This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Effects Of Euthanasia Essay

1567 words - 7 pages

The Effects of Euthanasia
The case Wyatt v Portsmouth Hospitals NHS Trust hinges on the life of Charlotte Wyatt who was born three months prematurely weighing less than a pound with serious heart and lung problems that have resulted in her needing to be hooked up to an oxygen machine indefinitely. The crux of the case is that the doctors (Portsmouth Hospitals NHS Trust) do not want to resuscitate Charlotte should her body fail and Charlotte’s parents (Wyatt) want her to be resuscitated. The doctors have tried everything to improve Charlotte’s life and have come to the conclusion that her organs are so damaged that she is in constant pain. According to the doctors if her organs were to stop working, reviving her would only continue to keep her in a life full of pain. In addition, there is no chance of her life improving and therefore she would suffer constantly he whole life. They estimate that she will not continue to live beyond her infant years due to her internal damage.
On the other side of the case we have the Wyatt’s who believe that Charlotte deserves every chance to live. When the case first went to the high courts in October 2003 she was unresponsive. However, contrary to what the doctors expected, she survived the winter and her parents report signs of improvement. Charlotte is not only able to make facial expressions such as smiling, but she also has limited hearing and she is able to reach out to people and touch them with her hands.
The examination of this case must be a philosophical examination. In order to derive an answer from the information at hand the courts must consider what this case stands for from a philosophical standpoint. There are two basic points that they must consider. The first is sanctity of life. This means that it must be considered whether or not Charlotte’s life is still sacred enough to be fought for or is she already too far gone. The second is quality of life. This refers to how the patient’s life is compared to the life of a normal healthy human. The courts need to decide whether she is in too much pain or if the circumstances of her life are bearable. In order for the courts to make an informed correct decision they must answer these too questions.
The first thing to note is that nobody is arguing for active euthanasia, this case does not involve removing her from life support or doing anything to compromise the current state she is in. The doctors would be refusing treatment after Charlotte was technically dead. This calls us to consider the debate on the morality difference and legality between passive and active euthanasia. Active euthanasia, which is illegal and equated with murder, is the act of deliberately bringing about the death of a patient. Passive euthanasia on the other hand is legal as it is the intentional withholding of treatment that could prevent death. The end result in these is the same and the intent behind each is the same which is why many, including philosopher James Rachels,...

Find Another Essay On The Effects of Euthanasia

The Ethics of Euthanasia Essay

1417 words - 6 pages practice and research. Some of the major issues concerned with bioethics are: abortion, stem cell research, fertility drugs, defining death, and genetic engineering. The defining of death and the different topics that it involves, such as euthanasia, will be discussed in detail in the following essay.Before the development of advanced life support technologies, death was defined as the moment when one's heart stopped. Today, however, hospitals can

The Practice of Euthanasia Essay

1212 words - 5 pages For years, people for and against the use of euthanasia have questioned and debated ethics of the use of euthanasia. The main debate has been about whether people have the right to end a life that many believe is given to us by God; However, changes in social values and political institutions have changed the focus of the debate throughout time, but to me the questions are still the same. Should we take a life that is given by God? Should the

The history of euthanasia

1953 words - 8 pages The History of Euthanasia An ethical dilemma that has plagued history for centuries, it caused a schism of belief between the ancient philosophers, was disputed throughout the Early Modern period, and continues to be largely controversial topic today. This topic is the question of euthanasia. The word euthanasia comes from the latin roots eu, meaning good, and thanatos, meaning death. It was originally used in reference to a peaceful easy death

The History of Euthanasia

1426 words - 6 pages Euthanasia has been a part of societies since 5th Century B.C. in ancient Rome and Greece. The concept of euthanasia was considered to be tolerant before the creation of Christianity. Pagan physicians would do both voluntary and involuntary mercy killings. Although the Hippocratic Oath prohibited doctors from giving drugs to kill anybody, not even if asked for, or from suggesting such an action, few ancient Greek or Roman physicians followed

The Legalization of Euthanasia

1635 words - 7 pages Imagine a person goes to the doctor and finds out that he or she has inoperable or advanced stage cancer, AIDS or some debilitating disease like Lou Gehrig’s or Multiple Sclerosis. Death is an inescapable fact of life, but in scenarios with cancer, AIDS and other fatal diseases, it is closer and might be more painful than one hopes. Recent developments in Belgium pertaining to the legalization of euthanasia in terminally ill children , as well

The Slippery Slope of Euthanasia

1289 words - 5 pages The debate on whether voluntary euthanasia should be legalized has been a controversial topic. Euthanasia is defined as ‘a deliberate intervention undertaken with the express intention of ending a life, to relieve intractable suffering’ [1]. Voluntary euthanasia refers to the patients who understand the terms in the consent and sign up under consciousness, while involuntary euthanasia is performed against patient's wishes and some people may

The Killer of Hope: Euthanasia

1484 words - 6 pages When asked, “Why it is important to accept Euthanasia?” the answer is always about releasing patient from pain, but why take a naïve solution when there is hope? Take a second and think about how will a one say goodbye to the ones he love? The answer is obvious, it is impossible to let go of those we love. Hence, one should keep an open mind to the following lines whether you are against or for Euthanasia. Euthanasia or so called physician

The Five Forms of Euthanasia

2424 words - 10 pages Euthanasia can come in a variety of five forms and it is important to know the distinctions among them. The main types that euthanasia encompasses are first voluntary euthanasia which refers to when a person has selected and specified that they wish for their life to end and have taken measures to say as such (What). Normally this is done through an Advanced Directive which is created ahead of time so that if a person becomes unable to make

The Ethical Dilemma of Euthanasia

822 words - 3 pages times yearned for” (Richardson, 42). Richardson then talks about the history of euthanasia by discussing the tribal ideals and medical techniques used thousands of years ago. “The discovery that certain berries had lethal effects was used as a means of humane euthanasia for people who were very ill or badly injured” (Richardson, 42). The author explains how medicine has evolved to the point where the quality of life among patients has

The Personal Decision of Euthanasia

2060 words - 8 pages The Personal Decision of Euthanasia Every year two million people die in North America. Chronic illnesses, such as cancer or heart disease, account for two of every three deaths. Approximately seventy percent of those suffering from a chronic illness make a decision to forgo life-sustaining treatment (Choice in Dying). The ongoing debate concerning this issue remains whether patients should have the opportunity to implement euthanasia

The Catholic View of Euthanasia

874 words - 3 pages The catholic view of euthanasia is that euthanasia is morally wrong. it has always been taught the importance of the commandement "you shall not kill". The church has said that "nothing and no one can in any way permit the killing of an innocent person, whether a foetus or an embryo, an infant or an adult, an old person, or one suffering from an incurable disease, or a person who is dying". the church says any law permitting euthanasia

Similar Essays

Non Voluntary Euthanasia: The Future Of Euthanasia

3037 words - 12 pages Non-Voluntary Euthanasia: The Future of Euthanasia       Non-voluntary euthanasia seems to be the natural direction in which euthanasia practice evolves. In the Netherlands at the present time, there is a fear on the part of the aged, about being taken to the hospital - where the doctor may have the last word about life and death. This essay digs into this evolutionary process of voluntary euthanasia evolving into the non-voluntary type

The Ethics Of Euthanasia Essay

560 words - 2 pages IntroductionIs euthanasia moral? Does anybody have the right to make the decision of life or death for another person? Should euthanasia be legal? Do religions accept euthanasia? These are just a few of the questions I will investigate in this essay.According to the dictionary, euthanasia is: 'The bringing out a gentle and painless death of a person suffering from a painful, incurable disease.'There are two main types of euthanasia. Active and

The Morality Of Euthanasia Essay

1031 words - 5 pages A living will is a legally binding document people create in advance that dictates their final wishes in time of their last counting days. With the living will, ill patients express what they want to happen to them if they were to become too sick to refuse or consent to medical treatments. Euthanasia, also called assisted suicide, or physician-assisted suicide, offers one of many options for terminal-ill patients or those with intractable pain

The Legalization Of Euthanasia Essay

1914 words - 8 pages Euthanasia legalization has been a controversial topic for years; studies have shown that arguments regarding the euthanasia debate are often depending on the process used to take the life of the patient. There are a lot of thoughts surrounding the issue of euthanasia and whether or not it should be legal. According to the Encyclopedia of American Law, euthanasia is categorized as a class of criminal homicide (, par. 3). However, not