their job of childbearing. It is their most important responsibility and also what gave them less freedoms then men. I will explore this fact in ancient Mesopotamia, Greece and Rome using the writings of Sappho, Aristotle and the scribe Any. The first laws regarding women that we have record of was Hammurabi’s code. In

The Assistance of Eating Disorders by Depression

1002 words - 4 pages The Assistance of Eating Disorders by Depression As a fragile young girl entered the hospital, several people stop to stare at her fragile body. As the physicians examine her, they begin to realize she hasn’t eaten in days. Several physicians begin to ask her questions concerning her eating behaviors. All she her behavior during the exam they noticed how depressed the girl seemed to be. When the exam was over the

The Humanitarian Work of Angelina Jolie

3135 words - 13 pages When most people talk about celebrities it is usually related to their latest fashion statement, the new movies they are starring in, or the new song they released. However, what is becoming increasingly more popular for celebrities to be associated with is humanitarian and development work. Through their use of songs, documentaries, and publicized field missions, the celebrities that partake in humanitarian work utilize their fame to attract

It is the duty of an organization's owner to provide job oppurtunities for the working group or labor

536 words - 2 pages /her duty honestly so that they can earn ever lasting profit. Those, who avoid paying their duties, will face severe problems. It is impossible for one to establish rules to solve all kinds of problems that mankind may encounter until the Last Day. We are all aware of the condition of developing countries in the world, and if the start firing their employees what will happen? The number of unemployment should be boost-up which will cause increase in

Progress or Setback?: The Implications of the International Intervention in Libya on the Norms of the R2P

3454 words - 14 pages : 87) considers Annan’s efforts to quite successfully have raised a debate on humanitarian intervention to the international political stage, and she further argues that these efforts (inspired by the failure to stop mass killings in Rwanda and Srebrenica) shifted perceptions. Intervention for the purpose of civilian protection was increasingly viewed as a form of human rights protection or the promotion of democracy rather than imperialistic

The Role of the Red Cross in International Humanitarian Law

1591 words - 6 pages International Humanitarian Law. Henry Dunant on his way to Italy to meet Napoleon III to discuss the difficulty of doing business in Algeria then under French control witnessed the Battle of Solferino in the small town of Solferino where in one battle night, up to 40000 men died and many more were left wounded with no medical attendance or any kind of relief. Abandoning his original plan, Dunant started to organize medical attendance and more relief to

The Duty of the Federal Reserve

717 words - 3 pages than the funds available in reserves; with the remainder invested or issued as credit. The Fed is an abomination, as is any agency manipulating and devaluing the money supply are acting unscrupulously by engaging in diversified weights and measures. The Bible clearly states such practices are an infraction of justice; “Do not have two differing weights in your bag…You must have accurate and honest weights and measures…For the LORD your God

Analysis of the Psychology's Duty to Warn

2137 words - 9 pages The duty to warn refers to a psychologist notifying a potential third party or governing authorities of the danger that might be inevitable. The duty to warn goes together with the duty to protect a third party whose life might be in danger. The therapist has a legal role to play by protecting a third party from danger through hospitalization and outpatient therapy while still observing confidentiality. However, the duty to warn might require

Kantian Ethics: The Importance of One's Duty

1634 words - 7 pages This essay will explain that I am in agreement with Kant’s theory of action to be moral when it is carried out from duty. First, what Kant means when he explains that an action is moral, it is when you actively use reason to choose and determine how to act in a given situation; what makes the action moral is the fact that you use reason based on your thoughts of what is right and no one else’s, nor subjected into any emotional appeal or instinct

Similar Essays

Humanitarian Intervention: Questioning Of Its Legality

2001 words - 9 pages affairs of others, just as individuals have a duty to value another’s autonomy (Holzgreffe & Keohane, 2003). Another concern that has been raised is that humanitarian intervention will be utilized as a tool to exercise ulterior motives for war, ones straying away from its chief goal (Goodman, 2006). Many fear humanitarian intervention will fall prey to becoming a justification for aggressive military action or outright war. The UN Charter affirms

What International Relations Theory Best Explains Humanitarian Intervention. What Is Your Critical View On The Effectiveness Of Humanitarian Inter

1257 words - 6 pages Humanitarian intervention can be defined as an ‘activity taken up by a state, a group within a state, a group of states, or an international organisation which interferes coercively in the domestic affairs of another state’. (Vincent, 1974, p.3) Now, depending of the school of thought, this can be seen in either a positive or negative light. For those who subscribe to the solidarity theory, the idea of humanitarian intervention is perfectly

Humanitarian Intervention And The Un And Nato

2303 words - 9 pages a way to unite countries by making stronger alliances and helping to support and protect each other. Humanitarian intervention has been known for both positive and negative effects and definitely has its pros and cons. The strategic efforts of humanitarian intervention are inoperative because the efforts are not heartfelt but are only done to keep their own citizens from becoming obstreperous. The whole purpose of the UN is to have a strong

‘Is Humanitarian Military Intervention An Example Of A Justified War.’

1464 words - 6 pages critical examination of humanitarian intervention, which is often considered a modern form of colonialism (what is colonialism?). In conclusion, I suggest that humanitarian intervention can be considered an example of just war theory, but it is debatable whether or not the ethical foundations of humanitarian intervention can be realised in the context of a power-motivated international world system. To discuss whether humanitarian military