The Impact Of War Communism And The New Economic Policy (Nep) On Both The Peasantry And Proletariat In Russian Society Between 1918 And 1928.

1118 words - 4 pages

The policies of war communism and the New Economic Policy (NEP) had a great impact on both the peasantry and the proletariat. Both policies were a desperate attempt to preserve the revolution and this is greatly reflects the reasons why some groups were advantaged and why others were disadvantaged.War communism was implemented as a result of the civil war. Historians such as Maurice Dobb, E. H. Carr, and Stephen Cohen -- have interpreted war communism as a short-term expedient imposed on the Bolsheviks by the emergency demands of civil war and foreign intervention. According to this version, the system was never intended to last into normal peacetime conditions and had no special ideological significance. While this has since become "the standard account," several well-informed economists writing in the 1920s, such as Boris Brutzkus and Leo Pasvolsky, viewed war communism in a much more ideological light -- as an attempt to realise Marx' anti-market socialist or communist utopia. The features of war communism were that peasant land was seized and then nationalised, however the peasant's control. As insufficient grain was reaching the cities the government introduced grain requisition, excess food was seized with Cheka support, it couldn't be sold for a profit. Large scale businesses were nationalised without compensation; this was extended to all business with more than ten people by 1918. All private trade was abolished, and the government controlled food with ration cards and workers were paid through food rations. Workers were told when and where to work, often working up to ten hours a day, and strikes became illegal.The impact of War Communism was great on both the peasantry and the proletariat. Most peasants were prepared to burn their crops and kill their livestock rather than hand them over to the Cheka, however the dire consequences that resulted in doing this meant that many peasants did reluctantly hand them over. As the Cheka also took the seed grain an acute shortage of food and a great famine occurred during the period 1920-1921. Peasants resented these changes and there were many great uprisings during this period of time. This included the peasant revolution led by Antanov and the Tambok region in 1921. Peasants that did not cooperate were sent to concentration camps and labour camps. The famine of 1921 caused peasants to flee urban centres in search of food. The impact on the peasants were that their livelihood was destroyed they had no way of feeding their families and hence dissatisfaction with the government grew. A wave of strikes in Pertograd demanded the abolishment of grain requisitioning, freedom for peasant to run their own farm, a Soviet based government rather than a Bolshevik based government and amnesty for political prisoners.War communism also caused dissatisfaction within the proletariat. They were unhappy about the extremely long working hours and the punishment they received simply for being late. Industrial...

Find Another Essay On The impact of War Communism and the New Economic Policy (NEP) on both the peasantry and proletariat in Russian society between 1918 and 1928.

The Impact of Stalin on Russia and the Russian People

1614 words - 6 pages The Impact of Stalin on Russia and the Russian People Joseph Stalin was born to a poor family in the province of Georgia in 1879. Stalin's real surname was Djugasvili; he adopted the name 'Stalin' whilst in prison as he felt the translation 'Man of Steel' would help his image. Stalin joined the Bolshevik party as a young man and soon became an active member organizing bank raids to gain money for party funds; this

Orwell's Comparing Animal Farm and The Russian System Of Communism

1438 words - 6 pages immediately forces the audience to place values on the characters, and this allows Orwell to create a contrast between his novel and the actual revolution. The novel has many direct relationships to the Russian revolution, and many of the characters in the story represent actual people involved in the Russian revolution, whereas some characters represent a social group just by themselves. This is done to keep the

The Civil War arose out of the issue of the rights of states and both the economic and political rivarly between the South and the North.

721 words - 3 pages Pre-Civil War EssayThe Civil War arose out of the issue of the rights of states and both theeconomic and political rivarly between the South and the North. States in theSouth seceded from the Union after the election of Abraham Lincoln, but theelection of Lincoln was not the only cause of the South's secession. Many eventsand movements increased the tension between the North and the South evenbefore the election of Lincoln and these events also

he role of economic geography in economic development and the impact of ICT on economic growth

2233 words - 9 pages countries are armed with good communications. On the contrary, some writers believe that geography still matters a great deal for economic interaction and for the spatial distribution of income.To discuss, I will concentrate on the role of economic geography in economic development and the impact of ICT on economic growth. From the existing inequality of economic development, we can see distance still matters in terms of economic transactions and

The impact of world war one on the homefront - social, political and economic impacts.

1561 words - 6 pages fact that so many women worked to support the war effort shows that previous ideas were changing and social barriers were broken down to an extent. Wages paid to women were still substantially lower that those that were paid to men. Social change in the way women were perceived. A large impact of the war on the homefront's society was that when the war ended women were able to retain some of the new found status in society and did not have to return

Communism and its Impact on the Postwar World

2146 words - 9 pages weak bourgeoisie and proletariat and strong tradition of authoritarian rule, China was a perfect candidate for this type of Bonapartist regime. In the 1960s, the Sino-Soviet split was really a conflict between the Russian and Chinese bureaucracies, and in its foreign policy, China actually supported a number of feudal and reactionary regimes like Pakistan, Yemen, Afghanistan and Indonesia. Its ‘revolution’ was therefore a “counterfeit of

The Assimilation Policy and Its Impact on the Indigenous Australian Society

1346 words - 6 pages the country had been living here for many centuries, and once the land was claimed by European settlers the Aboriginal people lost their rights of the land that had been theirs for such an extensive time. Many scholars have argued that policies such as protectionism and self-determination have had a larger impact on the indigenous Australian society. In regards to the assimilation policy, protectionism is the most adjoining of the policies, having

The Extent to Which Lenin's NEP Solved the Problems Caused by War Communism

801 words - 3 pages despotic techniques practiced by the Bolsheviks during the war were hence dubbed “war communism” and had considerably alienated the mass of the Russian populace against its communist policies. Thus the regime was forced to restrain its callous inclinations and accordingly abandon “war communism”. Moreover V.I Lenin introduced the “New Economic Policy” in which capitalism and entrepreneurship was maintained, consequently

Assess the impact of Stalin on Russia and the Russian people

786 words - 3 pages Assess the impact of Stalin on Russia and the Russian peopleBy 1929, Stalin had become sole leader of Russia.He said, "We are between 50 and 100 years behind the west. We must make good this difference in 10 years or go under."He wanted things to change in Russia quickly and so he brought up the five year plans, these were to modernise the Russian economy. He also brought up the idea of collectivisation. This was to modernise Russian

The Impact of the Scientific Revolution on Society and Religion

1010 words - 4 pages Over the course of the years, society has been reformed by new ideas of science. We learn more and more about global warming, outer space, and technology. However, this pattern of gaining knowledge did not pick up significantly until the Scientific Revolution. In the sixteenth and seventeenth century, the Scientific Revolution started, which concerned the fields of astronomy, mechanics, and medicine. These new scientists used math and

The Impact of Celebrities and the Media on Society

668 words - 3 pages The Impact of Celebrities and the Media on Society Music has been around for quite some time, and it appears to will be around forever. It has captured the minds and souls of many people, from all the different races and cultures. People nowadays, in particular teenagers, are obsessed with music and the music world. They go as far as idolizing their favorite artist or artists. They walk like them, they talk like them, and they even

Similar Essays

Evaluate The Social And Economic Change Within Australian Society Resulting From The Impact Of Calwell's Immigration Policy

2121 words - 8 pages example of what happened in the post-war period. Worker output was increased as the Chiefly government focused on a policy of "Full Employment". In addition, basic economic principle shows that an increase in population means and increases in supply of goods and services which in turn leads to more jobs. This, along with the younger workforce of Australia shows the inherently positive impact of immigration, an impact which has continued on

The New Economic Policy Of 1921

1493 words - 6 pages of a great nation. It is clear that the general reason of NEP's introduction was to find a substitute for War Communism policy. What requires investigation is the conditions Russia was in by 1921? At the same time in this essay I will try to explain NEP's pluses and minuses as well as why was it scrapped in 1928. The New Economic Policy was the third major policy introduced by the Soviet Government since it's

Foreign Direct Investment And It's Impact, Or Lack Of, On Russian Political Economic Reforms.

3798 words - 15 pages Since the collapse of the Soviet Empire, the new Russian Federation has had a tumultuous relationship with capitalism and foreign investment. It is not surprising that twelve years have past since the fall of communism in Russia and still there are structural problems within the Russian political and economic systems. Lack of political-economic precedent and reluctance for radical reform, from a top-heavy government; have inhibited the evolution

Lenin's New Economic Policy: A Study Of Short And Long Term Viability

2337 words - 9 pages , with Perestroika, in the late 1980s as he began to reopen the Soviet Union’s Economy. This ended up leading to the fall of the Soviet Union to capitalism and democracy just as the Bolsheviks of the 1920s feared would happen with NEP. Works Cited Richman, Sheldon L.. "War Communism to NEP: The Road from Serfdom." The Journal of Libertarian Studies V, no. 1 (1981): 89-97. Davies, R.W. "New Economic Policy." New Perspective 3, no. 3 (1998