This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Effectiveness Of The International Criminal Court

2978 words - 12 pages

There is a close relationship between human rights and criminal law. The scope of my paper will surround human rights and the International Criminal Court (ICC) in addition to human rights and international crimes. International criminal justice in this context speaks to those interested in prosecuting against the background of international human rights and humanitarian norms. The use of criminal law has many positive effects and pursues many goals that are worth considering. For example, deterrence, accountability and punishment are important principles that will be discussed in the context of human rights. Is the International Criminal Court an effective method to promote and protect human rights internationally? If so, why and how?

My thesis is that the International Criminal Court is an effective mechanism for the promotion and protection of human rights internationally because, by embodying the principles of criminal responsibility, it brings forth the notion of the individual as an agent in human rights and, by doing so, upholds the progressive shift that human rights conventions have developed. Criminal responsibility for human rights violations is important given that, by categorizing certain human rights violations as such, it allows for a progressive move internationally against those violations. International criminal law is an important tool that those advocating for human rights can use. The continued use of criminal law internationally, including the adoption of the ICC in 2002, will allow for a shift in legal norms resulting an increase in human rights. In this way, criminal responsibility allows for the education of peoples around the world by making an example of certain cases and displays the importance of humanity. Without an international judiciary and thus the recognition that human rights deserve consideration the pursuit of human rights would be undermined.
To support my argument, I will first discuss the evolution of international criminal justice and the ICC. Then I will address my three subsidiary arguments. First, I will argue that the International Criminal Court is effective because it increases accountability of human rights violators. Secondly, I will argue that the existence and use of the court increases disapproval and deterrence which protects human rights making the ICC effective. Third, I will argue that the International Criminal Court is effective because it allows for a universal standard of acceptable and unacceptable behaviour as well as transcends and empowers national jurisdictions. Finally, I will address the counter argument and conclude.

The Evolution of International Criminal Justice and the ICC
The evolution of international criminal justice is important to consider. Two ad-hoc tribunals, the International Criminal Tribunal of Yugoslavia (ICTY) and the International Criminal Tribunal of Rwanda (ICTR), have facilitated the adoption of the ICC. The ICC came into existence on July 1, 2002....

Find Another Essay On The Effectiveness of the International Criminal Court

The United States and the International Criminal Court (ICC)

4664 words - 19 pages The United States and the International Criminal Court (ICC) Statement of Purpose This paper will clearly lay out the Unites States concerns with the International Criminal Court and will attempt to resolve them. I will then argue that no country has the right to be above international law, including the United States and that it is in the best interest of America and the world community for the united states to join the efforts of the ICC

The International Criminal Court (ICC) and the Protection of Human Rights in Africa

1589 words - 6 pages 2 Introduction This essay will discuss the successes and challenges faced by the International Criminal Court (ICC) in prosecuting human rights violations cases in Africa. The ICC has been recently put under the spotlight by the African Union when it called for non-cooperation by its member states not to comply with the warrant of arrests that had been issued by the ICC against some of the leaders in Africa. This has created difficulties when

Subject: Negotiations Title: The US Opposition to the Establishment of International Criminal Court

2345 words - 9 pages IntroductionThe International Criminal Court is the very important institution, which should become the mean of struggling with such crimes as genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity, and many countries supported that idea, but the US took position against it. The aim of this paper is the application of several concepts from the course of the negotiation to the situation with the establishment of the International Criminal Court and the

International Criminal Court

1779 words - 7 pages International Criminal Court Allegations of war crimes, genocide, and crimes against humanity have undoubtedly received unprecedented press coverage in recent years – more than at any time since Nuremberg. This is not because the incidences of such barbarities have increased, but simply because those crimes are brought to us more rapidly these days by the electronic media. Since the early 1990’s the international

International Criminal Court

3688 words - 15 pages The International Criminal Court (ICC) is a relatively new organization; only just a decade old and it has seen a great deal of hardships and success. Since the creation of ICC it has seen a vast deal of criticisms that “[range] from concerns about racism and neocolonialism” and so forth. Not only has it encountered criticisms, but as well, people have questioned the usefulness of this organization? In truth, is it necessary to question the

An essay on the International Criminal Court, with a mark of 18.75/20. Including- Overview, History, Jurisdiction, Structure, Rights of the accused and Current Cases

1026 words - 4 pages The International Criminal Court (ICC) was established on July 1 2002 as a permanent tribunal to prosecute individuals for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression, but it cannot exercise jurisdiction over the crime of aggression, as the Rome Statute of the international criminal court stipulates that the ICC cannot exercise its jurisdiction over the crime of aggression until such time as the states parties agree

RE: INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT PROCEEDING TOWARDS ABDULLAH AL-SENUSSI AND SAIF AL-ISLAM GADDAFI PROSECUTION

983 words - 4 pages the judicial process and determine the punishment of the alleged criminals. On the other hand, the United Nations would guarantee that crimes of murder and persecution will not remain in impunity, which is the milestone of the creation of the International Criminal Court. RECOMMENDATIONS The first option would be the most preferable since it would enhance Libyan citizens confidence in their judicial system but the possibility to fall in an unfair

The Effectiveness of Amnesty International

1240 words - 5 pages The Effectiveness of Amnesty International In 1961, two Portuguese students raising a toast to freedom were imprisoned for 7 years. Upon learning about the controversy, Peter Benenson, a British lawyer published The Forgotten Prisoners in the Observer newspaper. This became the article that launched Amnesty International and the worldwide campaign to take action and fight for human rights. Amnesty International or commonly called "AI" is a

Certiorari to the Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas

3619 words - 15 pages Smith v. Texas CERTIORARI TO THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TEXAS Mark Anthony Bolden Jr. 2nd Period I Introduction LaRoyce Lathair Smith was convicted of capital murder and after some time being in court he was sentenced to death by a jury in Dallas County, Texas (Kennedy). This case deals with whether or not the death penalty should be nullified due to the jury’s improper instruction, how weak the two special issues are in

The Effectiveness of International Aid in the Development Process

2049 words - 8 pages The Effectiveness of International Aid in the Development Process If an individual was having trouble in some way, wouldn’t one’s natural instinct be to help him or her out? This does not merely apply to persons, but also on a larger basis. All over the world, countries are suffering from many problems. The majority of these sufferers are ELDCs (Economically Less Developed Countries). Whether their crises may involve

UN Security Council and the International Court of Justice

1396 words - 6 pages Court have endorsed the view that one of the purposes, if not the primary purpose, of the Court is the securing of international peace . Another problem concerning international peace and security is the ‘Crimes of Aggression’. Although, the major power in this respect is given to the International Criminal Court and the Security Council, yet referrals regarding settlement of such disputes may be made to the International Court of Justice . This

Similar Essays

Overview Of The International Criminal Court

2602 words - 10 pages Introduction The International Criminal Court (ICC) is the permanent court made for the main purpose of dealing with criminal acts committed by individuals amongst a state in a bit to tamper with the territorial integrity of the state. The ICC has prosecuted altogether … cases; of which are war crimes, - are crimes against humanity, - concern crimes of aggression and – (few) were prosecuted for genocide. Dividing the essay into the four main

The Effects Of The Purposed International Criminal Court

1318 words - 5 pages The Effects of the Purposed International Criminal Court The United States of America guarantees its citizens protection against punishment from foreign nations. As Americans, we are lucky in that the Constitution of this great state has a number of measures provided for its citizen's safety. Being one of the most sovereign nations, meaning we are politically independent from any other nation in the world, our government goes through drastic

The United States Lends Credibility To The International Criminal Court

1683 words - 7 pages becoming a member state of the ICC and what precipitated the U.S. withdrawing its signature from the document that instituted the Court. Once this has been established, addressing and refuting these objections will develop the arguments in favor of ICC membership. Finally, this analysis will lead to proving how the United States becoming a member state will increase the effectiveness and integrity of the International Criminal Court. One opposing

The United States Lends Credibility To The International Criminal Court

1607 words - 6 pages becoming a member state of the ICC and what precipitated the U.S. withdrawing its signature from the document that instituted the Court. Once this has been established, the arguments in favor of ICC membership will be developed by addressing and refuting these objections. Finally, this analysis will lead to proving how the United States becoming a member state will increase the effectiveness and integrity of the International Criminal Court. One