The Effect The Protection Of State Information Bill Will Have On South African Democracy If Passed

1584 words - 6 pages

The Protection of State Information Bill is a controversial bill passed in early 2010 by the South African government, but was soon called back into analysis. Since then there have been consistent rumours about the bill being passed into law. There are numerous organisations opposed to this bill, and few people who would benefit from it, raising the question of if this bill would signal the end of democracy in South Africa.
Right2Know is an activist company founded as an opposition to the Secrecy Bill. It was founded in late August 2010 in Cape Town. It opposes the deterioration of worldwide human rights and portrays themselves as a progressive force which carries the hopes of many. The organisation has assessed the Secrecy Bill according to their seven-point freedom test. There were several concerns regarding the bill, and the key concerns can be seen below.

In their report, Right2Know expresses concern that it is too easy for the minister to extend the number of organisations affected by the bill and that it may extend beyond security of the state, as the government says it would be limited to. They also state that the minister responsible for the extent of the bill may benefit from censorship, allowing the bill to be extended over an unnecessary scale. It also seems, according to this organisation, that information can be classed as “top secret” too readily. They also point out that the bill introduces easy exceptions to the National Archives of South Africa Act 1996, which states that information may not be kept classified for more than twenty years. The panel responsible for granting situations exception has little regulations, effectively canceling out the National Archives of South Africa Act. The Secrecy Bill also states that a report must be made on the secrecy bill annually, which is welcomed by Right2Know, but the organisation expresses concern that there are not regulations as to how this report is to be written, and insufficient information could be in this report, misleading the public. The bill has also removed safeguards on classification of economic information, allowing corrupt businesses to function without being reported on. Right2Know also feels that the bill gives too much protection to the State Security Agency (SSA). There are also harsh penalties for those in possession of protected information, which, Right2Know feels, will lead to a society of secrets living in fear of the government, and discouraging whistleblowers. A Classification Review Panel will be introduced to regulate the classifiable information, however, the Panel is not independent enough to be able to prevent unnecessary censorship (Right2Know).

Democratic Alliance
The Democratic Alliance, commonly simply referred to as the DA, is South Africa’s main opposition party which claims to have its roots in 1959 when liberal politicians left the United Party due to a dispute over land distribution. It is strongly opposed to...

Find Another Essay On The Effect the Protection of State Information Bill Will Have on South African Democracy if Passed

If you know you have Alzheimer's, how do you regard the person who will inherit your body? Is that person you? How is this case connected with philosophical theories of personal identity?

769 words - 3 pages I discover that I have Alzheimer's and that within the space of a year I will lose all my memories and all my character traits. I regard the person who will inherit my body during this time as one and the same person, numerically identical to the person who has been present in my body for my whole life previous to Alzheimer's, but with a high level of qualitative identity. I believe that it is not my memories that make me myself nor is it my

Impressionism and the Twentieth Century (Important) I cant remember if I have submitted this essay or not so...I guess You will have to look it up website dudes!!!

7717 words - 31 pages or tuba.Well-known jazz standard songs from the Dixieland era, such as "Basin Street Blues" and "When the Saints Go Marching In", which are known even to non-jazz fans (for more information on Dixieland songs, see the List of Dixieland standards).Jazz is an American musical art form which originated around the beginning of the 20th century in African American communities in the Southern United States from a confluence of African and European

Must Every Nation Have Their Own State if They Want One?

982 words - 4 pages your vote. This is no time for backroom deals with the separatists."3 The problem could easily be fixed if the Canadian government was willing to work with the province of Québec. All though international law and domestic Canadian law state that it is illegal for Quebec to just become a distinct nation. The effect the two nations will have on each other for years to come only creates problems for all involved. It is that preliminary object of

Essay Title: If free trade is so advantageous to everyone, why have many countries attempted to increase protection for their own industries and farms in recent years?

1127 words - 5 pages into our homes, places of work and recreational venues. Although trade has benefits on countries, in recent years, many countries attempted to increase protection for their own industries and farms so that keep them away from free trade. This essay will explain what free trade is and state what the problems of the free trade are and the possible reasons why many countries have attempted increase their trade protection.Take UK as an example, the UK

The Security and Protection of the State

1072 words - 4 pages the present in terms of security challenges and issues faced by states when investigating the fine details of documents and actions but when retrospective on overall effect and our current global situation there are significant similarities can be found. Structure: Part One: Introduction and definition of key terms (e.g. New World Order) The security and protection of the state has fundamental always been a priority of importance for any

Impacts of Trade Unions on the South African Economy

2400 words - 10 pages satisfied with the increments stated by government allocated to transfer payments such as child care grants and social grants, stating that the increment in the child care grant was “pathetic” (COSATU press statements, 2014). Transfer payments have an adverse effect on the budget balance, which has been a deficit for the past 10 years. Source:, South African Reserve Bank, 2014 An increase in transfer payments will make it

The Bill of Rights and Protection of Civil Liberties

822 words - 3 pages a peaceful assembly should not be prohibited. If burning a flag causes this much controversy should it be noted as a peaceful assembly? Now, 200 years later, does the Bill of Rights still apply today, under the different circumstances, towards everybody the in the same way it did when it was first drafted? The right to bear arms surely must not include automatic weapons. When James Madison constructed the Bill of Rights did he know that it would apply to nearly 225 million people 200 years later? Although these rights of the American people are consistently being modified, the basic right to freedom and liberty will always be there in general.

The Effect of European Values on the African Society

1122 words - 4 pages The Effect of European Values on the African Society Dead Men's Path is written by Chinua Achebe, a Nigerian who has grown up with European customs effecting traditional African society. In this short story he explores these effects on African society. The story follows Michael Obi, a young headmaster recently appointed headmaster of Ndume Central School. Obi is a very desirable man and wanted to turn the backward

The Breaking Apart of South African Families

2635 words - 11 pages . With the mineral revolution, African men began to leave their families to go and work. From the beginning of European and African interaction in South Africa, the whites have been dependent on African labour, the mineral revolution merely intensified this. It also led to an agricultural revolution in order to feed the workers. African labour was cheaper than white labour and so they were desired by employers. This demand for cheap labour led to an

The Current State of Mexican Democracy

1132 words - 5 pages cannot afford(O’Neill 1). This can cause representatives to pay little attention to the middle and lower class and cause democratic consolidation to have more of a top down effect and once again slow down democratic consolidation. It is also important to remember that the democratic transition is still extremely young and democracy takes time to form and work properly. On the contrary, Mexico is quite successful in terms of effectiveness and does

The Effect Of Decentralized Information On Programming Languages

1991 words - 8 pages synthesizing ubiquitous models, but did not fully realize the implications of the Ethernet at the time. All of these solutions conflict with our assumption that relational theory and wearable modalities are unproven [17]. Thus, if latency is a concern, Select has a clear advantage. Our heuristic builds on previous work in decentralized archetypes and theory [11]. In our research, we answered all of the obstacles inherent in the prior work

Similar Essays

Legislation And Standards Of Information Protection In South Africa

1993 words - 8 pages governance. Legislation is not the answer.International guidelines such as COBIT or ITIL may be used as a check or audit for theadequacy of the company's information security, but it is not possible to have 'one sizefits all'.3.2 Litigations related to Protection of Information for South African CompaniesThere are currently many laws requiring the protection of information in South Africa. In this section we explore the Electronic Communications and

A Narrative Written About A Girl Struggling On If She Will Have An Abortion Or Not.

1142 words - 5 pages . The 3pm bell finally rang. She was walking out to her car when her best friend Courtney came up to her. “Hey girl!” she said as she approached Ally with a smile. “Hi Courtney, what’s up?” she replied in a monotone voice. “Well you just were looking kind of down today. Like you didn’t even talk to me all day,” Courtney said in a concerned voice. “I just have a lot on my mind that’s all.” Ally started walking again. “Well if I can help out let me

What Does Globalization Mean For Indigenous Peoples? What Effect Will Increased Contact With The Outside World Have On Already Marginalized Peoples?

2716 words - 11 pages increased contact with the outside world have on already marginalized peoples? It is these questions that this essay will look at.GlobalizationGlobalization is "a process in which the constraints of geography on social and cultural arrangements recede and in which people become increasingly aware they are receding." (Waters 1995:3) This means that peoples, nations, governments and states are no longer independent but are influenced by events and

Team Dynamics. Good Leaders Are Made Not Born. If You Have The Desire And Will Power, You Can Become An Effective Leader.

898 words - 4 pages and of the abilities that each member brings to the team. It will not be formed because one member is a stronger leader than another. In fact, just because the leader of the team is strong, doesn't mean the team will be a success. It also goes to say that if the team leader is weak that the team will be a failure. It all depends on the structure of the team and how the team operates as a whole. If you have a strong leader who has alienated the