This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Economic Consequences Of Giving Dolphins “Non Person Rights”

2342 words - 9 pages

The Economic Consequences of Giving Dolphins “Non-Person Rights”

The United Nations declared that all humans have the right to life, liberty and shelter (citation pending. UN website). As an intelligent species should dolphins be given the same guarantees? Recently scientists have been calling for increased protection of dolphins because there is evidence that they are highly intelligent and capable of abstract thought; however the consequences of grating them Special protections of their habitats and species would be economically devastating to the fishing and shipping industries. The question of whether they should be given special protections has come up and this essay will examine the argument between the morality and the economic benefits and consequences of giving dolphins these protections.

Dolphins have been regarded as an intelligent species since the 50’s, however in the last couple years there has been significant research into their intelligence. Through numerous tests, dolphins have been shown to be capable of recognising themselves in mirrors (Psarakos). Until recently, only humans and certain species primates have been able to recognise themselves as a reflection in mirror, this is an important indicator of animals that are capable of meta-cognation, or to think about thinking. This in turn indicates a degree of sapience (Sternberg). If they are proven to be a sapient species rather than an instinctive one, scientists are calling for them to be protected on the same level as humans. Dolphins have also been shown to be capable of planning for the future and have a sense of delayed gratification. A typical case is dolphins picking up trash in their tank and giving it to their trainer in exchange for a fish as a reward. From this action-reward comes the emergent behaviour of the dolphins hoarding trash and delivering it piece by piece to maximise rewards (Ultimate Guide: Dolphins).
There is also evidence that dolphins are able to communicate abstract spatial ideas such as left and right. A study at the Sea Life Park in Hawaii trained dolphins to push buttons first when a light was flashing or a different button if the light was constant; Then to push the buttons in sequence and finally to only have one dolphin able to see the signal and light and the other dolphin would have to push the button based only on verbal cues from its partner (Ultimate Guide: Dolphins). All of these things help support the argument that dolphins are an intelligent species. By proving that dolphins are intelligent, scientists and activists could start arguing the pros and cons of giving dolphins extra protection of their habitat and species.

At the moment, dolphins are not currently an endangered species, however the call by scientists to give them “non-person” rights would give them a substantial protection from exploitation my many industries. By granting dolphins these protections, their habitats would be protected and preserved from...

Find Another Essay On The Economic Consequences of Giving Dolphins “Non-Person Rights”

The Importance of Giving Awards Essay

715 words - 3 pages higher because of student’s hard works and motivation. The second important point is that, giving awards is important in terms of economic situation of students especially who suffer from affording the school costs. Supporting students who have low-income and helping those students in their studies in terms of money will help them to pursue their education. Hence, students who want to continue their study but suffer from economical conditions, they

Burke’s Sublime In O’Dell’s Island of the Blue Dolphins

1512 words - 7 pages “Out of the north deep waves rolled down upon the island. They broke against the rocks and roared into the caves, sending up white sprays of water. Before night a storm would certainly strike” (O’Dell, 19). This passage from Scott O’Dell’s Island of the Blue Dolphins describes the Ocean that surrounds the island and characters in the story. In this description the narrator, Karana, shows the reader that the people on the island fear and respect

The Consequences of the Economic Development of Polar and Sub-Polar Regions

1406 words - 6 pages The Consequences of the Economic Development of Polar and Sub-Polar Regions Although indigenous populations established themselves centuries ago, polar and sub-polar regions of the Arctic and Antarctica have only fairly recently begun to develop. Originally classified as remote regions in the world, where the only activities, which took place, were small-scale fishing and hunting by locals in order to survive, they have

The social economic and ethical consequences of current uses of computing

1466 words - 6 pages The social economic and ethical consequences of current uses of computing.Modern uses of computing have many beneficial functions within employment and businesses.The internet is a valuable source for advertising businesses, with roughly 100, 000, 000 more people surfing the web than watching television the internet has become an invaluable medium for advertisements. Businesses are able to setup their own websites with memorable . COM domain

The main social, cultural and economic consequences are of the past, present and future globalisation

2657 words - 11 pages SCHOOL OF HUMANITIESACCESS TO SOCIAL SCIENCES AND HUMANITESWORLD STUDIES - GLOBALISATIONDISCUSS WHAT THE MAIN SOCIAL, CULTURAL AND ECONOMIC CONSEQUENCES OF PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE GLOBALISATION ARE.INTRODUCTION:Global interdependence is and will continue to control the twenty first century. What occurs on the other side of the sphere (world) is already being experienced in the United Kingdom and vice-versa."The Global village. The New World

Analyse the socio-economic, political, religious and cultural consequences of the Black Death

2646 words - 11 pages Analyse the socio-economic, political, religious and cultural consequences of the Black DeathThe Black Death was one of the deadliest pandemics in human history, with its effects peaking in Europe between 1347 and 1351. This essay examines the socio-economic, political and religious and cultural consequences of the Black Death, the worst plague the world had ever seen. The later Middle Ages, of course, are usually characterized by historians as

Discuss the positive and negative social and economic consequences of the Industrial Revolution in Europe

606 words - 2 pages The industrial revolution had a great impact on Europe, especially when it comes to social and economic aspects, since they underwent a great change during the period. Still, whether the industrial revolution was positive or negative as a whole depends on if you focus on either of these two aspects. Optimists will say that it was good, and they'll focus on the favourable consequences on economy. Pessimists, however, will focus on social aspects

Examining the rise of the Civil Rights Movement from 1940- 1965; Causes, consequences, and cachet

1038 words - 4 pages WWII, this movement gained power and became the concern of the American people and government. Many changes were occurring in the social and economic structure of our country, and the Blacks and Black sympathizers justifiably felt left behind. Additionally, many Blacks served our country faithfully in WWII fighting a war for the oppressed people of Europe, yet in their own homeland, the land of the free, they had no rights. Thus, beginning in 1940

Malcolm X: The Civil Rights Movement and The Non Violent Pursue of Integration

1148 words - 5 pages faith, challenged the mainstream civil rights movement and the nonviolent pursuit of integration championed by Martin Luther King Jr. He urged followers to defend themselves against white aggression “by any means necessary” {Malcolm X} Born Malcolm Little in 1925, in Omaha, Nebraska, Malcolm was the son of a Baptist preacher who was a follower of Marcus Garvey. After the Ku Klux Klan made threats against his father, the family moved to Lansing

The Consequences of Epilepsy

1555 words - 6 pages The Consequences of Epilepsy Epilepsy: Any of various neurological disorders characterized by sudden recurring attacks of motor, sensory, or psychic malfunction with or without loss of consciousness or convulsive seizures (1). Is epilepsy a purely physical phenomenon? The question is a complicated one. Put simply, the answer should be yes. The psychological trauma sometimes caused by the seizures, however, makes the answer

Killing, Suffering and Callousness; How it Affects the Rights of Non-Intensively Reared Animals

1800 words - 7 pages positions vegetarians use to defend animal’s rights. Thirdly, “The argument of Callousness” is relevant as it further depicts Feinberg’s definition of animal rights and suffering. Throughout Crisp’s argument against Vegetarianism, he takes a consequentialist view towards non-human animals. The definition of Consequentialism is an “act as so to maximize the positive consequences of your actions while minimizing the negative ones” (Phillips, Jan 10

Similar Essays

The Ecological Consequences Of Global Economic Growth

2079 words - 8 pages The Ecological Consequences of Global Economic Growth “There have been five ‘ mass extinctions’ in the history of the earth, when between 65% and 95% of all species were wiped out, due to natural processes of selection and evolution. Some scientists now argue that we are heading for a ‘sixth extinction’, caused by the actions of humans.” (Cock and Hopwood, 1996:17) In the following I’m going to look at the positive

The Conservation Of Whales And Dolphins

1439 words - 6 pages argument paper, because it contains up-to-date historical background on whaling and the numerous, international conservation efforts put in place. This book opens with an introduction, giving general information about whales and dolphins. Written to provide a comprehensive review of not only all of the threats to whales, but also efforts and initiatives that are working to reverse the problems the cetacean species faces. From this very basic

Economic Consequences Of Software Crime Essay

1269 words - 5 pages Economic Consequences of Software Crime in 1996 worldwide is the illegal copying of domestic and international software costing $15.2 billion to the software industry, with a loss of $5.1 billion in the North America alone. Some sources put the total up-to-date losses, due to software crime, as high as $4.7 trillion. Estimates show that over 40 percent of North American software company revenues are generated overseas, yet nearly 85 percent of

Island Of The Blue Dolphins Essay

1145 words - 5 pages In a village named Ghalasat on the Island of the Blue Dolphins lived a girl named Karana. She loved to sew and cook for her family. Because only men could hunt and fish, cooking and sewing was all that she knew how to do. One day a large canoe (ship) arrived in the harbor. It was full of men who were called the Aleuts, and they had come to the island to hunt otter. The tribe of villagers allowed the Aleuts to do as they pleased, but they were